J.C.BQNULL
1Dd•aei'.JotShettiel4
1971
A NOTE TO READERS
This is a copy of my undergraduate dissertation, submitted in May 1971 for a BA
degree at Sheffield University. In those days there were no personal computers or
word processing or spreadsheet software, though statistical software could be run on
mainframe computers. The original text was hand written, and then sent to a copy
typist who produced a typescript and two carbon copies (the typescript and one copy
had to be submitted). This is a scan of the second carbon copy, hence the poor quality.
The data and interpretations have long since been superseded, but the thesis may be of
some historical interest in that it: 1) contains the first (I think) computerized
multivariate statistical analysis of British Mesolithic assemblages, and 2) proposed a
basic chronological division of the British Mesolithic into Earlier (‘broad blade’) and
Later (‘narrow blade’) phases, which subsequently has become the conventional
interpretation.
Pa1•
mz 1 1
11119MMRP
1
2
ot the tea and llinoz7
!be in~iall
1u-..
a.,......
llodere
Subclin.ai.Olla ot the lieaoli\bio
ot
2
a.rope.
in~
l)
MAMAll> BI8 WAI (lP LIPI
),
IIEOLI'.fflIO
NZ
n, IMUINIP Z9¥P91:I'fflJCmm•
&iaOOYeri .. , 1875-190'·
•• 'Pygrq' perio4, 190}-14,.
Tb• be~minp
ot a,ateatio
atuq,
Sporalio t1llta and
19.'2-'9•
!he pae.._r
pen.OIL
17
•rl.J
.-pera,
5e
ll
18
l9l8-J2.
19
YmTIONAL
AJCl) sa-Lffa.
CIWGD DUllJICl !BI
Ll!I <UCUL AlG>ldLI l1(8'f-GLACUI,.
21
!he •qet.U...l
au.ooeaata.
Seol01ial
interpret.Uao.
!be •arote1111al m.clePN•
the Pl.alldriall
ua-......ic:m.
21
2J
29
•rill•
29
nn
JU ' 'WI IYPJPQIPORPI NP9HM9 IP somppBBITAP
6•
LI'lBIC RIIIAINS
,u.n,
•114
,
.•
セ@
• (i) . ~quea.
(u)
~
11, .i ... 1t1aatioa
,(.
1
Olib• lilbio
•terula.
¥-•t
•teriala
·-
7•
~aml
tollc .....
uurpret.'1.-.
ta.
IICII-Ll1BIC RIIIUIIB
IGDe •D4 •lltler.
Worke4 •Mll•
Allber•
wooa•nd
8.
'
10
!D 14ltm•
bark.
AllD l>lS'l'BillJTIOli
(IP
IOIS<LI'DIIC SIDS
alld
,.._
hp
75
GroQ1np 1denitt1ed wt~~.
Brt•t.h
The hi• tor, ot texoDclad.a • tuct_y.
10.
._oli~.
THI ·umTIOJC Cl' MIBOLifflICPtl:11'.aLifiCB
75
80
85
92
ot 11at1mtl plant tooda.
the -,loi~Ucm
ecaaGll••
Oaaatal
TerN9trial
12.
eoona.1 ••
92
95
'8
Dl'lllC
illcluatrw
JIJgl..,.iaa
''
101
10,
.
100
SaUYeWl"rUJl I iJ:.du5tri.M•
Horellaa iNllltri••
I
Coea1al inchlatrt ...
lJ•
92
1o6
D~C~iOI
107
Tn,oloaioe l a11pect..
,1•.
.Attiai
Ihe (iwuJticm ot t'wlctioaal
uo
ftriebll:l
ty.
S-ry.
w
u,
119
u,
u,
Claui fioe tion.
Mioroll•r
•t-tadi• a.ncl ~perimen1iel
:Archaeol.QIJ•
'lilorpaGM'ri.o a aal,pia
and .S..ori.pUve
•• U.ati••
at.it.au•
ancl -..at.er ... 1,-1.a.
)ul.U•r1-\e
Clater
15-
-.1.,.1a.
A OOllfUDll .AJW,I8I8 OP 19 dOLI91IC
A&SIIIILAQIS
tAe a.• .
'!be at.d.lari V ooeffio'\..nia.
fh•NIIIM~~m.
!he anel,aie,
D:i.. >M10ll - •ibocJa and r"ul:lia.
fW I a CCJP:
t@tcp
APWPd1J
l
セ@
( 1)
( U)
U.t ot 39 M•oH Ulia ... -1a1•
Jliorol.1 tbio.
•oro1.1t111c.
'tne
,.w..
ns tn,e
T•ble IIJ;tne
4PPl94112 Table Ii
ARPCP411.) Prua.-auta
lt.ai
lt.t
lut
ot 19 'aicroliUlic' aNablal .. •
ot l} •total'
••em l• S-•
セ@
1, ' •crolitJuo'
...... i. ... .
troa Uae .) oClllplter prapoa••
120
120
121
121
u-.
124,
125
u,
127
129
Pia• 1.
2.
fh• prlnciµl
culwna ot
lf•olitbio
!uropee
Seq,aeaoea ot •1.Jl T•getattaa.l
cbanpe 4ur1lt8 'Ul•
Leu Q.laeal and !arl¥ Poaqlacial
i.11 tlle
B,..i tiah Ialet1e
,. :~
,..
,.
,.
I•l••
Sub•ri.Ae
oontcaara erowad '11• aritiah
Bae Ol.lffe tor Ille euatatt.o rt.a ..
!Nbnlquea
ot t.be .,_oUUato
ot ld.erolit.ba.
'lbe •a&taeture
Clau itt.oa ttoa ot ..toroli
1na.
7.
lllaoroli~i.O
a.
Baf'Ulrc ot ld.oroli
,.
'.ll•aureaeA'U
aa ••lene
10.
Loc.tioo
ot 1ibe priAcii:-l
u.
Britiab
•P
incJu11"7•
tlillt
t t.Jpe8•
Ull)l, ....
thll.
em4 CoaUr.ea'9l
pert.Gia
trian&l••
ii .. olithio
•itea•
0-llt, &.'lee tor ih•
Mlaoliddo
12.
Oolpa-4
ktenrollia.l
aolutt.oa
19 ld.aroli i.lli.o aNub l11g•
(Pr•eno.-ebeenc•
ooetticient).
lJ•
CQIGll&te4}-4:iwrwiaa.l
111.orolithic eN~lulM
lit.a
Caaq:eW
aNezmlas• (~ided
diatance
15.
•.....i.,.(--11.d••
contiguraiiaa
ea..atec1
}-41-1~1
ooatipraUOD
ColllJ'lte4 2-d:lmemiual
oonti&Un•ioa
1'.
C~ed
2-4iaellaioaal
}-41.Mmioaal
auelllbla1eo
17.
eaaaltla1•
oontill,ln'1on
(holideell
ot
1illil ••l~ia
ot 19
cliatllnc•
twiattaa,
ot 19 aicrolitbto
tu.nc\ionJ.
aollfiglln,taa
diatallae
(Pneem.-.llaenoe
(n- ..........
tor
..,.
ot lJ • co1111•
tunotioa,).
ot lJ 'total'
coeffiot.ent) •
ot lJ • total'
ooettioien).
•
セ@
.s.
i 'J
r
•
t l 4 :
i '1:J.:,
Ii I
e..: f If It:'.
i J f. セ@ ,; I . ( セ@ i セ@ i f I • セ@
f セ@ f i
i
a • . ....l
! r
11
'
a.
• r · .' r i r f I l i ; • f f I .~ ·! i .! i I : : 1
l . ! J f £ ! 1· ! l J セ@ ' ! I 11 i f • ! I t f i i :
r ~a[! I • s : "I! t '"l i' 5 i.!. i
セ@
r: •i rr 1tt.r,:
;, i E 1 I , セ@ 1 5: It, iI J...1I ,It•, 1! i•I,I i : If; i !
'1
,C •
·:l
.
l!i
~i
•
I
....
I
.•
I
....
to\
If
I
II e I 'S. •
r "' ...
II
:
"t
I
It (
;1
.. I
f it
•
'
;
•
I!,
I
~It
rtt
. 11,c
It:
セ@•
1
:.
Io- •st
as.
セ@,! •i
-
!
'
•
M
•
• I
•
0
i
a
==
!l ;
I •
'
•f f f
..,
•
'&
セ@
:
,..
;
....
E ..
..
セ@ f
O
I
i 'f~
I
•
f
•
i
I
セ@
t
f
M
•
B.
'~
1
~
f :... =lI
.!.·
11,c
.
II• • •
l
I
1.
i
J{
f.f
•
.1
'41
( •
• f 'i It
Ii
,,. f' ; l •.. £. 5 , . a..
• r
r• , .t:.J., , "
•
セ@
.. "' & • •
"' ......
, ,
• I • I • f
e. .,. a
f :.-c •l a. i - s.1
i.•~
a
I
• r .... f
..,~
oi
B.
.., . ~•~I
of 'i • iセ@ セ@ l. セ@f'i. .•• ..; fr , '(
e. • .
'2 :t
... セ@ • ( II
i
.. " • r
s r
:@セ l, i: 11 セ@
i 1. : :-l , = i
; セ@ • '3 i • :3 .. · f I
I II ; i t f セ@ i ! f & セ@ セ@
; セ@ • ,
l i
f I
f f
a I
... . セ@
.,. I
:i
セ@
:i •
oia
f
..
1
f' J
•
IS
"
•
•
セ@ n i•
I
::
•
i { ;' .
f
t
I
::
. "
o
'I.
;
f ·r
J1
If
2.
J:.
ar r
i.• •r
a 10'
•
;c
i ... ,
I 1 セ@ ,, ,
i i ,
£ .s: i:: .. l
: セ@
I
,
&
,
1
f
セ@
I
I
:
11boU7 wltb U.Ul:le ...
IaW\iYe
-~
•7
a:1.q..
m.pt
....
their
prcwe Yer.J
t.be oeaual
u.u.uom;
••tw.•
I •••
be a'81H.ecl traa • t\lDc\im.l
ot a ~••
cllffiall.U.
nn. ..
•teis.ueal
deft.Ida&al"hfe~,
but.
セ@
llolr tli.llt
lea
teab-
•terial
•*ocl em reaulta
Jl"Old.a•w.U,
utholl
ot aillllar117,
and ~•
••lrti•l
aP}W'Gllallto the proobl-
are ia·,o1:Ye41 Dot 1 ... 1, ••
....
c.-ua
eapeo,J and tale
!be acQal
cl1.awe4e
ia ODe ot tiaZGIIGIIIJ•
}lNblea
ia4ioe"'
at.t.tioel
aal.tiYH·iate
•z••cqaN
•19
-i.,.,
-.
a~1GM
••Jeoti•i'.J
of llaaS. qaaU.uU••
ot
'bllt at pna•t
~t.oi\
Uwoln4
date.
1a
1a
J•C. JmllALL
,
i ..
f t si I
r ~; 1 ,
I i• l '
•
I
f セ@
... I
... セ@
1
i. :
.,l
1
I ..
I ,..
...
a-
f t
セ@ セ@
セ@ ft
•.., ,;!
t
Ii
r
r! r i;,
r
~
•
セ@ i .., 1 f
a ! I e. .... I セ@ .;
H
f..
o
I .l
, .;
.·
セ@
JI
セ@
セ@
It'
; ff!
1
4i
...
!.
5,
- •
1 I
I
l it
•
...
l '
.~
..., •
i
I
l 1 セ@
. ! 1&
1
£
1
;
•
I
セ@
f
.... •
o
I
i. セ@l
i
f
I
(g •
1;.
..
-..
セ@セ@
•,&
& •
'·1
I
..
! I .......
Q
l
I
セ@
セ@
., •
I fj.
.
O
•
! ·..
....
-
'C
;
セ@
...
!
fa :
5
M
'C
f f
"
i .' : .!;
!
r ~If•
,- ' ~ :i.r;
l ! I
I ' '
f ; ! ,;
セ@
1 セ@ 'セ@ ....
rf • 'ii l
1· I
...
I. •
I • • • t .. • •
セ@
# a
ie. •( • f... セ@ セ@[ i 5 セ@! I tn ( l i ·ii
i ! ;,- r I a i · I セ@ .( ; セ@ セ@
; :i ,f i
r IQ, l :: i
@セ ! [
;. I 1 セ@ I' i
I It • J • .... '
I ; rr,:. t
r セ@ - セ@8 セ@o
I r 1 セ@
y;: •
•
... , , r f ...
..
f lr •r BJ-
セ@
1t1
l J f 1 •~i .~
r {If : i ·lセ@ i II at •!
! セ@ •
I 'l i! I !'
I '
•t ;' iセ@ •• 'r
セ@
,
:
•
2
f ! i i ! t
0
...
t
,
セ@
•
i•
:1
i
...
•
2.
2
PI 'PISffl SI 'NP9IJPI9'
l
'Bi• •!'flllaeolocio.l
ill セ@
t....a
an aenerall7
••,nolitihie'
u,
area• 'b7 .ate •i,pearaaoe ot ...
aents,
.. uec1111.aroU:tha.
••••
ot tl.a.
•7
1-t
PN9 ...
_.
aNUeolos:t,oal
Stllcli ..
cml71.n tile U.t
ideaa 8N
1..ne11iai~ ..
Aae perlocll',
1
•en
'it m•
iben
a 'break or 'hiatall'
••
PalaeollUd.o
a.a4 Beol.i~o
1891) npneealtJls
Ta.or,
••
leoU.Ud...
• U..
lla4 ••
Baa...-,
JIDdder ..
pena•
Soetet7,
to ••
1•1 ... 1
tbe ._..
aad ill
1, pa..-tOlllarq
.
••trowill
pan-.
1872 1a
b
naim
)at.a
._..
lllai •• iart
tit
._..
reoez'4
1a apr111NDt
'be..._
tbe
18851 49:19-aW.BNln
!Ilia Jliaillll
Upper hlaeoU.W.o
later
Nainll
~_...
•111.abbo~
oOlltarta'bl.7 illto
\be 2-.A..
u
troa
tno}apa,atoa.
tncU:U.OMlly the ftret
ta • llel*" na4 to 1ibe .Aa~ogtoal
boak 'Pnbutoric
eaeenlell
wltb
tale \enia
.,.,1_1D J'reaeh m••,aen
18" (Daalel. 19'7: 26o)
• ... oUUato',
セ@
a.rope_. waaapt..._
ot ..
•GIil•Mt
•11-7 aD4 ••Upra(ida.ll7
p.reld.noria•
(0. a. JIOl"Ullet
erna sepaatiaa
lita.to
ta•
nUl
baa p11e before
1,54,) .
1D \be aNlllaeolAsieal
dlariltc •hiah
..
t:apl..-
•te~..S.
•inl7 • tile realllta
'beH4
•lcil• la7919
periola
or •• t
tao ~eilll after
vatU 1892, J:Oat Brit1Alh aaa OaDUnen•l
U..t
tUat
per1..o4 are
1'50, Bllrri_..
OOIRl'Cff... 7 (Dant.cl
period
, t111dare aberaoteriae4 ewer wide
or t.hta part1Clllar
1 t 1a
ead 'R..UW.0
poat-Fleiatoeen•
•11111.ngly laipl..y apacial~
'l'herefoN
....... ._ "'°s--.
'Pala..Utad.c'
or the 1.•1liatel.7
rwi.111
ta•
Pba ... ' I blli h
JU.au..,•••••
..
Mt
tw ••
•illl
in..-
ot • aobeme tor di.Ti41JW 111>tbe llbole Stolle Aa•,
...
I "'"' i '!1 •';
I,
:(
I•
• . •
..
,,
,
,
1
;!lf1:=;
·
1
!11
!
f
i!i'
.
1
J,
1
f!I
セ@ r I c:-1,. I t : .( ! セ@ l ri
i' i
i r I......
r-a
Ii : f : ;,
i
.
r1
I •
i
.
O
• .
·I
セ@
セ@
4
-
...,
1'1
•
セ@
I
.
'oC
,s
I
i. .
セ@
I
• .
セ@
I
; .
II ';I
!t.
I .:
a .•
"'I
1.
4
•I
...
o
"'
J
... .. ;
•
セ@
セ@
..
at
it
.
•
I
·
•
·~ セ@
:セ@ (. g
•
i
'i4
ii
I
セ@
I!
-.
セ@
l
t
~I
...
I
•
I I:.·:.::
0
f f.. P.,
;, ·(
•
.... セ@ '• '
1. 1 ...,! !
! i: J .: E • l
• [ I~ l
•
セ@
セ@
4
セ@
1
i
DQ
I
f
o
•
[~
i • •ff l I... •
c+-
I
•
•
i.
'
.I .•
I~
f セ@
•
i
I
:=.
.
~-
.
1,: 1(
a •
•
.e-
'
t
セ@
,
f
•
1.
I
·:1
r:
tti
'~
1 f
I!. I
q
セ@
セ@
·r f ,.
•
f •
:f .. i
.
0
セ@
•
セ@
l
t
J:,
.•
-
•
l
a.
•
::
£,
.. K E
f
.2
fr
·~ i
...
•
セ@ セ@
,
1
f J
! E;
I a
•
.+
セ@
l'
.~
セ@
II[
·•
''
i. f
f •I. セ@ . ,E
,
セ@
o
:
D
•
セ@
..
:11
R セ@
:p •
::-
r
?"
セ@ f
I
;
.
)
f
f.
I
g.
1.
it
c:
5 i. ,:
; J
r '• セ@ ' •
;
I
f lt I ...
f i ! i .. r I i
·I
t!
s-Jt
1- .. .,,, -l
:t •
,
...
•
2
I
1· ; rE
:
I
r
•fr
•
p
o
e, E' ..
i i r• · セ@• •i
..
B. ..., r
i ',...
10'
I~'~,~ I ! "f ·~
i
I
...
f
1.c.
•
I
I
't-4
,: fr
g セ@
セ@
! • ' i f - • i ,f 1
. @セ ... I t j •
E • ·1 !
Fi i ! ...f , ~r. 1 I
s セ@ i ·1 .it ,g; • 2.
f
;1~ f セ@
i - • -~
,. セ@
[ I f - セ@ e~ _g, [ ·r : :f セ@ 4 . . -! セ@ t
•
I!.·f • 1.
r:
!. r I
>
fIi 5
I
,:
i
"=
I
•
f
,
.
..
·.
,
!
.
セ@
...
.. !
• I '!
セ@
I
セ@
i i セ@ セ@ .,~ ,....!' , ·, セ@
,
セ@
l - 4' i • r • , -' s: ·•
s - セ@
It
!t
f ,
1
it
セ@
i. • J
•
i
セ@ i •
I
I
"'
•
a"• :.·r '( ,:
t ;~
l
! f... I
Ir f .i i~. a.
s• ri f· !
J
:= _}i f t • セ@
I 5 g;fr i l iセ@ セ@i
,~ i f l • • i
...,
t
セ@
•
f
t>
•
• · iI. i• Ii1 .I .@セ• '9@セ =
... I
P
セ@
:r· t:
' セ@• t:I ;EI
I
•
0.
p
P
!
セ@
セ@
!
•
W'
セ@
i '
n
0
f
'
...,
セ@
I
i
'
• .
Ii 'Ii'
i i
\;;,f
•
""
'1ult Uae an-rent
la twlqe
• pp
- t'1.ndll of arletana
of the
(18901 9'1) I and•
Deepite
li~c•
tbe 1•4
••
l••'•
g1"1'• b7
IYen •• la ta
nicer with
tile P
JIM••
-..
wae
ta• ....
la••
aU.
•~•
appeare4
tbeN ••
IIIIMlla ._..
(caned
•PPNN4
d4
...
.. ol.itld.e
.nemt•
1,a,J
(Burki"
Perr
a,
tlle
OCID9ideftl
.At Brana,
••
,_..
' ... o-
• WPV'
at
•••-la1•
1a
'Aail1aa-
apeoiti.o
19251 ~--
ot Ilia II-* ''file ._olitad.e
la
Ac•
tor tu
I'd.• .jull\lft•U.•
wbilta Ua alu: 1m1loeS..U7 .....
pertodll.
lorl4 lar
Clark
tlaen ••
period,
• •rked
aooel.-
all4 • w bft' ot r.giaaal
19J2, 19'61 Clli.Ue 19)1, 19J7) •
ot aaropeaa ,_.
1c1erea iner'llll'1a"9
19'2, 1'l7) J ••
at
1 aoeept.DDe ot • ._oUtlaic
ttU•
pae.-PleiatenD•
(I.Mlaaki
aa
1-k•
••
lliJI cliaoweri•
r the b•4:Utc
....
of ca.il~
tollonlac tll9 Puet
int••' 1D ._
et
hrlber
7•19
flt
With • aoc1erta r.-;
•'UlauooiaW
pat , ..
~r a aeri•
tile Upper Palaeolitlaio
NWMD
wrt.,1191 ot Chllcle (1925 et eeq.) 9114 Clark-
• •114 1D the in~
..
••
t•_.... IUa
tile ......
1iba tera 1a ta
l9J2, Clark pneeaW
U lrtt.ill'
la tan
tbe let.
mab •
pelU4
aaaac Britiala pnlliatoru•,
ptdoe
the Viper P.laeol.1•10
(JS2la 15)•
Tard.MWtaia•'
aacl ta.t
Plett.
•ta-opp, Cerl7le
1921 Blale.J
..
w the
18959) •
,.._.1 a<..
to pi.a
al•
later,
ana lacked
lPal•
•1c1ale111aa
ot lb• •eoUtld.e (Pi•"-
cUapaite
•i.a!P17
ill real.iv
cliMCJllrendaiarolitM
were tOIIDd 8NOOUte4
ld.eroli.tiba
.,....i.7
a.,o.1te
a.a.a.
c1a\ed
period
la 187' Ylelle
.....,.rd...,.
4'.Aail •here
11h1.ab• .,.
•ada-lMiaa _. 'rela4eer'
Da.Uere, ~• •---t.uaia•
...
-·
11,511, a,5-') J and 1a Ula eD4 aw ... 1 cH111••r1•
(Pl•"•
IW'CWNcteeiain
\lle reaatm
r••r4
break lD Ule -~ec>loSi•l
be-..••
a,a1b ...
195', 19'l ) •
to ...-a.rope.a
&laeolitaio
of the &coli*tc
...
•ieriala
a.ol.iW.o
Plll"lol JWOPff
Ai the~-
day, •»•olitble'
in !\&rope ranaiD& troa the beaiminc
period
ot \he apiwd
ot the leoli,hio
fJ"la •• a.JOO
a.c.
'° ., 1...
alarollol.oa ) .
•rltoa
dittvut
pwpa
Ii ._
period.
, l500
It ia alao
aOllte •Mnt
ONene4
a.o.
Uie pnbaiario
Pre-Bozwl to Che Ume
c- '11• 1-•ia
Bu.rope apMU'iwU.,,
ot iba •t.Ddard
raclio-
peopl•
.babi~tll
wt
be•-4
wtaaae eoODalQ' ••
Pl'ff8ile4
that
durlag
iNl>Oll'*l aD4 eoODalll.o •~t1aence.
are in ,__..1
192S: 2; Clark l932i 11 1965a2JJ
•er••~ that
the Meaol.i'thio ot hrope
• aa11tiDuaUOD ot the Pal..eol.ithic
arcbaeological
1Dd1•'-
uae4 •• all Wllbrella tera COftr.1ng ._
coaatal
Moe'
aoderD workera (Cbil•
GialNtaa 195')
ot ..
ot bulatina and too4 p\heri.Dg
••
w
NGDClll'i in Nortta-w•,
treall •'-rand
the· toreat,
•
l• waed
c.twnaea*1di
aerYe to
wey セ@
lit•,
bllt that
ta to
then
c1e.:.um1,
the ».aolitbic
•• a
l)
THIRI 1:ASA MAJORSHD'T Di mi CJNTJm; ())' PClfULA'l'I
OIIIa&ar!B
D ff lSffRH IOROPI
• JMr1DC•• Upper • awaleiu.Jl Jt.1cbpopu.ation denaii1•
•n
ntclenoed
tor Sau.tb-w•t Prance•
!be encl ot Ula .Pl.eiatnoe•
wtueuecl • 4ear:,cnJ)bio rM ... iOll iA tibia area, .Dd 0Gal)9n'1.Yel.7
ld&h a.i.tti•
ill Hortb-w•t
tvope,
•peoul~
arauncl the Baltio
U'iloral•
2)
!HID !JS A JIAJORCHANaaDf 1HE pOJU( CF STONX 1'00IB
• Ml.orol.1~ ~--~-••
iadia.iin&
t.be wia..pr .. cl ••
ot the
poei-Pleiaiooene
period,
la A\1Pt11"'9
..._ end a.l"Nllf ill the s-ediately
o...t.•
to obaracnmatio
&laeoli"Mo
IRlaUJI&teoilniqua.
J)
Dflll
•-1.a
セ@
.)
WJ8 A TRlriD 1'0'ulU:S SMALL GIJII .BUNTING
aplainei
a• • reapoaa• w the exUDc".oa ot
• mcli tla.Uy
at the oloee of 1ihe Pleiatoo.D•,
m•t.a•
!HID I .ASA KABDD IMCRDSI Di ffl!
DSOUIC. AND 1in.D f<JIL
l•di.Dg
lars•
to a affere
DH.OITATIOIC(It AQUATIC
'
S) !BI IOBOLI'DlIC UEUS O m CULTURAL
D:BGDIRATIOIII HIN COMPAUD
Wiffl 'DIB OPPml P~1HIC
• !he ap paNA' a.,er1 ... uoa ot laaaU»a reaourc.aa a l legedly l ..
w the breakdom ot the crpllia .. oic mi ty bwatiltg •ativiti ..
an
,.
thOQ&llt • be ot.ract;eriatio
ot •A,J Upper Palaeolitllio
~·
'Bua cbaDce ot aooial arcler la belin.S
,o baYe b ... _.. Gr'
1 ... l'IIIIPGMi ble tor the diaa ~peannc.
or the t ruoo-Cantabrian
.y .... セ@
1, ta pnera~
'n..
N111aim, "preaent:lJJc
11\bio
11•baon\iom,
am P.1-eo.U~
S. t\rther
proftl•, end iA
» • nnlt
ot the
.....
'-m
NW•ea
baa 'bMD ooaa1den4
..-aue4
cl•rl.7
W.•
oultur••
Gl1lt11nl
4n•Uo
ot ne'3U11taent
wti.tber
ill
NOOldlh
or Europe duri.Dc th• ••rl7
•• • •'tt•r
be raia-4
•lldd9n •••
t'oo4 oollan~
Jlolooerae an
enriroAMnta.
to -
1a,.,...-.
t1cm
9DYircaler'-l
ruu,
1D Aarope la
a
b7 the as-bi•
tor the begiall.t.ng ot the I.at
lnaatt:Da •D4 pthar1Jac
~l
._.,
poa'9PleutOMDe
'he X..olithic
oung .. • • hat
1.Jaoqtlam
Di• qUMUcm •7
...
la CMlwral
\o dittana,ia\e
am amiaolc:111•1
• t th1a tiae,
1enua:U,- 4-oriN4
ai...,
•••
and ~ra,t~•~
,ra'bl.• oornlat.1.•
of 8,00 .B.C.
the -1,_..1
•Jor
07
eonaeq11eMeal enrlronanul
"1wr7 delild.•U..
wld.eh ._...
the &eola&ieal
abaag•
~l
•Jor
•N
ONezored t.ba, lb• i•rdaW7
chenneru-4
pollen
••
tbeN
-1.t\11'91 • .,.,_.
it S. on.a.
llioreOftr,
period
oaDOet"4 tti•t
ot
-lffll-..L
aha••·
Cliatl•lq
aa
\btN
8JOOs.c., ntlaer
eaaclitl-
••
aa4 oola.r
eondiUom
ot eaniDental
prod\Wing
oloa• ot \he Pleia'\ooene.
•• ol•• ot
セ@
toreat
,.....Bcr .. l
ot •l'INI"
sraal
replaoe ,uac1n abNP'l7
re.ttor•t.'1.oa
a.c. )
OrllJb7
proo•W
ot th• B&l.Ua&
,o
the 1114-eiptb
llllleld.lla bad UMt\Ulldre ot tearpera '- Ju.ro ve bND tllll.Y elild.lla te4.
tbe di.N~panme
•••
tor
pa.,....,.,..
ot セ@
•117
Upper
It ....
gr•rtaua
Palaeolith1o
taa.t •
__,..
.._i.11&
looel
apecua •Iii.all prcwi-4
grc11111a, •--
ediD~ica
cl aoet
t; c,
a~tiall
at ••
,oMft
••-
i.JRero,al trora the bep.na1ag
(••~7500
,o poa~eul
aaei.lla'1GD
•l"'lllJw up, end ,be
en overall
1-teed,
duriltc • lt.000-J•r
nolen,
1.rr-..l,ar,
ah•••• Kor did
ioe
•ia..at•UJ
a11
G,yot.l
fraa
DO auddeD ohaqrcwer
Aa'Ye D-
8i.U.rl7
*he
•
ot the taan4n
r•ouror
..,_._1
r.w
•
I
p
?セ@ .,- r2 iセ@
• •
"
£ ·;•
If I..
,· f f
..I! •1@セ .•I@セ :i.,r~ •t
I
セ@ , !r
.
t . c .. •
1
...
r
lt
f
i .1 -
#
Ii
r:
I
- I I
4 •
セ@
l
a~
•
i セ@ • セ@ I
セ@2 .
. ..
f £
セ@
セ@
•
,
;
i:
"
I
"
J 1 tI t• f1 1 1 1 I セ@ I セ@
I
•
1
• j ·t i 1
; i -; ! .I. セ@
•
.., - ti i l" It' f
:. l f q_. .:1 f I .~ f i ! i £ f
@セ セ@ セ@ F I 1 l セ@
セ@ セ@ l
;
t
!
I
.
' .' I ,; ,~t 11,
~,
,
·
.
.
J
i ' I 5 i
• 'J
: i a1 !
•!
セ@
i i
セ@
l1 f
i • :I
; " ,.I
Ill
セ@
I
i
I
O
2
O"
I (11i!e,·l:1f1l
v
:: !
Ii
If
...
;
D
I·
セ@
. ., f
'
'
&
e.-
_i:f
I.;
1
,
iIi
,
f
.
·
~
!I
I ...f f .. '
! • r •
i f @セ : f I f
1
•
I
rセ@ ·r1 f.
ll
I
,
r iii,,セ@ : ' セ@ii•5 セ@ ir , r
1
·1t i If,·
; .. '• t' i
:• !aiセ@ •;'B.~·
' ,~
!
1 セ@
i
t
,
.
..
,
f
:• i! .. l 1• セ@
l I:
! ..
., l . .-. ( •
E
r
..
!
et
•
& :
r ..., t ,.
f
1
•
>
Ji
Si
;i
•
v
'
セ@
f
..
~i . s;
I
セ@
. 2!1l!J·
.. 1;1セ@
f
1
.
I
f
•
r· i...セ@ ...
;
... I t •
...
i;,'I
• ;- :•tt ., 8 s ,
1 'f · セ@ I~.· ... i • • l: ii t, 1 .. 1.
£ t i
i f .. ' ! 1
f
I
I, e- I!. • セ@
£ !
: Sr . a~
f ' f
r
'ii
1.. r wj t!/t ! セ@ r :S. § •
r ... •_. ..- E tti t• ..
::
f I'I• .C'.セ@セ@ r..- ,• !n 'S.:, f,
..
,r セ@ . t I • =: s, =
.. ... .. I
f
セ@ セ@
ta!
I
1
I I :-I l
'
1 ,B ..
fi Ii ...
