ArticlePDF Available

Riding the rural radio wave: The impact of a community-led drug and alcohol radio advertising campaign in a remote Australian Aboriginal community

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Objective: Aboriginal people experience a higher bur- den of disease as a consequence of drug and alcohol (D&A) abuse. Although media campaigns can be a popular tool for disseminating health promotion mes- sages, evidence of the extent to which they reduce the impact of substance abuse is limited, especially for rural Aboriginal communities. This paper is the first to examine the impact a locally designed D&A radio advertising campaign for Aboriginal people in a remote community in Western NSW. Design: A post-intervention evaluation. Setting: The radio campaign was implemented in Bourke, (population 2465, 30% Aboriginal). Participants: Fifty-three community surveys were completed. Main outcome measure(s): The self-reported level of awareness of the campaign and the number of self- referrals to local D&A workers in the intervention period. Results: Most respondents (79%) reported they listen to radio on a daily basis, with 75% reporting that they had heard one or more of the advertisements. The advertisement that was remembered best contained the voice of a respected, local person. There was one self-referral to local health services during the intervention timeframe. Conclusion: The community-led radio advertising campaign increased community awareness of substance abuse harms, but had limited impact on formal help-seeking. This paper highlights the value of radio as a commonly used, trusted and culturally relevant health promotion medium for rural communities, especially when engaging local respected Aboriginal presenters. KEY WORDS: Aboriginal, community-led, drug and alcohol, health promotion, radio.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Original Research
Riding the rural radio wave: The impact of a community-led
drug and alcohol radio advertising campaign in a remote
Australian Aboriginal community
Alice Munro, BSW (Hons), BA,
1
Julaine Allan, BSW PhD,
2
Anthony Shakeshaft, BA,
PhD,
1
and Mieke Snijder, MSc
1
1
National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre, University of New South Wales, Sydney, and
2
The Lyndon Community, Orange, New South Wales, Australia
Abstract
Objective:Aboriginal people experience a higher
burden of disease as a consequence of drug and
alcohol (D&A) abuse. Although media campaigns
can be a popular tool for disseminating health pro-
motion messages, evidence of the extent to which
they reduce the impact of substance abuse is limited,
especially for rural Aboriginal communities. This
paper is the first to examine the impact a locally
designed D&A radio advertising campaign for Abo-
riginal people in a remote community in Western
NSW.
Design:A post-intervention evaluation.
Setting:The radio campaign was implemented in
Bourke, (population 2465, 30% Aboriginal).
Participants:Fifty-three community surveys were
completed.
Main outcome measure(s):The self-reported level of
awareness of the campaign and the number of self-
referrals to local D&A workers in the intervention
period.
Results:Most respondents (79%) reported they listen
to radio on a daily basis, with 75% reporting that
they had heard one or more of the advertisements.
The advertisement that was remembered best con-
tained the voice of a respected, local person. There
was one self-referral to local health services during the
intervention timeframe.
Conclusion:The community-led radio advertising
campaign increased community awareness of substance
abuse harms, but had limited impact on formal help-
seeking. This paper highlights the value of radio as a
commonly used, trusted and culturally relevant health
promotion medium for rural communities, especially
when engaging local respected Aboriginal presenters.
KEY WORDS: Aboriginal, community-led, drug and
alcohol, health promotion, radio.
Introduction
Indigenous people of Australia (hereafter Aboriginal
Australians as the term recommended by the Aborigi-
nal Health and Medical Research Council for New
South Wales) experience a higher burden of health-
related harm compared to non-Aboriginal Australians,
which is most starkly evidenced by the Aboriginal life
expectancy being an estimated 10 years less than non-
Aboriginal Australians.
1
This health disadvantage
imposed on Aboriginal Australians is a consequence
of the complex legacy of generational trauma, the
aetiology of which includes colonisation (disposses-
sion, forced relocation, stolen generations), racism,
social disadvantage and exclusion.
14
For the purpose
of this paper, the specific manifestation of genera-
tional trauma on which the community-designed inter-
vention aimed to impact is the disproportionately high
rates of substance abuse harm among Aboriginal,
compared to non-Aboriginal Australians.
1,5,6
The
alcohol related burden of disease, for example is 6.1
times higher for Aboriginal men than non-Aboriginal
men.
5
Smoking rates are approximately three times
higher for Aboriginal Australians (4550% preva-
lence) than for non-Aboriginal Australians (17%
prevalence).
1,7
Furthermore, people living in regional
and remote areas (which generally have higher pro-
portions of Aboriginal populations) have higher rates
of smoking and heavier alcohol use compared to
cities.
1,8
Harm minimisation has underpinned the Australian
National Drug Strategy for over 20 years and
Correspondence: Alice Munro, National Drug and Alcohol
Research Centre, University of New South Wales, Sydney, New
SouthWales2052,Australia.Email:a.munro@unsw.edu.au
Conflicts of interest: None.
Accepted for publication 17 November 2016.
doi: 10.1111/ajr.12345©2017 National Rural Health Alliance Inc.
Aust. J. Rural Health (2017) ,
bs_bs_banner
incorporates three approaches: supply reduction,
demand reduction and harm reduction.
9
Demand
reduction prevention, or ‘upstream’ strategies, such as
mass media campaigns are designed to influence beha-
viour in the general population by removing or lower-
ing obstacles to change, encouraging people to adopt
healthy behaviours, identifying unhealthy social norms
and invoking cognitive or emotional responses
designed to positively influence individuals’ decision-
making processes.
10
While there is some evidence that mass media cam-
paigns are effective in the general population,
1012
there is a lack of evidence that they are effective in
reducing drug and alcohol (D&A) use for rural Abo-
riginal populations. A recent review concluded only
that culturally specific campaigns for Aboriginal Aus-
tralians are more likely to be effective because they
reflect Aboriginal worldviews,
13
whereas one small
study found that a mainstream anti-smoking campaign
positively influenced the thoughts and behaviours of
Aboriginal smokers towards quitting.
14
This lack of Aboriginal-specific evidence clearly
indicates scope for further evaluations of the impact of
media campaigns aimed at reducing the burden of
D&A related harms among Aboriginal rural popula-
tions. Radio advertising as a D&A demand reduction
strategy is promising because radio has comparable
ratings to television advertising on understanding,
believability, highlighting the D&A harms, and
increasing self-reported motivation to quit, but is rated
significantly higher on unprompted recall.
15
Further-
more, compared to television, radio campaigns are
usually cheaper for broadcasting health messages,
potentially have a greater reach into low and middle-
income communities, and have been shown to be a
trusted source of media for minority groups, such as
African-American populations.
15
This paper is the first to examine the impact of a
D&A radio advertising campaign aimed at, and
designed by, Aboriginal people in a remote community
in New South Wales (NSW).
