Menu

    Location & Hours

    You Might Also Consider

    Sponsored
    Goldy’s Gems
    3.5 (10 reviews)

    2.3 miles away from El Apretador

    Leanne R. said"love this place! went here on st pattys day this year and although it was packed, the bartenders were so attentive we didn't wait too long for drinks at all! compared to other places i've been to with that volume i didn't have high…"read more

    in Bars

    The Rex Burger & Lobster
    4.0 (895 reviews)

    Joshua A. said"To the lady Who wrote the review about food poisoning from this place in the last week I would just like to say the staff here has never been nothing but nice to me and anyone else I've ever seen them interact with. I've had a few…"read more

    in Burgers, Seafood, American

    Amenities and More

    Ask the Community

    Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about El Apretador.

    Recommended Reviews

    Photo of Username
    Username
    Location
    0
    0
    Choose a star rating on a scale of 1 to 5
    • 1 star rating
      Not good
    • 2 star rating
      Could’ve been better
    • 3 star rating
      OK
    • 4 star rating
      Good
    • 5 star rating
      Great
    Start your review of El Apretador

    Overall rating

    8 reviews

    5 stars

    4 stars

    3 stars

    2 stars

    1 star

    • Photo of Carlos X.
      Carlos X.
      Commack, NY
      142
      32
      58
      Nov 14, 2021

      I've been coming here for years to get their amazing pupusas but decided to sit down for dinner. Between the owners hospitality and the food alone, this will make you want to keep coming. They serve up very authentic Salvadoran food and their prices are extremely reasonable. They have a 2nd location as well which makes it easier for people on the north shore.

      El apretador sprecial. Steak with half a lobster and shrimp over rice and beans
      Blackened shrimp
      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
    • Photo of Nina C.
      Nina C.
      Central Islip, NY
      204
      625
      1650
      Oct 21, 2018

      I'm not going to lie, walking into this place is pretty sketchy. The parking lot was full of creeps trying to talk to my group of people. The restaurant wasn't anything fancy. It had good chips and salsa they gave you as an appetizer while you're waiting for your meal. Our waitress didn't even speak English, so luckily for the Spanish speakers I was with. The food was good. I couldn't tell what I really wanted because the menu wasn't that descriptive. It was Spanish and english description on the bottom. Not much else I have to say about this restaurant. There was a bar, too. Yeah, I think that covers everything I know about this place, not enough to keep me as a continuing customer.

      Helpful 4
      Thanks 0
      Love this 2
      Oh no 0
    • Photo of Gabriella V.
      Gabriella V.
      West Islip, NY
      1
      15
      18
      Jul 9, 2019

      One of my favorite go to restaurants, it's pretty close to where I live and I only go weekdays. Weekends it's crazy packed mostly with men day drinking. During the week though it's a cozy place to go eat. Not much to it when you look at it but the food is some of the best Latin food I've eaten, and that's saying a lot since I come from a Central American family. I've tried almost everything and have always enjoyed my meals there. The wait staff is friendly. It's great for just a low key meal.

      Pupusas
      Camarones Encremados
      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
    • Photo of Milagro M.
      Milagro M.
      Amityville, NY
      0
      1
      Jan 17, 2021

      The food was good. The waitress made our experience horrible. 1. She had a nasty attitude. 2. When we were done we asked for the check 3 times. She knew we asked for the check because we heard when the other girl told her to give us the check since we had been waiting for it for like 30 minutes. This place has potential but hiring people that give horrible customer service really will bring this place down. We are definitely not coming back. It was just horrible!

