Wait, did we miss something? Have Love Island's Toby Aromolaran and Georgia Steel dated before, or is there just a sexual tension in the All Stars air?

After months of anticipation, Love Island All Stars has finally launched, with 12 recognisable faces from the Love Island history books heading to a South African villa. Over the next five weeks, we're expecting coupling up, steamy challenges and pie-ing off, as the OG Islanders try their hand at trying love once more.

During the first episode [15th January 2024] Liberty Ford and Jake Cornish had to see each other for the first time since their break up in series seven, but fans also noticed a little bit of awkwardness between Toby and Georgia. So, why?

Well, the pair both competed on Peacock's Love Island Games, which saw Islanders from the UK, Australia and America all competing in a series of challenges. Both Toby and Georgia competed in the show, and while they were voted off before anything happened, they grew close in the villa.

wait, did love island's toby aromolaran and georgia steel date
ITV

"That might be unfinished business, to be fair," Toby said about Georgia in the pre-Love Island All Stars press round table interview. "Like if she came in, I feel like we'll definitely have to speak about the Games and, obviously, how we left together and like how we were going.

"But yeah, it's one of those ones where it'll be interesting to see if she does come in; it'll be interesting to see her and I think it'll be interesting for her to see me as well."

wait, did love island's toby aromolaran and georgia steel date
ITV

Georgia said something similar, commenting, "I liked that I coupled up with Toby [in Love Island Games]. We were in there for four days, so we didn't really get to progress anything. I thought he was a really nice boy, like we really got on. We kissed once, but we didn't really have time...

"So, I don't know, if he came in the villa, I'd feel really...I think I'd feel comforted a bit because he already knows me to a certain level, but we never really had the opportunity to develop. And I think, yeah, that could be a nice little thing."

Could that be a romance brewing already?

Love Island All Stars continues on ITV2 at 9pm.