Method
Context
The radio campaign was implemented in Bourke, popu-
lation of 2465 people (30.2% Aboriginal),
16
a remote
community located in north western NSW. The radio
campaign was developed under the guidance of the
Bourke Alcohol & Drug Working Group (known
locally as ‘BAWG’). BAWG membership included
health staff and managers, representatives from the
Murdi Paaki Drug and Alcohol Network (MPDAN),
police, local government representatives and Aboriginal
Elders. BAWG formed in response to the perception of
these community experts of escalating D&A issues in
Bourke in the mid-2000s. Figure 1
17
illustrates the
accuracy of the community perception in relation to
alcohol-related harm, indicating that alcohol-related
crime in Bourke peaked in 2004/5. Community leader-
ship around the escalating D&A trends resulted in
Bourke being the first community in NSW to introduce
voluntary alcohol restrictions in February 2009.
18
To
complement these restrictions, BAWG was awarded a
2011 Community Drug Action Team (CDAT) grant of
$10 000 to develop and broadcast local radio advertise-
ments that aimed to challenge listeners to consider their
own or their family’s substance use, increase awareness
of D&A harms and prompt them to refer themselves or
their family members to a local D&A worker for spe-
cialist advice about how to reduce those harms.
What is already known on this subject:
Aboriginal people living in rural areas
experience a higher burden of disease as a
consequence of substance abuse compared to
non-Aboriginal Australians.
Although mass media campaigns are a popu-
lar method of disseminating health promo-
tion messages across Aboriginal and rural
communities in Australia and internationally,
their effectiveness in reducing the impact of
substance abuse is variable.
There is limited research on the use and
impact of radio as a relevant and well-trusted
form of media in Aboriginal communities.
What does this study adds:
This evaluation has demonstrated that radio
can be a relevant and well-trusted form of
media in Aboriginal communities, reaching a
large cross-section of Aboriginal listeners
and achieving high recall of substance abuse
related messages, provided those messages
are derived from meaningful consultation
with the community.
Identifying complementary strategies to fur-
ther improve the impact of radio advertise-
ments on behaviour change, such as formal
help-seeking, would enhance the evidence for
mass media as a key strategy for reducing
substance abuse harms in rural Aboriginal
communities.
©2017 National Rural Health Alliance Inc.
2A. MUNRO ET AL.
Intervention development and
implementation
The content of seven radio advertisements was devel-
oped in collaboration with local community members.
A young mum’s group, for example helped write one
of the scripts relating to peer pressure. This iterative
process ensured that the radio advertisements were
meaningful and relevant by reflecting local issues and
the use of locally used terms and language. Table 1
summarises the topics and scripts used in the
advertisements.
The advertisements were produced by a locally run
and owned Aboriginal radio station, called ‘2CUZ.’
Locally known and respected Aboriginal and non-
Aboriginal community members were used to voice
the radio advertisements. The advertisements were
played concurrently on two radio stations (‘2 Cuz’
and ‘2WEB’) that collectively transmit a signal across
a 500 km radius from Bourke. The radio advertise-
ments were broadcast 25 times a week on both radio
stations for 4 months (December 2011April 2012)
during off-peak hours. Summer was thought to be an
appropriate time to broadcast the advertisements as
D&A related harms tend to be higher due to seasonal
festivities and holidays. Off-peak times were preferred
because BAWG members reported people drinking at
those times and listening to the radio stations while
they were drinking. The radio advertisements
were also less expensive to run during off-peak
broadcasting.
Data sources
Survey
The primary outcome was the awareness of the radio
advertisement. A 15-item community survey was
developed in consultation with the BAWG divided in
three domains: (i) demographics; (ii) use of radio and
recognition of the advertisements and (iii) impact of
the radio advertisements. The survey utilised tick
boxes, circling pictorial symbols and open-ended
questions.
Drug and alcohol referral records
The number of referrals to local services in the com-
munity was reported by the D&A workers situated at
the local health services.
Participants
A total of 53 survey participants were randomly sam-
pled from the Bourke community. A total of 60% of
the participants identified as Aboriginal, half (53%)
were employed; and the majority (94%) resided in
the township of Bourke. Table 2 outlines the demo-
graphics of the participants.
Data collection procedure
Surveys were conducted on a Thursday afternoon
after the broadcasting period by two Aboriginal
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
2002: Jan - March
2002: July - Sept
2003: Jan - March
2003: July - Sept
2004: Jan - March
2004: July - Sept
2005: Jan - March
2005: July - Sept
2006: Jan - March
2006: July - Sept
2007: Jan - March
2007: July - Sept
2008: Jan - March
2008: July - Sept
2009: Jan - March
2009: July - Sept
2010: Jan - March
2010: July - Sept
2011: Jan - March
2011: July - Sept
2012: Jan - March
2012: July - Sept
2013: Jan - March
2013: July - Sept
2014: Jan - March
2014: July - Sept
No. of incidents
Quarters of the year
Bourke
alcohol
restricons
introduced in
February
2009
Radio
adversing
project
commenced
in December
2012
FIGURE 1: Rates of alcohol-related crime in Bourke from 20022014.
©2017 National Rural Health Alliance Inc.
3RIDING THE RURAL RADIO WAVE
TABLE 1: Overview of the radio advertisement campaign messages
Topic Radio advertisement script
Effects of alcohol use
Scene: the grog is
talking to you as you
drink it, ‘Who am I’
question)
‘Who am I? My first name is ‘Al.’ (short pause) I can be your best friend and I can be your worst
enemy at the same time. I can lose you your wife or husband, house, kids, dignity, freedom,
money, respect, job, licence... and more. I can make you say things you don’t mean. I can make
you do things you wouldn’t normally do. Any idea of who I am?... (PAUSE) I’m alcohol’
Announcer: Grog it’s not the answer to the problem..... It’s the problem. So be strong... if you
or someone close to you needs help, please contact Bourke Community Health or Bourke
Aboriginal Health Service or your local Aboriginal Medical Service. Sponsored by the Bourke
Alcohol & Drug Working Group
Financial cost of
substance use
Scene: Conscience is
talking to an
intoxicated person
about getting a hit over
spending money on
food for kids
Conscience: ‘Good Job’
Intoxicated person: ‘Huh?’
Conscience: ‘Good Job’
Intoxicated person: ‘Oh yeah?’
Conscience: ‘You spent your last few dollars to get like this’
Intoxicated person: ‘(Giggles) Yeah... I did’
Conscience: ‘What are ya gunna get the kids for dinner, sis?’
Intoxicated person: ‘Uh, I dunno...
Conscience: ‘How much longer you gunna last?’
Intoxicated person: ‘Maybe an hour?’
Conscience: ‘Well that was money well spent, wasn’t it?’
