The Best Settlers Games of All Time, Ranked

Video Game Info
Updated October 19, 2023 108.9K views 9 items
Ranked By
3.5K votes
1.5K voters
Voting Rules
Game must be part of the Settlers series.

These are the best Settlers games, ranked from best to worst with cover art when available. If you think the coolest Settlers game to play isn't as high as it should be then make sure to vote it up so that it has the chance to rise to the top. Are you and a friend arguing over what the greatest version of The Settlers is? Use this list of fun to play Settlers video games to see how many people would agree with you and end the squabble once and for all. Be sure to share this full list of iconic The Settlers games by clicking one of the social media icons on the top or bottom of the page.

This poll contains games like The Settlers II and The Settlers 7: Paths to a Kingdom. If you're wondering, "What are the greatest The Settlers games?" or "What is the best The Settlers game of all time?" then this list should answer your questions.
  • The Settlers II
    Photo: Metaweb (FB) / Fair use
    1
    378 VOTES

    The Settlers II, released back in 1996, was a true trailblazer in its day. The game offered an engrossing narrative that followed the Romans, Vikings, and Asians as they battled for control over the landscape. Players were then immersed in a world of strategy and micromanagement, balancing colonization, economy, warfare, and diplomacy. The game was a big hit for its time, featuring improved graphics, enhanced AI, and detailed environments, consequently leaving a deep footmark on the strategy gaming scene.

    378 votes
  • The Settlers II 10th Anniversary
    Photo: Metaweb (FB) / Fair use

    Released in 2006 to celebrate the decade-mark of the original game, The Settlers II 10th Anniversary was a real nostalgia trip for old-timers and an engaging introduction for newcomers. The game’s story revolved around the Romans as they hit the road to discover new lands for Emperor Caesar. The gameplay was fine-tuned yet familiar, with players tasked with resource management and building a thriving city. Impressively, this version introduced multiplayer mode and an entirely revamped 3D graphics engine, which was quite the eye-candy. It rekindled the classic Settlers vibe while integrating its upgraded features smoothly, and it struck a chord with fans instantly.

    334 votes
  • The Settlers IV
    Photo: Metaweb (FB) / Fair use
    3
    403 VOTES

    The fourth installment in the Settlers saga, The Settlers IV picked up steam in 2001. The story unfolded with three races - Romans, Vikings, and Mayans - against the Dark Tribe led by Morbus. The game demanded players to perfectly blend their strategic prowess with efficient resource management. The introduction of magic and gods, along with new campaign missions, ensured that this iteration was not just an old wine in a new bottle. It skilfully pushed the boundaries of what a strategy game should encompass, making a significant splash in the gaming world.

    403 votes
  • The Settlers III
    Photo: Metaweb (FB) / Fair use

    The Settlers III, released in 1998, was a milestone in the franchise. It revolved around the Asian, Roman, and Egyptian factions battling the dark forces. It introduced a much more complex and involving gameplay dynamic with precise control over resources and trading. The game made a leap in graphics and technology, giving it a fresh makeover. The Settlers III was notable for its improved multiplayer component, which remarkably changed the game's landscape and was a game-changer for fans worldwide.

    290 votes
  • The Settlers
    Photo: Wikimedia Commons / CC-BY
    5
    213 VOTES

    The game that kick-started it all, The Settlers, hit the shelves in 1993. It was a trailblazer, introducing the innovative concept of strategic simulation in real-time. The game was built around settling an island, constructing a functioning economy, and defeating rival factions. It jumped on the 3D bandwagon early, featuring vibrant, semi-realistic graphics. The impact was immediate and widespread, leaving an indelible mark on the gaming industry and setting the stage for the franchise's future success.

    213 votes
  • The sixth installment, The Settlers: Rise of an Empire, came out in 2007. The game’s campaign focused on Empire’s creation ruled by King Baldric and his loyal vassals. Keeping true to its roots, the upgraded gameplay included managing a thriving city, trading resources, and dealing with various climate changes. It presented a more refined and detailed game world along with the ability to manage each settler individually. Its innovative gameplay approach and elements were a huge hit among fans, creating a significant impact in the gaming world.

    243 votes
  • The Settlers: Heritage of Kings stood out from the crowd in 2004. The narrative revolved around the quest of an heir to regain his rightful throne. The game took a deviation from its predecessors by focusing more on city-building than strategic warfare. The introduction of weather effects and 3D landscapes was a breath of fresh air, which significantly enhanced gameplay. Despite tweaking the formula, it left its own mark on Settlers' universe.

    228 votes
  • The Settlers 7: Paths to a Kingdom, in its 2010 debut, offered three different paths to victory – Through military, science, or trade. Each player could carve their destiny, thereby creating an immersive gameplay experience. The introduction of victory points was a modern twist while it offered stunning graphics, customizable maps, and a compelling multiplayer platform. The game proved to be a standout in the series by adding a little muscle to the bones of the established Settlers format.

    235 votes
  • The Settlers Online
    Photo: user uploaded image

    The Settlers didn't skip a beat with the internet revolution, launching The Settlers Online in 2012. This game took the core elements of settlement building and resource management and transformed them into a massively multiplayer online game where players built their empire from scratch. This free-to-play game with its persistent world and cooperative play mechanics revolutionized the way people played Settlers, proving its adaptability to changing times and tastes.

    239 votes