; r ..'~. e :,
(
'
f
セ@if 2 1·
a•
I ,i ,r - • <i ... ' 1
f l. •i ,Il }I セ@I 1a .ift .(• i.. ,J t;r .• . •P
, • •
1 ,,• , !t .1 •l
s:. I, •
I1 1 • ll i • r I f 1 セ@
r
E 'f ll .. t 1 Ii l .. 1 :r .. 8
f
?- ' I i ( i , r t-'
-• •
. f&
A ! I
セ@ •s • . i. ...
•'
f :.
•
'
''1
セ@
,i-
r11
セ@
2
f -a af
1
i.
,
E セ@ I
f f
.....
•
1
i'=
l• ... !,.I... I...
.. :i•
i::
r ·•
セ@
セ@ ;a.
I 5
I
.
f
e
I
Ji
JI
I • . .• r !
Ji · 1 1
セ@
1
• If i ••
f
1.~·~1f~~
JI:;!'
..., r r r
f
.
..,
[
I ...
f
f'..,~
.o
'
...
;
Z
i I.. .I•. Ist :tt: '!.
: i i I • j
•
1t,a1セ@
•
I •• -,~
t
a セ@
セ@
-
セ@
!
i
セ@i ', ! i Jセ@ !
i 1..
...
l
,
·,-=
... ·
r 1"' '.•( .fIi E ar
I
:; セ@
o
,
•
r. ..
r .. ·.'£ 1i .I . .f..
: 1 セ@ i Ir ·iセ@ s;ac.
't:: ·
•
<c
,r
iI.. . • .,.· ••
i
.
1:i 1i •·! :t •i r ! r i I,,,r i 1.,
i:
1
セ@
i
'
.. a .. =
-•'
1
';!Jri!':!;li!:i
r:
I ;.
l
i
a....
•
M
i •.- :,i; 2 ? iii
r i J i f i • !
セ@
f r • ••f i
•
·••et-•
R
,...
#
I ...I • rセ@
-
1
!
セ@
i
セ@
It.
f
..
!
ID
'
I?,
C,
a :
f~!i,(
f
セ@
セ@
r,.
I
-
f
1
.S :a
!
セ@
1
...
,
...
..
'IO
..
-p
,..._
p
, f
f...
f
1if
i セ@
It
セ@ セ@
セ@
セ@
I
•1
•
I
1
a
i1! .
1 1-=
セ@ a
I; i; •r• §I~
-- f
i !tI .l..I, J! J;l ! !, セ@, i... •セ@ セ@ , i.
.
n
.
•
1
•@セ
·i..
"'
-
•f
1
r
I
..
r
! i
, •
1 ;r 1!t
•
Cl ! 1 セ@ r
I.
rf1i1~ 1
l セ@ i i ! ~Ii!!
f ! 1 I t a i 1 セ@
p
ft- !f 1JiI '·
.. t 1 ·• • r
-... _
... セ@ • a_ :( 1 · :
r ! ..
2 i
a. ..
Ii ..
•r
;
Iri ••
セ@
l 1
i ..&
I ;;_'S,
a
"'I
:_ i I
'• f! ·1
• 1
l!~
• i -
..ts
.I.,.il
i i !...,
0
ca.
•
11
R I
oa
I
I:
J~!
@セ ,
セ@ , i f , .. @セ
. . t
Ii ;
f 3• ,..
1
I; i; i 1 1
1
0
...
t'
s.
!»
,.
1'h• NDYeDU.OMl DOUoa ,.
iaar••lll&
nideace
la • CINalal -..
tbaD n.l,
ia 'he ala•ial
ot the •••
u..-e 'b..
period,
aooaap.n.,tac
period,
radJuataea•
aDll
...
ta ••n
lay•
wlidlV
a.n
wu...-
taae •net
-na
.... tan,
deaplte
-.nt.U.••
aup
Pol' tM
•
parpc:ia•
....
anenc'111g fNII ••
• hftlilla
., ....
eo~•
•rlier,
aD4
lnel
\be 1. ttt•'-17
t.be •li4it7
the Dee4
•mot:
tar
•-twr ot
ot \be~
uao.,1
end Bel\ic
quae\l-
all4 Bnidwood
aftlle4 sHlost•ll7•
laelp tMliJIC •
HIN
• 4itterent
•
..._ill
ercbaeot..gtaa
1lbe
and RN4 (1957)
ot ,11. wnd.Dal Pleiatoo••
adapUOD
al.a and
....
97-8) tat.et:
(19'ls
•
aacl 41:~_..itiatiOD,
t.eobni•l
ot • M•OU.tld.• ait:
reaouroe
セ@
aD4
cwer----•a
ea eartr-
atiM ....
·-
oli~io
ilmowUOD 1a the ••k• ot eool.og-ioal
•
ot the ~u1..-.,..1
i.Ddi•••
tale aultunl
aan
by the rtailrc
wi~
ahona
nad.ju-...,;
\be lllaaia ot aal.tunl
ot itll al-t
NNllae
lien
lnidllood
-~---..i_..
alld...,
t;blllldJlc ot
UI ..
aNociated
tona ot apect.ali.M\ia
-1'1aral
tor
redlaoe4 reaCNl'NII, -.
a.,roy.a
<al7 alOD& ••
oulturee,
a.rope, alld
aploitatiGDa
ta oaacnare, alMSpc:aaiDl.7 aon
n14eDce ot • ._
of tile ••e
art.ate la
illaoni10D
tbentore,
l"fl9luUoM17.
.....
per11a19
4ea).aciatioa.
.-.a.ptaU.an.
ta tile Macl-ua
caaatal
allbllllrge4 or
'1'aeMtl&re ot •IV' cult11nl
paat,-Qlaeul
tut
M ibe hot
••
anl apl.oiutica
u
!Ilia •••
a.rope abGN
ia
)(Nol.i 11uo perioct
tor '°e oea11i-,1oa ot eoeatal an.a
ot aq• U.o naouro•
•pp.ND\
1l ••
paper,
applioatiall•
ot iM l)eriod
reaim
beg:Sw1ag ot
Ko apeoial
セ@
PrrBorNl
ta n'81M4
the term, 'Meaol.i'thio'
And it
1a ••
ill Brit.ill
••
menl7
lortb-w•t
pnt .. 'ble•
\lae ,.,..
eeon,mo or aooio-wltunl
• Mim'olit:111.o' or
セ@
to the tima ot the •1,1rNt ot
ai.pt.ttoanee
4 ~""-
la aoae •,a
•
• NJlal f'-1-eol.!Ud.o'
are
ta
10.
lllftria~,
• diNret•
l"Nliatio
hen
1a
ea helpfl&l
ot •rcbaeol.asi.•l
amdiYiaioll
.juat do aot
p-aaplnp
rn-ortc
\Jl)Oloei•l
oluded
tnoloSi•l
••1'111,
aad
•terial
tau-
...
a baaio
lCn~
ooa11r.
ot CNl'TUt 14-e• 1a 1..-
e diNuuiOll
bacqrGWICI to 1:hia eDQUir,J iDto
1ih• lfNolithic
1a
Brite iJle
SwthVD
llloat 1.DtlueaU.l
tora the baaia
emaac Qp0l.01tata
J.G.D.C1-rk,
baa bNa
e114 Illa idea•
ot aode111cliacuaatoaa.
Ill 19)6, Clark 4iatilapiabe4
WO •ill
p-Gllll8
wittai.D tbe •orth
l\ll"OpeeD
».olithlo.
l)
1 .AJCe
2}
• Mlorolitbic
._,
p-oap,
~n,
..
ot セ@
cul.cur•
lowland
toreat
ot "-11•.. 1111
an.a
aul.tl&Na
1a \he tiret
11"0Q ••
!ARDIIIOlBIAR• And aaaequ•tl.7
aul.wre ....
ier1111 tor 1-.er
ea uori.bllnd
er.a'
and lt:Sghlealll •
the
,-J:'9,Clark:
tend.llOloa,
ar-P
,oa ...
aodel'II
1'7 ...
2)
BLAim ANDftAPEJ
aurd.•>..
diaUDft
au-.••
iJrtllruW.7 •1 •
ot
that
1aa 1a di.at~
tiOlll*WD' ta 'lib• l:itbio
W
the 41ffeNDC•
aloeel.7
betiWeea tbla an
•••ca,loooupat:S.am or waari.•
e'b\lDCMNeot Ulpl..-te
'b7 tbe -.paraUTe
1fld.olaere
• wi tb aub-grOlqa
DWSftIE
Ntle°'i-
111.i...
ftcel),
••W
calturea
, .. nl.17 agreet
The
cwar tbe
•ork•n•
.wAGLIMCBUJt
- aad relatecl
•114
act ....i,
tao
\beae
Arabaeoloa
Id.a •rliar,
tr-1't ll"Ollf tU'IIII (• ..
l)
It aaw .....
\Jae aNCIIICl
......
(1958, 19'5) hit• remn.4
eDCl propoeed
u
tenet....,••
to••
ea tbe beat.a ot 4nel.Opae.Dta 1a :aaropean MNoli*o
paat torl,1
and
tl&• MACLII031Allt
u i.-~
lb• Bl.94e aD4 Tnpeae ar011Pan
ot •terl.al
troa the Bla .. aA4 Tnpeae
ot 'boDe, antler,
au1lili}aa..
al"NaJ wld.le ait•
..
real
"17 aUua-4
OD
ll'CIQ8
am wood., ••
Jfagl...,.:ua
ot the •ri.-
aitee
taci•
•1147 aolla be .....
a
•N
ot
0 elld
u.
,ex.
o.:o.
pnl1117 end•
Ill
CN
m ltoth
セ@
•VODCa1arolitbio
ere obentr\maecl
lt7
all
eltlleD.t 1lr tbe tl1D11tOl'ke
e'lleenoe ot
,0
Blade
-'\
,/
I '7
'-""
•
.., ..., ,_,--, ___
,,'
.,,, ,"
Magle mosian
,
•
co
0
FIGURE
industries
1 Tagus 2 Cocina
3 Provencal . 4 Guyenne
5 Breton
6 Ile de Franc e
7 Swiss-S . W. Ger man
8 · N.W. German
9 Polish - ~-:hite .re..issian
10 Pontic
-....-...
,,..., ,,.,,
and trapeze
The Pr;in cip al· 1-:esoli t,hic
cultures
of
(a fter
;1ark
:~urope
1965)
I
I
Ear l y Coastal
b Ohanian
a Larnian
c Danish
d ,;jcanian
e ~ . Swedish
f Gstfold
Azilia n
13.
'
IPOJ:JfflIQIN! AlQ>El W <I' WI
Bae
wt._.tor
11 tenwre
•nbaeolestal
19'SJ Giarllataa 195').
•7
f1I
w11_.
• ...i.,
t.be, ft.abM. and
aDd wUd
buda
'-•*"_.-4,
11P ri.Ter ...
(Clark
19'6) •
a-tm
baft-..
., ...~---
a., ...
pl....,
tna.
r-1.
aloac
tra
a.paa1ta
ot
t1.eldll 1B al.1.uYUl YallQa,
tao .. 'burie4
au.Utie4
..a..
--'111\a
doaaaUo aA4
セ@
ot oanclitiaa
llllaUDc
alld ......
•114 1a • Tariet7
•cr1a
laD4 llllrfa ...........
1-k• b ... , ooUNt ..
'Dlq
aa4 rook llheltere
•l.altc•• Mona•
Jib_.. oondiU.0a.•• DNA fa..-ounbl•,
tbat
IIDft4 altod
c1ri...._
pea\ iJI lapland an.a.
1B ea••
end.,..
wU.c1tru.1111 allCl ••,
aad ewer abaita
uad
1
ot
wild ea, wild pig,
iladi•• tba\
Dllri ..
tra
pDenl
A114ill NIie
1a alao aapl•
for taeir
• •ri.t7
1a peata
eDYira-
1a Ille acmaal alloioe
pthared
abona,
••
t...i....,
セ@
tt.1
en4 tlat
•ou..r-1
teobnoloo•
elk,
'l'h_..
ot 41.aocwered 11, ..
u.,.,
- 4Nclce4•
w
M abeened
mterula
Tb• cliaU'ibutiaD
pri.litariq
••
lllmW red and roe clNr,
..uisa.a •tunllr~
••n••
•••
セ@
4oee aot ....
'flle1r eo•CIIIO' ...
of \Ja.tr
4*U.
.1,...
llaaol.1Udo
or
• tiNot17 or
•CODOIIIIF
at,
peopl••
h8'iDc
4egree •f ocat1aait1
NellllaUala
and
la'\e-Glaot.l
Ute UCIIII itaia, •• to •81
• セ@
••-
wbo OOOQll.elthe laropeaa
poJlllbtiom
,he .. te'bl.iahmelat ot • leolitbic
1.Dd.1reaU7
trca
tM
19'J,
regi-.l
giwa
NN
1a
w ... r117 'be •eleo,tT~·
et plaoe, tltnat, 1, _,
llnil
..
Clark 19"•
,__..1ep11ntael
• uoa1,
DleretoN,
!lle llleoUtbio
_,
1i11Neaadiea
Inarialtl.7
•-na
•cleq•W,
1a
1925, 19Jl, 19J7;
(dlil4e
-....1.a.
-1--.1
•'
Ut....ya
11..UUde
tl'OII
_...,
aa4 flooa old. lani
•••
alao bNII talD4 ill
a-1.ei
•ur-
ill tuta .. ,-ita,
111ola,a
for -.p14i
1a arpaic
or •'-r-
...
depoaita,
loaed
'1i1• ldDd 1a Star Carr,
alt.oup
likeJ
ait•
a<ae well-drailled
ti.aer
anil Star Carr,
19.)7, 19~
(Pequarl
aiallar
m.a.a.. lt
~( tll9111b an
.beip\
oo.aioMl
lllilat
1
•
llkeletal
-u
1, ta
.~.
alld
NlliltGiiall\7
The queaU.•
fnol.oaiaal
•vca•iecl to
_..,
NIN
tra4iti_,
tlallffel",
-.i.m
Dantoa,
(.Abllrser,
it aot aotu.l
clla00t'ere4 1a a MaoliW.•
.. 11:b t.he 4-4
buried
et Star Carr.
-11,
••re
augg•~
akeletal
l'l'OII ~•
.,.rJilla troa 5' to .51 Je.• in ,
"1 th proportiona tel7 -11
ot aten4e4 buriala
it •1
tlaat he ••
-..
Here, antlera
•PJllll•') ,
tau4
llancla and
r .. ,.
in bark baYe bND na~
wnppe4
BalUo proriJIOe {Clark 1965).
troll ~•
oONnd
h•••bNA
•
u'f'e-..
reaaim
th•• people
that
.,..,..
ot •IIP tirta
off \he OOM\ of .8r1*9111Q'
to '\he •proto-lllgl..-ua•
appeara
ohert and the
.tauDdi alld at Bolaa .. :rd (Dews)
ba1'e b"n
•
o•terle
tnditl-
•1111.Ytu.at,
in SoutberD
Tm.eo and Hoidl•
akeletial
(latr'.fardeDOUiall)
or ea••
In the •jority
ple tton11 Pl"'INlllllla°ltl7indicate U.Ti»c areea,
•••J wblle, . at
t.n
lmt or
apland aii:•
ot
a:uta.
or baael
ot a..iltap
Partlbe._) 1he rwinll
the remaim
n1na,
AA ou.,1iataDding aite
19~.
b.a••
auniTe4,
reaina
to oantaiD the carbom.•ed ah.Ua
OIi
at affda etc.
oaab•
on aoee Britia.b
bNA t'OWl4: work ..
•••
1n Yorkahi.N (Clark
onlJ MD-orpld.o
b.oa... er,
ot' renim
or l»rk,
rolla
anUer,
boae,
• .. 1a. ariety
or Maeoli\hic
naiDII
traa tbe
~• illterre4
ot at.tun
ettioi-'17
••wli•ot
wrtiere,
anvere,
ot »..U
lithle
ibia
cloea aot prcwe
flu•
tit
peraon, ao, ao • laraar
aaocu,e4
1a a ...
YGe4
wtt.b tll1a period
ha~e
ot llluaUJ:ac
tri'bea witil cliff-
ww••t.
puabing into MII 1-nda and 1.DMl"ldll&liltc witb aae another.
whetbar thM•
tri.Na
babitualq
reaged
ovv long <liaiano•
\hey 11ere eoatent wi 1ib aore aoatiM4 mm Ung grouncta, then
iulaiJII at
tool.a
tliat
.na \ltiliae4
tbie .. palati-
reaaiJIII
wid•pna4
ot oer\eiD
lb.ilat
lad.'N9
ta 11h•baD4 ot • wll
IIOltility
~.
.ta BritaiA haTe 'beell clia•
aDd ain
abapiag
(Balle• l96os 14,),
•uca•tt••
'-' ...
flt
_.
pn9em.
It co-14 'be
•l"P•tb.t
».o.1.Ubio
-•,
or a.t.bff
ia no aun •.1
Jmlltiag
a ..._.
ot
waald aot IMt ilwol"ffCl •• bi• anc•tora
lend teuna,
ot ateppe h_...
laqr-d1a'8110e ad.graticma t,7Ploal
•twU.e•
ot Ralllti.De (195')
it
u •• well
_.
to b•r
iclaa elld -~
reglolllf
taa.pendeaU.y
ar \b.roqp
or •pr•41.Dg
ot ir1u1
'by Tirtue
••• ou1,un117 4egenenk
,-;-10,
•U. ...
ta
tile Meaol.1\Jde ta
ciultunl
a.u.ahed
aarici"'•
preteoe
(•••
8Dcl aab.n&••
p.z:Ui,
aDd Clark'•
19}2J alao Barrima
....
ot tba FnDOG""Call11altriaa
Upper PalaeoUW..
detiAitt.om
19s,.).
M•oU~o
\be"
Clark
'bo1a wezreebanneriaecl
•••
ot tunctia1111l raeo... 19,
•uu•Una
growada tor
tile e11Ure Pal.eol.iUdo
•
C1Yil1Ntl•'
ff·-
lllurt ......
(•
i& a ....
'!he 111111'-r01vru ..
•P1- aad
•iailar
1a
..
or
••
•••
wna propcae4
(tacludinc
peri-4
A•r
-·
mbi'-"
aul.et.l
IICIIIID
aapiem).
pa,atqa• am iatellipllee
'•'II•'
be1ra ·to tbia B.wa~r Cirtu.aa,1aa.,
nalll.
u.._
to セ@
--.
dcwtman
a...-n tl•
etb°''
»aaolU.bio
•t
or tlwir
witb
etbaa
of the M....iJ.thi•
aa.pe IQ'tiAn&lerl.7, ~•
world
The •ill
• paelU..
trib•
,....
4itterenoe
•
parallel
QOII
tbe progreeaiTe
._..
'° the
••WZ'II
oi-n.11.•U.-.
w
lh• po1a,
period
dittv-
attua U..
ot .anlao'iloa.
CiY1.U..'1oll
it bad bel.4 tor ai: l•••
ot
tJnariallly
ia ,11at lt NJlN8eDU,
end of tbe llllllter
1a
etboe
!Mir
llOClera eU.oa 1a be ...
'111111a
'tiben •••
•r11t•
ao •••
0m ot 1ih• Sla_...'8
Koztl'.1•'
llalltera
am cli4, not eDOOWl'-r •'Al etboe ftr7
mmti.Dc
ia i.
of to.7.
(Boao
aDtllropoi. ..
ahOWIIti.t
ffi4enc•
wbil,a._ セ@
ap-iall tu.re a nd pel'IIIIIMD'Iae\tleaen1a1e
PJ"N•t.-da1
the .._ol.itllio
of tool-kiDC
to ...
• lllani»a and pt:laerUtc,
..,,, or aapertor
ot the
in.,.• (1'es..l.-r4 a. Cba,rclUa 19591 190) •
or • ...
'11•
OOllt•t•
"9liatio
u.••••
1'),
b7 U.U. a l9'oa
~r
•nl7
IINoUtbio ) are toi-sc,twa, •114 *h• 1111ol•naardecl •• t.he l.it.-apaa
'llmtw
.jqe
It tile •t-
of llf••
•7
•A
obllen-
It 1a aul•dilll
lty a banter-ptilerw
セ@
.. ent
titt
tbrougbmt
lMJrTallinCor •nn berler
\o lte 110 adequate
ao,
warl4 ot Meiaolithio .. ,.,
were perbapa oaiable
.,.....,
セ@
to the cODtftrJ•
1a 1ibe ~-
-.be ...SU of aul~l
There ....
But the litholoSical
are perbapa auggMii••
ill ld.nd ~i
1D toUowiltg tba
._..
w
ill .
•• till•
.UUan
7•:re•
PAnU
BlCK'2UU> !O VJBO!r.I11UC8TUDID
16.
<r IPQLJfflICSTQDJW
D swr,pnHRJWI
M Pll59f¥P'
».oli\bio
Arohaeol.aa7 teDIII to be -1.uaiv..
allCl ••U7
wid•ll!"9cli
IIIIIIUJta tor 'P)&IO' tliau
..
Britd.11,
It
ot fliat
a Aiatclry
u
a U.tu.
IIGN
セ@
ot
the
OIM.1"
pnnioal
buladred 1r.re
CMD •
"81lA look:1Ri at aurfaoe
and eniquariallll
U't.a latereai;
aad •o
real-
Arcba•ol.oa
areaa wita. •• eDtbuaia••
m••tCMIDdtbeir
8aae eollHUOIIII
Baa:1..-\loa.
Many
ao wp-to-date
lie Wiuly
of tlinta
tor 'tliDUJJC'•
!Ida
•7
into
--.,
aw,e~
baYe
04J.t"
ta Soll~
eacl
w
tbe t•
obange
r•••
ua h
uat
Purtherw,re,
recorta
a..
a..
tor
and are aftU.ble
•9117•
ta.at
tbare
1a
and lleJIU"9
procae41.rap encl IIDDOp'llplla.
セ@
aboll't their
pat
c1i.ac0ftl"i•
ia aot the tarritar.,
to kJIOIJwtw t •rl.y
ot
4:iaooverere
eal
ti.Ddll aDd what tbe, cGD114erecl iaporlant..
1lbat they loakei
deteraiMd
and the
.._..Ilda
1ibeD
tbe :W.olitld.o
--
But it ia alao valuable
peper.
wi 1b aot.u.-
Coa~U7,
work, and •udl anatinc
ia•t
ot thia
ot oaaplU.ag • liat
•u.oo••n•
CID.17lMgua
ua jouraala,
awtMrN
Ua• preaut
ha•
ba"l'e b .. n loat er aeoret.S
aocCUl\
'lb• ••
tlleir
~,
arabaeolqsiata
- Soutl'r .. at Jhal,aad
lll)OII
k•P' • a a1u,1Gll
ot iJagreat..
1a SGIRhera
•i.Dc•
·- teur
••t.•kllollledp or Uae cliatribu\toa and netu.re ot
Br1ta1D •• for1-. r•W
tU.nt oolleotioa
ta.••'Nell
aliadata
Z7•
ooaurrenoea
la pniclM.ar
laold,IIS•
uahrita1JI ••
Sinoe
ocilliled tb••
totally
GPNMicm
1a DN ....
diaGOYU7
clitt'Ulle •114
an
ait•
Meaol.ttbio
ot Meaolitbio
it baa 'been tbe •l.lllte.,
......
•..W.orka and
reoopiMble
abwt 1920, blollletp
IA faet uW
.fiDdll an
tor am
•u, tha., ul \ila
tel7
n,POl"\ede
'?banter.
aeleetin,
an a\'-,pt
aNOUllt
u
ua.
ot M•ol.i*-•
here ,o 1i•• • chrcmolo1ioel,
rea•Nb
iJa S.thern
m1:b1a,
it ld.pl7
\Uldarll.'d91
Uae
17.
ot idea•
aw.i.,..n,
of tntenat
•Dd nifta
baTe eupe4 ._oliWo
•hiab
•'1ad.i•·
ltEk Wt991F1Me l87z:1903
The laat
quarter
...,...1ooal
iateNat
111*••'
aND
'° cietin1tive
_._..
~-n1111
._..
c.n_..u7,
reatr4ed ..
The •rl.7 Jal'9
'P7PIJ Pvl .. '
....a
la *•'1W.e
•·•·o.•v
ta
l,Ol
&.Colle.,
Jara
(1,0})
ill tbe hDP:lDN•
•rob
(••I•
188};
tlDal ot Tflr1 ••ll
tb•
uoaeoloe,•
al,T•
...
•7 be
tU.at
•
ta.
the
.u..
t:M
1...,.117
aw.l
PiMII ....
a aPtMd,al ...
pa, t...-rd
illll»W
wla t
•ric
'PJIIFIJ
fliata'•
._,
ra .. , iA tan 'P,Jpd..a9'• Die ....
clhd•H.••
Pl.ti-tiYere
'leolitaic'•
..._.rdecl .. 'lleolit.ad.o', ltut
1 ..
baaevw,
190.W.i:
ot \)le 111"•-'oen,-,
'At 'Frnr' brtds
illol.._
•co11 .. ~·
publiaatt.aa
ot
• rnolutioa
and lleColl.ey Mll.roll aDd •••B•S1&tclitte
188', 1897)•
Sutol.i.tte
J.rl7
anlquari••
t .,.iam,
ill SOlltb'- ..
And
ot the m.nateentb oe111iur., •rked
*97
_..
-.
!Ila
wcrk ot •
•Wilk and peretaW,
1ibe QJOloal•l
--.eDet'7
aD4
et~
bpl--·
la 1,12, B•Witt•
117 •of'Mld.lla
and .....
,__.
u.a 'llidc•'
re.. ••
And
a.,v
セ@
._..
anial
But the iat'luenU.l
)a_.., ••• )
1
,-r,
aDll reterri..Dc
aNociaW
la aiaiat_...
セ@
i.wttaa
wt.ill 'aeol.itbll' (Na~,
(acvt Dawkia l9U).
n ....
a11 •r11
..
to th .. •• ,._olitaio•.
'Pn,rq', Jl'OpGaN an
Prot_.or
ot P7P!1
...
•ra11 c1,12) ...-
tlualll' • •UCP9UJII tbat 1ibeir llllikere ....
(1912), atallllina 'bJ Ille , ...
1"11Ulio
lb•
tor breakilll the
iapl......_
In the --
akime
leo.U1ild.o illba'bitaata,
Palaeoli~a.
'-7
•• Iel°t ot • a•i'-
•i.-tDI ••
Pliata,
tor
..S Parker aclftMe4 • \IIU:J
•DO•t17
in ta.
4eolaNCl ~,
lmiT•,
affOlf-
18.
Tbf lfgiDDing
o( S;pH9tic
セ@
, oUoaing
1,QDlilahing ~ei.r
/
-.b
•terial,
diaoOftrl.e•
••r
a'hnllt:n
tuture work •••
111Y•rioua
or wllteb r-ined
••
the Pemd.u
induatrt .. , wbich he teraed
du tina\lon
la at ill
in general
to ••• P9md.ne ll•olithio
ot 'Prance ell4 Belgiatteohe4
to oerlaia
§R9D1"9
flP41 •P4 ftRme
Br i,tialll
Pnri.oual.7, litUe
prlnc!ple
ot wo ••pent.
Perllapa bi.a
p-oupa
Morecwer, ~1.,
with tha Tarclenc.tabn
until
..
•aona
.ad •11·arro11 Blade'•
accepted.
Thia
Wd
ia4uatri
tile
..
beoa•
1955).
1,955 (Clark
19Ji:9
at,apt
bad been mcla 'Co llllderatand
Ill l9.J2, .1eG..O.C1-ric pmliahed
.
bad beaa •d•
h1a Ca!lllbridce セ@
the widenoe
to briJ:lg tog•lber
.. ta.
tb• •:id•
TM.a •••
variet7
tbe tira't
ot lliellolit.bic
\
tiaa.
la tbu
•de
country
.
and aubjeot
and 41.aoower:I.• blve IIOl'td on
· on the ... oli1aio
•Dd autaori'tative
replar
aiiandard
et
euawt.iOD
CJ..rk'•
atudi•
eentnl
the me••
\riea
period.
'tba
•inc•than,
(19,J,
oontribu.tiom
ecMld b• ezplained
retennc•
AltilCllll,b idea•
atudy.
the at.Dda.1,1 •Olk
atill
initul
t.bia
ahlll1 .-ttb
19)6 ) J • nd 1ntrod.l,oe4 • laigb
19)9) •
ot th• Bri.tiab
to ooatiMDtal
In tba •ln,
, nature,
•nd clia'tributionel
the ot.recteri•'tic:111
with
boGlc 1a
{l~l*• l9l5,
wan of a 'tJPOl,ogical
that
thi9
He tolla.ed
1a lirit.tn.
1.Dto hia work
to ceretul
an4 tbe
lleaoU.thlc
wenta•
1
au.rpruinal7
1921e,), and the 1-b-1 'Ter4enou1aa'
iladuatn
ptittll
dead.ea ot aurta..-.ollediltc•
1i .. 11ec1ha
tille aa • ~t
1IIIC1ertaie Pellld.ne
'Broe4 Blade'
• ttiniti•
(Budtley
1n the Penni_.•
~ley
(Bllckley 1921-,9).
Ida reoopition
1
• • •••
am b• oaabine<l both •U;b.
orer •DY ,-re
NIIII 1-Por'a• contr1butioa
'1:17iJMliYidl&ala
loa\.
JIOlf
•1•
•ad .-,en uaw'Hd
atand9rd
ot ' Jd,lioet1GD
tm't
ta
and
'
oollecRiom
•\
and .all.Nbra
t. the work ot Pnnoia
tboup •rdl..T Yff7 •otentif'icallyf
bigb
a.rri•d
Jauual••
uapmliab-4
intreat
Of oonaid..,.ble
Be •de
lorld
tint
1918-32
Stw\Je
111dui9-
'.lb• pt"ofOIIDII
1.At'lu.eDGetbat
mve aerca
ideaa
Clark'•
..,...,..al_,
t
1
ot • lleaolitbio
-~
P9riod proper l»eoa•
'P7PIJ1'liJ11ia'
period
'n'1a ...
•ynhea••
lithie
elao •rlced
hi•
pabliabecl
P.i*'
11a Pollera ADalyaia,
Ulitiated
•im
lnglend
!be period
ue 1952,
nato-1
Clart
efter
ot
Jfl8r Dire WUtrecl
.....
••
ot 8urre7.
the groatnc
s.m.... t
Cleric'• notiom
194.,.5.._,. the atemi•
••
n.nda ot orpllio
ta addiUen,
w
Meao-
ot oaattaeat.l
{CodlliA a114 Godlrin,
of a,at ..
tic
re-
GOaTati•
19JJ).
(la*I end
prolitenteda
'1'11•._oUWc
••1tl••nt
hia
wbeN1a7 preeiae
artat.ctial
ot in&aatrial
a.n extam1Te
and cliaV'iwUOII
aae
ot Meaoli:tbio
(1951, 19,.._, 195'), WM
b7 i .J.l.aaktM
• aya\ea
f1eldlro.rk
•in
c!i•tributtou
aotiT1ty
(1961, 19'6) baa
ot South- .. at Dial•Dd ••• the •ubJe.,..
.attera
a"-adiN ov•r •a.J y•ra
t.avoehloed into
lllddl•
allffq
19S,.., HiUI 1959, •YDN" 1962, Roclle7 aid Mellal'9 l~J
•tudiea
ot turUi.-
det.Ued
tnduatri•
tar the Britiall M11ol.ithic lDbtrt.ea
ettuiti.M
Le•Ul•
•IIPl'OI"
lent
and the J9Ul
•n4 WOCklh•d in the Pom.NI,
'b7 Sntan
111>
by other work.era.
aU.om
and 1a セ@
lngl.aad;
aulNlequntl.7 t.ken
fNIII ••._,.
tile
ot • llllllber ot nglonal
tor Meaolitbio r••roh
•till
Jlore eipltioant
aub-
tat
· aonpted.,
the tiret
'11• al.croli\hio
OIi
ta •oae
1a,
aree• ot
4eU.llit
geaenU,
eppeennce
~.
prwidecl
1D Northern
latez. •ork•N
q\lOahecl.