Announcer: Drugs won’t fill your kid’s belly. If you or someone close to you needs help, please
contact Bourke Community Health or Bourke Aboriginal Health Service or your local Aboriginal
Medical Service. Sponsored by the Bourke Alcohol and Drug Working Group
Effects of
methamphetamines
Scene: Aboriginal
Health Worker is
talking to the
community about the
harmful effect of the
drug, ice
‘Hey there, all of us at the Bourke Alcohol and Drug Working Group wanted to talk for a moment
about the drug, Ice. Do you know much about it? It’s actually hard to know about it as every
batch of ice can be different and very unpredictable. It is the most potent stimulant or
amphetamine out there. This also means it has far stronger side effects and you can experience
worse downers. Spinning out when using ice can also often occur and is caused by high and
frequent doses. It is characterised by paranoid delusions, hallucinations, and bizarre and violent,
aggressive behaviour. These symptoms usually disappear a few days after the person stops using
ice, but by that time you can get you in trouble with the police or your family. So be strong... if
you or someone close to you is using ice and wants help, please contact Bourke Community
Health or Bourke Aboriginal Health Service or your local Aboriginal Medical Service.’
Announcer: Sponsored by the Bourke Alcohol and Drug Working Group.
Peer pressure and
substance use
Scene: Lots of voices,
like they’re in your
head, peer pressuring
you to use a substance
Voice 1: ‘Don’t worry... just do it’
Voice 2: ‘C’mon.... try me... you’ll like it. I’ll be your best friend, be by your side when you’re
alone, we’ll be together forever’
Voice 1: ‘I’ll make you feel good, give you energy, I’ll solve all your problems, I’ll make you
party all night long.’
Voice 2: ‘Now, I’ve got you’ (demanding / domineering)
Voice 1: ‘I’ll get you addicted, use all your money. I’ll destroy your relationships; make you lose
your children.’ (getting stronger)
Voice 2: ‘I’ll make you steal; I’ll make you lie... All you will want in life is me
Voice 1: ‘But most of all, in the end I’ll take your life one way or another’
Voice 2: ‘What’s wrong? It’s not MY fault... you made the choice to take me, didn’t you?’
(sneering)
Announcer: If you have a grog or drug problem, go see the staff at Bourke Aboriginal Health
Service or Bourke Community Health or Bourke Aboriginal Health Service or your local
Aboriginal Medical Service. Sponsored by the Bourke Alcohol and Drug Working Group with
the help of the Bourke Young Mum’s group
(continued)
©2017 National Rural Health Alliance Inc.
4A. MUNRO ET AL.
TABLE 1: (continued)
Topic Radio advertisement script
Effects of yarndi use
Scene: Female and
male teenage cousins
talking to each other
Boy: ‘Hi sis’
Girl: ‘Hey bro what’s doing, haven’t see ya in a while?’
Boy (depressed): ‘(sigh) Nuthin... am bored, nuthin to do round ‘ere’
Girl: ‘That’s no good my brother I just bin for a run and now I got some homework to get
done!’ (PAUSE)
Boy: ‘You wanna go for a smoke and catch up I really need it’
Girl: ‘Nah bro, I don’t do that sort of stuff. I’m too busy to get involved with stuff like that....
But I’ve noticed you’re different since you’ve started smokin’ the yarndi less like yourself or
sumthin’
Boy: (angrily) ‘You’re making that up... I got no worries’
Girl: ‘Well I heard people bin saying they worried bout you smoking that crap just thought I’d
let ya know that’s all, cos you’re me family and I care bout ya...’ (PAUSE)
Girl: ‘Well if ya want help with it, you can go talk to someone at the Bourke AMS or
community health. Anyways, I’m off to do me homework for tomorrow!
Announcer: Yarndi it’s not in our way. Go to school and play sport don’t choose yarndi. If
you or someone close to you needs help to cut back on yarndi, please contact Bourke
Community Health or Bourke Aboriginal Health Service or your local Aboriginal Medical
Service. Sponsored by the Bourke Alcohol and Drug Working Group
Effects of tobacco
smoking
Scene: Father confronts
teenage son about
finding a packet of
smokes in washing
Father: Boy, is this yours? (angrily)
Son: No... (defensive)
Father: Your mum found this pack of ciggies in your washing...
Son: I dunno.... Maybe one of the fellas? (defensive)
Father: One of the fellas? Whaddya mean? (ANGRILY)
Son: Look Dad... I don’t wanna talk about it. (defensive)
Father: Where did you get these smokes? Answer me boy (pushy, angrily)
Son: LOOK DAD... It doesn’t matter where I got them, I have seen YOU and MUM smokin’
ALL my life (PAUSE) Maybe YOU should have thought about THAT before you yell at me.
(Emphasis in the capital words)
Announcer: Parents who use drugs have kids who use drugs break the cycle before it becomes
your kid’s habit. If you need help to give up smoking, please see the staff at Bourke Aboriginal
Health Service or Bourke Community Health. Sponsored by the Bourke Alcohol and Drug
Working Group
Safe partying message
Scene: Nephew and
Uncle talking about a
Chrissy party on the
weekend
Uncle: ‘Hey Reece, whatchya been up to mate?’
Reece: ‘Not much Unc but am getting keen for this party on the weekend aye!
Uncle: ‘Oh are you going are ya?’
Reece: ‘Sure am... gunna be a BIIIIGGGG one Chrissy break-up and all!You better be getting
stuck in with me...
Uncle: ‘Nah mate, I’ll come but gotta drive to Dubbo Sunday so gotta make sure I’m under. Are
you drinking, eh?’
Reece: ‘God yeah... I need it’
Uncle: ‘Member last time you had a big one? I couldn’t wake you for hours... was really
worried bout ya and almost called the ambos..’
Reece: ‘What are you saying... stop being me father...
Uncle: ‘Look, I’m not telling you to not drink... you deserve a bit of fun. But this time just do it
a bit safer bro. Like you could try having a water in between, or have a big feed before you go.
Do you drink heavies or mid strength?’
(continued)
©2017 National Rural Health Alliance Inc.
5RIDING THE RURAL RADIO WAVE
Health workers. Thursday afternoon was identified as
a favourable day to maximise responses, as families
are paid government allowances on this day. As an
extra incentive to participate, respondents had the
chance of winning a $50 meat voucher from a local
butcher.
Ethical considerations
The project meets the Standards for Quality Improve-
ment Reporting Excellence Guidelines (SQUIRE).
19
A
post-intervention evaluation of the radio campaign
was implemented as a component of the MPDAN
Evaluation Framework. MPDAN was funded by the
Council of Australian Governments in 2008 to reduce
the harms related to D&A use in remote Aboriginal
communities in the Murdi Paaki region of Western
NSW. The network comprised three Aboriginal Medi-
cal Services, a public health service and a D&A treat-
ment agency. The evaluation framework aimed to
identify any impact of MPDAN activities on the com-
munities and to monitor and improve the service
delivery activities of the network as a result.
Results
Survey participants
The characteristics of survey participants are shown in
Table 2. More than half (60%) identified as Aborigi-
nal, about half (53%) were employed and the majority
(94%) resided in Bourke.
Use of radio and recognition of the
advertisements
The majority of participants (79%) reported listening
to radio daily, whereas 15% reported that they some-
times listen to the radio and 6% reported that they do
not listen to the radio. Three-quarters of respondents
TABLE 1: (continued)
Topic Radio advertisement script
Reece: ‘Heavies mate... why, what’s the difference?’