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
    • Photo of Leo F.
      Leo F.
      Brentwood, NY
      205
      3
      Nov 7, 2020

      This used to be one of my favorite places to get food locally. Def was top 5 in the neighborhood for pupusas but idk what happened as of late. As I normally do, I had ordered pupusas from this place for my family and I. Over the last few year the quality of the food has gone down but I still maintained my loyalty as a customer. As I parked my car and was walking toward the establishment I could hear a large crowd of people inside. I knew the place was good but it hasn't been this crowded in ages. I open the door and I was completely right, there was a large crowd inside with a thunderous roar but it wasn't people sitting at tables or at the bar but it was the TV that had the roaring crowd from a soccer game that was on. I looked left and I looked right and there was a total of 6 people in side, the 3 waitresses, the cook, some guy that came in just to use the bathroom on his way out and myself. I had called ahead and got my order fairly quick. Rushing home do to hungry I made it home safely. I opened the bag, opened the plastic carton where my food was, she was beautiful, she was golden she was ... a disappointment. I thought that maybe there had been a mistake. I had ordered pupusas which for those that don't know it's basically a meat and cheese filled tortilla except in this case there was no meat or cheese just the tortilla, so you can see my confusion. I opened up every single pupusa I order and it's about 10 pupusas total and there was about a fingers length amount of meat and cheese in these thing. For that I would have just gotten a slim Jim and eaten that instead probably would have been cheaper tbh. I was so mad that I thought about throwing away these "tortillas" but I decided to keep them and use them as tortillas for tomorrow's lunch. If I wanted Masa in a bag I would have just driven down to Brentwood market and bought a 10lb bag and it would have been cheaper than what I paid for these "pupusas" this place has gone down the drain. The pupusas are trash, the carne asada looks like it came from a malnutrition cow who had Cowvid-19, the carne asada is usually 78% bone and 22% meat. The ceviche is still the only thing they make good but over priced, the shrimp must come from Alaska. Oh and the chips they give are great also but I think they get them from restaurant depot so I think I'll probably be taking my business there instead if I really want good chips. Do yourself a favor and avoid this place unless your really hungry for tortillas and like sucking on bone marrow. If you have no social life and want to feel like you're at a crowded bar just pull up and tell them to raise the volume on the tv, then call some friends or your better half and they'll think you're having the time of your life but really you're just at a disappointing bar/restaurant contemplating suicide becuase you just wasted $25 on 10 pupusas . I really don't know what happened to this place, stop firing the good cooks and rethink your life. Maybe restauranting isn't for you, learn coding or I hear the coal mining business is coming back. But just restauranting isn't your thing anymore so just.. stop it

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
    • Photo of Walt R.
      Walt R.
      Islip, NY
      145
      7
      4
      Jan 14, 2020
      Updated review

      Delicious authentic seafood and really good prices for high quality meals... the pupusas here are amazing!!!!!

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Dec 20, 2019Previous review
    • Photo of Jay R.
      Jay R.
      Hartford, CT
      12
      14
      7
      May 7, 2014
      First to Review

      Ask For The Popusas Revueltas They're Great And Always Fresh And Hot and Better Yet Reasonable Prices

      Helpful 1
      Thanks 0
      Love this 1
      Oh no 0
    • Photo of Juan D.
      Juan D.
      Centereach, NY
      3
      2
      Dec 23, 2014

      Very good eats try the "Carne asada", my favorite dish fresh food always!!!! me and my wife always pick it up on our way home.

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0

    2 other reviews that are not currently recommended

    You Might Also Consider

    Sponsored
    Food For Thought
    4.0 (212 reviews)

    Bill S. said"Welcome back Food For Thought! First off, I don't get the credit card issue the other yelper mentioned, I bought a $7 smoothie and used my debit card? And the lady with the shamrock tat on her wrist smiled at me and said…"read more

    in Juice Bars & Smoothies, New American, Cafes

    White Castle
    3.5 (26 reviews)

    4.3 miles away from El Apretador

    Enrique I. said"Coming from Brooklyn the White Castle there are always unfriendly, slow, crowded and u got a 50 50 chance of you order being right but this place was on point. Clean friendly service and my order was done fast and right. A+++"read more

    in Bars, Fast Food, Burgers

    Collections Including El Apretador

    People Also Viewed