ID 19)3, A.Retatris
datri'butloa
セ@
f1Mll1
'
t ot Clark.•• ettoru
a• • r.-1
ia larael7
upOD
-.ad
.. to
•inc•thaae 14••haft
••J8,セN@
aoU•
..
Talua'ble
recarded
a..
cow.aセ@ ••
•loag
~.
.....
and a.8'
In aore recent
and d-'eilecl
induatri•
ot tremen
appreoi•
7•"•
ot ••
a,udi•
u..
.A.D.
v,o1oa
bfallka ot \be La11er •114
'l'ba ....
Tm M•ol.i~o
••J... ot
pepen
induatri•
or Sauth-w•t
b 1 c;.J'.1.1mrrigb,
(l9'o,
Jng l• ad encl Vrfll•
196J).
Vlbilat
laft
J.s.•u.•
bND the
(19'0)
20.
'
•nd 1841.ey ,..a •U.ra
(196.la.
) UTe awu.ria.a
~.
fficlenc.
f1oaa 1:be
Pennl,,...
ID •ll
,.,..
tibia,
ot ita auwc-•4
*re
aDd
a
caatindal
1.NDCl••7
troll natriotiTe
••clUJ1.llonaaina
Redle, 19'8• aDd. SiWPN,
aa •ppND1.
will:l•••
tdeaa, •Dd to
eor-•
n...
aD4 a.l•
amloguea,
the BriU.ah ... olitbio
ma pereiatecl
vi,ologt•l
11po11
1"9).
Aloaa wttll tbee• dnelopaau.
•
セ@
\he brit1.M
19'8J Si-
Pllri ot aoae woritera
M•ol:l.Uli•
1969) •
Thffe
1a IIOlf
at.udaa,
ell4 cliatribu.U..l
-a-•ia
M0101toal
ill
(Clark 1955)•
911J)bM18 oen be DOted.
• ohenge 1A Nl9•roh
NNDtl.7t
• diau.an
the ten4ency to Yi ..
b•ner,
••peot.a (~•ef •' al 19'5J
'° 11on ••7
:la 11a an. t.era.
tbtrre ta
tJ"GII atandarcl
(W•iariabt
19,,J
'
'
IIFtUPJWc G&WSP
PWJNw
ffll W2fl,tWtls MIRPill
JWt::<UGWt
, g.,_..ll-r
!be ..
la tbat
ot ~t
iariaa
,-t
la ......
aclhae
•114 Sfflllllllder
bc:1111•M
L• wn Pat
bill are atUl
o.bn .. crteria.S
Clll
the }:lent •o.rotouila
nalae•
aliatic
or the vegetatl.oa
AJarl
ilato
X.'41r, 111
ot theM tiYe
poll.ea aaa.a
1ibe atallllar4
tola.r (t'11•2).
ill SoeDll-
obaern4
41vicJed tm Pollt-glaoul
tlaq
'b7 a 41ttereat
GGDtirmN the chareoter
aooepW
..
ia-otu ...
1JI audl
ot the PmPglaoul
atntipa~
ot obaen.U
111• aoa aD4U'imUom
pert.ocla; ...
tar aub-clinaioll
baaed oa ~.
1
a na\llt
i-•1¥1-.....
1••
tiYe Pffloc1a, ••
1,1'.
faallur
••'bllabet
b7
or ... ie'8U
troa the aMUiaa
,t
Le~ei.al
1ie ._
aequenoe,
et Ula ••lap-1
iapliaa'1.0lla ot ••
TM 'bcNlldarl•
W
1-e•
•artb-w•t
ooaai_..ble
et.Mel -
aM tClilllldMM
radiWl"NII,
911111there
1a a tiaa-a•l•
'DI• Le•slaeul/Poet-gleeul
Ial•
ebal9 t.b• gndual
4~11\
1a
clnelo~t
WOU&htto
aD
after lcae Yin
Nlli-1
ditt ......... , ot Y-,.'8tianel
ot ••'•
aot1Y1ti•
'!be 11,era"1re
Yi~
la
4itt---'
llllit'C11'111~7ot pollu
elflaliom
••
4iagre•
4iffeNDt
......
poll•
....
llroecll7 ap1ha
-
o, teapente
41eeidlloull
1.aterterene..
••W.uhea
•••
.....
.,..ra••• •
ill 'ndioearltoll
•••W.ubect1a
aot b••
the Bri.'i.ab
ror.-, •t *b1a
A wit.q
appUaaW.e
beoeuae ot the J.oaal
111.atory 1rlaing
troa the 'ftria'bUU.r
•reaa•
oa 1:llia peri.o&
lt7 OcmiJI (1956) 1 l' •t
baa bMa aeo••l'7
pollen ....
eDd lt,r am.a
acaatl•
hu
v•s•u-
LaM-.laoul/Pm•~otal
• ._ • .._
Jurope.
reillterpretaUoD
1a .,..atJ 'but OOIWeaiMt
(19'8 ) I aDClPelalJtctoD
(19'9) •
troa 41.:tt...-.nt real-
•-i•a~~.
,._ri.
an
'Ille .....
ot Brit.ta.
4itt...-
セ@
1
ot pollen zonauoa.
•,ate
Piglare 2 giY•
curaoir-
yepiatioaal
•iJI
~.
ert.aUaa ot tile pollen sonea ta an,laD4 all4 ... 1 ••
WM ,__...
of tb~
loae II (All•~
teQOnrll.,J
¥1'19 (Be-1.a
larq
·
aboa
•PP.)
•ri:• the boandar:,
D• zor;, IIIfty JrcNndprz
- o~eau.oa.u,
pm.oat, •• ibe lnel
alld Poa~oial
Le\e,laa:Lal
ot laerbeoeoua pollena oalnoid• with•
peroenta1•
or .AP, s-11.l--
pcsa81ltac•
ld.abR
•aa.
be-..
talla
wheN •tMp
iJI tbe
ia jyp1ps:
atHP rue
,•i.•).
laclioearlMa claW
'tra•itiOII'
llea:ial
ror
tall
Ol'palO
wit.bi•
relatt.ac to the uatrglaetal/Poatl-
•t~
'\be cdur.:,,
a.c.
8J()0-8200
(n..).
IRW I 114Y,I CJQl6L
fPJgp) i
all!OU.Dia et hir,b polle11 1 an4 aa llloJW•e
Zone YI ••
., .... aub-dina.4
SA tlM eNo1.ute
••1- ot re1..u.,.
•.-
on ••
frequeac!.••
ffelti (C..,rlua) reaohea
Jaftiaularl.,J
ia &he •uooee4ina iilicl-Boreal
li-1•
aaauntl
ot
..IYI(Ulaia
•peaal.1-,
Sa Ml•
Sc1atber11 Britaua
Vff7 ldp
NftNII
propoi
(n.)
clitt81"ent
,1• ot .BIie
1aaa ill ~.
tot.la
(VI.a)•
.91.i(Qureua)
acre lii&Mii"laDt セ@
1-NOM p.qp11ai"¥el.7
Som YarlaU•
) and
treq11a11a;J of
But
RJ.!1.
ta po>l•
111late loae Y, •114
el~l.7
are ~-,
Sa VIa •P....-
at a-.
ait•,
...
the Bo!wle
~$
セ@
of 8riteill
pille as:1-
nortb (no).
••
be illOtM la
ooaww •rl
z-. n.
ier tn
ab•»a•ia
alyr
ubiqld.taual7
arlce4
ia pollen
•Ill!•4eeru••
(alaaa) pollen,
Im Wt <Afld!fICf1RI9P)a
troll
•it•
to aite
-
ot ,mat
apectra
iJl poll&
of tbe .AU.Dtio
Rail
001111'\17'tb-, 1.Ddioate deciduoua tor•t:
ell;
•hena•:116•.&
)1Elb ua th• nortb-w•t,
trequencd.•
are
w-miD14
lowland
YW,
lial
and
but
•r-•,
aa ...
period•
OT•
uauorm.v
ot ••
-i
DQt to be repr•en'\ed
1n the •GA1ih-••t.
a'\
witll
percot.pa,
BerbaoeOll8 poll•
...-.u
aa.ove aa.1200• aa4 la
•
•ree•
OI\ pl.~11
ot
clegr,M
(TUia ) toiw •i&Diticiant
but litUe
lar;
trequeDCid•
1a • NUrkabl•
then
1.JlorM••
la
'by • very gr,Nt
41.llgn•
peat-tormllrc ln,rp harya aAd .lllberm
alld4eaq
~---~"-
or
quell01•
ltonel
nn
s •rk• the
Tbia 4eeline
period.
A, G. 1,'1 ) •
{Salta,
_... •• ia t.b• pollen
UC,0Xt.a,
1a taken••
1)
Th• wlicJi
v
no-
ot pollen
la"l"WWare apGl"llcli.•117
of heted
(•••
'1la
fltntago ltnsm11
alli
ta-
•11icla 1a ..
aod •rly
Blata_.
atteapta
have 'been q11•ti-.cl
apeotn
cir
1~,
1
alld tbe baualary
beill.-
•one boalldar1••
r.otcara baYe to 'be iak•
llllliber ot ~nt
..._
ot the i.~glaoal/Poet•glaoial
interpre~tion
ol.i•U•
..
11¥e ocG111pt1ue4'b7 .»
in Zonee VIIb •114 Vlll
ta aare OMCNN \ban •rlier
• s,arti.i.r
be-.
allb-
grGIIDI).
Opell
aonee ta b7 u meanaatffigllt.tor...rcU
wi~
1a um
1a Ptrlicvlar
ia eantU.e4
Dae ecological
tbe boualery
Tbe elr4ecl1Jle
ot berbe,
Ul4iaa tor ot
1'1da p.~
thNe a-..
ot the A U..Atio ond the 'beainDi!II ot ••
end
into
end d.iaga•
aya\wtia"-7
242-J).
poll•
oornlat.tng
•re
~·
ocmaidftat.iolla
ta DeTer allaolut ..
i.ntroduoed. 'by • ftrlat7
••
HIii
.a.
2)
'!he etendard
percentage
pl211nte -t
ot one or •nenl
Hitherto
'4,"81 oount ot ei Uier tot.al
pollen
.Abaolute Pollen
employing
ot Nab apeoi ..
per aquare
are l•••
.Aocording to ITeraen
th••proTiaoa,
V.itb
ot eoologicel
1"oz"lirit&in
earl7
ah.811&••
the JDcliah
162).
wt
ha.n·er,
ran l,Srellel.
clwnge NOOrded b7
aocoan,
or the
tor clin11 tic ••olutioa
of ur1De
and la.nd
.Accordingl7,
it
seua
anel.J8i.•
that
Th• iaree••
,u, セ@
to 1.DdiGllte • · tu,porer,
ation
Jncblld•
therm>l'.b1.leu11 treM
percent.pa
aMliontiaD
ot the 1r.z.m..11 t~.
Iveraen
•ua••
U...
beta•en
JngU.ab and Dtlliah
re11•0118ble to make uae ot
iind winter
&Ut119r
ot the occurrence
j
I
ot 1ibe pollen of' c•rt.in
moHu.s.c:.5
at nrioua
tNtPentur•
and ahruba (Ivereen
end btrclh parkland
a J~
1A
\eaperatur•
Yege1illt10II 099:r ..
of! l.J
0
•
0
p119t
bop
195'1)•
ia tonat
r•ultiDg
t-.v
apll
in Zeme U (J.ll•J:)64) 18 gene.Uy
ot oli•t.,
oCNl'9e
1a BOlll"'M
\he conatency of the relotionahip
beaed on oaretul
•
pollen
no more '1lan • au.ocMaioD
eou
IvwaeD' • deduotiODB reg11rd1ng the YEsratiODB or
in セL@
(•••
irioet Briti.ab
r-etho4 or abaolute
and Dani.ah v•geta Uon auco .. aiOIIII •ugg•ta
tluotue\iom
enturea
b .. n developecl
y•r•
to giT•
studiaa
haTe prori.ciecl aoae •Tidellc• of pnvailiDg
{a.Dl.•7 l~;
per
nideooe
Occaaionel
•enenlly.
aore aoourete
Recently
repreaenta
1a poeaibl•
Detail.d
or th•••
decline
(1960) mah ot the veget.Uon
it
ot
Ptlet•g l acul.
poUeD profile•
Pont-glacial
produat.ion
the r .. ul ta ea IUlt!i>eraot gni.DII
to thia
11ell aa.pt•d
ate•
be
•• proporti.OIIII or the
Couna t.ve
centimetre
peri0c1a ot the Letrgaciel/
•rly
or AF•
1~69, 42), which upr••
PenniJJgtan
3)
•7
the percentage
ot any abaolute
were •l.moat elw11ya expru1e4
tigurea
protU•
pollen
d•pnU
inffitably
eTen tn the abaen~
plant..
utboaa
or repreeenting
It meena 1'ihltt •n abaol.11'8 increa•• 1n t.he pollen
leeuli.ng.
other
method
taken
reooloair
, of'
lJt. 0 (15° • l,°o
loda7).
:U.at.l.-rl1 tree-line
atudi .. la Sautihero a.r.11,1
•uca-t
Al19
and ••
JuJ.3 ,em.,eN ture dePN99iOll ( 0.•2•S°c) (Blltaer 19'4&
t.DalQi0\18
wCMld imFl¥t;ba\
th.in during
the
.1ul.Jtuapeniturea
ueill li~"
Cliate
6°c •l"'Mr
were ,• -
rathw
•••
a11
-.0,) •
'fhia
duriDg .aae All•-4
oonUnental
alld pouibl7
an
the dr7 aid ..
In Zeme III ( lOUDgtir ~;,a•) lfJ.P domin.ttW poll•
•rk1Da a cliat'l.o
deteriontioll;
and audclell and ctraatic
!he nnel
with
at gnu ...
flllJ1 w-11 ha,re be.za • h•tb
Brita1D
a rapid
OM •
ot 'Mll,Pentl&n
woodlaild or tO.l".. t replaoiaa
Juat aow.rapid er .b,aa proloJ:lced ••
Th• palaeobO-.nical
(I•vae11 lj5't,),
Britei.n.
.wt mcb ot the Tqetation
a
protU ..
not i.JltlicatiTe
the neturol
repr .. entilli
(t.
1 tiea
cbe.ng..
the appeanince
Of 11he Pl'O&r ... iVe warmiq
tn• 1••
apeciea
competition
Bowev.r, dr.ey
in the i 're-Bor•l
<••I•Cllldiam)
inaic•tea
ciuriJiC*II•
'bJ Fre-Boreal
Of climate,
aacl ..._l
80
,o oli•x
("riacwl,}and iY.Y (.eedara; Uadicate
..
e-
a=
'4Nlpenture
Bid
reoor4 1-T• little
tor
reapcnaible
boundary 1• ~ent'ore
• w11rmeluate.
aab
l"ost-glaoial.
the mei.11 .factor
the prMer.ee
et
tor tile •••
Thi.a U not to N7 tl»t.
ne
-.u-.
....
1a uoer'ai.At
from pioneer
clic! not oecur duriaig the •rly
nr,aa ...
'loalgw
• ••ra olua\a
•na• recorded
The rrrBorelll/BoNel
clvllJoi••
iD DeDaPrk
wh-icb eD4e4 'lle
aeoomed by Godlria 195')
)•
••tten4
Ill/If
protu .. • t. the
and maxim ot mal\f ke)" genera in the . pal.le
aigm.tiaance:
vege~ticm
, and crolfb-r.,,
ot ~ture
ve getatiOD auoceaeion
•ncl t'luctu.atiom
mt.tletoe
opu.ion
the aequence ot 1wdgntion
h
clue,ic
aD
ot
veget.tioa
the Pl"ft'aUillg
1ihia ria•
dr-
July telll)lntUN
Mrba oeoua plena.
tZ'CII Denaarlt iapl.1•
eTidenee
Prr!:!orul
then
......
reool'MCl by pollen
the ria•
V.t
bounc'.ary ·~•u
ooueq11entl7
i.trglacul
J\IIUper and wUlow buahea ancl 1ncl,Jd1.DC •Dl'
1.be chanae or vegetation
apectn,
not,
ot therir.opaile
And during
cluatio.
•ter
pl•a1ia
the BorNl,
warmer •Wllf!lere end
•rmer wiJltue
in ~l
am •rk..S
tod6)"~
OD acoc:NDt ot the gel1erf:ll variety
t...,orel
N111Nltl•
end rep.oml
•••
Yarie tiona 1 it
or il
i• not quite
apectre,
ol•r
what eu.U.7
Ver7 111.p ftl.11911 ot C0171.uil llaT• 8QIPll'9cl
the
a Pl"ffal•i
torea,
u•el
ot
pauibUi',J
pi.De aaael
'Die bor•l
セ@
ooeeatc,
then
periocl
or ar,n..a,
u
incN•••
1D alc:ler
ia 3-.r.U1
in I"' 1.Atell , .
1A Britiah
d.ia81"8••
1e
•ter
ore.Uz:ia AeW -111111 land.
lwlal&d
•prea•w~
Uia
'Dae pDeftll7
~t
• tree
mve 'bNII
ezplaaat1•
aocepW
wla1ala ooamw et
poll•,
a.n 1DcN¥••
r...i-...
1A 00Mat.oi•7
ta
by • riae
p-GIIDlll-
セ@
-.r ... , and 'ni.M4•
DO& ill ~nd
or •.-t
la
er.a.
ot
the tlae
.tDoidiJIC
IIIDllt .tswunble
,eapen1.ur
•lt~
..
2Cc •rMr
•aalagoua
ex~enaicm
'Cli.aaUo
Opttaa•,
or Uma ia Jacl•nd•
( tbsn todoy ) in 8wmer'•
•U111DerTalu..
la Bor1ib-ltea'
lteen n•rdecl
cl1'11"te - the
wU:b the l?liiXiwm Dar'thlr9rda
.Bar .. l ••
•eem ~o •••
•
I••n•
eDCI 0.50c •raer
ct.ractaria
..
la
the 1-te
i ... t.
aenen •• 1"'7 (ltackn)
....
i,riarily
opea to alder,
or babitaw
ot o..ro.eaaoua bla&•t
-.rope ••
•~er;
a
oo•ld.o
e cai.nge to .,..
Al der i•
1be toUG11incAU1111tic i,eriod hB1t aenenll.J
QUOtM
ol.iaat••
t.lawe ••
Bore.l
ill the JalrOilOl"tioaot Jtlau
Midden ~mica
dnelePIIII,
..ur1,1a
the B.A. T. (YICV'1le
•rial
- end thent<:S'9
1a • tairl.7
lnel
n
irl ScNtherll
(•rlier
or ~.
•• tndioati.Dg
4r7 conditiom.
let• .uon.l
lwel.
1aae
with ela and oak
the Pl'M~,
~11
percent.pa
•••n
aidN
tar a -.ery 8li0Cle1&eq.11ei•
• .....-.1
ccap»Uioaa,
t<JllfercJiathe encl
that
11119aDcl atreea
natriewcl
.a.e
be ucludede
•••mnc
to decline
type ot oU.•te
en increeae
( 1...
- ..
oemot
zoae Y; wt
•• aeen in l01tere4 leke 1.-.rela at thu ti.mia.
NUD49r,) I ancl thia
oondiUona
1A
a w111aU7 aoaai.4el'9Cl to haw bad • leu
i,eriod
ia ffider.oe
anat
A veq
pla ...
elld pine
ocntin.ntetl
Cene~
U..
ot ah1n:1n& tone,
inoNaaiD& ill prGpQtti ..
Britaia) •
a.t セ@
w~ndll
セ@
to bew Men •
appeen
airab, •veou~
ltelar a oal:IQ7 ot p1m ar
Hnlb
3nd <'·
reat
or .Uder
aore indioative
•edge (Cbdi\111 ... n.aeu11) noted ta Dealirk•
winter
te~turd
tlvin opti.ala
•~
\eaapenturMe
O.k end ela et'-in
ve1etet1oa
baa , ...
•
4z7 lalld
cleaoribe4
proainenoe
bebit•ta
in At1-ntic
a..,ectn.
a termed 'llu•4
•• tbe • oliat.t.c
cl.1•••'Agete
Tbe ,....,.1
o. ...Poreat•
AtlaaU.o
(LO ••• ), •114
Uoa ot Bri ta ta.
._..
27.
aecva,.i.r
.
}4rbepa,
1., abaul.4 be aeen ••
t..tiOD
•IM;(; ...
11-0.,.
oen be riaualaeci
iaD under e.c-l,«'CICi,qt.ely oODDtant climatic
ela and li.all,
~.
a• in pl.,cea
Ou striking
to tla~
chaus•
ot blanket
lihe Atuntic
durins
bog on ~a•u
oover wer &ll the dry lead,
toreat
are lik.el_y to
open ubit.'8
•:.art
aoun\aim,
hi&,b•t
ar.o~ decline
duouaaioa
abOllt
ot J.olitbic
or •holly
men, which atart.
in particuler
ot oi,en ground;
eaaoouted
1a wnu,lly
Atl•n•a,
and the110 char:g ..
CCllll)CIBition in
bireb
~-•;
topogreilQ'
•••
••re
!hia
analogoua
ltu, wi.liter
acniTiU.
thia
1.Dcr•••
SA tu
which 1a nn inrporlant
ti)Acn to india.••
ere
c:ri&iJl,
OOCU1TeDDe
at a~t
bJ an
セ@
a1m
1• or cliatio
ot the agriO\lltl.ll'al
•oo~rd.ed
continued
retu.rn
in
to • aon
pol.lea
indic»tor
ol•%'9nce
toreat
zc.oeaVIIb
••
mI;
end •t'cer
role ua toreet
1~11t
could be &le to a woreeatng ot cltm'-,
aleo to • woreent»g or aoil eondi ttone.
tba11••
o.D,
2,500'
eetivity•
tandea to
aenenl•
the ettHt
1-nceol.ata,
Pl..ntligo
with 1,eolithic
-\he ~.aor..l
oontte,oua
There baa b ...
- whe\her it
to lte of •iciea~r•d
1'1• p!"oe.. • of a.roreatation
tb•
&
or ela J)Oll.en mrka -the eni ot
i'requ.enoi•
\he ca:.we ot thi.a decline
Th.a ela-deoli.Jl-,
hene,
ie
LiJacola-
elld the to119 ot iM
ca.ata
troa cer1i•1D are.a where loa.l
i.D tbe
or whether it ia fer'$l)'
ot
n the ••
eDd the 01•en.1Jag ot the ::iub-.8oreal period.
lttl.antia
ttae.
m•e b ..
end セ@
lnela
ot at l••t
to al1;1twiN
and ot
where topogni,tay 1 ..
then,
}A'riod
ot
to tire• grmtla.
\lnt'.iTounbl.e
A
o.aoo• O.».,
the .:>Quree,
1'he general ooncer,tiOA c,t the .Atu~tic
pl.oee.
the bepmaing
••
11reae "b°"
tor Grtmple,
t1r••'
ill-drained
or
• --.10
ot the DClll"Ul-lt•\, ••
aaat
forrter lake beda ill paz-b ot .8ri'ain
roi.aed 'bop onr
'ftae
conditioa•
oak.wood, 1A plaoee
including
Year
Alder would 'be lll"9dow1nantly the tree of•••
nge"8t1~l
\he dG'Nlopaant
pun
~oea,
:n:ad 1a otl.er
mah b!roh.
oon~~
• tage ot a ~tural
t.be tuael
to thee•
Mlqleratl&Na
SUW1Der
i•penture
ill the Atlantic
._..
0.5°0
ocmclitioa
"•riod
eolder
b•t
•
ia
2°c waraar
(I•ne .. 19~).
.A
E!TGLAND,Um ':l.AL~S
Ti11c
based
Bl·tt llnd
Sernarlder
on C . 14
periods
datin;
vtage
Characteristics
vecctation
Zone
of
''
·
C:
o.,~
.µ
1000
rs
r-i
m
Q)
+>
{.)
H
<l)
0
VIIb
rJ'.l
I
.0
2000
::s
Vl
~ -___...,...
-·
Alnus-,iuerc
-Tilia
H
0
It-!
us
'
Q)
, i::i
Ulmus decline
3000
.
t)
r-i
•rl
+>
rj
•rl
()
セ@
4000
cj
VIIa
m
r-i
+>
r-i
r)
Alnus-'~uercus
-Ulmus-'l'ilia
セ@
.µ
LJ
0
0.
5000
C
-'!'ilia
r-4
d
6000
VI
.
Cl)
l
i"'l
r-1
('j
I
PinusUorylus
b 'iucrcus -
Ul1aus
a
.
7000
8000
Quercus-UJ.mus
Ul:".1.Us
Corylus
V
Gor Jlus - ,;..;ctulu - 1-'inus
IV
l.>otula-l!inua
III
.l:"a.rk'l'undra
II
Betula with park
tundr~.
J
Park Tundr~
et
(l)
G> r..,
f.-4 0
Ot 'l
APrise
9000
•rl
t)
r:J
r-i
t'J
Cl)
+>
ill
...:l
1000()
B. C.
FIGUHE 2.
gequences of main ~eaetational
changes
during the Late Glacial
and Early Post
-elaoial
in England and Wales
(after West 1968)
'
Ivan•'•
1a 0Dl7 b-d!lg ftllli.atie
baa
u
analya .. ore e val1&able oontrilnaUoa;
»elt1•4n...,_.ture
W poi.Al ou.t that prevaili»& ate\eorolagi•l
chenc..
'tblit ieapen"ur•
In contreat
Pea \-glaolal
'to tha large
...
the reindeer
and the taae
ill eiae
re4w:tioa
11nd• tunm
the Lote-alaolal
ha••b"n
I. great
•IIY
world
ea 7et
poa1Uom;
••-lnel
IIO preota•
,
other
~•ir
be taken into
•tmte
to bGlr quiaklJ'
d
period
•Jor
euch aa .U4
apecie•
elk,
auoh •• red
ID .t\HUtca
ti.mea•
pr•em
111
ot tihe 1-raer ••rt•rate
•-le
eocount
pr.-eat
41.atrl.buU•
in c11lcul8ting
are 11an7 poaaible
exiata
of the ~et
t'aJ.l. セ@
'
~• world'•
wit.b \ihe r•nora\ioa
poini
horee,
kiatoJ7•
aDci •o there
c.,.._in
ot toda7,
ia Bolooene .. poaiu.
land
lowered b7 euat.atic
ni4eno•
Th• aal .7
a ,proallieD\; ---lnel
DO
••
<hariDcibe i:,._.,ai,.oul
••·lnel.
ha••to
t•otora
Conaequenily,
Iel ..
cUatributiOI& pat'-rm
uaed to iJRerpre,
dil'tl»c 119at •••laTel
error•
1a Nducecl to that
but •re not r•Pl"•entecl
or data,
et PNYioua i11,erglaot.la
aince X.te-1lacial
ere largel1 · Wlk.nawn. Par aailler
pette.l'DI
on t..t.-glaoul/
or 'biaoa •r• Jmawn to haTe b.-
apec1•
~eriod,
Due to the i:-ucity
apeciu
..1.a
exti.DctiODB tram the Brit:lah
deer have \lndergone
•hi•
large
wild m:1 the wolf alld the b•Ter•
wild pig,
aYailaule
te, knallleci.i o of the eontaJ:'.PC)ra17 r.un. 1a
Th• clwr11oteratic
troa reoeat
eperl
ot 1ntorutiOD
boq
ere not found ia the Holocene;
opiaim
trom t.b• Boraal on..arda lie '1ithua \he renc•
wgeta ,1on and olia
very Umi.ted.
but 1\
•011rC•
ot
aaowit 'b7
glnoiatioaa,
ice •hN'ta
and
Ml\ie4
ot tormer int.ergt.ct.al
or abeal.ute aoreec:ent
riee clurtnc the Pali•g1-clal,
&nd
ia twt
the reMl\;
there
••
ot • oompl.•
b ...
int•rplay
•uata tic riae
af world-wide
?he de LalleJ
aeuilJ&to
cour:s.e. of thi•
refT•ent
ri.ae
nla tiv•
elld sore looeliaed
,..t
to b • agr•ed
ia
IJUuiler of workere (Godwtn, ~uggiite & 'tiilli•
1961,; &lld Shei.,ard A CUrny
be reprded
ateble
1968;.
1958;
b7 •
l96o; J'elgere•
Fairbrida•
of llllJV of the••
'Xhe detail
an pia
on, (tl though
have been plott.4
of •e!l-level
chengM
n,crw_.y.
iaoatatic
-t
curYN
vE1lue1 as so CIUChiAtonnet:i.Oll ccuee tram
ea of queatiOll8blc
I.ID""
eree••
#.ccording
(1968& 320) world aee-leYel
loo. lc,wer U..n preaent;
wo• poaaibly
a::it.Xi.Dun
Joined
to ,,Mi
to the corrU.neu!-; by s. •ide
ott
m"itair.1 was aut
'b.Y e euatetic
brid&e ecroaa
exact t.lJai.Di ot tha
'iDB-ulaticm'
to Meeoli thic
Dr\lCUl
DlatributiODol
UDmelted,
position
1.Dterg~cial
hbia bMn e~eated
below rrea•nt
1
the continent;
were atill
Purtherm.ore,
dry until
i ta of DoYer ••
ice .._
'l'h•
tlood.a.
mr:trecw_.,
it
of DICh debate;
in Northern
e l.erg• proportion
the f'in,l
( BJ00-7600 B.O.)
end tlui t there
w1111
snd vegetetion
etudie•
1
(reimtngton
~e
ia cleor
evidence
elao aug~eat
at lcaat
Zone VI,
AB
that
to ita
period.
It
1969: -.5) tbait
certeinl,-
aore than ,0.
cormunica tion between Britiai.D alld
r1Dli Irelend
th11t Eritein
whkh 1Would i.nvolve a aee-l•••l
there
ic• nmaim.ag
pol.r
the fo&t-gl.:u,ul
••-level
!'ree ulld
iAclioatect tllat
ot eea-lnel
rf!'6tontion
grounda
t•v•
&lrai;.
of upsnde4
u.~t-U well illto
on pl\ytogeogl"llpbia.l
connected,
duriri,g the Poet-glacul,
atudiea•
·~·as delnyed
duri.Dg tbe Pre-lloreel
'by at l••t
•• continental
1a the eubjeot
.au•t ma,n thst
end this
セ@ 't.n
the
or 11Drr inee
titudiu
"ti,ere was still
by 8.}00 l).C.
or ••-lnel
ban been
t.o .t3r1t.in
Subsequently
rue
mo1ted, ond the lam
Erl.1id.n mat
11nd
and , 'Ireland
tn the nort.h ( ft.g. ,) •
a mrrcM :iJJthn»
ia perhr~
iai.lvua
la••glacial
the
during
the preaent
depr-eaeion
Nort:h
セ@
ot 1.00m.
.. be•ill ••
peat oon\ed.nj_ng Bo:ref'l _pollen ~•
bMB
dredged t'rca it•
On
the 1-•ia
of en fln.lyaia
of eoeatel
radiocarban
d.tes,
Godwin (19.58) co,ieiders
in proareu
during
the Boreal
The iDlula\ioll
et Britain
pat
that
depoei1ia anci • t•
tt.t
eustatic
$nd wea f'Ully eccompliahed
pnauubl7
toak
riae
during
plaoe "bet'ore ~t.
auooia'-4
••
•otully
the ,.tlantic.
Yet the dete
..·...
....
,:::, _,'
...
50m .
,·.·.::
200m
..
3a.
FI GU.1S
セ@
8
of years
6
-
101
T
-
t
-
-_;;;
/
I
301
•
ft . OD L _________________
FIGU:1,.;
,3b .
B.C.