Uncle: ‘Mid-strength cans are only 1 standard drink, and heavies are 1.5 standards drinks... so a
bit less alcohol can mean ya won’t pass out or start bluen’ like you did last time
Reece: Well, maybe I’ll try middies this time... they’re a bit cheaper too!Tar Unc’
Uncle: ‘No worries brother, see ya Saturday.’
Announcer: ‘Party safe this summer. Look after yourself and your mates. And make sure,
whatever you do... your kids are safe, as you can look after yourself but they can’t.’ Sponsored
by the Bourke Alcohol and Drug Working Group
TABLE 2: Characteristics, radio use and advertisement
recognition of survey participants
Characteristic N %
Total 53 100
Sex
Male 26 49
Female 27 51
Age
1825 7 13
2634 9 17
3544 10 19
4554 16 30
55+11 21
Aboriginal status
Aboriginal 32 60
Non-Aboriginal 16 32
Did not specify 5 8
Usual residence
Bourke area 50 94
Other 3 6
Employment status
Employed 28 53
Unemployed 6 11
Retired 5 9
Other 14 27
Use of radio
Listen to radio daily 42 79
Sometimes listen
to radio
815
Do not listen to radio 3 6
Recognition of advertisements
Heard one or more
advertisements
40 75
Did not hear the radio
advertisements
815
Unsure/did not specify 5 10
©2017 National Rural Health Alliance Inc.
6A. MUNRO ET AL.
reported hearing at least one of the advertisements,
17% did not hear any advertisements, 6% were unsure
and 4% did not specify. The advertisement that
prompted the greatest recognition contained the voice
of a local well-known and respected young person from
the community. Table 2 summarises responses for the
use of radio and recognition of the advertisements.
Impact of the advertisements
More than a third of respondents considered that the
advertisements challenged their own, or their family’s
thinking about substance abuse (39%) and 22%
reported that they sought help.
Referrals to drug and alcohol workers
Drug and alcohol workers reported one self-referral dur-
ing the period that the advertisements were broadcast.
Discussion
The current evidence-base for media campaigns to
reduce D&A harms in rural Aboriginal communities
comprises very limited research.
5
However, it is known
that tailoring media campaigns, specifically using radio
as a medium, can be an effective way to target messages
to Aboriginal Australians.
5,6
The results of this project
indicate that the community led radio advertising cam-
paign increased community awareness given the high
level of recognition of the radio advertisements, but
had a limited impact on formal help-seeking, given
low numbers of self-referrals. Furthermore, based on
the trend in Figure 1, a reduction in alcohol-related
crime can be identified after the implementation of the
radio advertisements, but it is not possible to infer cau-
sation due to the retrospective, single setting design of
the study.
In addition to the primary outcomes, this evaluation
highlights that a high percentage of the sample (94%)
self-reported that they listen to the radio on a ‘daily
basis’ or ‘sometimes.’ This finding supports the pre-
mise that radio is a commonly used, trusted and cul-
turally relevant medium for health promotion
14,15
and is highly relevant to rural or remote Aboriginal
communities.
A strength of the project was the process of design-
ing and implementing the radio advertisements to
reflect local issues, language and culture, which
ensured that the content was optimally meaningful
and engaged with the target audience. Given the
unique characteristics of the Bourke community, rele-
vant community members and groups participated
throughout all phases of the project to develop or pro-
vide feedback on the content for the advertisements.
The MPDAN evaluation framework that supported
the project was also important in identifying the need
for research on D&A projects and encouraged com-
munity members to evaluate the impact of their cam-
paign. The community and MPDAN staff were able to
develop an appropriate, practical evaluation methodol-
ogy capable of assessing and explaining community
led D&A project outcomes, albeit with some method-
ological limitations.
Engaging with researchers or evaluation experts at
the time the radio advertisement was being developed
would have better facilitated the evaluation process
and likely delivered a more methodologically robust
evaluation. For example a pre-radio advertisement
survey could have provided baseline data, against
which to compare the post-test data. In addition, a
literature search to identify and adapt best-evidence
measures of awareness and best-evidence methods for
optimising the accuracy of participants’ recall could
have been undertaken and the results applied to this
evaluation. It may also have been possible to imple-
ment the radio advertisements in one or two other
communities, which would have enabled an analysis
of routinely collected data, such as the crime data
presented in Figure 1, using a multiple baseline
design.
20
In addition to utilising higher quality
research methods, collaboration with academic part-
ners may even generate ideas to further improve
community-designed programmes: for this pro-
gramme, the inclusion of complementary social media
and text messaging services, for example may have
achieved enhanced outcomes.
1,5
Conclusion
The research evidence-base for effective media cam-
paigns targeting substance abuse among Aboriginal
Australians in rural and remote communities is cur-
rently insufficient. This evaluation has demonstrated
that radio can be a relevant and well-trusted form of
media in Aboriginal communities, reaching a large
cross-section of Aboriginal listeners and achieving high
recall of substance abuse-related messages, provided
those messages are derived from meaningful consulta-
tion with the community. Identifying complementary
strategies to further improve the impact of radio
advertisements on behaviour change, such as formal
help-seeking, would enhance the evidence for mass
media as a key strategy for reducing substance abuse
harms in rural Aboriginal communities.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to acknowledge the Bourke
Alcohol Working Group (BAWG) and the Murdi
©2017 National Rural Health Alliance Inc.
7RIDING THE RURAL RADIO WAVE
Paaki Drug and Alcohol Program (MPDAN) for their
assistance with developing the programme and con-
ducting the evaluation. We also thank Lillian Lucas,
Chair of the Bourke Aboriginal Health Service
(BAHS), for her timely advice about the importance of
linking current, specific substance abuse harms to gen-
erational trauma.
References
1 Australian Institute of Health and (AIHW). The Health and
Welfare of Australia’s Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander
Peoples. Cat. no. IHW 147, Canberra: AIHW, 2015.
2 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice Com-
missioner (ATSISJC). Social Justice Report 2005. Sydney:
Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission,
2005. [Cited 4 Mar 2016]. Available from URL: http://
www.humanrights.gov.au/sites/default/files/content/social_
justice/sj_report/sjreport05/pdf/SocialJustice2005.pdf
3 Dudgeon P, Calma T, Brideson T et al. The Gayaa
Dhuwi (Proud Spirit) declarationa call to action for
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander leadership in the
Australian mental health system. Advances in Mental
Health 2016; 14: 126139.
4 Dudgeon P, Walker R, Scrine C et al. Effective strategies
to strengthen the mental health and wellbeing of Aborigi-
nal and Torres Strait Islander people. Issues paper no. 12.
Produced for the Closing the Gap Clearinghouse. Can-
berra: Australian Institute of Health and Welfare & Mel-
bourne: Australian Institute of Family Studies, 2014: 172.