4
- - ,-
•
20
ar ound the
~ubmarine contours
British
Isles
thousands
セ@
100m
2
· - - - -f - .- - --:
I
I
:
I
.JI
Time curve for the eu stat ic ri se
(Godwin, Suggate and Willis 1958)
ot
,u
••••
tiDll
aepent.ion
prec1-•l7
det~d.
ot lirit.1.D
.Aw.U.Dle
•t abcM't the end of the BorNl
)21) tav~
(19'6i
chenot11riatic
In the
Qa.llil
;go-;
of the
re1--r•ent
A\laA\io
••
riae
lw-1
eoaa\191 a~bUitJ
'-i
tu
period.
about by apl.in
ap .. :itq
Mllded tc
••
.6u.t evidence
liDweYer1 it. aena
er 1 ..
_..
1n the relatiTe
in the
tbet
ot the i.Dd.
nor__.. .. t and aink
relna"'
tile
ot
M ooaolude
by tile i.w
1-Dd and ••
o£
thcugbt
from the
reeaom..ble
ooq)le,ed
le••l
leTel
••
It ha• been 6 .neral.17
pz-e11eat.in • reg1-
or b7 dollDlrerpiJli
raa
comiclere4
the pr•1nt
that
.'t.tlentic•
J,.a 'below the
t;nmgreeaioa
bilMN then ohf;Jl&
..
'broupt
a.xi.iwrn-
{Chu.roh:1.U 1965)•
J'lendrian
round Dr1t.1A
eliut••
.Bo, (North Dff'CID)auggeata
•oae
••
~.c.) lfa».J
the a.A.:r.
period•
C\ll.ai.nateci ill ~e
at \,ea-.ra
of
'f•t
circuletion
of the
ill no defi.D.i.te evidence
-we i:'oat•gueul
1ibat the euata tic
auoaersed ronat
there
of war~e
took pleoe
divitea.
et the tu.e
the ocu..nicity
e.neui.Dg AUa.ntic
•¥,
a&M
ocournd
baa not
it
Zone VI (7000-5000
chlring
eatablisnwent
incre:-••
11pi,recably
that
but opiAi.oa ru.ina
th~ break
the conaequent
D.C.J:
woulci iuelt
that
lanc;..u
e'Y1denoe ~-"
period;
e dBte ao:ut:1me
oliinatolog:i.111ia belin•
(o•500J
the OODtinent.l
troll
Brit.in
AU..nUo
haTe bND
broe41J'
baa
(Cl:alU'tlhill
tJl , the aouth-••t
19'5)•
PNcna• lcllolfledge ot
da'\illg
of' it.
lit.bic
atudi..
progr1aaiT•
bay•
waa are
-'e•ive
Alao tbere ••
aanuJ
\hen 'tocla7, and the cC*e'bl
OD either
increeaed•
end ctu,Mel
'!hi.a
nuat
beatM;
.MNo-
to Brittab
or •rl7
baTe ecological
and ett•i•r
aide ot preaeat IIB3or eatuar1...
at lsDd connec·Uona
and_.
and 'NU.ble
nidenoe
1
•Uh
for KMolUbio
1vllaequent
aetu ...
Poat-g1-oal
lowLtnd hab1'8t
tree laD4 oonma1Di.C11tionbttaeen Brit.iJa
aeroea ih1 dr7 Jforth S•
'lbe --~
rel"1111t
would have meant 1:.tvit the ••board
b••D aorreepondingly
area•
1t&ge• waal.4 be cti.Notl:,
tJ."llnagNNian
tor s number or r.aona.
Loaer •••lnela
ta.a
the eOIU"tleof the Flendran
n.
woal.4
ai.pitioanoe.
•114 the oan,uaent
oo:wwu1ioe·\i011
euau,10
nialriat:tana
, aow li•
b••••
ria• meant
on tollc llllffr
•WNMrSe4e01117
,,.
with • preoiae
tno.ledp
oan ibe eoolo&iaal
thq
are
セ@
the oow:we aDd da'i.Da
aignU'i•nae
ot gnat 1.aporienoe to
ot the watatio
ot th .. • ta.ta lte properly
au.r
......
ri.ae
.a; enc!
future una.l'lltancU.nsot the Britiah
... olitbiO•
In edditioA,
" Telicl time curYe tor the wat.atio
place coeatal
lii"i•,
chraaoloeia.l.
contat.
•peoiall,J
thoee iA Swt.b-w•t
ria•
would alloa
liriteill,
iJI th•ir
WI
to
proper
P!R? W
THI1VII>1NCI1!'al TF.!lQSOLI!BICD! SC'UTBIRN
BRITADI
'
1..
fLW Mi>
wm;
lluoh oan be l•rued
man tram the natur.l
01· the tim.abit4 •rUol••
C,qr acat or Scut.bern or'i\ain
au...
lithio
or flint
and chert
•tcN:&e cna•
reaim,
'b.)'
the great.et
r.r
the COlalOD .. t. •cure•
drtn,
from alacial
peuW.•
••
end river
a;nvela,
aad セ@
wue
GD
•11117
r•ta
ot •Aich oomiaa
ID. chalk e.Dll llar
p:oiury
w-.111Ml.Y
uae4i
:ae'ter1al.a o\ber 1iben rltc.t
rarely
th••bunt.ere
proporitoD
of mat.r~l
oi.,-
loc.l
ot
e.Dd waate ot •Dllt•ctuN•
impl-nta
deri•acl tli.n't and dlut
b8ve not •~1YN
, •teriel.a
orpnic
Co.llMegue1,tl.J,our knawledo•
on their
or prebiatorio
wUh 1ibich be r.ahicaecl
he UMd. the akUl
at-eriala
them, ,md \he d .. igll •.ad ~-
ieaolithic
al.Id ce.-biliti•
ot th• inteU1£eime
Ela•bere
DOdul.N•
oCMl.4'be obtainet
•Ad t.h...
•nd ca.aial
•Wuled,
b•obea•
Vflr7
t ao'-1»1-,
..
quart.d. '-•
SQIM •el•~iiYit.,
lfi•~i.De 19,6, lO); •nd •'
boa demnatrsted
wt
ure or a1rrerent
tool-li.1~•
qulity
~ppen
ot f.linte
1nt,reati1lg
thrt
att at the aa•
treaturecl
~a
tree
OD
aitea
attorda
to utiliae
anytb!JI& tl»~
appanrai
U.t
or d.itt_...t
bND t.abioaeil
'l'bia auag•ta
or leas u..
widenoe
prope.rtaa
19'()1 5J).
t.raa the w••1'1
(l9J9)
a.boa tor the b•t
_.
1D the Pema:Sn•,
iaplemena •••
ia iaa141atel¥
Cl.rk
Wle4 111 tibia •a.d'•o~
UI ita-1.t
AAII it
oonaboicS.llJ'•
1ibea
the •bility
to loaal
l'&'ltt•rn4
._..
tb• dtat.ac11ve
ti.ae,
acaa ft1"7 well ••
knPp1Ar11 •ith
ot tliDt
• •hiab
ot
bem
ot Farllbaa iA Surrv,
- •n ob'Yioua predU.atiOA
-.rare ••n
009aicmel~
••
s__..117
••
dit1 ..erent. ft1·ietiea
Tff'1 poor tl1nt or oherl (S.llaa
akilled
'4rial.a
the •i~
•hem akiJJS aoicrolitba
tlinf.
the V.oli\hic
kinda
n• •
IA .iouth- .... '- a>aleDll tltn
obeerveda
oberu
1D tha uae of
it 'iii
tl"GII •
tba Pl"911ell0e
ot
1-y to hand 11i11ab
'th.t
aucb • t'eoU1,y
ocmaua11183C1U.l'De.JII
and make
'?be Keaolithio
1)
lllaily
reoogniaecl
by oer\aia
2)
lit!uc
induatry
b7:
ot km t--piDg a.acl retouchi.Dg,
tecbniquea
lh• illduatey
deaanded
are ohanoteriaed
•uppU•
ot UIIPl... nt
a:tenaiye
by enemi,ye
•terul;
..
do nut
cm an uamilletioa
and a theoretical
H•
periJNDw
••
litibic
(Bln'11e8 194,l; bllld.M
are baaed •iAl.J
kllowlecla•
mrritc:1
• c:ran and a.
out.
ot the
wt ot
for lmtanoe
floor
abipping
illpl ... Dtae
ot Meaoli'thio
atlldi•
Serioaa
tloozw
cbippillg
le.A 5)
( tip•
セ@
bt
Were finiahed
\)e!i,,)
......:,_ ,,,
1.
a~etaaiill.
tilli.ahed
ill f••t
proporlicm
ot fli.Dt taken troa the O.kbaD1er (Bentlle)
pi.NM
aboll" ),000
.A "Hr¥ ••ll
4'ebr-i.s
OODYmed uto
tlaJced ••
••85,000
elao
\nea•
1.,wnt
aore ao \ban eny poat-Meaol.i1ild.o 1Dduatz7• HeDOellellolitbio
•terial
d4
brproduc-ta.
•• .117 reoogniNble
.~ull,J'
1a cbal'f!cteriaN
teohllology aN Tff7
object•
ot tl!Jlt.
ot the tukiJtS
it
All the • •
ia w.biab 'he ».aolitbic
'l'baae
and Ballaa 19'<>: 52-68)
19561 1~18;
or finiahe4
r...
u
end ••te
•terul,
Olll.7 rarely
obTioua tbat
llwatera ••re
bipl7
.
tlint
baYe ukllappi.Dg
•killed.
oontrol ot • 'IIIIOleua' 1A oon prepara Ucm.
-.plate
M•oli
oous •••
.thio
'l'h••are
plattOl'IIII d"eloped.
tlinW
Hall.•
f'lakrl;eda
(l96ot
tDdi•tiTe
6S) obeerT•
.atioa ot a aocmle .....
perouaeion:
tri.,.,ng
percuaaion
flak•,
·t.JPi•l
•~P•ecoordiDg
elao
tNqu~
ot the 1.Ddi.Nd
·to the IIUllber ot awikiRC
.ly ohereoieraed
perouaaiaa ,eabnique
from P•na:1.laa uaMDlepa
tt.t
ia aGae i.natanoea to baTe b ...
bul'ba ana rippl
illdia.Ung
the ua• セ@
..
lt7 Dal"l"OI',
a.re ftry
( Oakley
the 1.llittal
cerriacl
Gilt lt7
pre~r-
a1reo,
pr(JDOIIDOed oa aome oon
• wooden or bane baJ11Nr, encl ill aome
1.naianoea a atone hawr
- altllcalgb -~
セ@
dff-1.oped b7 peripieral
• .. &n.-ahepe4'
aN aocbal•
themael••
the •.1oriV
Ulldol&bted.11 c»rriecl
trca it•
tield
bu'\
M:aat 001'911 t'ou.114
ott.
'bla4ea akuck
1a the
Lea• fNq\lellt
core (t.4,.'9,).
°"'
all aetwal
(whether
primary
Sw:,h
aodlal ..
are
CorM
ID ,
taot
8\lCh
•lllt'ao'1lre
1a aot 1111ree•••ble
it
or pebbl .. ) were alao •ft"ied
or • b.nd.7 aiae,
• 11110leua•••
aa••, llioroli'ha,
ot iapl.ementa - k.Di... ,
nri•'Y
illpleaent
GalfpiDcaite,
at Dead-
and flaked
be quiakl.J' · produced•
- .au.lei
•••
tool•kit.
a IIIIClaaa wea a P1'elltial
fr:21nt1»•
Blatt
•e-
Jukina
to
Stone
M ••11'18\oaea,
GallGII
(w,-r,
left
Bladea •1
eN aawaU1 1...
baYe bnll
lb•• (f.4,e') •
,teobDiqu•
a au:rcl•
dorsel
bullla whiob an
ot a wood teebllique
li tba•
tl.k•
Darl'OII
are 2-rid&ed and oonaequ•U.1
he••••rrdittuae4
aepente
antler
to
thought
aJM!at the aite
ot
a114 • n4
bN•
Ul8e4 •• ber ballaft'S
1:he uae ot a bone er woocl paDCh
produced b7 t.beae ditteNDt
percuaaiOD •••
pebbl ..
percuaeiaa
ot a pebble beamer produced wide tl.ak• becll
tba ••
wheru•
.iertal
percuuioa
and i»ttencl
•ua•ti• t.bat
there ia a
,,a).
a oar. (t.4,e~).
dil'Nt
•tabri•te•'
paohea,
ana indirect
done b7 'botll dir.at
'ttone 1:aetteracl at OM end, •7
19'2;
aiailar
ha••
·Nell
._.,.. bMa reoorcle4 troa •a.J •tt•J
(Bnn•)
tba•aba•
deer
COIIIIIDD
fora
of oore P"Jll!lra'tiOD •114 aotual
u
·tbat, ...i.ei
!Jato 'h• ..-iJtc
and
.. mre 4H'f\aae
or Ui• 1Ddua'17•
d.iapaa'tio
tro •unoa•
Another
or 'p-taatio'
hi.Te blacl aU pouible
tut
ibilat
(t.A.,-2).
••te mrri
oore (t.A.,-.3) with two oppoae4 pi.tt<rll9•
1• ih• c7l1Ddrical
'71d,oel
••
tlaking
ot the
am セ@
ot
atriker
Coneepondjngl7
OIi
bi. ...
are dia\i..DC'ti•••
!laoae pro4uoe4 b7
ride•i while ~.
prodllaed b7 1alt:i.reot
.
UWI 1D aM'd~
1en.,.U7
regarded
and •D.J ot
1ih••
•• Wt'idenoe ot \ht uae
iD tlaklnl•
be olaued
••
ah.on, aediua
'lihan 2. 5• lGa&•
Lona and Meli.ma bla4-
'lh•••ere
b.ae•
Short or 'mloro-'blaclea'
or long.
kai.T .. ,
acatly'
oODY~ed
gra•era,
aorepera
into
miorO-
alld pointed
'
.
•1.Delr
and doule-ridaecl
elihou&b the generaU7
uaed ar\,itnrU1,
• ditt'erenoe
oould ak•
• M•oli\laio
014retioe,
atioa
tor
itdftnoed
microlitiba,
Th• qu•U•
at the••
all ia,poriant
a.iakle7
GIie•
•n '•ll't'il atoae•
he eelled
to plaoe IIOdul .. on wh·Uat
haYe 'been olaiMcl
funot1oml
tb1Dk• that
•~
auitebUit7
ot '•ll'ril•'
t.obniquea
ill the
ei'l.ber end.led
.
ham,
or reel deer antle~
oa the lmH,
iDcU.•\e
F•111D .. ) whei
b7 ••t•,
preaWMbl7
'•DY1l atonea•
oa the groaada or
•7
am pel"t or tbe
haYe tot'IIIICI an aDYil
(o.k.1•1 19671 28) and
~,
nocbal.. •ve
proN'bl.7
w an aoae •oft • '*erul.
.
141• in, SUP' ot Blf 411
parpo9M•
~imll7
•ppl.i-1 re'hllab kJlon .. 'BLUJfl'ING' ia •••
at l :'8 1a.. , • ld.oroli,ba .
Bu\ 1 t •• elao uaecl •• a proi.at1'9'e
retouch or which the 'baokad knit• (7.1.) ia •• --~•·
1)
.A a~ep
2)
ADO~er
ob8noterla'Uc
•de•treatment
ia
UD-
aDCli'ymer (1962: JJ8)
aJ1Cient aurtaoe,
waeclby ih• Bralldala a,pper9
(C•ntrel
•it•,
Rallkille A Di.ableb7 l~);
eimaocnp.1c parallel.a
auitable
Techaology ia
Similarly,
b7 otber workere at Yaricua
JfoderD
au .. (•• the
tlut
aurrounde4
they were 'being atruck.
ODe
haY• aoa. detect
bla~
:1D11.. olithic
(or V:Ulato1a. Grit)
on••
or bladea at
r
tor •ki.na aicroli'-
•• be •nted
(19.39) tea.maat llarcb Bill
(••I•
workera beline
•Old
ot dU'terent
the aurplua
at '..lbeichaa a caa,pl.ete l)eir
•ua•tiYe•
.. ,
Olll.7 csert.t.a a:1.ero-'blaa.a •ere
• that
and that
akul.l o.p found l7iJ18 iDYened
•relJ
both were
ot • double-ridged
q-.ite • .....
•ortins ·thea 111to pU•
into
•ld.ng
ott
1Daa11pen do) 11 alld u.ae th-
ia oca.a1onallJ
aectioa
thiDner
:towaaoa aoaae a1,
WOi&ldairik•
.lmafper
pemasa ena
Brandoll :t'lint
1on ia that
1apr ..
iD batting.
Pl'OII the qua11t-1t7 ot· bl.ciea
~t
'ftae general
laladM•
'DIMMING'
( r.~6)
which
..
•
.. •
. .',.
../
'J
.'
.,
'
..
-~
/
1
5
4/6
I
-1
I
8
10
..
'.:',,
r-r; :u
4.
Techniquco
of the ?icsolithic
(Jencriptions
in text)
flint
induotry
••
ett-.cl
D,. ngulel'• .U.t.
11qUUUe«
•
'ftd.11provided e
l»welle4 eclp.
I't _. uae4 SA ebll'UII ad.oroUt.u, end tor
セ@
the outt1.a& quli~
or ell e4g-.
J)
' DfC1l-m:aat ot eda.. prOlllaecl • •bei"P
fl'eq\lellU7 1-t
Ul'f'ft9U7 •
セ@
.l l ...
to px'OCJlac••
ae\llo4 eJl4 ••
w
ued
landJ•
The 1*Uiial' ot.i
IIGi-111" •
(t .i..-7) wbiob. -tiaM
(l'Srtiaaluls
trdab.U'
••
OD•U.
t~
Ott l»laa.a aJld
tt7
blade dirteioll
'fl>e CeJIG'lll. liQC I •\oil
lllaa. e.,...na
obau
-
1a Ulat at.arol1tM
セ@
,.a.
•.U
'be•
to ~·
e llicr011th
ot .saot ehepe, length eJ1111fi.4th , require4;
beiJC Grientewcl
•bal*
oearlJI&1ne .--ra
erounathe
bvJlJ ot R9rcuaato11 ,
-ia
A d.lNin en.p , lee'tdlls • ci...
Awa~
~e · ~·
on . l•TiJI& • buW
or •aoMl!l ' セ@
••
Up ot • l»lada ) .
セ@
file ' alm'o-lNria
aepent
Me
fl.tb
-.t
' t.abla1que (t . 5-lw
•wee~
to be•
• • '- pradQ!Ct or au:iroittb
•e• w Jieff
been ued u
~--
pTar
•••
tnoture
•eotlom
'° heTe bee
clettalt.17
•-
4arael ride• (•)•
Cm-
to hm tb.N• pie«:99 ,
butts , heff
objeat
•
eJ:14
triadJlg
•peoS.eU,
1
b7
(f!& • 5)•
b!pl--18
or tiaal
It bP be911le 11etter ot ccmt.rovnt17 ••
ot bl.a4- •
•Hoe
ot m.oro-bladee , llllCl •outillla
1a the llutta eD4 ttpe
~•
auoua.a
PrffiaS---4e
8.l'8
were
lJI 8oathara lllg-
o.ttea
kV opc9t1Clll iA ld.-1.ith
tbe
aequenl.7 • the eellilltiOII ot e l»lada eJliS the -'-'
セ@
1fff9
01 'ClBDllI.ll~1
roana.a.ac••
tor ... •• • petlt
retouch.a
lotd*I
ot NgM tea セ@
n U'tle\allt
C
.ag..
!be butt
the ruaei
of セ@
bha. ,
to" "8D'f•!'hl'M
•
mot\1r11o
<•-U-
u
eo oalled b ..
uea t<¥r
uae it
lee....- •
«.oet; llut it 1a &eDenll.7
aauhetare
(BalJe•
. el:tba &h -
larger
67) •
1'be ·~
1~1
-~
to
•1'"1-•
1a
~p.roduoeci by vH.ns
• aotch -.i-t
セ@
aGNttma Cll"1ala riabt 1Jl to
ott , l ••lAI
er hiaW
u
_.entull,y
セ@
1
Thu
bee
attterant
~e
c.""Ltu.ns
. th1a particlllar
p%'QO!•
aJl4
JID
NPrdad
the wbjaot
19.32, 97-103) • aJld haa bND r,iaat'Cka by
di.at~
ot tba blade.
セ@
•• • gl"a'+'II!' facet.
....
to ha't'e bMll 4-aloped
of gnat
write,-
aON
or ta~
eolltroYG"9y (aee Cladc
partial
••
tor
niCMllea
withiA the ».eol.itbioo
pbaaa of •lllfaotur.
1a tedmol.og.i.oatl.q
Ulte ot ellqld.ry ao tar ma pron-4
aUOD •• to •b,;r thaaa 41.tt'aNDt
It ia tbe
ot a ... ennc • •
Ula point
1d.Cl'Oiluri.ll' baa be•
••ppad
Then t.ba bu.tt t.a
halt
.. oU\hic , and -14
mr. a-.tely
to 4a'9raine
ridca •
doraal
a acar OIi the othc
OOlll(laniOD aoar CIII the bl&U bt
t,et,nig1,1e
•t the bulbar 911d ot • b1-4e,
U1Y•rubl.y
PT •ti.ah.ciQry
a
'+'Geel
apl.aa-
wobniquaa •are uaedt aJl4 oNaa cm tha -
.-oritahop •1te.
lt!tmS1ee Jt$n1e:ne
1..~
Ba"ered
u-
hallatg1,1•
p,latfbnl
tlaltiq
ax.e ware rea>iari,.aed
_.. _.a4pa
oom1a.na ...iut•al:,-
edgaa -
11:,-U'aJla't'etWa flaJr:1iqgl a.ad
:ital of OON baa•;
11
sra•- •
aa wall • •
an dua,i,oet1o -
or 1.haaa operaU.-
(t .409}•
ot nei»rpa•tna
( r . 1i,.-10) an tba reauita
!he ' >P ' •••
g:rs•... n
2.
ffl'CLOGJ
, CLASSRJGITI(l(
NIPftMIOlfAL J!lfflffiR'1'IOJr
t'ypologl•l
atuq of illl)l-.nb
.a. hi* tllnt d4 chm
ill -..oli~1o
their
gaaual
J.rebaaoloa:,,
.. paoi.al.q
I.Ok or at.ratigr,a'*'7
raeeai.Da
•
aDISorpaio
••r, •t:raa.l erta.noa
aaut .. o.n be ••bliabecl
l•
•t
tout ot
to -id.er
' tlallc~'•
t'lillt
am aberl
batcmt cbrclllologiaal
llJ
thJ,
_._.
.,.,a wS.l:h tb-.
-~
セ@
•
tx.tiHDt.
pl.,e
1D 1he c,.ae of Brituh
a tandem., 1A tba paat to aa.li:too mob ot tnologioal
to be
._pen ,
alMlh •• core N,11ffeD-
•-
role
a.rt••·
traat.aaDt.
(r .,.,.8) aal u ... liarpen1n• n.Jc•
f'bkaa
-..oUthul
'by akilful
Nllfted
by thiJI Clban-erlattc
!Ille by-proauct
at1•
Q'e
lut
anai,.-
•
•ltd
•Jcir
With
there baa b-
na.a.
!h_..
aequal'IIOaaand 41.aUActt•• 1r
llltJQ' probl-
ta a1.D4.-
•riN1Pt
a flmCli.oaal. ~t
aN
•t
1-ol•ecl,
..ul. be
ot rt..
-a.
hara
nai
weN
tb•• Sapl-u
lit•
ot &no11tbio
of
CID tb1.s poiAt
ebout the t\metio118 ot tarl1cw.ar
11,po11~pbio
ps:rallela , but iJa
~er•
1a
no~
1n
little
•
·~
fW:lat'-t ar
shoald be trsaW
Oollffq11e~,
mtn-t1sn~o
GSD
be 'IIIIM
~10D
mi t1•
Mamo:J
1thic
_.,..
type •7
~-,
Pll:rtbsnlOrs there
aa.ch of 'lllbat to11-
hm'YS
on.
ezclu.ivel7
SN
i.e conjsoturs
, sll4
out , ,rhstbw
sits
es SIUCb
•
tl1Dt
...,_olithio
1.
... oUtbic
i t •.Y beve bed •n-1.
tn- •
W..olithio
-~
tool \JPS
mo umsd b7 bimtiJI& o
pset , 1t l'lsl4 the aa•
S1-Slerly
be•sd
bes lleeD Ullderteken.
s~
of tl'ls pr,seen.t ar noSDt
mitiSS •
SN
sleo upon SJlterenoe aDd
wb.J
, 1*la\18s • iiarlicw.ar
tor • perttcw.ar Plt'PC19e
, or lleoeae it
セ@
iJlpl-t
セ@
e:rcbaeoloa , ot whteb pitU\lll.7
セ@
sbCDld lie bes..S prusrU7
T)'polagScel enal,aen
bll.Dten?
ill the dlU7
pl.7
Yillh
Our 80tto,a
lerssl.r
What part dtd ~ey
u.ed tat'?
OoDted
end chert •ta111
sn
セ@
CSD
bs sorlsd
sJl4
or DO'-, 1.llto the toU<111illgostegorum :
IOIIUI) PUCS3
s)
Blaa. slid Puk e Toolst maroUtaia , acrap«ra ,
'ss n', bla4e sspr ·• , 'pst i t trPJlahs tm•.
b)
Con
'fooUI:
a.•, eore aarapuw ,
·~ ·.
blsa. ,
tlsk• ,
1:z1m1•
'Dlens sre tile filailisr
oore
gr9Yft9
,
pm•- • pllllGbes.
tlalten , ahllttsr , oona , elll
oetmprt•
•t
with ~t
... oli"tlaio
ArcibaeolQS7 aeas:rmU7.
•'EPP l'!A
(1)
セ@
sr,
sbicll
~
セ@
. ot tl1.m is c011111.deN4
wcrksd U it b~
or retClllob , s~l
u
tlffinc
or sctge
the slgllm ot sscr.rnit
trsetant,
to pro4lloe • PNds~nd.De4 tool or 1apl-nt.
ths r•alt
セ@
It.}.
•>
m,ci,fJ!1Otkt !oolf
t'lle exa111'11ation
or the lleiriLe4 c Z""ilM
,1.....
up~i,Ga
tb.
• • • •• there ••-
aJld are
tb-rora
raug),,17 'brdt.n
1
'• idraerapan1
JGNDl•
• .i.,...
baa
1
'blaa... all4 •«- cm thick
tm the
, 1lbeD
n.Jc•
QI"
•1•tam baa beau
, ...,_acnpve'
cn11CS ' ( f . 7. i.) ; aria lt
tluJt broaa ola.aau1.cat1aa
•
baaia
(r . 7.2) .
ll!ICllll.4be
-jil,aw'1-!o
of
•
It ·-
.. t;iJ!g.
tu "-'loll
セ@
iau.wall.7 qnacl,
ot
-.1M111N
Yhtn fNah
Jdllea tni•la
~t
Yen
Dl'Ollgbt into
alld the tat aorapad Oft , and t 1.Mue nhna
aanpa ud
f1- tluit
plllnru,
IIOJ'aPII" 111\b ita
aa or tile ,ra .
a..r
, luit
alt!Jla •
lllOt au\,
•~,
••
Qo
U •ral-l,r
and- anc1 ata.-acnP«r9
a
s
It
1S1tal 7
»91Bad au.t
74 Wh1cll -ia
t,-pi
llalldl.a
-ia
be NQ1l1red,,
ad&et'la1tila th_.
セ@
ti.al wh•
would "81A
SldJla yGQld ff
Clalll)o
br*an
oca,,-a,
2b1a wwl4 ba ....
Saller
:,reparaUoa
,
ot llltUla •
1a the praprat1oa
*ill
iaiU.l
p..nUala
fl'Qa a1&1Mp'alidCI
alll1- and ai4PMn~
rw•-ble
racl
to a»;r partiOl&lar ouli-
'lfo.14 d.1ati.Jliuiaba4
holl-
akff9
to tb.e Braue
tll. Palaaolitlaie
aui,.abla
WOrlt~
(t . 7.:5) arid
to ate4
セ@
oa t'1alt•,
\1IO aaparata
Aa 7at ao •~ndel'11 ola .. i!'ioatoq
piaoaa.
ac1op1.a, but -~
g~
u
aot al•Ja
acm1pa:n Yan tub10lle4
S-
lllat
sra"- • ate , .a.
la waalapa
t'11Dt Uldlatrua
>
n• .. bat.au
to 'be a ~U'allea
a.n sir-eat
saiaPP
ApJ
of two aapera1:e hone
A aClr'Olitbi.o boat • aonpuw,
or 1-. all4 •dibla4• •
1)
of ».eo11Udc
pre,par!Ag a1dm
ftN
proba'bl7
the au,
-.a
of
tor tha
tau ot
•• • th:ta
akU
•OIN Jlart.h .&wic.n
a~
••-4
\.bet •oa
••n no dQ.ibt
othen
tr.
aonper
cJ alt b~
a •top.
-w.
Oil the other
tunetioial
poeaillle
•o ~r
セ@
the raaiDiqr
band doable
r.
or llafl~,
bad a
••
oaa
1:h-
r1aca •etiJIII ..
and wbilet
aua l>e pvi
iJs
r...-ed
1'14• be •111&•ta
oal7 lta aot.ta,
'° arrance
eaa-
an
AOtea
woald no\. 1t7 \ludr
eone tor these dittw-•
proyed poaaillla
eltb~
•llldJJ&tl.ke
ot the dozul
part
en4-~pera
typee of ac:ra~
!he ditteren\
u treciu-lltl.7
wooctea•s-r e.Dcl
ri4&• (l-'601 tia•J, no.JS ) .
Janus,
lld:1-?
lt
JfaU.n (1960: 60)
COGk'e S tud.7 ( PeNl1M9 ) elah
wOllld t'eoili.tate
セ@
wen
~pers
ua.a • • the,. are.
elOJIC \11.ea-1
,-rt •1
••
en1..,.ti
tbet it 1IOl&l4haTe be.a vaet'lal tor uootbillg
It ta pou~
lie
XncU en t.ribee , alld Witll ,r.eesn-daJ'
1e •-bat
!he hoU-creper
wean, ..
the ta-at: ot ... ol.it.tuc
JlNpen~
mture
-
1t
f-r4,
or cul~
chroDological
v.ral eeri-.
Cil!AVDS (t •7•S) eN aot lmoni 1Jl .. olit~c
It ia gene.re~
bw
aN-4
aDC!antltrr
4-Yalox-a,t
ot t1wa pz
t'ltahidlliJlc •
U'teMtTal7
ffidtnca
-~orlV
SftTUII
atroqrly
prlaril.7
P9ri-*
Ct-9..-era•ere
~bl,J
•••
oo pebbl• , antl.ar
hri.o4
1a t t.belr
prwent
aua•t
at St.r
•ill
••
_.
tor Ule
tb.e7
•ere ff14enUy
tba 1enarel
waipt
lien
acaaNf>J.... .
ot Nd daft' •
flla~oi-e
va.a
ot
ot antler , ••
1A tbe -~
of anUw
!Jt'>
aJl4 b cme - tor art dll
rwtna
•- •
th e hwatiq
the7 •aul.4
181-lt and tt.g . 79) .
DO
the
•itb
C.rr ( Cleric 1"41
aUee
ot
the •Alfa-ot\JN
in later
tor b°"1 JQl'SJONIIJ llll~ ill the keeoli~
of Briti.ab
1.a
UTCl9h•da
eurrflakaa
eo DeJueeq.
tha •••
..,.
UN
IA the Upper Pale.oU~
a~ta
"lie
w-
••pom• &wwblJ,
ot 11AM an4 grOo"r•
olaioo
thq
allll cC111fC9ite
be~,
lte no lC111£erquite
••-
tbet
or aroma Age eaalllli>lag••
oa tlle
IIUt"fbed, lnn . IPicpd~
'Id.~
-~
. gnTwa
45.
are •01
Th-
claaaU'1caUOJl
•ia• • bv.t
ahapea and
d-
m.at .