5 Calabria B, Doran CM, Vos T et al. Epidemiology of
alcohol-related burden of disease among Indigenous Aus-
tralians. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public
Health 2010; 34:4751.
6 Australian Institue of Health and (AIHW). Substance use
Among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples.
Cat. no. IHW 40, Canberra: AIHW, 2011.
7 Guillaumier A, Bonevski B, Paul C. Anti-tobacco mass
media and socially disadvantaged groups: a systematic
and methodological review. Drug and Alcohol Review
2012; 31: 698708.
8 National Rural Health Alliance (NRHA). Alcohol use in
Rural Australia. ACT, 2014.
9 Van der Sterren A, Anderson IP, Thorpe LG. ‘Individual’
harms, community ‘harms’: reconciling indigenous values
with drug harm minimisation policy. Drug and Alcohol
Review 2006; 25: 219225.
10 Wakefield MA, Loken B, Hornik RC. Use of mass media
campaigns to change health behaviour. The Lancet 2010;
376: 12161271.
11 Robinson MN, Tansil KA, Elder RW et al. Mass media
health communication campaigns combined with health-
related product distribution: a community guide system-
atic review. American Journal of Preventive Medicine
2014; 47: 360371.
12 Boyle T, Shepherd CCJ, Pearson G et al. Awareness and
impact of the ‘Bubblewrap’ advertising campaign among
Aboriginal smokers in Western Australia. Tobacco Con-
trol 2010; 19:8386.
13 Gould GS, McEwen A, Watters T et al. Should anti-
tobacco media messages be culturally targeted for indige-
nous populations? a systematic review and narrative
synthesis. Tobacco Control 2013; 22: e7.
14 Durkin S, Wakefield M. Comparative responses to radio
and television anti-smoking advertisements to encourage
smoking cessation. Health Promotion International 2009;
25:513.
15 Hall IJ, Johnson-Turbes CA, Williams KN. The potential
of black radio to disseminate health messages and reduce
disparities. Preventing Chronic Disease 2010; 7: e6.
16 Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS). Bourke region data.
Canberra, 2011. [Cited 12 Mar 2016]. Available from
URL: http://stat.abs.gov.au/itt/r.jsp?RegionSummary&re
gion=11150&dataset=ABS_REGIONAL_LGA&geoconce
pt=REGION&datasetASGS=ABS_REGIONAL_ASGS&d
atasetLGA=ABS_REGIONAL_LGA&regionLGA=REGIO
N&regionASGS=REGION
17 NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (BOC-
SAR). Rates of alcohol-related crime in Bourke from
2002-2014. Sydney, 2015.
18 Senserrick T, Lyford M, Hinchcliff R et al. Evaluation of
the bourke alcohol action plan: final report. Sydney: The
George Institute for Global Health, The University of
Sydney, 2012.
19 Davies L, Batalden P, Davidoff F et al. The SQUIRE
guidelines: an evaluation from the field, 5 years post
release. BMJ Quality & Safety 2015; 1:17.
20 Hawkins NG, Sanson-Fisher RW, Shakeshaft A et al.
The multiple baseline design for evaluating population-
based research. American Journal of Preventive Medicine
2007; 33: 162168.
©2017 National Rural Health Alliance Inc.
8A. MUNRO ET AL.
... Relative to non-Aboriginal Australians, for example, Aboriginal people are up to eight times more likely to be hospitalised and five times more likely to die from an alcohol-related condition (AIHW 2011b), while Aboriginal Australians aged 15-29 are 4 to 5 times more likely to die from alcohol-related suicide than their non-Aboriginal peers (AIHW, 2014a; Saggers & Gray, 1998) There is no simple way to reduce the burden of substance-related harm experienced by Aboriginal Australians and, as such, a range of effective and culturally safe approaches are required. Gray et al. (2000) identify appropriate strategies including: acute treatment (sobering-up centres, detoxification; Brady, Nicholls, Henderson, & Byrne, 2006); counseling and residential treatment Calabria et al., 2013;Munro & Allan, 2011); support services (health services, accommodation, crisis care); and prevention (health promotion, cultural initiatives, supply reduction; Demaio, Drysdale, & de Courten, 2012;Munro, Allan, Shakeshaft, & Snijder, 2017;Wilkes, Gray, Saggers, Casey, & Stearne, 2010). Regardless of the strategy, access to Aboriginal community-controlled health services (ACCHOs) is vital to an Aboriginal person's right to self-determination Taylor et al., 2010), even if some Aboriginal patients prefer to access non-Aboriginal specific services (Teasdale et al., 2008.). ...
... This research included a retrospective examination of the impact of a drug and alcohol radio advertising campaign implemented in a remote community. The campaign increased community awareness (measured by the high level of recognition of the radio advertisements by loyal listeners), but had a limited impact on formal help-seeking, as evidenced by the low numbers of self-referrals to local treatment services (Chapter 2; Munro, Allan, Shakeshaft, & Snijder, 2017). In addition, a retrospective analysis of a suite of community-led programs implemented across four remote NSW Aboriginal communities from 2012-2015 was conducted, utilising a quasi-experimental design to evaluate the impacts of the programs on reducing Aboriginal alcohol-related criminal incidents (Chapter 3). ...
... Chapter 2 examined the development of a community and researcher partnership to retrospectively quantify the impact of a community-designed radio campaign implemented in a remote community, aimed at reducing drug and alcohol harms. The key finding in this chapter was that the campaign increased community awareness of substance-related harms, measured by the high level of recognition of the radio advertisements by loyal listeners, but had a limited impact on formal help-seeking, as evidenced by the low numbers of self-referrals (Munro, Allan, Shakeshaft, & Snijder, 2017). A key strength of the project was that, as the radio advertising was community-initiated, the design and implementation of the radio advertisements reflected local issues, language and culture. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background and objectives: Despite the importance of Indigenous drug and alcohol residential rehabilitation, the knowledge supporting these services is limited. This paper aims to: (i) identify the research output related to Indigenous drug and alcohol residential rehabilitation services; (ii) classify identified studies according to their methodology; and (iii) describe key characteristics of clients and services, and critique the research methods. Methods: A PRISMA compliant search of 10 electronic databases for studies of Indigenous drug and alcohol residential rehabilitation services from Australia, United States, Canada and New Zealand, published between 1 January 2000 and 28 March 2016, was conducted. Results: Of the 38 relevant studies, 20 were service descriptions, one was a thesis, 16 described treatment or client characteristics and one was a pre/post evaluation. No systematic reviews or the development or evaluation of measures was identified, with reviewed studies found to be of relatively low methodological quality. Conclusion: There are few published studies on Indigenous drug and alcohol residential rehabilitation services, an average of one paper per annum internationally, and only one treatment outcome evaluation. Three key features of the reviewed papers included (i) studied services were mostly located in regional areas; (ii) services provided multi-component programs, with little alignment between the models of care of other services; and (iii) the majority used qualitative, rather than quantitative methods. Client outcomes will likely improve if future research can establish best-practice, culturally acceptable models of care and increase the application of evidence-based, culturally validated quantitative evaluation measures to complement existing qualitative research.