:not
anc! indirtc!ul
tn,ea ( • •I • alark 1951.J Y,-r
1~2) .
at s,rta.nt
•~•
of clataNlJwlg
m
alao oo
or
Blaa..
'SAWS' 1
GD
!!ri~
that
bC!M•
But lt
entloa
ot pl.tant
'Sew'
atua
u
•PU.
a~ti.oa
reaaaaable
•bioll
a..ip
aq
it
50 yara&) .
8/7000]l.C.
lCllllg•
d#l
Jla•ilr
Tari-
of
or the
._oUt.ll1G
•tu47 111.tb aueh apacwati.oa
a:leroUt.ba
period,
•• to pu.rpaaa .
were par1a r/1 ~
.
Je.,.U.
It therefore
--.r
there 1ICllll4ba • lild.W
oc:mtQra to to be e~tb·•
of llui.o
In the
·
would llaTe to be t'llltillMb
l'l-oa t.ba
ot ataort ra11&-•(probab).z • •id.am
aOC!U:P9'
en.a.no.
ot ea.
• an4 claW to
ill 0.-rk
cJaacnJ:,ecl ill Grilll..y 19581 l.6t ) , were abOll't 5'
(J1.a&1-1an:
ea (X--ritJ
wooclanarrcis abanJ
to II014 -tb• t•~
end .-t
•1-t ..
the pre~
1'ha •i#lificaDo•
Hn'8tlODo
BO.. ot ela woocl tcuna at BoJ.a.pari
fGlllld Oil Bri\iah
セ@
aDd .x111Jtit greet
kUliJIC or ll"VllCJingpc,waro
w•pom •-
the b•t
on.a
C'll~
cCGD«Jtecl wlth
WN
laplePt•
two eondi.ti-
a.ad \be beae 1a eotohe4 to
prea-11,1,-
... i . for
aae4 iJI ttia obaJla and tor tia~
•ha"- •
At TinkeJ
J111gl..-1an
exwntot
ot. ... oteruti.c
to auppoaa that
a..-
It ta
•• 7et • mrertaiD.
ill ru,,i1 . a1ld NP-
a-..il.allia
'4emt.C\llate4
OOMUN•
ait•
ea ·-
••po1111
woiu.a hlJTa to
oaae ot propelled
t,nea.
botb.
1a that
aJl4 Ula U.lte . priaril.z
•-
e Wtuut
ta.a
セ@
tti.y
that
pll:tity
reoeiTec! a gret
1-1
u
1Ja tha preparatioa
the cbaneta .r alld
mCII.OLJltiS
are tha
セ@
and are
ait••
1a no •7
aanatea .ag.. (f . 7.') •re
111.th ..iiba,~
fflD
1D grat
OCICNr
th ..
on
tbair
detiJal
with acnpere • there
ot
pau1ble
r-ooaa,or
of tb1II ftri.lltiOD
aDd ban
.a
1a equally
NP~
Aa
au~
their PNCia• twictioll
were •
tbq
tlalt•
... olith1c
pucaa• or •aa• ' ·
thcupt
th•
• •ialldardo wict.l., ua.a
apia
C1arlt 19'71 ~ ; a peat 4epoa1t pi,oducec1 a
the Up baa • al.qt
earcac•
tha
baatri.Qg;
tor
e aic:r011W.O
\t1n,Ung -r
requ:1raa to a\aac\7 ttl•
...-,11h-1Te
1.a that ot J.C:.]).Ourk
ola .. s,t'ioeticll
(1,:,,..
pollrt ,
tbe llaae-.
tU.p~
of th• ~
ot m.croUU.
and 1,39 ) , baaecl oa
·
.\.·. : ..· . .. . . ·.
.
.
..-- -
.
·
~· -·:. ...·. ·. ')
;·. .. .. . ..... . ... -./
. ..
. .
セ@
.
"
--....~ ·- .
Q
Tri mt1ing Fla kes
Nodule
!lodulc
Preparati
PHA5E
ij
\
I
II
セ@
,,..isi
I
セ@
on
\
'
セ@
'
a
-
I
I
I
.,
-
セ@
Side
. ,.
view
-:.•.
. ~t .r;!:lq.ng of! a.
narrow bl a de wit h sin gl e
dor sal r id ge
Alternn t.,i.ve ~ositin.n~
!"or punch
~.tr~n
g .off ·a
broad blade with double
dor sa l r idi;e
(§;) Tiny s c ar cau sed by
poi nt of punc h
Prod uction
of a. ' . .i cro - burin '
a -c ( after
Clar k ) i l l uo tr a te t he
e arly st ac es in the pr odllction
of a n Qbl i quely 5lun t ed Poiat ,
th e ' micro - burin 1 (x ) bein i; tne
was te pro duc t . d illustrates
on
an enl ar ~ed sc a le an OB f oint,
showing ( y) the ne gat ive f acet ,
a
b
d
C
PHASE
III
snap ....
Microlith
made fro m a
na rro w blade
©
@
'
Microlith
made fro m a
broad blade
' mie ro - burin '
mic rol ith
FIG U.ffi
( a fter
The manufacture
Hallam , Cl a r k
&
of .microliths
~ank ine) ,
.m
llhlipe,
~eJn
t..boi•gh w
'Jbu CUMifiaation,
tor ffY«r91 reuam .
Ill the r~t
( •pechll7
place
Jiu olaui!icatioll
Cbrlc dertaea
th .. , taraa heYe bffA rec cip1 e.a
ill oth.fto area• -.t.cb
ao cot
el\lloagh t~te.17
tn.ae a.re not Dl&llerioeU,, e~tioaJlt
セ@
built
u
it
In e&litioii,
pouibl.e
, tram the l.eqe
Cl.erlt 13~
tl&-lS, ,
セ@
•7
11"t.t10A
iac:acJel ..
aDd
bet.re• ••l••
aD,J aae atte .
• eri .. a7
S-
trapaae ( ••
elld taaa1tal.ea trui.ii..
.
fte't'erlbr
trca Wbioll tuDoU.oa.i
betncil
adcrolitu
ot
,_,....rU,ll• di.de tee\ b7 iatractebie
••JIOU
t.h-7 •er. 1Jlteade4 rot-o
ahatta
8-r
-t~
Gr
Pl..xx
, 1) .
\np••
ltearu& Oil the Jll'Obl• or
baTe baea reew_...
!'iia •~icaAOe
~ata
attU
baaJ.oall7
1a aNocuUon
lllli>edaei
u
•itll
••
セ@
cv.1.ture) ot ea e1-t
(Clarit
CQlllplete arrc,w-
1.11place (t1g . 8. l ) b-14 b7 resi.•
'Iba 111.croU~c
o~ • poillt
aa eldllpt•
(• tri.aJlgla , or pcaail>q
Oil \be Maia
au:rolitbll
ret ) .
ime.
tt,a
ot the Laabl&l\ fSnd. Cla%k (1951.1 10:S) baa 41rtdecl Vie
Ster
Carr
lj.51t.1
diaCIOYer,
) and • berlt (a •1121'1•4,Uquel.y bhoatecl tor., • t ,aa.a With t1la
bllalltecl ._._
wooaea
fCUlll at
at thia ttnd t.a been enhanced b7 the
Jrt b. SWedell (11.tgl-i.an
111~ ldcrolitm
ecla• •till
tltat ,
tunoti-1
wt a 8111,ila al.capted tnppa
part ot tile retcQcbed
at LUla lUlt
arature
have a
iJI Brit.inl
carr •lth
u.tt
fillaa
Jllo m.croUtu
iat.rp,at.tioa.
1Dta-
cta t the r-•v.1.t ot • cnna-
arteh
a-Adthe clltterencu
•t.riali
ot tb•
1At8"9UJ!g
be
to Ula
\riangla
e.1mlar appeareJICe WOlaldnot
but lt.7 the deatp
1968) ,
It 1a apt4lNZl.t , troc the cacai.ta11e7 111.tbwbieh t~
Jrooea4-
••ter,,ot hi•
OD
foi91
U-1.ee
.au
-
( •e• •c1lq
1
to the elaapte4
trlarcle
thet m:lJuolJ.U.. sere precuioJl-•da
OOCN.r,
•n ' e
intenedJ.,te
the a..U
ci.nc•• t,ypoloa ao.a prot'i4e
1 ... ,
1Ato It.ta echs
to reooptae
UC91.II&a tnMitioa
creac~
~orwbl7
fit
Ill&~
trca attee in 8Cllltb-••t
sue.
HO!Wlall eDd hrtlbe._} .
(•tter
stardard, ia i..r fZ'OII ~,et.,
ot microlitu
ot •• anel,a-a
on the t.au
'ldlat ti.
tn-
teela to lie tlle 1'ancUonell;r atpitiant
wrltff
Cla.rlt).
1i&l,lre 6 Ulu\ra'-a
•Jld poeitS.on of Ntoi.ch .
ene»\
t=o t.o tulloti_..l
....-i:aJ
'r od 1 "'B
B2
B1
.,,,
C2
,\
D2a
i:>1a
D2b
D1b
D1:i
ln.r.;e
{!]
D3
D4
f':_o,,c:;11 Er,
D7
=-
D6
D5
A
セ@
D8
E1
P(.2-G
•
F1
F2
F~ .. L
6.
II1
G
Cla~r.ification
of mic rol i thG
(::ce ove rleaf)
(. 12 •,r
-i
frc:·
:,ct.i;~ l nµeci1·ens
f)
2
1
3
/'
セ@
-
--
"' -----
4.
6
........
-
'-....._
=
8
9
FIGURE 7.
1-iacro li thic
(descri
imnl.emon t types
p tion
in
text)
A•
Bluned
a.
Bl•ted c10ll1l'llllole ofl
1. o..
2 . ho .ag...
c.
Blwrte4
<lDe
.ag..
•a&•
·
lo
2.
D.
obliquel.7 dOID part of
aoa one edi• elld earou
ObliqllelJ.
fr'llmYeraelJ'•
0,0,,51,e
1.
...
••
Ieoeo.i..
aw leae.
lh
L
tor.•
an4 aura-We
!naagl
~enu
••
b.
the baae:
.
arc blwrt.a.
char4 bl\mW .
,. Losell£ .. •
....x..noeoi." tona.
5. Sub-trleJlpler
6.
0-~r
fo.t"M•
tona
( wi"- ibree .ag.. blullteai
tnpeso1a . rliaaoide
no . )
7• JllOl!fPted tnpe•••
8.
S.
'!ft pea ...
Poune with 1DYU9• re\OllOh at Nee1
l ••••
bluzat.
2.
poiatecl .
Be••
P•
aou--11eaed Po1Dta.
lo S,-U'iael.
2. Aaa,-tria.l.
c.
Sbollldered or !!aJl&e4PoiJaia .
Bo
Cbuel-ena.4
lo
2.
Jl
,
( trannezwe) al'l'Ol!bNcSe
.
( 'tnpea•.
)•
poiatect.
Jla••breed
Be••
Larae (-.icroUthic
'Petit-trel!Cheta'.
) apecdeen- ot t;ne Hare •lled
......
.
a
a
b
b
1
2
3
a
b
105°
t,
4
;{
7
6
セ@
セ@
8
5
130°
10
1 i nch
CID
11
9
Th e haf ti n~ and use
of ~icroliths
1
Fo!"ep:,rt of a i:esoli thic arrow from Loshult
sr.c,wing a nicrolit
..ic ti p. au d ba rb held in
b~· resin
( not to scale) .
2 to 4
.~ftcd
aninnlo
r:icro~ith:;
nnd birds
l'ossible
r:,cthod
;;ca lene
:iicrolith
5
7
&
6
~od nicrolith~
10
.\ rod
cicroli
11
J·o :::ibl e use
u :::cd by Woute rs
for
, Sweden ,
position
shooting
small
.
of mounting
found
in
sc,.lene
huoan
nicroliths
vertebra
at
.
Tevicc , ;:orbihnn
•
th for
u:c;c n,; n fish
of s cal.ene
nti crolith
ho ok ( aft er './outers)
ns a fi,sh
hook .
.
.
... ...... .,..
.,.
.
l}
t
lo
'W ,•"
セ@
11'
,., o f :
..
'
·t
'
'•,
5•
8-.,u: : .
·5, - ··,,5t. m.
~1Et C HT : I - ':, 75 c.llJ
ii-,.\
/
セ@
-1
.,·
,.,.·.
' ..
....,
·1
:,J
H£1GHT;
I
..
L tt· 1 •
:-t )r ·:(t ;:,
:o~:·.
'
r-•
•.)
,I
&_,·nfi:· (l ··tt :·_,..:..
V V..
\JJ W セ@
ES__
eo·
,1 1C,L!' セ@
~":,( '
·! •
. HECH 'T
·.
·,5 -
t •
l
. ...
'
"] 5
a
t:ill •.
セ@
('
.
.;
'
.
I
6,
-·· \
.; .
,o
I
..
·. ...,.
I
•.
..'
•
I ··7~ ,:,~.
.!~-.セ@.
. H ,IG HT
セ@
·5 - ·15
·'75 - .2
,in.
~W\ .
..
!,~
: ':::;.::-l ' • •
_ ;_ ...~· .. .:. ) ·_.; _,.'" ): .. L
I
•
·- --s. --DZ.
.~ RI
,_
A
I
C:
B .l.~E :
. _,_.
.14,0 •
·£,
I
•
t ·7S .::~
- ,.
I
r
..... .....
·-:
.
B
FIG~
9
ngle
measure
ents
of scalene
( fro
icrol~ths
Halla m 1960 )
"
.....
1)
fif6
2)
BABE -
MODp t.ed \rap•••
\rialfCl.H,
•
ae
•de•~rwlinc
and -flak•
ditt'ered
:la appeannee.
•7
.,iaulia-4
•• 8'IGb.
•4-
•ua•'-
tn,ea
nrie\7,
whether
or
Moat
\aere
are
~•••
tecmNlogical,
a • th• 1..,.i
or pure
a•t:uaU7
battie<l ••
type
bare.
1t
1'.ellol.1W.O ait••
ner
aa an arrow 'barll•
n, (.i-..tea
VPN
arrow; ~h
Loea.l.t
vapeae)
tha
Oil
ai ..
bea
t•
•
tou.Jlt
pn1ctiaall7
ffeJ:7
:that tkia
Siailarl.7,
ei~ft'
セ@
•C11111~1111,.a
the Up ot
nlW'••tormar arrow
•t
or •7
•7-
Bllt there
t.n• tciwad
be
or c\11:tunl,
ruaonebl.3 to auppoae theretore,
It ....
or セ@
cerlaiJll.J
goYerlling
ha• iA aae tmtance
1• a
,, and B
ot oaretul.17
Nll•Oba
cOllljec'tur••
lliCreover, it
aiapl.J aJM11111:S..ve:raallz
ued
DI.( t.runsle)
••
eooaoad.c 1•0&railhical
2.)pe A (ooliquel.7 bl11111ieclfOiDt)
tona ••
'l'bq
to be urpartant
ou,tlt
fa-OU•
Britub
t.6).
(•••
crecW,l•
Da•1,
IYeD if tbia were ao, 1:be ffr'J nrietJ
that
\bi.a
IIIDlll1'1.D&,
Dot baY•
reaill
their
'?hi.a 11.De ot rN•OIIUII 1a • pert~
•• proJeotiT• \ipa
••rYel
alao •••
fro•
it and augg .. \ torma c, °'l• O.,, ~·
.tend
One aigbt
one.
ot abliquel.7 blumed pout.
wri.01111 tortl9
wi t.11aal.7 \ip
.._
quadnapl.ar
ad.croU-. aAd \anged .S.orolitu.
tipa •bea-
'ibe7 are rau»de
lithiO
root ot
la tb•
t1J)tl9
tunoti,oa (a) at the wrilU
•lR"l"OIIDdill 'h• pnei••
Tb• dU.-
llllllV prolal-
1n KeAoli'ilio
Ball.ea (19'0) •114 AeWoll\ere (1955 ) •••
oaa•
a•t oi._.
ad.pt
S.U.a
aald.Mcl aeoae ·\riaelly
nlldaa fl'OII a
•*_.
r•ol :yed the•el••
tno
or boae abaift, al,,._.
barPaagl
..
thu
lera•
th••aa.i.n.
""
(19'°'
1J1 wbicb arolaeol-
area ot E.D&l-••
OD
119nUel
•,a
to ibli
n.,.7) •
.r.s.
41.1-.
taur g:rwpa beae4
It
ArohlleolOQ•
aOMe 200 SCALIII tnangl•,
ot aiMa wer •
a1a. or the 111.orolitll.
tollwilll
\o reaol•illl
iadioa 'ted ••
at.cro-
amr,••
the
chat•
at
1.'h••,he
t011114,
111111l•
oppoatt• the loms•t
...
an.a,
a• l»rba
••'
1a •
the7 •aul.4 naul\
•oo4•
ill the
5-'·
Seri .. I
•
;5°
II
II
•
,oo
IY •
It i• inter•tult.
pot.nu.
iDi;o the acalene .•art•;
open.a up anothe'r
a1'l'01'19mrte4 wit.b wriowl
ta tiaur•
they aall
tball
t'
a
aors.. , w~u
.-,
aUea
••
aaat allalldant
Prffiou
Oil
a1.i ..
ma\11111
a.Dc1fiahi»g.
tor
,•• well a• am.mla
.taroli'ha
1a
•"J
'Pllled tor ••
ha-.•
(fla.8).
f'Ua
are
Wou.tere (1955)
•loaa the
•k•
bffJI alllCIIII 1lha equip-
the iatereetiJtc
o'been-
'rocla' are
1a Bol1.n4,
na7 be ra1ae4
8
typea ot 111.orol.ith
aa t,ert ot ocapoei
to arrc::,i,- aD4 •pear-a!wtta,
part
whether ell
w
graaa•,
pbnu
••poaator
t:,pea were •--
or tar tiah-aor'iM•
1.Ja t.be liMol ithic
of '•1.ckle-like'
tapl ...
a,
and the lilce;
Planu
eoOMllf'•
or ot ....
allhauab
Some
1a-
ao ffid.-e
tor aucb • t'Wlo\1on 1a t~•
J.a 7et no 1'11'11deeid.o•
cUtt•NJJi
•1mur
ld.erol1tlna
tJPN•
Gell
be •de
about the preoae
Marp1ologiaall7
tuno'lioaa, bu, 1.a different
,
api.Dllere, or
ot the wrioua
aroual a propoeect ••
pleyed
1 ...
ot water ooun ...
bellk•
wateraide
'hoaka',
ae\UNleD\
11bou:\ the tuAction
undoubtedly
clittff · ia wut
ot a type B alorolitl:t.,
•ua .. -w _, •••
heTe 1"ormed セ@
•
alli.ala
aa preo1Jlel.7 mcle aa aoal ...
llot
ba••Nell
!he qUMtioa
tUting
••cl
ot baftUc
'Writere
lapreuioa
'Rodia'Wfl'W
writne
diacuuion
baa tended. to rnolve
taotured
aJIClthe •\bodll
1Ja 'the lalolrll aree• ot ._oli\laia
tba\
bu.t 1,
••ll
aboo\iDg
~-tietal•
tn,ea, aDd •7
ot M•ol.itbio
414 aot.
a1t•
a.
blwat-ended.
prni.Gll8
tor
111.arolitba,
ot 111.oroli'tba uaed
b·ut the geDUlll
...-trt.o
and otAer
ot
ty~
'rod',
Pd
.Aailian
9Jq)erimenta ill Which he au.00... tl&ll.7
(B) la •--bat
1-
were 1"aua4 to tit
cen be drawn tram tM.a ob••natioau
セ@
'rod'
'rile
pointa • t Star ~rr
line ot iJlY.. tiptton.
pouil>l•
1'.be type•
ot
cQltllera wtt.b the berb-angl•
or CanU.nentel
but tboee
(1955) 4-orib•
1Uutnw4
angl•
The antlR
A' preaem, no1ib:Utg concluai·n
and birda•
~o
to note ha. t.h"e
bane llnd entler
loldere
lt.'!Jo
•
oontata
dU'tenat
t\lnOU..
t7pea
(•tba:lo, ••Gp"apliO,
•7
ot
hev• ud
NOMmio,
ar teobllOlop.aal) J or •IV •iJWl• type •Y
/
1a Nr'ata
\mi••
ill
are deellq
w1UI prediotable
ot daip
aacl 119ttern llbic.b l•••
aabine4
it wi tb eueb llllitorm.ity.
The COlm--~ ••
tool-i1pe
!he ou.tt.i.11&
ob'8.i.M4 b7 • •pecal
ooracr of '\he atr-.
·9.
Uaat it••
the r.ot
tre••e:n•
•~r
With
•x.e•
iaecl
tw
wood l.Dduab-19
Scae
tcm11 •7
all
feY0111"9a 'bro.4
• tiranoheta•
nnp
troa
baNJrc•
¥.edia
aot
tihe
1 plok'
ai all).
11'8Pll08l a1gnit1canc••
~)laol.o&1oal
t•tur.-
41...-
witla •
ta• Jd,.-like
(195'• 17)
--,1_..
,__..u,
pnpnU•
la orau-eentca,
em lipi
that a~io
u
It 1a
twacU-1
eppanat
!Illa
The weS,pta of
a&ea•
io the ax••
aeti-
abepe•
beav trenohet (•l•Gll8b lt
an uauall.r triangular
•V•
••1-'•
Renki ..
alNT••
ahOlfa Yer'J' little
•114 treqt..ldlJ'
betw ...
ta
abape• otbera
f'\aDoit.oaaliaterenoe
Iba 1:Jl1l•l
...._u, •
Yar1
aaa\aa a aecU.aa rid&• wb.ieb impert:11 a,-t.ry
d.itfereaoN
ott
b7 atriltiJIC
priDciple
me41ua a.ad liabt
w Joa:
repr••••
tnachata
ec11•la1 in
ot fwacr'1.01111ta ea••int•
• ftrld7
are fola4 la e.i,1tors
2lba
dM:lllltoldal croa-aeat.oa.
at cae
tnm•ereel.7
.i.-u1.,1-.
clef) ·~
lai-o h•V•
alld tnentare
Yaaol.itidc.
ot W.. • tnacbet'
the b\lrlll
beea 11.ned lA ••tl•r
.liYialoa
Th• 'ThaaM Piak'
aot ,-ned,
u•
baw
llluRera
ot the Dritiah
ftJl1.alle4 apeoiaaa
ta ooaeq•DN
•i•••1114fCll'a ~1•
ffllU\F of
Oil
loci•
•
1'.bNe tl.M .. are e<1aaaJ7 tow:ad 1a •uoctatt.oa
ou,u..aDll warkiltcwoode
aD4
tol1-ine
•rleta•••
'blOlf •truck
acnan'81•
reabarptlle4
t'lak••
aDc! oroae-a.-'1a.
hl'lal
The gnat
••111
aa,wba,
•••
one waaderiJJc Mir MNolithio
• obancteriatio
•da•••
ls.Ye had aennl
Atert
typea,
1a
ot
tor
a.a 111.ao
ftoOII paaalble
it 1a aot •o tar
!law 819' ollraaological
or 1eo-
CORI SCRAPllti and Call
reoocni•ed eaoqi U.oli :tbio suublag••
tool.a 'to clia·UDpiah,
.b•TY
.cnn.naand
today u
for •llY
•onpina
to reprd
On moat ai\ea
ea toole
·woric without
•Y well hen ltHA adapted f'or
turtti.r
· ~·
Tb• tendency
with 11Upicicm.
a• they ahow det!Di te aipa
ot •oaa · kind,
and aamtimd
mcturee.
beTe
II
SOM i.ve
proteoti••
or
ed'&•wae iJl
alcag cae edc• (r.7.1).
r•~
b•• ua-4
the f'ona
uaed •• !.lfIVIS,
ctJYioualy ••
!be pu-pcae ot other utiliae4
ne11 ban been .batwt.
plec•
'lhe7 •7
1• uc~i.De
gmp µpqg WPIMe
W..olitblo
.r eenata
wtve
b8d et leeat
atone• other '\hen flint
a tentaUve
セ@
reoo&1d t.1oll ot
pro~i•
and aberle
fe)pbl•• MA •Hf?Mnte•• •
ot qu..risite
P ebbl.••
KeaoU\bla
Geaftiecl
tom indicatinc
or tlint
•a•t•
uaed tor o~r
have frequently
ltND NOorde4
end lorp
IIUIDberaool.l.crled
troll aurfa ..
to••
oa aa1t .ai'-
aD4
att•ta
and ii
a. . cribed
JJIU"t)Oa•
•1
••4 •• aucb.
n
t.b8t
••enthe
in the abe•~
kDappi.Da•
Whet la csrleia
or more detaile4
ta that peb'bl•
t•
quartait.
Scae •Y haTe
troa
ait••
'b•r
the ..
ahod.JII ptrcaaioa
nab'bere or pou;nura on Yeg•'-l>le or other aubatenc...
lalawiiag
Jlonover,
a pntweDOtt tor '\be inclireet
•• ba_.ratonea
than flint
t•
bu, . aurpriaillBl:r
'h.uae.r9tonea',
t.bet 'Uley luve 1,eell
'\eobDSqu• in ,ool•akiaa;
ptibblea reeo!de4
and ailu"°9e
a.ii•,
l'bey are often reterrecl
flt
cl.a•••ot
nan.r u.aworked f1-k•• end bl•dea blive obYiou.aly
or miAa.te irreglllair
1.
Tb•) are di.fi'iou.l t
normal oar•
aucb 'tind•'
the peat haTe HP
vm«IDIPfJJ£iF
( 11)
B·
11biub
GRAVDSare tJl)M
almlr
a1nat1.o11
perouaaion
and other
'bnd• .. , ••n
b•• uaecl ••
There ta ao •ure •Y
aaal,a••
or Tariaua au•
and •t.riala
were
56.
セ@
deli D... 1el.7 ooll.CJted
b,Y ..eoli
purpoa•,aotul
apeoitio
depoai:b,
'iUh
SUtatou
1.he rignt
t• have been
•
l)eabl•
kiDc! ot aGel,-e11,
t1"'0li
aaob ia:>r• ooald be lMmed
tNanologr,
At • llla:bar ot ai tea 1D Cormrall
baTa bNa
fol.&Dd la X.ol.1.Ul.ic
4-~r .. aio•
ahaw wl1-
entel.1
'bn.Ue4
Sou.tb-••t
the••
eooDOIV and tollc. aovementa.
tbq
are all
190,;
'-hare ••
ooourrenoe
baa
aooop• •
'l•••
u.~•
abell
fiah
fro•
GIie
.a.
pr•e:it
Saa
it' delib-
•it•
'l'h• relennt
ot ooeiatel ad.dclan a.i~•
abo\lt. tweai;J' of
ertreatv, ••
aDd cloeel7
coaatliM;
oon. iqalemant..
IUlll>va.
ill
ahd-
in i~rtb-w .. t Scotlan4•
lll•
the••~'bbl•
ot X,b llpd ill
aite
tool.a (•••
Waimrtpt
.
4ebe te •• to ~eir
beM ....
lee 'M>the
larael.1
tbe chlael-Uk1
the .
r
..
lera•
obJeota
•
rrecJc-111:e1at
ab.U
ia lhat
tu
cm ar :l•r
ba• ~roducN
r~.a. lll).
both •idea
• to•
el0&ig.,ed
ia
ooc.ai0111llT
cnade ohiael-lilce
analogoua
with
OOQlr
P-.brakeahira
QI"
to produce•
Brit.ill
and Oou.tib ~•lea
oout•w;
Clll -·
iypee are charac,eria"io
ttb.tN
ihe
baTe bad more dat.nt
'L&e:ett
soooa'
2.
lar
troa 1oc:el
ob~ined
ahown セ@
tor
Pl'Mt11Ubl7
b'OII Deflm and Ool'llllall baYe DHD touDd at
t1nda about :U.olichic
eoattueci
and on.a;
Moa,were
er imended.
but aipiti.aaAil.J
pronanoea.
libic buni4gw,
•
••1087
r ... im
tub
.a
ita ah1U.
Iii~
sao"t.a•
1>••
aecl
BolleTIU", ~rience
1a dro1,1~a tato
'Dolllna
OD iMA•
twlc\ioa.
•tar, ~• aot,
•1'•llbere
to deuab
セ@
UOIID U.t
-·
~rl9
rill
tnerpnta
an
liai,eta
ld.dden depoei'U•
ara,aadll the • ooepted
Wllikel,r ....
1'beir liaihcl
\l8ed pn1111i-tq 1D a
$hey._..
in JleaoU.thio
woal4 Daft
I
•••1tram tile llhell•
•u.e.• .... ;pat ........
that
pr•u-.,Uon
~ia•
Tba -.Ol7
aoh
it
'bod7ot
Vi• •'1N
q'Ui.oklJ
ti•
ot
droJ>
Pebble••!4 £JwRtclPebblf!
pebbl•
uauall7 conaiat or a1100th
Bopr-gl.p•• P9rtw,H4
,.
pertorat.a
Bom-glau
ill diametv.
inchN
pertontecl
l••
·ih• oenwe being
ti.n
(tia• 7.7).
how-glau
eltalaugh
troa both •14-i
that
on either
aal7,
frGII OM atde
•Y lt• watim.ahed
appeariltc
!hey are Oco.aiaaally
are apparently
'•oeh•da';
allie4
ill aectioa
Cupped pebblN,
all
pertonte4
Some. •Pi-ed
iapleMDU•
•r• not, a.ad pr .. u.bl.J
othera
like
'° •• ••oeh•cla',
referred
•• to twio\iOL
the-re ia no impliaaUon
, ot the ~ol• ill
the dhmetff
he•,
r..
a
pebbl•
pebbl•
lad • ••pent.
f\lnotioa.
Palllr1ca\1on ••
ot '•oeb•da')
ettecned
until
oppoainl llolloa
aMOOtbeclby • &ri,Ddillc proc ..
the other a.OOtb).
b:,
PHkillc en altffDtte
by
••••
cono.n,r1o •on,ert..nc••• pndiaed
alld ao ia tnd1U.onell7
MNolithio
quentl.7,
ot '•oehu•'
t.be ooo\UTMOe
weN aultaeq11eatl7
ahow oae enter
ot paetntinc
The teobldqu•
,peaked am
trom both aurtac•
pebbl•
1.D tb•
ea••
(lD 'the
Th• ontera
Mr&ede
(•••.,.l
aurtao•
CoDUnen'-l
culture,
lfagl-ian
(Cl.ark l9J6; 158; bnkine
aDd cupJ>" pebbl•
Camr
194-9).
1D Britain
1a
•ir
nltioam.
80 •nceb•cla'
At l••t
troll Sou~ern
Cemnl
!llaland
P9DD1N41
1a.
the ...
l .96,: 108).
in.N
1.a
DO
texu
Cm the Othff'
et tour aite•
Tb• •ia
••n
ner
ch1ppilw
fQund oa a proUtia
OGlll)ln• apeo:l•a ••
la 188,.
lU.bio•
The
w•t
tloon•
abipplDg
dred&•d
•lorit¥
Cllpped pebbl ..
conoentnuona
•"
Ai
floor
tou:D4
•uooia~d
4M1PSW(&-')
••led
At
•
uolaad
an4
'•or
ti.t
Ulduatria• 1JI
hi Bpd
OOD-
(P .....
with aio:roli'-
'••••d'
)
etc.
tnameni •••
l&Dderpeat ot Aila11tio a.t.; alld a
troll ocieatel pee'\ tit Boreal
•"
South
-ta Kaat Anglu
,he idea
1,ar'I ot pca~K•ol.itbic
were
the
troll
'•cueacta• troll
l95'J ••illlrri&b1.i196J,.
and Blagkpp (Suaau) '•oeb••'
on diatuct
recorde4
'tA•J btY• ml¥ DHD found 1JI Keaolitbic
band,
(Ra*iM
'•c•h•da'
It,
e'Yideno• io aupport
ooncluaiv•
h .. da• alld cupped ,p11bbl••
Britain-
1956: 59, tig.11),
(ll•llld•
(BaU.a l960a 68), •nd at leaat 2
wwal• (\1ieimright
hi••bffA
am about 6 ouppecl pebble•
nnaa, bu\
1-Ye 1aioe bMn record.a
ta
age •• S0lltiae111P\oll
are •••wned \o be Meeo-
Meaolithic
ccmtexta • ••
,a.
Lf!E lelf'9P (x.at)
Tia• n•
~rui,e
and Tbp!i9bfm (Bera.)
atert.ala
..
end quaruiti.o
W•ld
ot tb•
01iher natert.la
•ere
u•• been
Th•
tor qart•:tt•
part~rl7
aaalataae
to
,allel tlvn.o-
ot tile
'•cebeecla'
... IWl8•
• dec:lded tolk-aa..meat
•••
ta
'reatri~e4
Scaiereet,
the qmruiw
tor
aelec\ed
more ar l••
Nt
ot
pe'bbl.N
PRbl• ~
.And tibea•
wider ,ro. .. no••
• ••
tmerprnatt•
PWaaUon.l
poliahed
-~-r.
a• reprda
i.a • wide reap
ffZ'7 セ@
to
ia ffidenoe
tool.
perouaaloa
~r1.•
.. a-a•
1
Ml>re
Bentu bol.ed • ._
•uca•'1ibat \he
--D
Ilda •wi
._..
••n
raain
M .. 1d.
wltb r1.-.1
tor ritual
entin17
Jlaa.Utlaio
haft
'l'heN
llei1;ber.
'fhe:ntore,
m....
'9rtl
' broacU..,~-
'•oebNd'
••
• bat'te4
Ob'Yiou ex.!l()l•
wilh ao
et.tber 114tTeruae4, or
auooiaW
i• eequirN
Qappecl pe\,bl•
2oa to lt-1••
atudiecl
•114 ...-
and cU-enelOM ot peltbl....
l~
ar •~•r
••J or paaibl.J' t1-•
0'1181'9 Mft
••t.ala•traa
2• to 7• • and
tb_..
frca
'•oeb•cta'
perlpa ... 1 bNlaiDC,
meMift
naultlJlc
a~
or t.be •nz
:ia ditt1cnal,.
(195', 6o), ......
b7 Ranki•
. us,
...
セ@
1a De'YOII elllt
'fh.••ftlle7.
utilia
da' ••n
Th• pret'ereace
diatrU:natioa
ao~ iJadigeDDU, •114 -t
•N
•••
tor pertcreti-.
ot lb• Bunter Pe'b'ble Be..
ll'•-1a
al,eoul
Jt.
wbiob •" • 1io
at.ao. it. geologio.l
ua~ena,ing,
out.ro59
t oomcnlJ uae4 tar '•oeb ..
-•ton.a,
•114 •U•bil19
a,-.'r.,
1956, 58J•
(Rallki..M
-* ilat.Ddecl tor
Allallr8aoa.ra
uae.
•r
aigld.ticance.
em-tic.
Shfl• 9reeNPM
ot ana,
ot uale
ban
fia• ,) •
•Ulll.r
1atena t ta tale taot
been
aa well ..
HP
tl'GII • aall
T.be ttac1a fNII ••
aillllar
preew'b17
'lbe7 ....
••da ....
dtJNu are
trca
NO~
セ@
BNd am
.,ntnc,,n
at
aik
ot lt)t
let
Ster Carr(Clark
IEM.W: lffl
Sar carr are •err
1a ».aoli~o
(ld.111rript
(P--J
d4
1967'6 • pl.xx) •
1'•Ulllript
19',1 ll2) •
•like, a11d oloaN.1'
mob
om\ata
19~
b•cla
196): 112,
to tara • neoklaoe,
•'k'WI& to8•ther
reoordecl .,
4rift
ta. t OYer lJO pertan ted, cU.H-lik•
•
tbe ooniaen.
,,.
~.
Qobn
t•
OD •
baTe DMII touad auoo1ate4
(l•Wal•)
12 11111119
ot
th•• ooapi-e
S.U.•
aon
aaU
were aoew\94
ptec•
Iroa axid•
ta
ta.re
セ@
J&eeol.1tbic,
pauible
apron~..
tboap
1ibat 1 t •••
LUIII*
INt
ill BrUaW
ani•ttiN
c.
ban
an4 • , ..
ot the
to have
wbeN oobN ....
ill
to the OOl"IJ9..
A•
セ@
ta Briui.11
cloab'*- It ta
tbe
oODceiftble,
c1eoorq,urc
the peraGDJ or
OOIN troll
ntber
ot ,he •olitllic
at S•r
b-
Carl' (Clark
tOIIIII!
'9J•
(a.11.aa 19'°•
et- ••
are aot oer'au.
a114 thi•
•U•,
the peri°'
tor
oolou-
•
,u .... ,
aa,aa
with tli.Aw , 111~.
,he pneiae
avggeeta • ooauoti•
poiai
セ@
auooiat1
ta thlt
Clllly kwn
with tn41Jlc
Pem-
tbe · preaenoe
CouideriJII
iaen9tiJII
Bo1TCM4-le 1a ~laa4,
1951.,1 1,7) are
fbr a\rlk.-.•liab'•·
.... •o.14 ha.......
ocea•t-ll7
and J3relme A&• reaim
ot tbia snJld.te
t1.A&I _,
pouibl•
•••
*•• ~" an
of Jleol.lt.bio
uae4 ~t
ritlllll,
wit. arletaeu
J.ll ob"ri.-
ot snpath
•a
oohN
pou ... 1...
ot 1rall pJ'ritea
imenaturc•
ll,loh
ot iibaa• aoUvitia•
ued tor
am
a114 Deepa.r.
ot oabN re•i•
••
i.Jt&oloUd.JI&or penaul
Pinal
troll PenaiDe
to 11•• •• i.mpnaaioa or lit•
mdeDoe tor either
DO
1,,e),
(Curit
pieoea ot re4 aD4 yell°"
Coak'•Stuq
an4 1A burial
Pr••V-
At
(Clark 1951.,, 167).
C.ft'
colleotiaaa
tona • .,..
la nriou
beea uaecl ow1 zr.bll7
iw,
•t
CivUiAati.OD ta ar'
llmter
••ll
tlia
......
tloon•
••rereocwend
reel ba-ti~
out ~t
or reel iron and ..
ahipplltg
pieoea tCND4 a, Sur
(19'oa '9) poilau
• .._.,
of 1.U.•
with MNoUthic
wt• aild.lar
often be •••
a1,..i...
Bri tab
Smtbff'll
....
loaal
ooaurNDCe
•114 •ft'7ina
perloct.
W:H¥PTWTPIAL§
AlmfotJ IP!JHPTB
!here are ......,_...
tOlllld •
... olithic
1a t.DON
chlppiJt& tloan•
ot pe'bblea am tlillt
for --••'
or ..... 10.1
tJPN
'°·
l)
2)
SUtatane pebbl• trom DnoD end CormraU baTe been taund at
(Renk:ine 195').
hraba• end Oeldaanaar in the t.•ld•
'Kaoeh•cla'
•1»¥ Wulden
,)
ot alien
•it••
quarbit.
are oomparatiTel.7
(R•llld.De 195') •
OOIIIOll
on
oh--' ot the Blaokdolfll bill.a (SOINl'Set) end the
blUa ( Deftll) .....
to bav• bHll widelJ' diapened. •1Dl7
Gl-e._nd
•ldaD
to the
'WMt
(Stone 1958) •
1a oa aac)7 touncl on •it.a
1D South-tt .. t SD&l,an4,
and••
tTM aarriecl to ait•
Oil the Iale ot ,igbt, and Fa!'llha•
Moat ot 1t •eto baTe CON tram aouroea • the Iale ot Portland
11illelf (P.l•r
1~70) •
~)
PorU..Dd oherl
5)
Oil Perm1Me a1., ...
abalklalMla or
K.U.ra 1964.)•
All tb:l.a ol•r17
OYer a
wim
~1•
ot thNe extn__.
whioh ooul4 aal,J •••
COM frca ibe
ta • 41-tiJlotiTe type (RacUq •
tuD1
••twhite
!orkahire,
incJioatea tolk
of Palltrglaoial
u...
t"1.IMta1n terma
ia at preaent loet 'to ••
or berter
.,,.•••
Bolfnv,
ot •••cmal
Syate•tic
the preciN
p.tterna
cbanotffiNti
ot fll"J'UIIIordera,
eigDUioanoe
ot acw-nt
,on atucU•
lligbt
or traa.
prcwicle
61.
7
1QtLifflIQ !RtIW
Vff'¥ little
la kllwn about KeaollUdo
nta
Br1'81.Jl, a altua\loa
of praaw'1cm.
••
aenenU., adnn•
r•tl•'-
or ao loa.U.\i•
So far Olll.7 • clos..
blft
OODdiUam
pro&aeed ltGDe
an'1.er lllll)leaeDlae
41HoYen• ot 111artt.a'b-.
i.oi.w
.aa.Bor*
4Ndae4 froa
.-,en
A BoNal
'-7
•••
pi ...
Nia"Ment
(••I•
two plaia
•-
at
Le•i:Ue
illdua'Q7,
Oa1,7a
(Clark 19'2• ll5 ) .
19lJ ) , •114
t,JPe
_,
19'1),
aa are •ix
of ....
'Iba ...
al1iboup
n•ill
•taal•aiM
ot antler
NOOHn4
aiaae be•
iJlto ... terll
recopiaecl
(Clark
tna tbl
riTII'
to repzoea•\
aD\ler
•gl
..
...,..,
la••
at Ba\t~•
aD4
1eai.U..
All
ian oocurruoea
reowen4
attoak•beaclll
troa
19J2a l.8) .
oben"OD c1ecora,t.ea at Ba
wi~
(Ana_...
aaa\lM4 the t these taoi. tecl
allll Battera•
oonaideNd
a.Te 90• trea the ....
i1t1
11-h•d
tna
t.be
(J .. up 1970)•
ot tbea• ~--•
att1Dl.t1ea
•*-
ot IIIDla
pola1a
Sk.ipe•
•iJlsl•
aaaple
tor two ot ilaea• (~
t7pea baft
•llclftortb
baTe 'b...
poillta
aad a llaDe ba
111.ddler•-..
tlla
ot •taller
potnu
.,
of the OOIR1.Jlen'tallltgleaaaua
ut.Da10D
ftAa. are aiallarq
...
••ttltahecl
••
(Yartca.), llOJS~ (lerla& Cl.rk 19J2), alld. two eDapl•
lNrl•
fNII tlle lmer
...
-.....
•Dd Olrer
C011NC111•t.l.7
1t ta aeaenll.J
aD
Da&l•• Banecl
llorUalcel
the L...-
bewe•
ol•el.J GDIIPred to 111.i-ua
'bND
en.rt 19J').
iUoa,
S•
baa 'bND
1'22,
Bra ...
po1.aui-n
1A Bolctern.u (Anauen& 1922, 192J) • •Dd •
allll llorm•
セ@
u--..ted.17
and bODe wGrk 1Ja Sa.~
aatlar
h•enr,
••
traDabet as•
fOlllll&l aetulq
toad
lll7
Ana.,..
at Ski.pa•
clepoai\ •• 1ibe 'boae polDI.
la ...
... ooutecl wita •
•1
Thenf"are .a..tr
preoiae
baa proc!\aDe4 • auaataatial
q1111a-
,.
ill S•~
and baa. arMfaota
Brit.ta
la aNooiat:l•
•Uh
• lllaroliWc
flia\
lndwltr,
- the aite
utt.11ae4 •lag
•en
sype...
at.h,
a.talle4
ectc•~;
and then•••
paraUTe ••roity
T•riaUOD
ao'-4
••
•• la wenU
ot W..
Ta$
u-.
•Uweai-
baa •t
•• • b.H•poell
'DI• reai.D4er
liue
bened
'IN' ....
s-
•1
peillla
H ..
1a wt~
antler
iir.ai ...
alld ea '-
ban
MDU)
lithia
tanc for •Nlll"lllll
or
•na
•
t.be ta ..
waed to • .._..
tlle claa•t
tnea•
ccapartaoa
ait
ill Tie•
and ot
•U•
ot wood;
ot ho
tb••
to
,pal.au
tu •jori'7
CoaequnU,,,
al
u'f'e
•1
a barpooD h•cl.
tor the Ster Can azatler pdata
ot the 1•nenl
ot ai.ldlar
•..a•~
o•tiMnt,
a
attiDiti•
aaro1t7
•a•(late
ot bane
Pn-Bor•l)
111p, N •t ..
alMl
botb
.a •Uh
9\111ptoloa.
The
polllta
(binla~NII)
G, ttg. S,..)1 and OM ••
Grwp
la Brit.a,
..-1aa
la Brit.aia
aaae
1aa
be
,o ta.Te 'bMn ape9rb..- .. , altlaou&b • t•
..a1clen4
•uu•• \bat
Oa the 'beaia
o1n1....ODe _.
la tbe
iaire•
•14•
bllt •
t'iae,
•t.r
cm bandl.•
a\eri.81
ha-,• Nell ....-.a la
•ctffe4 •• atflllllbee Ill ( ••..
Clark
.r
pertor
•l 1ihw&hshe
6 I),
J)
po1ata •-
ot nela
prabe'W..J
\he realme
apeet.aMa an
abafta•
••Dllab-4-
wtila • J)elfoaUall
Tff7
ot ,ha ••·
セ@
Jll'9811111,~l.7
_.,w
•en
ohanoteriaUo
r, and •P9ei.DC ot berN,
....
1
(A1 .I, C,
ol t.beae lleft-4
h•d,
•--•••
there •n
abancr\er
S P'9Q9
yet ~-
Tll• wrt...19 tunoUom
bartaa ••re
allll the oharaeter
Clazit 4eft.De4
ot ~•
olaNitied
IO h
oar
Olll.7 aae apNi.MD •••
セ@
ot
ooa-
1D • t'ng1N11tei7
(both t..tuna
the ooatinea~.
1D n1-U•
•• ..U
ld..tl•DN
GD
the
hoa
wp......a bena, and•
abaenoe ot
'Dae ajarU.r
UAg•
~.
"°"_...
All tae po1aa were 'bel'NCI cm
allglll.ar ~le
with ••
QPN
aaat ot th•
poaU)le.
arked
ot Hl'N
Pa1-eolitbio
ated threlap
ot elk •114 •••
••lar,
at11q •••
anc1 elk • .u_.
Ben Nd .._.
pout (ttaa• Je.7•51.). or 191 apeoiJlem
ot re4 et.er (•tag)
187 ._..
ot i.te
(Cl.rk 1951J.
tu Uab b--
witb
tbe berlMcl
ditlOIIJ al~
..
§ter ctrr
ot
arocw•••
aplimer
1.a well ao.am.n-S.
,ee1a1.qu
!he
ail•
•'rcmcl7 •ua•'-
IS"9...aea~
oal.z ..i.
bND ua.«! ta sh1a teallld.q11e la 1the
I and the T-,:Y •1deapr•ct
tor she prodllctla
flia*
OOCl.ll"NMe
... ,
p.Yer
of tl.1Dt
'bone alld anUer
ot
the Sur
a1te •bioh
(RPporhd
IJ'9TUW
•
C.rr
ld&bt
'by eQ91"1•
Britiah
are.
...
pol.Jlta were a1ml.i.rl7
,,.
ot red deer antler were alao tCNDd at St.er
Other toola
loulerl7
diapoeUc
Q rubaiJtccton '-be tipa
th•••toola
IICat ot
la taet
•• , at
bol•
ft•
aD
••11,
adapW
•ed
4ri.Tea abUqu.ly
'lb••••re
•t\arall.7
tor ••
'be
tor
•• mMDI
(fta.71)
St.r
la llld.Q\I• •-.
Can'
-1117 (W,-r
.
Th••tinda
•• an arl"Olrh•d.
••
•
OD
•IV other
At
Pfllte\Jt
la Rona
l9'8a tia•l.65),
(Clark
qld. te ••aluaiY..
!Ito et.her tiada
torka•)
tor
•U•
l:Nt
ot
potata
At
w b.n
•••
•••
thia
ot Ol'pllio •tenal
la auooi.•
1)e,mea1D the
セ@
on. ot reel cl•r anUer ••re
..
piecea
(19'2,
ti1•
be••
llozeoYer, tben
in ,.Brit.ta.
the IJ'OO' '• and aplin'ter
teabldq\le,
aor
ot antler.
poiat ..
boae objeot
aa
セ@
U.an with tb• atoae tnduatr., a aot
pe~ioalar
ben.
OGIIMa barbed potm ot reiA4Nr
pioked
•killl
lboee troll Star Carr, and
ualik•
• •~•4
c1eaerT• aan'1•
ai11Uar Mrbe4 pot.Jlt •••
an4
aite
ua auoca
•nR"t.bel ...
roou,
\Ip
prodlaoecl ltoae \oola
ot polmecl and bnell
artt qlliu
W•l•
(19511,, n.a.69).
piDa tor akin
the w•lta
wbiah •••
kDalfa ».olitbio
ot 'bll~
at St.er
r1s.n.
a1t•
tar~••
cli.rMI ff14eaoe
tor ~. })ro4uDtl•
ar taat.-ng
an4 lt,Ul •t.aarpala
lirituh
tnanaen•
taun4 alftll& wit.ii Tari ...
ao parallel
,rd
tua.a
wo plaiD pot.au ot '90M
19'2),
or akime
bcmea at elk (tta• 70) •we a~it1oull7
are •ortb.Y ot 1.Dtena••
a'1an with ldorolit.ba
tor p,aboiJII
•e4
•• bodk::\N
tlaktna
•.-...1other
But
pr•9"ede
that
parpoae.
poaeibl7
ocaaalomllJ'
and
auggNU
l•tber
working
luaea
the bell4, •o the baD4le WOl&lclbe
pauiblJ
••carpel
pota~
Clark
•ttock-b•cla
J)erfontecl
~n-
troa anUer
tban reel 4eer antler
tbroq.b
or tor acme abd.lar
and ahepea
olotbillcJ
ot
to • ••ri•
aGllte •• 1..
tor tnpa
tar
--
uaecl aaab more •~r11lglJ
•••
e4&••
to to.na allOfth bffelle4
ne\riotecl
111• pertanUan
ObJ•crla fabrioeted
(19S,.., na-6.5-66) ••n
Ilk aDUer ••
CaJT,
•1aal•t.
t7pe •en
A
0.JT•
ocCUl'NIICe ia iatenaUJIC•
J'rCIII ibe
a.UR,
11Pla 1852 •
V1o1911f
9!••(Settle,
Wi 1ih two rcwa. ot 'bllrN;
\be abon
at
N:YNA
a
\Jlo~erlelld
).
{CU.rk 1932. 14.J.
SciuUlva BrUaill
aad baYe theu-
tCllljlld. I.A
uU.ke arq •~ere
oo.paraoaa with ltiaerieU7
clc:ie•t
•1•
oaaatal
w11ib • tl.1.IR 1Dduat17
la Monb-w•'
i.ned
SooU.nd.
a,u
,,..
!be ..i,
tontect
ill •Nooutioa
Theae polma are totely
palnta tOlllld Oil MeaoU~o
2.
t1lad ••
lleitber
ot 110l'ked all.U
tiad
.. •-11
.,
traa Jn&l.•114and Wal• ta •
reoardect
cliao tram .....
per-
.1,••, rmtem {cl.ark 19'8&
oU*ic
ftcel) •
,. ••s
'Dl• cli.a~er7
ot •fferal
••ablac•ill
ir-•'
ia .. , at
troa
to b• clia~
with a~pbio
{aa.11.-t..a)
•Olll'O•
ot the
••l,aia,
'tbe7 oouli
anetaoa
ot
attiaiti•
S.l 'tio •twial,
l"•t
Ster Carr pieoM
'beooae
'-
..
n,. 7-.)
1951.,,
••t coeat
Siaoe allber traa '•
geaenl.
ot tile imdia~
1D41•Uoa
§BE Cfn: {en.rt
•'
ta riMr ot ••ppaa .. Baltic
t.• TffJ aip:ltioent,
tor iiM
•llber b ....
ot Britain
oerlain
DO
oaa be giT...
But
fiDda
, ~n\
tl'GII tb• alte.
,... Jed •94 Bprk
ot .._.
ftada
Brida
ait.ea; and apia
l9~s
pl..DI);
ltND •ed
and Claa
a• t.pva,
'Nea a& etfdifl
aulNeq\Mlllt ••
of reaia
adwDON
er •• .tloata
aDll ooa.'enieaa
•lpU'i•DN•
aa
U,&hU,
•WNl"Oll8
layer (CJ..ric
ot U.. anhaeoloat.al
wri ...
M'Ye
ex:plana U.OIIIII .. JTOlf Ollell •1
tor ne'8; larp
ot •~
•••
nre
tO/lt' ooateuaere aad olothiag,
roll•
•7
ai..llpq haYe
bi.rob bark, 1aiencle4 tor
or t 'or 1.ta
or •l*r-h•da•
C111multe
•• a •ovoe
Siplt10.nl7
セ@
ot
ltNll reowerecl at Star Carr and alao a\ 'l'batomm, and ••em to
cSelOent•
"' S~r
'buil\
a t••ur•
needed tor IIDIIBU»g arrow-
reata •••
i.Dclia.w
or mrk are per\iOlllarl,r
§ME 91££ la ot kq
ot 'btrah 'bark an
wOlllld rolla
wood
OD
Oarr birch
iJno a liYillg
a1ie productt.oa.
tre•
plaitonaJ
were apJarentl7
alli Woocl ..
r.u ..
\ Uft
bND
uat.na core ax•,
uae4 ea~i•el7
•nil
tor
banc1l•,
•h•t•,
ban
wa7 ,ot tiniaii.4
(birab)
•n4 other
objecu.
iurpoe•
'lhe 11C11t
tmportent
padc:ll...
wood•
aDd •Dother
AD aetul
••retowd
w1.aa"9o
dur011t
uae
OD
•••
per'
••
tCIW!d 111
t..u
or • wooden
at••
another dndce4
frail
....
All
e.lloN
and the suaaex abore;
tll• riYer et aal..-on-'l'ba
two
•
(J' .. 111>1970: 51)•
ltelaw 5' ot peat ocrnred
ll'
It ••
clva-•t
t'l"'Ca セ@
(lld)
tOIIDC111a ahel.17•rl
snaa
troa the ATOii wlle,
ftla••V•ll•7•
1-Dd •urta••
•t Clafff! (Jaaa)
u: .. et §pmrdt•
lz,u1abd
canoe••
an old ooeatel
out or •• oak tz'Ulllt (J' .... p 1970).
ot V•ol.1Wa
kllon
tilld
or baa 1:a oamee
ola7 at Spardp1ieat (neer lra&'bollrlle).
It•
little
paddle.
Pur1ih.er eTi.clence tar •e
aoll••d
- elth~
lOIIICwUb • 6• "-rt
th•• t'1Dcll
au-.4
to
ot 1AcSe,erm111a1e<Mte are
an4 ~"
..
erie
aDd
ia reed.._.
(SurNJ, •
ot
8
'ffll WPII MWPP!ffllP!J9!
lh• 1enenl
la
arob.eologi.Gll
OUlldaa,bllrial,
ot babitet1-.
i111P011e•tobjecle
'-,
aenae, • SITI 1a tbe plea. •hen
.to.t.•
•it• are
UaueU7 1ib.. •
,ouaa,
or the
bMD
•-4
after
ai\•
,arda•
? heee ait.a
•ltea', •
to•
1eunlq
~t
p-auda
illpl.-.nta•
ileen o.Ued
ill wbioh
a kill,
n tber
an
or •lallar
a11111
.....
un
•
cllaoorere4 it
Ma
.•ta•tom, fOIIDI
wlaiall gi.Te li.ttle
OODti'\i-
••re
• •P.
•
•• Yraolltbia LOCALITIJB,
la 1ll!p09aible to
セ@
Yi.dad paaitin
uaoea ot _... ••
...
ilao ooll-'i•
4utrl.but.1-
1'be queaH .•
ia ~-
Brit.ta.
•7, , but
al.7 H
raaiDI,
.r
and,
laaa b ...
ot Keaolltialo
Mir mob an~.
t•
_..
UJIHl..Ufio
ait•
..a.r
aDd
oCJDtitioaa
on.
ta
tool.a llaTe
•billh
•1'-
....
wt•
セ@
ffi..._.
4eftm.te
all4 MleoUT••
la .lrlt.1.D
lcnc,n,
Briuab
ot kaalrn ait•
eU Ina'\ • ._
•bola'
a ...
ll•
N •• •117
ot ._
auONUiOD,
t:n...-
hat
it •7
werwh-1-Sas •Jorit.7
1a poor ...
i;reMJWUola
1a
about the .. _...
w ao w1clttloe ot aint.tcnpllio
.All 1IDld セ@
ae-.1
1n ..i,.11&1 ana•
or .)It* b ..... \la the avtaoe,
•
cliNJ)pNNCI.
of ' atnii.p9pq.
•Clll'ke4
•n b•
ara •
._11
'~p
••
lnc1iTiduaU,
1•waa
allllalllaDOeor Meaolt.'111.oai\ea
beoa••
an -s,u-alr
••
ar_.
apeak flt ._.
--•be.......,
Yaaolitllio
where tliat
u.e •••
iibeae aiw
IY.. ao, cletim.te oanoJuai-
•• 10,000.
QI"
a1, .. .
••
•1•
to.._
be poaeible
pzoet.,.i.i.
~ll
tleora'
aquen
And the7 haft aot alllla78 bHII r1oac 4acl iD41.Yi4ualq.
it. •-14
ftaa it .....
Bri ta uu tlin
et • t•
'abippurc
·they appeerecl to lt• plaoee
OIi \he oUaw baad,
tbe Peut•••
therefore
kaolr•
ot an
looelit7
tlla
•r••
a..w.c1 wttaa •1 w ot \h1a k:lJl41 tAU 1a •PM1a~
•19
tt.M-ai,o\
widel.7 1D SOil~
l:o oOY.- w.U.-den.n.t
foaa4
M'H
out
4o
ill Ulia • .-.
••t• are
ta •Dd
l..apl ...
like
ni4ence
000\&re
lfNoli tide
law
<r Ml}qt.I'§Ic arm
R-lm
••
JlffU"
IN
Nat
be
pr.-
iD anea
• aened
tiaea.
Meaolitllio
pololi,oal
:"'or iu 'tence
ntAt
oorer keepina
l1tU•
•h•r•
atertal
•her•peat
Dllt it 1a not セ@
that
a nd diaoovff7
prelliatorio
liai.U.aa
prnen,
•
reaim,
r••ia•
onen been
tM cleane
colleoted
N~Ul.17
!be rNOrd
ot Meaolitllio
an.-
11197 •1
a.
.AU Naim
•1 •••
l•
a-im
•••
At,.
Or, er.a
•1
•1
ban NeD
1.
be
Nell to.ad Mat
•rJUI
ot tinda be uaerpN,ed?
flNa
~).
tiJlcll
••
セ@
•
••'
ia • a-11
t.ep or 1-ebia4 a
a1w.
ap U.pt
there
..
ooapl.at ..
lalaak
araa&
re11-.
..
tloare'
1a
ffnl.7
.lleaoliW.c
•1'•·
....
to
halYe
ooanaaiag
i.111.li•
ertiPce
Jr(lbablJ'
tor
ot
••t• aoaa\1--
tOUD4 •
• IIUl•
111)1.aDCl
•~•·
Pouibl7
auab
•1111
peo1a1171a
11P
bNII SJa aU
.uotiaer arn....-ta
NQ~
0: cmipptap
lara• baal4er.,
tia\ril:Ntioll.
••1•
lwDtere •1111their
Maolithio
aheltere wa..
collecriiaa
ot
app•l
tl'GII oae or '9o a""97 tU.Aia pidt ..
1abipplll&
•U•(altMqh
Ot tileir
abanoiariae
dittenn
•aidac
1a
clittiault7
ttae ••lbeUo
Yapri•
adeq,aa-17
nadll,
Pl'OM'bUit7,
apeoiam,
r•crdecle
IWftr
t•-...
Clwioua a1, .. ... ari.DN aa
geologio.l
tozwerd •• apleill
p&t
1'heN are OD17 aurtaoe
arnnc--•
iD tbe oaae ot
Thu
or ltNA aalae4
p..UW
or ••talMliq
wAiob ataocweret
OINl&piecl.
nnw baTe It.-
•1
Jlo Mrtlru•ka
u,
like
or • ..,
wi1ibia -iv erea 1a nenr
1ooa11,1-
:tnter,retaUoM
a..-enl
w
lmentoocl.
am tae
ld.croli~,
tliatwOl"k,
'l'hentare
4iatrilNtioa
iD the ia.tt.ar. ot tbe n.11111,...._•lT•&
rooted
.
mah
.r
aot beilti tlllq
wlu
Wl7 alip\.
ot recorcliJI& 1a often la
~gree
'l'be7 bave too
'11•1r arobaeologioal
pa~
troa kAclaiDC the U..l
fhia
an
t.lae
.)at
a'IICb •• chaAOM ot 11N9erntieD
taotore
b11t elao t.he tactor
• r• reoo:l"de4.
rMaina
runt
ne.~l
ot a\lbeeq,aenU1
reqvJ.nmen•
Meaolit.ldo
a 1.tM ia ,1aeae al'#•
b11t the obanoee ot diaeoYer!Dc
.....
or 1a riTer
Other arwa
1a 1Ja pNCNU•
1111at.bl• T9&e118ti011would baYe Mtiafied
ainoe
baa prcwi4ed • ata'ble Te&etet.ion
•• 1A the Pemaiusl
\llldia~ed,
wbtrn tl11Tial. depoai tim
Talle,a
baa leken ,i. ..
obaqe
oolleniaaa
repreaent
"he place w•n
••po111
wh.Ua't ••iti.Dc
.a. •-ot flint
rauna. soae
an
or ahi-ldnAt
Others,
ot tlillt,
pieoea
rw!.M
ten-.ae
m.orolit.m, •7 1-e the
ot ...
•••t• ia
wll
H •cSe ot 'the •a.,
A aent1.0ll _,
aitea,
Mlaol.i\hic
ot '11• JlelloU~o
80llt
a:pl.a1111Uon
t'ltataork
•t ~ta
1a M
daab'
111111
t thq
rrue4
Widely
•••tend
the
lt••
oould baTe
per:loda.
Age tU.nta that
an4 the l't•l4e
•U•were uaei,
by thN•
later
,aplaa4 eree••
tor <rery 1111Gb•
the kUla
....
ot
ill the PenniNa
Npect.117
aoubt ot their pz-•111oe iJI tqu
theN
died with one ot
cm• ad.U-top
that the ••
••
ot en cq,...a.4
·U.
leoli.1ill1c all4 Brou•
It l»• aot 7et l»eea tiral.7 ••'bl~
pieoM
do¥ aaha it 1a p .. ibl• tbtlt
1
alopea bNY.r ra1•
ra.
that
enbltl
A f\lrtber
tleab•
atn7
had
lay MeaoliW.C •cba.lta
loai
•oeidenlelq
rea,iJ:I& plaN
ot p•
ror ...,......t,a
OooeaioDelly,
MNoli'lld.c a1t• 1ituaW
••
baYe lMeJI 1"114 -
beYe ....
•7
•PMielly
ot an apaaed
••tiered
at 111a poet.
•peoialq
••pcm.or •Y •rk the
the••po1111a 1-uri-4 ill lu
• look-out
or that
peopl••
and
lowner,
there•••no
Jlllll'PC9• •• the ._o1ithiAs
...
mmtue.