... This finding highlights a lack of mechanisms that enable Aboriginal 'control' of research, including a clear definition of its praxis. For example, six of the studies that did not include Aboriginal control of research, did include Aboriginal 'research leadership' (Tyrell et al., 2003;Mooney-Somers et al., 2009a;Gauld et al., 2011;Adams et al., 2012;Munns et al., 2017, Munro et al., 2017, revealing complexity and confusion over what these terms mean theoretically as opposed to in practice. ...
Article
Full-text available
Most research involving Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples has been conducted by non-Indigenous people and has not been a positive experience for many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities. This scoping review maps approaches to health research involving Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and communities in Australia from the last two decades. A literature search found 198 papers, of which 34 studies met the inclusion criteria. The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Quality Appraisal Tool was then used to map the quality of the reported community driven research. The Quality Appraisal Tool privileges, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people’s epistemologies and ethical research governance. The findings reported on strengths and identified areas for improvement in reporting community driven research.
... Multisectoral collaborations have the potential to improve the quality of service delivery and the quality of research being produced [5]. These types of improvements can be accomplished by ensuring that the services themselves, and the application of high-quality research methods, are highly tailored to local circumstances [6][7][8], along with advances in the understanding of co-creation of new knowledge [9]. Evidence for the policy and practice of multisectoral collaborations in suicide prevention originates overwhelmingly from high-income countries (HICs) such as Australia, the United States and Canada, with less evidence coming from low-and middle-income countries (LMICs) where suicide rates remain high, such as Bangladesh [10]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Governments and third-sector organizations (TSOs) require support to reduce suicide mortality through funding of suicide prevention services and innovative research. One way is for researchers to engage individuals and services in multisectoral collaborations, to collaboratively design, develop and test suicide prevention services and programmes. However, despite widespread support, to date, it remains unclear as to the extent to which stakeholders are being included in the research process, or if they are, how these partnerships occur in practice. To address this gap, the authors conducted a systematic review with the aim of identifying evidence of multisectoral collaborations within the field of suicide prevention, the types of stakeholders involved and their level of involvement. Methods The authors conducted a strategic PRISMA-compliant search of five electronic databases to retrieve literature published between January 2008 and July 2021. Hand-searching of reference lists of key systematic reviews was also completed. Of the 7937 papers retrieved, 16 papers finally met the inclusion criteria. Because of data heterogeneity, no meta-analysis was performed; however, the methodological quality of the included studies was assessed. Results Only one paper included engagement of stakeholders across the research cycle (co-ideation, co-design, co-implementation and co-evaluation). Most stakeholders were represented by citizens or communities, with only a small number of TSOs involved in multisectoral collaborations. Stakeholder level of involvement focused on the co-design or co-evaluation stage. Conclusion This review revealed a lack of evidence of multisectoral collaborations being established between researchers and stakeholders in the field of suicide prevention research, even while such practice is being espoused in government policies and funding guidelines. Of the evidence that is available, there is a lack of quality studies documenting the collaborative research process. Also, results showed that the inclusion of co-researchers from communities or organizations is defined as co-creation, but further analysis revealed that collaboration was not consistent across the duration of projects. Researchers and practitioners should consider issues of power and equity in multisectoral collaborations and encourage increased engagement with TSOs, to rigorously research and evaluate suicide prevention services.
... There is no simple way to reduce the burden of substance-related harm experienced by Aboriginal Australians [8] and, as such, a range of effective and culturally safe approaches are required. Gray et al. [9] identify appropriate strategies including: acute treatment (sobering-up centres, detoxification) [10]; counselling and residential treatment [11][12][13][14]; support services (health services, accommodation, crisis care) and prevention (health promotion, cultural initiatives, supply reduction) [4,15,16]. Regardless of the strategy, access to Aboriginal community-controlled health services is vital to an Aboriginal person's right to selfdetermination [13,17], even if some Aboriginal patients prefer to access non-Aboriginal-specific services [18]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Introduction and aims: Aboriginal residential rehabilitation services provide healing for Aboriginal people who misuse substances. There is limited available research that empirically describes client characteristics of these services. This study examined 5 years of data of a remote Aboriginal residential rehabilitation service. Design and methods: Retrospective analysis of 329 client admissions to Orana Haven Drug and Alcohol Rehabilitation Centre from 2011 to 2016. Multinomial and binary logistic regressions were conducted to identify trends in the data. Results: There were 66 admissions recorded annually, of which most identified as Aboriginal (85%). Mean length of stay was 56 days, with one in three (36%) discharging within the first month. A third (32%) completed, 47% self-discharged and 20% house-discharged from the program. Client age significantly increased over time (P = 0.03), with most aged from 26 to 35. Older clients were significantly more likely to readmit (P < 0.002) and stay longer than 90 days (P = 0.02). Most clients were referred from the criminal justice system, significantly increasing from 79% (2011-2012) to 96% (2015-2016) (P < 0.001) and these clients were more likely to self-discharge (P < 0.01). Among a subset of clients, most (69%) reported concerns with polysubstance use and half (51%) reported mental illness. Discussion and conclusions: The current study makes a unique contribution to the literature by empirically describing the characteristics of clients of a remote Aboriginal residential rehabilitation service to more accurately tailor the service to the client's needs. Key recommendations include integrating these empirical observations with staff and client perceptions to co-design a model of care, standardise data collection, and routinely following-up clients to monitor treatment effectiveness.
Article
Objective: This review aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of strategies to reduce risky alcohol consumption among youth living in rural and remote areas. Introduction: Youth living in rural and remote areas are more likely to drink alcohol and experience alcohol-related harm than youth living in urban locations. This is the first review assessing the effectiveness of strategies to reduce young people's risky alcohol consumption in rural and remote areas. Inclusion criteria: We considered papers that included youth (aged 12 to 24 years; also referred to in this review as "young people") who were identified as living in rural or remote locations. Any intervention or strategy designed to reduce or prevent alcohol consumption among this population was included. The primary outcome was frequency of short-term risky alcohol consumption as measured by self-reported incidents of drinking 5 or more standard drinks in 1 session. Methods: We conducted this systematic review in accordance with the JBI methodology for systematic reviews of effectiveness. We searched for published and unpublished English-language studies and gray literature from 1999 to December 2021. Two authors screened titles and abstracts before full-text screening and data extraction. Two authors reviewed the extracted data to identify studies that reported duplicate data (eg, due to progressive publication of longitudinal data sets) and, where multiple studies reported the same data set, the study with the measure most proximal to the primary outcome measure and/or with the longest follow-up was selected. Two authors then critically appraised the studies. There were no interventions that assessed their impact on the primary outcome in more than 1 study; in turn, the feasibility and utility of statistical pooling and the Summary of Findings were limited. Instead, results and certainty of evidence is provided in narrative format. Results: Twenty-nine articles1-29 reporting 16 studies were included in the review: 10 RCTs1,4,7,8,11,13,17,20,26,27; 4 quasi-experimental studies2,9,12,16; and 2 cohort studies10,28. All studies except 110 were conducted in the USA. Only 3 studies1,2,4 measured the primary outcome of short-term risky alcohol consumption and included a comparison group. A meta-analysis of 21,2 of these studies showed that interventions that included motivational interviewing had a small and non-significant effect on short-term risky alcohol consumption amongst Indigenous youth in the United States. Meta-analyses of the effect of a variety of interventions on secondary outcomes demonstrated that intervention was not more effective than control for reducing past month drunkenness and were less effective than control for reducing past month alcohol use. The heterogeneity of effects was evident within these meta-analyses as well as studies unable to be meta-analyzed. Conclusion: Based on this review, no interventions can be broadly recommended for reducing short-term risky alcohol consumption among youth in rural and remote areas. Further research to increase the robustness of available evidence in relation to the effectiveness of strategies to reduce short-term risky alcohol consumption among youth in rural and remote areas is urgently required. Systematic review registration: PROSPERO CRD42020167834.