'l'here are MYenl
5wthern
,-.. n {probeltq ... aooo .e.c.
•• -t
litble
o.altur••
or
d.iatl'illutioll
tit•
~"1 ind1Tidual
NeeAiem
~.
1
ihere
iY• of •
.....
elaoat
or AWltiD&p-GlllP9
•tJl&l.•
IJ'OUP,
セ@
ot oo.atoaa1
.,
or
pleoe tbe 4ia,r1but10n
ff•
repl.,lr
...
.....
:ta i.ao-
an
illdi•U•
Ill additicm,
IJ."'OIIPOil --..aiTe
pot.au ia tillll•
1D Ti ..
ot
1Dduatr,y 1a r•pr•••t-
Ja117 •it•
eooeomd.o inditioa.
eD4
~. ~it..
work a'ftilabl•
ot ... oU.thic
pepw9,
ie
or .....
ilbe •••c:aoiated liWo
•
ihouaanda ot
tacnor
ot a1, ..
•rv .. ,_
1a
4iatrilNtiOD
oy oa=-1 MOloai.•l
19"-rll
at ditterelR
'-'
111'tbie .....
aatiure and cliatrl.bu,1•
•1'91
mYe bNII ODGU.piedb7 iii•
le ao praat••
!1>9re i• IIO pnuel
.._._.
'° ,ooo a.c.), •rk•
\be anul
Thenhr•,
ait;e •7
nr.t
la セ@
oertl.S.nl.7 eakne11le4&e • ••aOJ1el
or b7, dltterellt
i., .. •7
about Uae »-oU.thic
prcmeW..,ocmtlllllGUIIOOC111patlon
cw.-
oCIIE'l'Mpon&I to
:rurtb___..,
••nu
•• tar •• it 1a kaalr•
BriteU..
ot kDO.-n att•
to
poiata
IIODe Tff''.J
wAtcb d.eacril> ..
au ..
ill Smthern
up-to-•t•,
._l
wmt u
Br1t.at.n.
with
klMMD•bout
l1111teed •
ael.eo\e4 •r••:
the
;.
SCN\b-••t
bgbnd.
,.
Sou.ih-w••
ln,l•ncl·
Ulltor\unatel.7.
ioa end ••ologicel
cbengeJ bu\ • •jor
OOG11Pt
tioa with la\er
tbe
lt ..
._oUtld.•
au-'"'ot
•
•ctc•
aecrtiom
'fberetGN
:latrick,
oa tlae beau
Bolwl ar .AU.nUo periocll•
tl.00!9 •••
ot thee• an
~nt:
ot KeeolitibSia tne llan
alOllg • etretob
ot coaaUiae
b ...
tMt
eTitenc•
JU~ iaand
ot \he ooeat •
(•l•JII
aulllbe.r
alll"hoe a1t•)•
._~
\be ..-
......
17 eoeatlilae
ot ..UMaat
CRJMDOII'
mu (1181.at.rltlk et el 19}6) aad LDI
._...1a
セ@
belo.tc \o the
ot ait .. •7
mu,.
.
alaoa,
Cla7
ot Tery Maaaua iateroalat.1.-
the •.1ori'7
ioo.w
Boallff
.
It .....
pr.-
Ila••b"a
ooaat
1:ben ta ao preciae
..
pea••.a.ta•
det1Jae4 ahipplltc
11Gr~lan4
IYarJWb_.. t.beae attea rea'l •
'blaa
witla J*,lea-claW
la\e
Dmiaaa ••
1a olitt
\0
a.a are ooirerel
apa~
lqleDd
bee bMD. the orerwhehd.•
a.1atr1•(:a.,J.Je). J'liata
pelata
1-land
rmai.D8.
•loltc 1!le
peper 'b7
•
nc!T•re• ooadi.Uona ot preavq\-
taetor
Ba......_.
'bT
.a.
da'-• .i....._
..
f'Nll •rilepool
~eir
~\orio
•itae
•' •19
tou4
he• bMA wri.U•
!bia unc!aabte417 retleeu
troa th• aout.b.
1)
little
8'.lrpria~l7
a\ aa.,
u..
1a
,l
the •rl\f
•••
Poal-alaeial
'
of the pnaen\
oamaeetede at l••t
li\Ue
--.l4
•t
baYe 1-MD l.ooaW
U.Dt (••• tta•}).
in ~rl
Tbentore
witb • ooaatal
MO
work baa 'bND dODa to enable UII to inter
Ye'67 llllab l\u'Uaer to \ae
thee• a1, .. •7
11'•
aa ....
Dllt'or-.Mli,,
fNa
baYe , ...
too
the !IOQllll
cliaouMM 'b7 .. iatrialc
tta..
. lmollll at that
at1oa,
(l93lb),
lo atteac,t
~-ltl.1
altboqb
•4•
••
ot attee
IIOte4 the aaaber
blat be _..~
ot loa-
,o a111l,ae the nriet7
1a a...a.t
tale aitu.ti•
anel0&GU8 to tibet 1a
Ceza\ral Pe-t ,wa cliaou.uecl by Ballam ( 19'<>)•
~.
2) Radle7 (19'8)
•Jon,7
ot
laaa aul1aed
aitea
kaalr11
v-,.
ea.a~, llhiab 1- aari.llU
\bare
ia a •:rited
ot 'be ..,..
ot tale •U
1N 1ud•
tiad
tritalia
.U...
llaat
the
ell"
permit
an
!'he ..
•7 .U.a
clia\ributiaD
ia *8
•1.no•
b7 Recll.q
'betw.-a 11008' a..S 1,500'
ua ;heir
at ~•
41.Moffre4 iDWria~
7 aubeoU,
...
1.
••
•bae
ddUlllDecl
• 1...,.1
that tbl"'ff
,ta.
•U
oancliti-
ot eroaiaa
(19'7)•
41N-
b7 tire.
tile
Ute abMDM ot 4etaU ..
Central
atraU-
baye .-
A,pneeat,
taeta
)dtoln
VJ)Oloeical
ohrcaol.oaiael
er other
blaa DND deel"$ wi\ll
PemliD•
•1'-
ot
'!be •Jorit7
•e•
to
Oel). m tb• IIDor9 tlaat aN ecwerecl 'b7 PN'•
pree..,.,1...CbiJ,iJW
iawfaea
pea'
lte•eeD
haa Nell
'-
witl:a 'fardelloialaa
aorarn-4
ail•
tib• ohoioe
tloon,
••
,o•
•
•••
lM•
peei alld the @4er1Jiltl
CC11111eq11an~ U..
.S.l!Ude&
tb• pa,,ere td cUavilNtua
eaaloe7
-t
whiob
baa 'bNA ~ad
•117 cul:-.anl,
to .....-,
•1'••
(196o) alld
...
Ill
aa4 w_pper OOID'S•
alaac ttngera
'llbere PM'
a117of Uleae
olitlwl
o11T11ual7 • ta•tor
dn•
al"N•
M N aai.4.
poeaible
N-ell
cliatiDD'l•
lie
•tAdn•P'
an
aore
_..
1, ia
••~ia
J)
and are a°" ~ad
•U•
are 111111'1
Q..IU, alll MAUI.U<2QIS.
~--
clo Nt
1Ml.olri-•
pe.,, and
Moe, ot ~-•
•i4e
the •og\h
ot gritatcm.
on the 'bread •pine
aoore.
ll1p
aaae •all
are tOQDcl an th• undu-
b•••e:i•• h•dlla\ere
and par'1.oularl7
ot ••
ot l.ara• ait•
GIi
the
ncrtb.
although
•peoul.q
•loaa
tCNlld
t\ar\her
the dol•J
in
billa,
•Jori'Y
aDOn 1,000• o.».,
r1Y_..,
.-,
the
baTe ao tar b"n
aitw U011 a little
\be peripieral
Balf nv,
lat1.Da wa\enucta
セ@
The
IJ'.'Olllld,am ,11.U an wauual
rwaiu
ot ai\•
pauei.'7
l>••tCIWld ia
ai.'99 haft
t•
at
la Yi•
tiOA 1a .North-Mat Yorkllhiree
'° high
are oontiWNl
alNDdlanoe ot a1woli'-•
Jqua~
the •1 t.
lara•
111t••~ ot
ate11-.
Balla•
1ibe aam1.aen,. 1, .....
ot oaapla,
areaa,
71.
aurtace (wbidl uuall7
•}
A well•dretnecl
lt)
The
o)
Jfot too t1r t?"Oa riYera
pr•.,.• ot
en edJeo•
1a not to a,;.y t~t
But tld•
aoU).
.. Dd,
itMnt
or etnea.
aprinc
or •terw.1••
Pennine
••••ml>
lag•
and T~!"denoiaian
CIIID
be
oaapaNd,.
the hillll
then
lam,
to higb
atirel.J
TU riYen
( ...
\rib•'tioll
acwing
clua-tered
around rou.,ee eud
&llaa
196(), •P
,) ,
eda• ot promnen rldc•
a1, ..
·U•
ltball.CM hilla.
aclwaoe4 Yer:, tarJ
and ~Uabecl
セ@
a:,ai-1:10
Aplll
ten
1a
J.G.D.
li "1.e 11,.ra_..
19'2J Clerk•,
AJl&l,u.
Altb-,b
1960).
!he ..
ana Mitllara
pr•erwli•
ot orpnio
Yelleya
(et. '!WOMILi
m.LIJG,
border1Jls
•Dd ...
111..
ot aitu.U ......
then
f'ort.beGIIUIC IUMJer _..
aen ..
bNt
t•
baa len
••NlhiD&
uar...at
elacet
all
•n
tor ,be
am\duble
tloore sre waall¥
Nan ftNDd •'
bu .. th llON reoen\
---.o
( Clark,
lomt .. 1A riYer
(or.
pu.iD
aharea or 1&1c.• (or. JIXZA.Mand IJtlflW(,
u,- tnoea •••
a-.
ta la.-
1ao ..
ait••
or 1A clepmi'\a
-.e Pam (of'• 1.AMQIPOPJ)
•nd PIAOOCX'S r~al() •
'to 'be di.aoo,end
OD
aaave hi
cli.atribution
n..trcrc!J • ea aaaq n1CJRD.. iD Che
llarto>Jc.), or olclae to ~•
Jlort'olkJ I
re•i•
セ@
Chippiag
are
aw
19W..).
ere lmolrn troa acet
and tOUD4 an the IIOMrll aurtaoe,
-~1.
.....
olithic
Ul-apl.on4
1
kiJlda ot ai't:e baa not
ooncerniJIIC.. olitbic
aN•llbl..1•
litbic
oanyereel;,
._olithia
hea been aya\e•tioell,7
•1'8
!aat q'1ia
'tha_..
1.1.
JN\ b1 no mena all
atudy ot the -..riaua
Cllll.7 a •inal•
1-114 Wnllalld, Dortll ot セ@
we.lei heTe prcwict.cl •oocl
P.,,,iNei
ot DDl'Chl (ladle7
- tb• •1'8
'Daer• i.a ffr7
Th .. • aiw
ot 1ih1• kincl in '-
are
emera••trC111\he dat.Yom- well .. dett.necSenaaelld
11hich
}'Oim
ot P•••
aonmenta
..
-the
wbioh toll•
P'iilB ..
ae ... 4 to
an
end ht.U\op,.
tar aba~lnc
aDC1looali
Another
peaetnt
bllt
gi~J..tatone rep.OD
But 1n the oentrel
aitea
1a thli t ¥... oli lbio
ndc•,
along
the Penn1n..
1ibrcugtl
Y11lleJlh
pe i'ln'II
loak0'1" paata
indiaat.ea that the bwatere d.14 aot keep
and ri••r
are •"1
eoatave
•it•
or riv..uae
Tb• preaenoe
aeolopoal
aipltia.noeJ
•aal,ata
lball
u.,
•t•• •
'-be NAd dunea
•IV'
UD4aio~
clepoai\a•
prec1Mly
!Ilia
wh.t will
wbiata baa alr•cl.J
aihll
Yarie\7
11111
'-•
l>MD
72.
u.nderlaken.
'l'hrQl&gl':outentern
habUa'la
to bewe been taTOUre41 ea at ST.Ai?CADR• Coaaequentl7
•••
BrJsl"nd ienersU7,
llight lt• auppoaed th,it fiah.1ng end rawling
S) fllro-shG11t ~• grwtv
aet*l...mt
ia 4iaoertaible
ri'verin•
a r1••rilie
Ia prt!.cular
195') •
'l'bli11M,whiob •"•
Meaoli~
.c auooist1•
wi.tb ~e
corridor
tor monme:Pi betweeD Nat aDCI
surre,,
セ@
of the
T!Ma....
Am tilldll,
Saa.reet
aDd Soutb Vial••
atiwe ot e
anal
Suu•,
awwa,
111 the Sauth-••tull
eoially
•ll7
aaxit-4•
b7
....-oua
ha••lteen
tnq\lelit,
!Id.• diatriuulioa
to blt'N lHtea Uae area
retlMta
uitorll
ri•dne
~tterta
11a•tera or 4iatrU.u:Uea
are kaolra tra
of-•
1D\ ..
•1
•it- loaeted
retie.et
•
1Te ow119'110A, al._.~
1D4i•tea
the w.U•ctreinecl
~n eroheeologioal
ABiliGD OClll)I
aphaaia;
illtereat.
or the Wey encl
tbe illtluenc.
'l"be Yaat •Jori\y
girdl•,
GrHnaan4
an4 «very
r .. ,
'!'he
or aa .. an
tboup
again tlaia
aucb •• Pill'flAK,
ana C>ADANGiER
MTe 'been 1DYeatigatecl •.Y8t.•ti•l~.
e •tJ'Ol".o8tenderac7 tor the lu·ger
poac1a an ta. Sur.N,r-lln1.pahir•
Prenahaa
pona..
and water
tawl.
Th .. • etntch
1'h• ... oli'Uaio ••i\lemeni
llllnller of intereetina
tntioa
But the W•l4
• ecmoenU"atioa of archaeolosioal
ot ••W••'t
tuturea.
ahii:,1<111&
tloOI'd to b• located
border
•
u~1all1'
a.ar
lbere
lool,tier,
at 'the al.H•thern
In the ti.ret
pleoe '\hen
of 1iNDeM\ ex.a alOD&th• nor11b.erllU~ore1
ia
.11ur lara•
.. ot wa t•r would have bffll "pleie
pattern
1• •P-
litMrel,
eatuar!JM
1ib• The ...
JIDle oorr.1.dora w;ca the aonm11l'te of bunten.
aurtaee
Dore•'*•
ill
ot ool.OD1aeU0r1 (Raoki .. 195'; 91 Shlae 195&, 1').
•1"-
on11iinl1
._.
baa tt¥r aaae workere DMA \Jl410-
rep.on the ri•eriae
alaoat
tlilat
tribaiari•
...
tnollldilre BllOXJIOURD, LOIIR HALS!Oli
• a Dc1the OOLIIJYALLU•
••-
ia all 1.nteaae
alaac the wrioua
aDd Baapbire
tbon&b 1 ..
then
ot
1'11•as. iirail can bi
ot 11Nol1*1o lype towa4 along ita e.ntu-e ooure••
into
19ttn11
to haT• been a •Jor
••t - ia41oa-4
tree.cl
it
were UIIPQl."'\alltaotiY:1.ti••
par\ of Sautitn-D BrHaill
(Rr*ille
e,nd laik•ide
regioll
1a •
or the Iale
C.lcha.nger •114
•i~
tiall
aowa a
•:rud oonoeaot Wi.lll'\, ill
7J•
depoaita
rele~
to the l•'ter
•J"li.nJ • uuaar
of aNc.ciate(S
ot cbippi1>4. noons
ahir•,i Utahire
IIDE'l'llr.
end
nora.i,
nor do
••ndiJ
ac!.la
t:l~d
eroaion an th••
ot .tai'Rl'OI
1-
ev1ci.nt b_..
OCCJU.I*U.OD
or the••
erteu1ve
••
(19-32) view that Meaolithic
40lffllan4a,
Brome .Ap remaim mat
ot &mp-
ait•
•ctiTii.
and IWDICI
than 1D Ule
ell~
the sr•t.er
aur.l.7 be rMpoai'bl•
obal.kla.a.
att.noU.oa
for the apprent
ill
coaa-
i M wen
l•cliJ:lc
,at •pi.culture
baa tendecl to c!el.11111.t
r .. urch.;
to aand;y aoila
to aoil
u
;at'-rn
But a
•I-peer to have be.a. • pot.ent loca Uon factor.
thlr1
Clark'•
tiJll8••
Kdolithio
bND c!i9cOYV.._
cm the cballt °"tar.pa
Uaollldi.J1a thu •Jor
the riYerbe
It WOll14affm 11.kel,y \bat
h.••alao
aettl ement 1a a ... gre and aporadi..
haYe been looe\ed
Sip:U'i•ntl.7
aoulh•••tJ
a\lbllll81'1•DOe
ot t,ae ~oleat
floo~
chip~na
tor Meaolithic
ms ... herc mdenoe
amber
Foa-t-alaoiiol
alll
of x.oli"Mlto
laok ot Meao-
Uthi.c •teral.
6)
Tepoanpbi•ll.J',
( .._...,
QaatOGka, BocSlda MDor, X.D4' a
the
and Bll4eaa),
with
tiatrifttioa
••ll
lars• inteffeld.llc -.ew
ot "9eoli'hu
I•teaa
aitea
ua
be diTi.cled into
e)
Colla '-1•
,)
livel"llia•
c)
upi.na.
•iha•u
1a c a.atalJ
•WT
, ...
or dutributi.OD
lam.
!be
'-bell then
u •
••U.•..ni ....
1a opprent,
tbe tol.lcMiJ:rloa'9goriMI
e,D4 12por1aat
et tiJSlWA.IJ:)aos, YJLLAl'm,am JLJSCOT'l'.
beaab pebble tliat,
aDI 'lill>e\
area• • IA8ftlll
Taunts.
a co-
i"ina
t•tur..
.an ..uau.117 ot
RiYer wllq
'?be Cllll.7 ille,or1111D1ia••elllbli1•
Upl.,Dd llaaolithic
oa Dlrtmoor,
tJacl...._ '\be !!l.dMn att•
ai\M
Th••• ooaatal
aooopa• an
Glll.Joceaaia1111.l.J be.n •4••
f:rm !!BHOP'S !ULL, n•r
la a.-,ual
•ii
l!INDallla
1,10) •
!he al.D
ftJldll la.Ye
Billa,
aaa paa-.1
•Jara••
•"
and no ii.Teri.De pa\iert1
at.tea •7
... oli~o
( Qrlmell
1
Ille .Bla.__
et ani.l•
1.Nidenee ot ope all.$ .. an4 na•roh
aN no atntltied
Jn4.
la _.aU.•elJ'
a1, ..
ot hl&b a110rla1*
ot anaJ,.Dd comata
\be S•tlt1•t
•1'-
ba••bMD loaaW
en4 DOZJQU POOLon Bodad.a JloOr
•
cCIIN8
74,.
(Wallllrrigbt
19'0)
o1a• nl•\iomhipa
aot ol•r
beWND
- do ~ey urel.7
particMlar babitati
pt1om
•acmathe
are
or
••aoaa.l a-apeotl
111.~
•trild.Dc f•f.urea
lara• .......
ooouw la
•
t1.nda ot ,raaebet
1111 to
a'bou, llereli~o
grou.pe tor •
IAnati•
ait•
la ibe
••tb-w•t•
ot Qreenaalld oh.rt url.Ted
•Nil
t•,
ban
•• el••.bere,
clitteNDtate.
abert fll-a Portland.
and
ax•
lb•
or aoae
1'he pre-
ot the ••me groapa?
achanoecl •• to enable
the Blaakclalm and Baldaa BUla,
I• addlti.oa,
ot •1te •re,
1.Ddi.mte the pret•reaoe
plaoe 'there ia a bi&b boideaoe
IA the tint
1nvMt1pte4.
tn-a
tbeae 41tferent
are aot autno1enU7
'there are two
acat •.1•t-timll7
t'rom
•IIDDI 1ibe •~eho1a.
•hereaa
the 'p•ti.t
tnnahet•
ot tb .. • tacstan elw!•
preoue •ipiti•DN
tor \he .._-.
7)
the Mnol1tad.o
ai\•
WalJlllri&bt (19'J;.
*erreta.
totel
Nf'leot
oonoentrat.S
gcwernel b7
retleot
ih1a •7
• laok ot Nll•rob•
•
00011.P9tionOcaN
,.,..iN••eeioa.
'l'he •jort.ty
alOD& tb• belt ot lollland triDgillg
••tl4on
!be ait•
paper b7
bi&hland area ewer 800' O.D. tOl"IIII about
be 1.Ddioati.•• ot an e0Glllaa1'
WJST).
to 'be largel.7
.....
and ao far encleace tor lreaoli.tbio
t.bre• 1oaelu1...
or l't •7
are tbe •li»Jeat ot a nod
'l'heir diatribuU.oa
1'h• eenv.l
ar.e,
of W•l•
tbe ...
ot BtDY B01MIS(ao..r)
•••-.i., ..abeo1uteq
i.Dolw11Jtc
lara• quant1t1•
'7Pl•l
tu
ahon
1,:
ot the
troa
GIily
tor the Welah uplaDlla
ot X.oli~c
Nlltb
ea.at:
aitea are
•19
•e• w
{at• llABIBAD, l'IIIBIIU.1'JIR
and AlDRIS:tlll'm (C.rdipmhire)
ot 11.ttonl •1•
ot 'U.11pet aooopa•.
iA S01&th-wNt
xnai.na,
'
M IPTPJ!RAV91er ffll tBTPASffltb
IYffPCI
la tM lUibio
?be Tart.a U.•
l.Ddlaatriea
uto • ... _. or
on ~. au
ot dirtdiJlc
A• tar••
JD&laDd and l '•l•
1.
The lllgl-iaa
2•
lmutriN
,.
!be Jlorebaa (ar
!he noopt.ti•
1tie7 an
b7 c11a,l.lld •ooial
elitad.o
!Ilea• ll'OIIPUP,
_..
of
••ed
ot tiaZOIMlaio dinaiMI
of :Dll'Opee
are cODOerlled, three
wt. tb1D tbe MeaoU.\bio
iclemifte4
ton ~e ••
ill the abap•
11p ...
an:ot.nsa•
dittennt
pea of ld.aroli •
•1 tll.la the 11...U tbio
01.rlt.
parliaalarly
pron.dee • OODYeaieat ....
alarolitiba,
lna~
r-tm•
•Jor
grftpbrp
are
illduatri .. ,
Ilklaatrie••
atfiJllti••
wi\b Sawnterrba
ot t.beae
1enanll7
11-..
••lc1ea,)
~tri
ga-oapi
., ...
...
lirael.7 r.-aathe
work
OOD114erN •• cli.Niallar
auMblapa
ettea",•• r•pr••~
aep.nte
• la
ot J.a.o.
•111.teotur.4
arobaeelesi•
.. 1 -1 '-area.
"the 111,1...
•l"W
around the Balit.o s.. , oen"t.re4 •
ot •aae •ai-un
diatinotiTe
, ...
u11 induav:, .... •iallaritiN
in.o•
DIJBOuR.D,
De-rk·
.ron..
DIJ,ING),
...
!he ... ••t.al
ta tu •noJ.oetael
ia Saut.bera Brit.la
alorolitbio
wUib ... ..i.
• 1eoaa•r10•
the7 an
el...-
reatric\ecl
a'N pnaeat
la nnge
t•tu.n
aillpl.ioit.J'•
vi>ea AN 1-J'Se with Nl•'*iTel.7 aillpl.e
ill .re
tram the
The
.....
{ ot. STABCAD,
to TriaDgl ..
{ oft•
7'.
Dle), lrrepJ..r
iaoacel•,
and rarel.7,
irreplar
lllgle-ian
ait•
ot •,1 ...
(aee ftcelO) •
erblld
~•
••terni-rta
loll-~
beiabta
aD4 JoHn
on
ill cm.raot_.
41.tt ..
1an •it .. ill SoutherD Brit.1.D 1• centred
ot IDgleD4,
lllt
'° 1,,00•
ot wp
la tile JUJISJ:af ana
X:.rtaaw
and thentare
(at
Pere~-
iA ~.
lllcldenftel4
(ladlq
Jll»orata S.tla-.•t
1D
poiata
•uoll •• DIIPCd aD4 on •neral
O.D.) at aihe
n•r
at afffl'al
looaW
tor eaaple
on
VeUe, to~
troa 'the TM ...
•lao be•
a1, .. ban
aoae ot W•Ml'll BrttaiaJ
ldplaD4
aaat aicroU.tha
grol&Jla•
The cli.atributioa
-•
.Abcweall,
exceed 1• ill length,
torua,
(D6), •n.S tnnaitia1111l
'l'npea•
(m).
oreacenu
or oUier
troll thoae
elcmpW
aiiea
196ilt.);aD4 ma
•nd ..U.n
JnclaDd (1~1
l~O),
•PNtall7
DOZIIMU POOL.
are ea
f•~
-.
u•
aDd lleakecl l»ladea •••
la ••
pl"aeDOe
oa aaet
11e, rarer.
•1•
of 1ibe ....
, aze (or •• tDlliaaUoa
ot Ua preaenoe in till• tora ,ot abarpem.1111tl.-k•).
tNQunt
1D Ti.•
lla&l,...
•
la U.t
area• (•dl.q
Mek1:11
toreat
ao _..
1:baD ea b1.gblaD4 •it.I
ewer••
1 ...
a.me
•D4
obn.Oli8
la lligbl.an4
196A.,: 20).
talaae 1.DcJuatri•
ooaUJlellul
• ooatineDt.l
iapl.1•
1a Sm1ibtll'll .Brit.1.D wbicb apprcaia'9
SaUYeterrt.aJ
altillOlllb
nalTOlf.-,
~QIN
<-~ •.. 1..
82), areacena
••
ot the tena doea
baa.a
aDd 1...
uer -
aTU'ale ~n
tball 1• ill llJISthJ
· loac•
• Dlla), aarrw
(D2) aD4 wrla.
the produidian
11po11
of 'Yff7 aall
•
tbaJ 1111Mb
...
ibaA • oeaU..'ln
セ@
.,.1;
oriain tor the P'CNP (Clark 1955; WaUlllrlabt 19'3) •
a • terlal
tn.o lllorol.1
Moat an
are acla aore
az•
tora, eocnc:111V,
the
I
, ...
1'b•e
nsastn•"'1111 ,m11nw
olaael.¥ to ••
Th• ,_..
~laD4
wttb •
the caateapor.17
•114 Jlellan
'!here are
lllpq
1D IUterD
of "their ellppOMd auocuU•
a:pla•U.•
nn
ian ait•
c11au..,1•1W1c
Ma
!he_,
NM
ClbaaoteriaU.c
•roca•ltlut.d
fnpaot4
aD4
•PM'i-•
MlallllGlliaa
clon ..
tora (1>7)•
are re-1.q allalte •
t~
•re Tria•l•
orb~
Tb•7
e4g•
•n
4itt~
(Bl la
ill olaanot.r
\o lflaleaaaua
919 •...U.~o
~nt
el•d
dittennoe
and
ot'
l•la81
ai\ea
PNt-&laaial
•t
~•
ua JNt
occur
looal1t1•
iheee
aurpnaiJls.
oomequ•nU7
Coeatal
io ~ia
(Clark
pQlp
•1.atr1wt1on,
ua t.h•
1a upl.11D4 are.a
•orth
tbe7 are a1w-
It 1a pnenlly
0Jt ire.a
ot •• en
Dnoo ...
ialM,
tba t
c~
ot
at the oliaaa
ffell
Vl• a1-enoe
ua S•UI
ai'-9
lnglaD4 and
and :North YOl"kahil"a Moon.
oaaat.
flo ..
area (•N
Norlbern
elld the Jlortb-••i,
Aaclta
セ@
With one
a&••
•glea:.ae1ea
PMBiNP
Were ftlaiiTel,f
TeaeteUon;
bNll a~
to ·~•
•s.wewrrua• •it.a are looetecl
aandy ao.Ua or clOM io
a\ecl •
all
ot t;.nnabei
to Wal•,
In oontraat
end " .. ' ot SnglaD4, part1cularl7
a1t•,
ooou.r ewer an B'temiYe
auob 1nc1ua1:.r1..
••i soou..a.
•Jori'7
lheN
•a.uwi91"1'UA'
Britiah
fraa Baat AD&lv aDll Linool.aahiN
la.la114
tb.e
•
• \be oaaple\e •• .._.
Diairlbu.t:1..U7,
tia•lO),
tan1.
1a oonaidere4
Corm9U
Uft
alao
l9'J)•
19551 almrriabi
ta• lmbe• CJMlfee}!MJtlR
AA• t l •••
ot the Borsbaa ll"INP abcllr••
a1x-. •ai.-u•
of
all
tbe 41-UDIUYe
&NMtri.e
........
811d •s.weiwrua•
t.,..
ot '-
..i..
ot IIDnbaa a1, .. , _,
tatie
TaltCed Paula(~)
aa4 tbe 'Pe'1i
alae ot ld.orolit.ba ea
1a ••
the 111111.-.s..a
lower•
Bonaa•
a1-..
1)pol.osiaa~
d•cr1Md
1-a
la aan
naui.oiecl
Jilt
ftriaD1a
\ilae
Boll---••4
(lonlla..)
tarw.
'l'naabei'
indiYidlaal
aiie
1a • 41ait.mt
la nlatioa
llw.w•,
ia of"•
con
1 __.
t.b011Pt to be abaranw-
o\her
Pal.at (P),
the •riati•
M witla
W14e•
axe -1.WDt,
althOll&b the
ta a\lbelalliull7
io alaroliiba
(Clark 19J9).
theza, llolwha• ••Nblape
uv- ... SG11tla-•••
ran.
and tDDlllde
an
or •s·-·•err1aa•... ..w..,...
1111,1
...
(ftaelO) •
セ@
induat.r, then
ot acea aDll ada•
prepor'1ca
Mtabl7
tJpea,
aloroUtblo
two Pl"ffi,-~
Blat セ@
io be • oClllplei•
i ••-
ua ita ranae• !be
ot -.i.m, oenved
tale Gl&l\ure .....
iO N
•re aan
wried
c.........
1,-,ihe
•Jorl.17
ot •1~
oa the 1•14
NprNei*ecl
000\lt'
t.baa either
Borebaa
culture
ill the
ot lent a..S Suau
1a Ell•\ Malia
aa tar
FIGU /~
10.
Location
map of the
principal
Mesolithic
sites
..
''o
..
,.ce
lir.:t
ovcrl0.:d
a
'3auveterri~n
e
Horsham
0
Coasttll
'
(south-west)
!·WI er 'ffll ffliEfAL !OOQLIUJic
§IDS Il! S9WHJBN
fflITtPf
MAP:Pf!Jtl
1.
Brl&ba•
,.
At,.
Braxbou.rae
Col.ne
D"paar
2.
5•
,.
7•
8.
9.
10.
11.
. 12.
IBUM:I
v.u.,.
l2•
ll•
Abinler coaaon
Add1qtaa
.)I...
BeloOlll>e
l5• B•edi•
Doa••re Poo1
a.rU,pool
"·
Bla akdon
Iokormmw aor
1PlD&ComaD
,a.
»•
Cberldll
l7• BlaahemeU
Downton
ltO• Fardlaa
x.111111
Lower Halatow
Mtreden
~.
Baaaocka
42• High Boak.a
4J• Iwerne Mim ter
Kidd1•07
セ@
ll•
Shapdak
14,. ·
Star Olarr
i.,5.
15.
1'ha tchaa
4,6.
r1n1·• ,, »• .!Piaw
1'. Battwa../XorU.k•
17. Bnncl•lNrtoll
18.
19.
20.