Article
Full-text available
High quality intervention research is needed to inform evidence-based practice and policy for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities. We searched for studies published from 2008–2020 in the PubMed database. A narrative review of intervention literature was conducted, where we identified researcher reported strengths and limitations of their research practice. A total of 240 studies met inclusion criteria which were categorised as evaluations, trials, pilot interventions or implementation studies. Reported strengths included community engagement and partnerships; sample qualities; Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander involvement in research; culturally appropriate and safe research practice; capacity building efforts; providing resources or reducing costs for services and communities; understanding local culture and context; and appropriate timelines for completion. Reported limitations included difficulties achieving the target sample size; inadequate time; insufficient funding and resources; limited capacity of health workers and services; and inadequate community involvement and communication issues. This review highlights that community consultation and leadership coupled with appropriate time and funding, enables Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health intervention research to be conducted. These factors can enable effective intervention research, and consequently can help improve health and wellbeing outcomes for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.
Article
Full-text available
La publicidad es una parte de la mercadotecnia que ha demostrado, durante décadas y tal vez siglos, ser efectiva para la productividad de los negocios. En México, la pandemia de COVID-19, desde el mes de abril de 2020 y al menos a mayo de 2021, ha dejado estragos comerciales y empresariales diversos, que se pueden apreciar en la quiebra de algunos negocios y en el nacimiento o desarrollo de otros. La resiliencia de las empresas, capacidad de sobreponerse a las adversidades del entorno, ha sido un tema importante durante la pandemia. El objetivo de este trabajo fue determinar en qué medida impacta la publicidad, tanto tradicional como digital, en la resiliencia de las empresas. Se realizó una investigación empírica cuantitativa en el mes de mayo de 2021, en la que se aplicó un cuestionario en línea de 30 ítems a una muestra de 302 micro, pequeñas y medianas empresas de la zona sur del estado de Tamaulipas, México. Los resultados mostraron que las empresas encuestadas manifestaron utilizar casi en la misma proporción la publicidad tradicional y digital. Se encontró además una correlación significativa y positiva entre los dos tipos de publicidad y la resiliencia de las empresas, por lo que se puede recomendar a los empresarios definir estrategias encaminadas a utilizar todos los medios publicitarios para anunciarse y así incrementar la posibilidad de tener sostenibilidad empresarial, en particular en tiempos adversos.
Chapter
The chapter outlines priorities that determine suitability of promotion and prevention programs such as: delivery and content relevance, localized communication methods, level of collaboration, facilitation of stepped care pathways, practical reach and accessibility, sustainability and scalability, evidence base, evaluation method, and demonstrable impacts. Integration of high-quality programs and services, with a community-led approach that is sensitive to local needs, experiences and strengths, is the way forward.
Article
Full-text available
The Gayaa Dhuwi (Proud Spirit) Declaration aims to improve the mental health of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples by supporting their leadership in those parts of the mental health system that work with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander populations. A further aim is to promote an appropriate balance of clinical and culturally-informed mental health system responses, including by providing access to cultural healing, to mental health problems in Aboriginal and Torres Strait persons. Developed by the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Leadership in Mental Health (NATSILMH) as a companion document to the international Wharerātā Declaration, the Gayaa Dhuwi (Proud Spirit) Declaration also sets out principles for governments, professional bodies and other stakeholders to support Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander leadership in the Australian mental health system; and principles for working with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mental health leaders as they exercise culturally informed leadership within the Australian mental health system. The Gayaa Dhuwi (Proud Spirit) Declaration is being promoted by NATSILMH as a new paradigm for shaping mental health system responses to Aboriginal and Torres Strait islander mental health problems.
Article
Full-text available
The Standards for Quality Improvement Reporting Excellence (SQUIRE) Guidelines were published in 2008 to increase the completeness, precision and accuracy of published reports of systematic efforts to improve the quality, value and safety of healthcare. Since that time, the field has expanded. We asked people from the field to evaluate the Guidelines, a novel approach to a first step in revision. Evaluative design using focus groups and semi-structured interviews with 29 end users and an advisory group of 18 thinkers in the field. Sampling of end users was purposive to achieve variation in work setting, geographic location, area of expertise, manuscript writing experience, healthcare improvement and research experience. Study participants reported that SQUIRE was useful in planning a healthcare improvement project, but not as helpful during writing because of redundancies, uncertainty about what was important to include and lack of clarity in items. The concept "planning the study of the intervention" (item 10) was hard for many participants to understand. Participants varied in their interpretation of the meaning of item 10b "the concept of the mechanism by which changes were expected to occur". Participants disagreed about whether iterations of an intervention should be reported. Level of experience in writing, knowledge of the science of improvement and the evolving meaning of some terms in the field are hypothesised as the reasons for these findings. The original SQUIRE Guidelines help with planning healthcare improvement work, but are perceived as complicated and unclear during writing. Key goals of the revision will be to clarify items where conflict was identified and outline the key components necessary for complete reporting of improvement work. Published by the BMJ Publishing Group Limited. For permission to use (where not already granted under a licence) please go to http://group.bmj.com/group/rights-licensing/permissions.
Book
Full-text available
The purpose of this paper is to draw on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander (Indigenous) perspectives, theoretical understandings, and available evidence to answer questions about what is required to effectively address Indigenous people’s mental health and social and emotional wellbeing. Social and emotional wellbeing is a multifaceted concept. Although the term is often used to describe issues of ‘mental health’ and ‘mental illness’, it has a broader scope in that Indigenous culture takes a holistic view of health. It recognises the importance of connection to land, culture, spirituality, ancestry, family and community, how these connections have been shaped across generations, and the processes by which they affect individual wellbeing. It is a whole-of-life view, and it includes the interdependent relationships between families, communities, land, sea and spirit and the cyclical concept of life–death–life (SHRG 2004). Importantly, these concepts and understandings of maintaining and restoring health and social and emotional wellbeing differ markedly to those in many non-Indigenous-specific (or mainstream) programs that tend to emphasise an individual’s behavioural and emotional strengths and ability to adapt and cope with the challenges of life (AIHW 2012). This paper explores the central question of ‘what are culturally appropriate mental health and social and emotional wellbeing programs and services for Indigenous people, and how are these best delivered?’. It identifies Indigenous perspectives of what is required for service provision and program delivery that align with Indigenous beliefs, values, needs and priorities. It explores the evidence and consensus around the principles of best practice in Indigenous mental health programs and services. It discusses these principles of best practice with examples of programs and research that show how these values and perspectives can be achieved in program design and delivery.
Article
Full-text available
Context: Health communication campaigns including mass media and health-related product distribution have been used to reduce mortality and morbidity through behavior change. The intervention is defined as having two core components reflecting two social marketing principles: (1) promoting behavior change through multiple communication channels, one being mass media, and (2) distributing a free or reduced-price product that facilitates adoption and maintenance of healthy behavior change, sustains cessation of harmful behaviors, or protects against behavior-related disease or injury. Evidence acquisition: Using methods previously developed for the Community Guide, a systematic review (search period, January 1980-December 2009) was conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of health communication campaigns that use multiple channels, including mass media, and distribute health-related products. The primary outcome of interest was use of distributed health-related products. Evidence synthesis: Twenty-two studies that met Community Guide quality criteria were analyzed in 2010. Most studies showed favorable behavior change effects on health-related product use (a median increase of 8.4 percentage points). By product category, median increases in desired behaviors ranged from 4.0 percentage points for condom promotion and distribution campaigns to 10.0 percentage points for smoking-cessation campaigns. Conclusions: Health communication campaigns that combine mass media and other communication channels with distribution of free or reduced-price health-related products are effective in improving healthy behaviors. This intervention is expected to be applicable across U.S. demographic groups, with appropriate population targeting. The ability to draw more specific conclusions about other important social marketing practices is constrained by limited reporting of intervention components and characteristics.
Article
Full-text available
Objective: To summarise published empirical research on culturally targeted anti-tobacco media messages for Indigenous or First Nations people and examine the evidence for the effectiveness of targeted and non-targeted campaigns. Methods: Studies were sought describing mass media and new media interventions for tobacco control or smoking cessation in Indigenous or First Nations populations. Studies of any design were included reporting outcomes of media-based interventions including: cognitions, awareness, recall, intention to quit and quit rates. Then, 2 reviewers independently applied inclusion criteria, which were met by 21 (5.8%) of the studies found. One author extracted data with crosschecking by a second. Both independently assessed papers using Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN; quantitative studies) and Daly et al (qualitative studies). Results: A total of 21 studies were found (4 level 1 randomised controlled trials (RCTs), 11 level 2 studies and 6 qualitative studies) and combined with narrative synthesis. Eight evaluated anti-tobacco TV or radio campaigns; two assessed US websites; three New Zealand studies examined mobile phone interventions; five evaluated print media; three evaluated a CD-ROM, a video and an edutainment intervention. Conclusions: Although Indigenous people had good recall of generic anti-tobacco messages, culturally targeted messages were preferred. New Zealand Maori may be less responsive to holistic targeted campaigns, despite their additional benefits, compared to generic fear campaigns. Culturally targeted internet or mobile phone messages appear to be as effective in American Indians and Maori as generic messages in the general population. There is little research comparing the effect of culturally targeted versus generic messages with similar message content in Indigenous people.
Article
Full-text available
To compare the burden of alcohol-related harm and underlying factors of this harm, by age and sex, for Indigenous and general population Australians. Population attributable fractions are used to estimate the disability adjusted life years (DALYs) for alcohol-related disease and injury. The DALYs were converted to rates per 1,000 by age and sex for the Indigenous and general populations. Homicide and violence rates were much higher for Indigenous males: greatest population difference was for 30-44 years, Indigenous rate 8.9 times higher. Rates of suicide were also greater: the largest population difference was for 15-29 years, Indigenous rate 3.9 times higher. Similarly, for Indigenous females, homicide and violence rates were much higher: greatest population difference was for 30-44 years, Indigenous rate 18.1 times higher. Rates of suicide were also greater: the largest population difference was for 15-29 years, Indigenous rate 5.0 times higher. Alcohol consumption and associated harms are of great concern for Indigenous Australians across all ages. Violent alcohol-related harms have been highlighted as a major concern. Implications: To reduce the disproportionate burden of alcohol-related harm experienced by Indigenous Australians, targeted interventions should include the impact on families and communities and not just the individual.
Article
Full-text available
Radio stations that target African American audiences ("black radio") reach a national African American audience daily, making black radio an ideal medium for health promotion and disparities reduction in the African American community. Black radio can be used to communicate public health messages and to recruit African Americans into public health research.
Article
Only a limited amount of research has been conducted to explore whether there are socioeconomic status differences in responses to mass media. However, the methodological quality of this evidence has not been assessed, limiting confidence in conclusions that can be drawn regarding study outcomes. A systematic review of the effectiveness of anti-tobacco mass media campaigns with socially disadvantaged groups was conducted, and the methodological quality of included studies was assessed. Medline, The Cochrane Library, PsycInfo, Embase and Web of Science were searched using MeSH and keywords for quantitative studies conducted in Western countries prior to March 2012. A methodological quality assessment and narrative analysis of included studies was undertaken. Seventeen relevant studies (reported in 18 papers) were identified; however, weak study designs and selection bias were common characteristics, limiting strong conclusions about effectiveness. Using predominantly non-cessation related outcome measures reviewed papers indicated mixed results for mass media tobacco control campaign effectiveness among various social groups. Most studies assessed mass media impact on low socioeconomic status groups rather than highly socially disadvantaged groups. Methodological rigour of evaluations in this field must be improved to aid understanding regarding the effectiveness of mass media campaigns in driving cessation among disadvantaged groups. The results of this review indicate a gap in methodologically rigorous research into the effectiveness of mass media campaigns among socially disadvantaged groups, particularly the highly disadvantaged.
Article
Mass media campaigns are widely used to expose high proportions of large populations to messages through routine uses of existing media, such as television, radio, and newspapers. Exposure to such messages is, therefore, generally passive. Such campaigns are frequently competing with factors, such as pervasive product marketing, powerful social norms, and behaviours driven by addiction or habit. In this Review we discuss the outcomes of mass media campaigns in the context of various health-risk behaviours (eg, use of tobacco, alcohol, and other drugs, heart disease risk factors, sex-related behaviours, road safety, cancer screening and prevention, child survival, and organ or blood donation). We conclude that mass media campaigns can produce positive changes or prevent negative changes in health-related behaviours across large populations. We assess what contributes to these outcomes, such as concurrent availability of required services and products, availability of community-based programmes, and policies that support behaviour change. Finally, we propose areas for improvement, such as investment in longer better-funded campaigns to achieve adequate population exposure to media messages.