Wood
Oekbanger
P .. CW'YeD
Portland
1,,.7. P•cock'•
Para
i.a. s .i.. tell
4-9• TUpte
Woocl
50• Toa Bill
caasw.(s.w.)
BOZ'MN
Jlo19ton
Sldpa•
51• Buffy Bol.Ma
52• ComtaDtine 1-7
53• Da7ligbt Roak
11aaco,,
s,...
55- Yree•ter
'MYYBIWH•'
2le
22.
Baqer- Slaaka
fh• Beaoan
2l• Crin1oA Dene
24,. hrndal•
Moor
25. Glen Wb_JU.n
2,. BaU Mar'1 Hill
27. LJD•Bill
28• lf11Tle7CroN
29. Preata tJD
JO• Waqtord-1.ekenbee
)l• While GUl
5'.
Jl(ab S..d
5j.
Y.U.na.
S1• P..,i~
58• l' eat.rd
th
fl•' /Jt•Ba•'-
Bol
(et• FSA.COCK'SPARJI)J ••t.erda
ea C.llbrida•hiN
aorih
(et. DOtN'l'OlCand Ii,JllN'IMIR3TJI), and •• far •• Dora•t (ot.
ill Wiltahire
P<ll!LAJQ))and Glouo•tenhlN
SG11th Wal.. , and the Iale
fer ~h
probl-tio.l•
Oertainl7 ao
aoepl
the
... , t.D DffCIIIand Oormall,
llow tor the Bonham cul~
traa the three •Jor
aloroliWo
•te4
~--t,
tn•
1a rev-
•1'• ._.,..'been
in Jaat Aqlu,
Cllll7••
and then
•• Cealbric!lae•
.A~rt
'-
further
D NOGl'd4t4
Dortll ot tile Tham• Valley
olaiald
Iu
ot Mani 'bllt
•rea•ta
la . th•e
'1'00 BILL).
(et.
Fo:lnt, baa D..
Bo1.lo.-uae4
r••W
it 1a npreadecl
&laeolithie
•7
eaayen~cmlq
or S011i.ber11 Bri'8ia,
1Nllatr1•
there
that
ftrian1:a
reoopiae4
20, l.95.5&18J
Weinlrript
ot ih• .A4ftncecl
t, lhll"ri,rala
to the inelopaent
CRISIWJ,1411, 11)d.ab 0C111tri1NW aiplt1oaaU7
ot the 'S.11Te\erri.e11' illlluatq
•-er
autaaon ba'N
nrioua
baY• NeA • fc,u,ri.b .i ....
wiUwa
ia 1:hi• oautz-1 (Ar.-troltc
l925J
l9J2s
Clark
1'63)•
W IW'PX SI W9!9NI9 DTPW
acae later
To anUaipa'8
comlua:loaa, it -t
aa • llilole the JIMolitbiO
Brit.in
oc:apl.e\e ..........
uU.hft017J
they Mft
}«'9Ga
aiaiaD
...
Shiia•
(1,21..) ke ~ncl
iDdlaatriee
time, .1.L.Ara1.roltc
oomeque11Uy •rk-4
atronc
the
in Belliua,
1D Jlolderneu
1922, l92J ) •
••
eomider
,o reoopia•
• ••i•
inauatriea,
aorolitlii•
Br1tiab
'Broad Blacle' and 'HarrGII Blade'
,nc11-ter
w
at "thl• pala
t.D
that
aDG reqlliNa
an b,t •
Drietl7
wm
Ila.
• t.
Bllakle7 WN the tint
•ND
VPC>loaiclal dirtalom
CoawenUoaal
DNA arrivad
wi.ada
OODt\laeclaie\e
1a 1Jl a Tflq
encl it 1a imtruoUTe
Franou
diriaiOD
n~
N atreuN
achocau»c
deol•N4
••n ot
1
.-i ... 1oa or tl»t
A.natron,•a
ta the Pinmi.,..
' induatr,
• Cllltural
11i1ill •rl.7
conaeotioa.
be-
(1921) J
Tar4enA.rollll4 the
the boae poil&a touacS at llorm•
that
t7PioPl
when be c11au...,1abe4
1Bduatr1•,
•arc.etBla ..
typologi•l
oonti•atal
cnaltun
aoenUODI
111,1,aaeua
iato
t.ne,
•Del
en4
Eaatel"'D Jll&lalld (Anr
at MDther
Grullldy'•
Parlour,
61.
.u
er ...
•cae ot ~.
l••'
,o hi.a._
•ugg•MCI
ortaiJa tor.,
all iDdigeDOWI
iDdwltrua (Araatraarc 1925) a lie uawr-
)(.eaolitllio
Bri\iah
ot
poaaibilit7
.
••UJrc
a auniwl
ot the prorinol.al
,encSene,to poMt.rio
1a l9ll
._.,.
IION
.,_u.W
~--
•i-
eqdwed
'!b•
•Jor
l• ••
•n
n.
woalcl •••
reeei•e4
paaitioa
1ai't1al
1.llduaU'i.•
oonUMDtel
YeriaU..
ot •
,oPt.u.nd',
elld
•Pl'••ecl
·rea•roh-
...
•Ull
•llbHQ\lelltl.7
•al
debt to
But Jaia
Be aaknalrlelcecl
the
•t,
oaiJtC ,o tbetr
*-•
ocatiDeDt,
tbe Bri'1ab
•114 •Olll.4 1-tw
(Clark
Ial•
llaa••
19}2& 92);
•ol.0111.aa'1•
t.no
lnwatri•
(19)2:
t;wo
18) •
•la
JION
&NN419
:
( '!ardeno1•1.a•')
aDd .be 11l&aaa-1•
ararieriae4
of••
-.17 apeoul
.And
ot boae polDta et •&1-1.a11
en aow.l
Pare ld.oroUthi•
lt7 Ille pna ....
to
t.bet \be diaenerl•
ot tbe BriUab
are.a,I-·
ot Xort.urll
tl"oa t!l9t 4irecRiOllt
Ida cli•iaioll
lliorolitbio
ap119ren~
Cll1t;una
1ibe W..
wi~
1..-J••
SD&lADdrepnae11W
IJ
a
•114 Ua OODtriblltioa to other llioro-
t.a relaUoa
tne
I
.irt.4,J
1a obri.CNII•
1
1.,._
t.be taot
••
._
pal»U.abe4 ta 1932 -·
of tbaagbt ...
aD4 be aoeepted
~nt
mti'we 111.oro-
l.oaal or prorill01.al . '"8105)aallU
a ,enc1eae1 --..-
1A Jutena
to 't' in
troa, lbglanct
14eaa he
Suni-..1
aat he••
aeasn;pd.o
pr-oai.17
A&• 111Britau•,
ot • 'Crenelliea
perliaenl
For.at
alaibi'
Buakl.Q aDll Cbil4e,
l1'1d.o illluavt.••
•b•i.Dg
•Dd oore az••
work ot •1111ibeaia•
pou~Uit7
•Ol'kff9
••
a1-..
.U.ndiDI
lleaolithio
woricnw like
reprr
lMat •lnaQ
ffeDU ••
119PR OD
'endad to 4el.1al t patt.rm
•rlier
......
1
ldoroli<tba
Clam'•
Briuall
the kwa
1eneraU.aed -1.tun,
t
u
fC)J'lla.
....
111 Id.a elauio
Cbilcle,
'A-utipaau11•
ua ,_... of eoDUMD•l
induaU'l•
li~•
aioroUti•
,a..w1u1.,,..,
Jloanw,
tau.
la•el with • det'1111tel7 ~t-f'1eiatooene
lb• •rli•t
preted
i., tbe ......
'lllero-lNrlD'•
1'•1'danolal.all Ult'lla .....
~$
ol tamabet
atVJJNW
aDd 41aUllpiala
..
•x•
aDd MOl'I
auab 1.mullb1.•
,wo
aub--O'Wl)91
.u,
to
82.
,)
,n •rlter
in.a.•
'b)
••
• later
• netiv•
aeoaetn.c
••1•,
••ll
1"4 '1117
geoatrl.c
ad.Ml• 'l'H'Cleaoiaun
ot -·
'Ta:rduo1.at.an•.
evolvi.Jtg au'\ ot 'lb• •rliw,
*,
alrool.i
to W.
DO
V'i.c .1, .. of
•IV
dw•
... , JD&laA4,
and••
••1141',
1iplaDd o.r
Ia tile 'Dia_.
end Limolwbire,
Clark l"Napi.M4
'aloro-lMari.A',
aD4 tOIIDIItti.ir
11°0Q (•peoiaU,
Jlaalwun
•11111,1.-.1.aa• ••
In
oul~•
1•14
~.a.
•••
•1~. bQ\ aaa.J attM
Pou•
, •• • later
ot W.at a.1114
Smtih-
•Del 111croltlba ot w-
ana
..,i....
Whlcb •PPINDt17
oloa•t
Anglia
to
• wriant
ot
tbta
1ih••
lowl.aDI aitea
au
were abaneteriaed
'T•rdeneuw•)
1111trid1MU•
•nl
\ha
leok•4
•1* "the BalUo
penllela
o•Uaental
1"8ohe'i
the lebel
uUl
later.
aoa-geG1D1a-1o
11iorol1tll
'nriaU.•
beta,een
'b7 tibe 'ld.m'O'"'burlla',
toz,a ot lliaroU.~
lteween the axe -1...nl
and he •OU&htto 4-tnte
Tara.aoiaun;
peru
alld narihalrda through ldt
Clark aoted • grw't
and aew'trri• (1...
uplei.M4
...
O"WP •• • whole
OLLIIIG aid LOOI HAI.STOW)
• elthoup
not atri~
•&•suaa
Y•llq
at
oaaatal loatiellll.
by Udabe't
41.at,apiahed
1eometri.o \ype.
w ••
w ,i. • iJ1n1a tf.OII' ot
TardeJIOlaian
lo lte oontinecl to th• 1Glllen4
GrGlllp II •--d
IJ"GIIP ••
lat.e Tardeno:la11D OOlllcl'bt rNOpiaed
1he llri.tiab
tor
ald.lt1,ec1 • pndi.lenioD
••t .11111Jor~
111BrU:ai.a eca.parabl•
llldlaa~•
BoweYW., • •U:w•
am Corniah at••
Welu
'•""°"in.a.•
to th1a
Clark nternd
1'bia be • t "'5.buted
AtlanU.
Tb•
'to the
a:raQe
afflaiii•,
He reoapiaecl
cmraoter-
aracl-nry • udlar
at ZDNBOVIM•
Penninee all4 , ...
•ua .. セ@
but ill wbiah
el.-nt.
epi•hlaeolit.hic
inauatry
••t Jn&laD4'bel-.ie4
On lbe beaia ot
b7 the ·~4
Ta~elloi.aS..n ot ZOMIIOVD
(lelg~,
podibl7
iDdua\ry
b•t
ot the Pennuaeea
ocapenbl•
auemblag•
(~paaeVi.o)
with the •rl7
hre
••a•,repreaente4
tno
pre-1 ...
a ooraiatellt
:lJMliridal
Boll.-baae4
~.
he
and Ula looal
oorrei.,1oa
wiUl
-~ •rte••
lllah
•t
Clark'•
nllllequen\
1tO%'ktwa bMD dew"-4
to •••
i' Nlclen ai:tea,
a,.
end ta 1,,,.
he eooorded
'° the
dd
19a'\ AlfClu,
tbo•'belolls..t
llhioh be
w
t.be auooeeling
ot t.be •rlier
frail 1.D&hatn•
la ta. hl'lllb.-m repo~
the I.au
and .an,in
ot ••
v.al-ian
'° 1, ••
.,.,..,.a'-'
ia ••
aaltun.
a1tU1,1...
The •al•aaeS..11 oul .'8ft
ihaqbt
that;
•era•ot
oulture
or botb, u
Cl.•rk'•
tnpn"'l'-
v.•l•
lato
onr,
araeol.o&i,•l
appniaal
et••
ua• ••
appliecl
..
ot t.
\hiad»c;
iadiaarild.Datu.,
•- ••>•a•lbareot.-1.aed
• cliatiDn
....
1a.nt1. ...
of
CNt 'b7
aeoerapu.oal
prob-
セ@
\erri'-7,
aDd Clark
'ba•iaJ
the l'N'-"t
OIi
ot oOD'9ot bew ...
lol'IIUa
ab•iJIC
the tao.
.. la Jnclaad •114
1-atri
&J"GIQlla,pez
Up w:aW .a.e ier,
Brt.t.111.
CNl ture,
rr W
bi.a
oonteap-
on r.-
1ihe tent 'Tarcl...U-
by luropean pnhlatoriam
1t1 the ·~·
•&1--1a•a.S
)vbr14
ana atoo4 IIIIDhallena
.. uUl
ta 1955-
the
de-uaw
T;nolasial
... oliihio
••
oa
•&1-1-11
ld.cldl• Tarclelloiat-11 .....
, '-
Tarcleaoi.aua
ai.tu.Uoa
ot
111the •••
41na1oa
llapMOllaa,
of the
nl»Ml'&e4 aor\b S•
Ute ..
B• 4ropped
tllaa h• lla4
'be coino:14ellN Ula t the aoraa.a
aituaW
araeaeotiola
kJM:lia'nto baYe entered 1.mo Xeatern
••
the trlJts•
apna4,
it OGll14 mrtl7
'ftleretore,
.i .....
~•r
1,waa aNMM
W..
re,prNenW
Olllture... ••1•117.
1'ala H-4
w IN lHlrDe
"'941.U.om.
cllar1IIII
1ibeBor.l
dffelopaent
•uoreu11Qalture•,
Be thua naopiaecl
Tart1--.a1a11
~ad
• •tl••
19'6} lla4 uquiTOealtl.7
llorNaa
the Boraha•
he aaalgne4
Cl.ark dno'-4
the
atroacl1
_.e
t1nhntqu..
atnlll
repreaent
b1a •z-1191' appniaal
• Clas
·~·
-eablaa•
!DduaU7 aD4 1'8 wi.dier attiaiti••
tltft"llbte end ._....
(OoDUMDtal
••• 1A the
AU.nt.1.e pen.o4,
(Cl.ark A Benkint l9l9,,
the t the axe eleaaDt ••
prntoual7
.Bor•l
the la'bel
(Clerk et .1 is,lt,).
'Tardene1a1aa', and referred
the tera
he applied
(et• Lal'D 8AU!OIJ), ea 1ibe
-t
perio4
ot tile • •lden
'M • clia..a1on
1•r,
'llozwu•
•• the
allab •• BROXBOOJINJ
alld ailrilar
rel..,.11,1.D4wltn•
lbe
• ._._
ot dr --~
4en.Ya,1Ye 'L•m- .Bal.ate. CW.tun•
p-GIIDc5a~,
••
Dl the ...
,o DDD-&eoaetrio alt•
ian'
Valle7
Tba-
aepen :te eul1iual
(Clark 19'4-) •
!al'deDDiaS..11' •
'Ma&l....
\hea
t ... D1qaeJ lNt
'° ld.oroli~•
INbaeq11eD\
81+,.
led to en •ppreoietlCD
r••rab•
tNbmque
and ~e
Uoa ot • d1a t1nei
reoopi
to the hrdenoiau-.
and with a reawioted
119rellela 'bnwMD the Britiah
led
Clas w
re,nat
SalffeterriaD
imiaUJtc
of 1ib• ... e wideaprad
, ..... セ@
Id.a Nrlier
P"OIIP, uaarelated
S•unt~a
llOre obri.oua
dili'R'il>utiCDe
1.nduatri•
end the .Prenab S•UYeterrhn
'i.Dduatn•
Wftd.Dol.011 and auba\iM•
tor 'Tardenal.aia•'•
atfl.n1.ti•'
OOCIU'NDOe
ot i.bia
cm• Preaeb or1&1,JI tor Bri 'tiah
with
lior COllld be feel .iuatitiecl
'Seunterrt.aa•
induatri•
ua
(Clark
1955, 16,-18).
Ill reeent yara
to Arabaeolog
~nt
\hat
-~
triblltional
lloilt
{195') and bclley
are not oantine4
(19'0)
••
Wbilat
X.U.ra
1~1
end it 1a • reproach
II ttempta
to accept
the
to teke a took ot t.bia
rN.lit,J ot 1'1gl...-1aa,
••4 a t"tention baa been turned to 41.a-
a•PMRS•
blapa
w1th
m••aome to light;
workers •••
em Horsham varuna;
bnld.ae
tt ..
taota
there mve bMn no aerioua
1.DtonaUOll!I
•saUTe,errua•,
i
_.
inc11•W
to Soath-••t
th•
OOGUrNDOe
baa ahoarn '-'
•al-un
(1969) baTe • .-trete4
:lngbn4
aaa...iag•
•it.a
• bl"Oe4 Blade'
~.
•••...-
•aila· liaimrigb.t
or to un4y
1
ot lfllgl..,.ian
tu Pennine
tut
1a SOl&tb-w•\
UMUIV7 ••
Jnal-n4e
•fflD-
fJ'CNI1a11land JnclaDd (Redl.e7 A Mell.are
18-22).
Detore .,..iderlnl
t.wDOld..o
aob••••it
MODGIQ' aJld
a. Ung.
the nalU7
11 blperaU••
end illpl.iaatiom
w daw
ot the
OOlfftinti ..
l
tJie evi4ence tor mbt.t.at1aa.,
10
ffll 9JIPZJCI!
<rMPQW'fflIQ
JDiJffll
Th• nicJenae tor cllel.11.Dgl lD MeeoU.tb1c hrope
areJ bi.Ii
Pl"'NeDt ..
teadecl iA .Id.a food qu•t
rm•ed ~•
u
then
autftcdent
to abanp
la 19,9, and tel\
aituati.OD
to
witb
juatiti.a
•ua•" tbat
•n
•••ODIi•Clark
tbe
1A c1ietillpiabine
a.>11:naooaatruotecl
ldr.ldl ot n11t'icial
diatinot
l.afarmU.
Jda b9b1'9Uon
a 11hole ta at
••
bJ ».olit.bio
tao
•11
(O..r*
19)9: 9&-107)I
a)
Light,
tliay
hape the bu1a
b)
witb • woocleDtra .. ork,
camtn10tiom
ot •• Jia'fflao ~-
Of .Ariaoa..
palaeo-Aa1- t1.c an4 AJIOieD't Jak1.M ierri
oa
*• beaia
ua-4 1n
ot e~phia
81111aff 1
of IION no.At
In Ti ..
Urttiab
ffi.4--
1111tuftl ahel'\ere
dtaoovert•
- •••
e.nd roalc
be••been taull4
b•
•uuaaW
Ula•
tlw toaw
••n
tna.
it ia inQl'ell\.UII
with
o.n be ~red
lJI BrU•i.D,
ot
'-'1••
ill the wiAter ..
111pe,rlic,w.ar
Where •wU.ble
in&latry
i,araU.la,
an4 the lat"-
llaua•
CG11Penbl• ·with t.be •riib
dwelliy,
Semi•aub,..-raDNll
reoalli.Da pu-
it
....
th1a
that. lllaolithio
a11.i,....
'\o ...
bGlr the
Nb•••·
lmlatnw loak to
wiUl • m.crolitb1o
Lwela
Parl.au.r. amJIJILL (Anlli.rolfs
at llotber ~·•
1925), .IIMG JIBTJIJR'S Clfl (Baaa-G1117e) ~net tblr VIC1'01ll'.li
CAO, Se.Ue
19.}2)•
eroaiOD l!lql091JII
lea clitta
In the W•14,
Send rook baa prc,nt\e4 nat'Uftl rode aheltere,
V.088
ot Jfnolitbio
Clark 1,J9s
oooapiiaa,
-t
aotably
ot loaer 'l'Wlbridp 1iella
which•••
JielcSet
•it• or 'l'ILG.t.TI WOOD(• ..
aoae or
the
lo6), BALCOMBI
(J'eNllp 1970) aD4 BICBRC>C'ra
(JIODey l9S.) •
~11 tbftit • t1iDt indl.ultry or Borebam type 1a auoc:tate4
pnotae
aignittaanoe
ot
th••var.laua
mtural
(Claric
aultel"a
with burtba•
1n セ@
At
!be
or •••011al
86.
•°'1Yit.iea
1a .....
•zwai t.a
•••
D..
illbabiWdi
ot Delaadc {Claa l~-"'
oc
t.eapente
.u.
nd.•t.1all),
el.iaU.c
•la•ot ..
the
II' セ@
,
Brit.Uh
Iale ot
CULVIR I ILL GIi the
Jars• .,..,..... ot
Jd.taben m.&leal aad
lncliaat.1••
or t.aterat."•t
alaba ••
U..tolle
lai4
"rteteeta
a11
8NOOiat.e4
sur
la)
Col.De V•Ue.1
a,
De.-r
セ@
lr aNGllk BUl.
1a
at.au-
plat.ton
• parallel
7Ja1a ti.l*
r••rb'bl¥
- aD •.S.pat1all
to • ..-,
ot tbe aotml
lndio.tea
w-.••• ,r
~ro•
uelterw
•
Briiiab
••
aitell•
bNll cliaOOMNMI
09apa
ot 'biftlaoo4
••
at tb• iiiar.l
bt.
(lak•1del
oaa4i,ioaa
•1• .r Duw.-
•114 flh_.
(acCKll!'\'liJlg •11ill Clark'•
..
-~
(Clark 19511,). lo
dNlliJI& bclffYR MaffiV••
Duv._..
1.D the
loaa-.S
•• progabl., the tlOOriJII ot lipt.
1a interpreie4
t.1111111
nalnl
•114 ia ia\erpreW
0.ft' ·
Ai :3VJl CAll1 an arWtoial
'811Cible ffi~
ot
i.Dlluaia7:
•>
••
(iD
or but.
Wi*a Jiagl--1.P
OQCRlPeti.cn
lwel•
lwela
1, - oocu119tic111). • tloar
Ia al7 tuu- iJlllt.DOIJS bl'fe uwoea ot ar'Uu,uil.
セ@
eore-
19701 S,) 1a • large
ooour at. ari_.
top ot ibe ad.Mr,
tor !Sel:olithio •ellillp
I~
( tena?)
•bd
_..
ooaatal ld.&IIM (et.
PorilaDCI (Palmer
- ......
pcuiol.¥ ih• tloar ot a abeltc
( D.-rkJ.
Altllaap,
ootlldned iD Swt.b lial•
waul4 •••
aaadi\tw
(Pe.Aell.U.re,
u na•ti•• or Glll7 abort ooau.i;.Uaa; elld cml7 -. •1-·ao
produoe4 m.4eDN
., 1t r9th4tl' WIDer'alll, fclr •D,J k1.D4 ot babi'tatiGD
a\l'\ICR\ll'ee
1-rp
the •
caaltun
ia\o anelGQDIIIIai1ell
thQ' ._.. OOll.1}494•••a1all7
111 faa bi.ng
aupply,
•• iD Uatt ~le
ree•rab
r••t
ureatoo4
llD ...
tne•
aitWea
801)
baa
ltaelt
Bmffer,
that
S~nU.,,
illS~ilD
t.r
are ot tM oaaatal
the 1•r,
~'
jl.).
la the Bebri4M augata
pen-l
Unonl
the W'i
•tana
.1aag
,...ina.
•ba911Ce ot Ul1 t•un.l
apeakusth••..-u.«.eniaWCllal.4
a.w
lbecnt.1oa1i.,
and •Y
.ill セ@
UDae$1Ja,
J.A ellalyaia
of
Dllaillb V.gl-t.11
tvpoUNei.
) b11t. Siar
Carr
wa• .i..t
OOOl&pie44viJlc the water
oert.Ull7
or •
tnoea
S.biteti.on
or (X)LQ
Le,ard at the aite
wu.
end clepr ... iaa'
V.A!Llf ta
la•• (Le,art
•ncl -.• deep aa4 conteille4
boll-
•N
roone
aoae ••7•
1a
1Ht wiatw
quan.nJ
vi..-po:tnt,
aoeP'
iJlc •o
tllaa7
r1-.'8).
rill&8'
(Rwlt
or
oiNular
bt.rab •Dd
•UDc tb•
WN'e
a1te,
•
ooaupiecl
W~
•
Naim
セ@
tor
a
U imt:NniTe
P"GIIP ot
h ...
セ@
1
OOD0•'1'11tioll
ot an acnual ahelter
mdenoe
at tao•
wlue
19~:
or Worth
traa tbe type atet1a11 ot
cJurinc tbe .. ,,,.,.
11IU,
•111&•'-••
rocka
Butser
(Ma~,
IIDlltbae
BIM*le7 (1924-) tau4
tour abelten,
repnaa\ecl
(Jt.-5 aquare yardl 1D ana),
Of wOJ'ked tlida
ua. cnarlJi.Da.
OlaJ'k aoeepla
to
Tb• Beaburaia• a1t .. , to Jwtp
.......
Th• nicleno• troa ~. n..n7
1Sa-U"Nt.rri,aa')
ha••Npr•ent.a
etl"l&OtuNa H"• r91dDiaoeat
ai.ld.lar tw:K,tic:m.
Cl.-rk (19.)9J
U.aa,aaei,era.
(S
tt&o,cbt to
th••atom
••Med
to 1.D4i•t•
o1ua,uw
'tire-pi•'·
..
19.)71 ~),
At aDO"ther .Eunine
ot wbet
aa a atone Hit1Jla
•ilMl.7ot reiDIINr •enebn•
fraa • atet:latioal
tnoea
セ@
aot cluatailar
ea- bi.dee ot 'teata (luat l9'2J
dOlnl the .,-..
• tipi
.lleiMdarf
tor or apimt
Carr-
'!hia tbe7 1n.rpre\e4
la both iatenc
A•riaan
.a
*bee• wcaal4
(19.)~ 1 bypoth•ia,
1a ,.... ... ~7
1D 1:b• llaaburg region •r•
w weipt
•eel
'Dl-.
ri.•e::- graTel.a aD4 ""'9811meltl7
Clark'•
s-.r
ODe •••
- pciulbl.7 • teDNtence,
or tor • ligbt wooclen abeltar
,
19'1..).
Aa.loaom atODe at~lll'M
ot onl plaa OD late-
u.N
•U••
at
ab'9illed
(21,
or tor ue
ot pit;-•el.U.ap,
the babiut
'B•rtba
at~•.
i• ao cJboM* nidenoe
Vi_..
ANrtbae
auueture
a.laoial
,
al\._..
•••
paMible
(Racll.e7 It ..
••ia ot
Oa tbe
1927: 500).
ot the lat'4tr
ot '-
aoooped aut
to .. 7 that
wlaiati wmld
that
tloore
1.,.
b7 MiM
'• beep ot reclllenecl h•~
•• 'either
wind-Dreeka •, Ql U>erat-17
.k
k1Jl4 •ere diaocwerN
a• wi4e
AJril).
(October•
ditterent
.. b7 aoe••tioa.
rn•l
l.nterprated
IMJlltba
Jrabe~
b7
cme 111.tb •
eluaiera
ot
a1te ot BADGIRSLACKS
makle7
tauDd a U,t.r
of tli.Dta
and red
ocmre,.aa •ua-
roof'ecl witll b1rab wip
aDd illteN
tlilla7
Of セ@
•~
aacl b•th•r•
aiai-
lar
t.o tbe
awaaar abel iva
lllterenoe ot the
The
It ••-
akin .._.
•helten.
Their
o•.o. or
oonoeiwble
ta.t .W.oli~o
loaalitiM
•'
Mare deftld.'-
MNoli~
buntera
At
•1,:.-r...U1
_.,
trOII fiwe
ooai.
\.A.0.-1111
l>)
l'arrr.a
( ~7)
o)
".. b
•114 ai.U.r
Pallt-aJ.aoS.l
iD-
upl.nd
~rillC
period
w.-.
tiai.n at ~ent.
"
a.uookJt
e)
S•b•ton
elona
aaawtion
1.z~&.11'17 ot
11r41•
Borehaa tnie•
fiurrq)
••
rn .. 1-4 aipi.ticant
aoooped °"t ut
~•
t;11e
•urt'•c•
aam,
p!ia
ar bolloaa,
ta
11111!
com.iJwlg
lt::ntiom
ot tU.at t.aplea.eata, nnd oco.aioa.U7
t'l.uta.
Th...
or 'pit--1.lup•,
hen
'bHD
•1cle17lD'-rllr•W
so COMtl'\IOt.ec! •• • pnaautiaD
~'bl.7
er braolca,
the GrNrlall4
(suaaez)
ortU'iouli,
•1.Mt •Dl which were
apread
(Suaaez)
thMe ait.e
.•rkec!
•1•
Wood (Alwr.,,
oharoo,,.l l'nd t'ire-ei-eaau..4
wit.la gnu
a
1t
l1ur1Ag the •interl
Mah aaaocated. wit.b a rUm
Ab1•ar
inet.nc•
hui tlacre
et all,
•)
.u
In r.et.
laiata abcMt the kiAda ot dll.UiJl& aW110tur. area'-11>7
Incland,
of Sau.th-••t
(at 1-at),
ot the •rlier
ccnUtiom
ml.dff, it
aot atp1tt•.ntl7
aua•• •• IIIICh.
o.n.
a'lwar
in apaaecl paeittom
•GIil.cl OOOIIIO'the PenniNe
•bo't•
1,000•
lMigbta
1ilutt 1iM oU.-tic
ill Ida!
•n
nat;ure, a.a • aitueUon
aon
wooden or
of light
1:h••
repnaent
\o auppoae t!»i
praml,.l.e tliall7
ot 1.250•
u
fNII the Penot,,..
ffidenN
r••oatbl•
et el.nti.Glla
North-•••'
/1.ruaaa.
ot
ot 'Iba l:la'fabo IDdt.m
oonre4
with
ar ccwere4 with enial
aCJIIII woo4en
••
the
api.Dat
rr. ... ark
tbltdled
19J9J J..-p
akt.lla (Clerk
1970,
5&-61).
At SIIM1S1'0N (Curit
1-.l"l•t
ot wnlah -·
HASSOCIB
at~
aClle
\bne
la pi.-.
(Tall 1'1S) om pit••
cliaoowerw4 almlur
boUa,
o,al
19~)
V.099
pur•el.lt.ap
a'balat lS'
J' clHp, INt lq
l>7a• aDd
•Ueoc-•ncl.
at ABINCl:I OOllllllJ
were aaa•W,
he"
4,• clMp.
1be
1ibe
Aad at
la 1951 L.& • .B.Leake,J
Vien
end nerrc111·ua Clll&Uiae(••
.....
e...-ift.cdal
l.Jt.' l>7 lo•)•
.A
•. f •5
f..
セ@
ii
I:.
-·
1: i
~., t
!
If lセ@
0
g
iセ@ l
•
t
•
-
a
0
セ@
セ@
i I· .f.• ·~f.
ft
• セ@
I f Iセ@
8 -
I s'I r tiff~
• :.
i
~i ..,',
セ@
.ll lt.
:
&
セ@
ea •
r
セ@
0
セ@ セ@1 @セ t f !.
! • i S
5 セ@ i : iI
i
f I . • • .. f f セ@
a 4 t • i i I 5 • • f f r
-;- r i & i :a J f Ii セ@ i Ii
! ! I l f I ; Ii : I fi ! ! f
, ' I ' l t , • a, i i I
f
1
セ@
セ@
セ@
I
I
a
i f
•
g
·
U,
I
i
<
ii
•a- J.:セ@ セ@
Q
•
セ@
-
j I @セ
t I
l I
r : i
il a
...
'. '~I
Is!..
.
·
'<
セ@ ·
I Iセ@
Ii
1·
t ., . t1. Iセ@ セ@
セ@• セ@ f ~· セ@•
I セ@ セ@ i1 セ@a
•
e'° 1 :! ,••• セ@ r
'° •,
';''I
I•
£ i : I
f ·1
i , [ I l i £ f • •
f I セ@ .. I
I
II I a ! i セ@ I •
i I 1 5: t , • l t
b' •
ft !
1 ,
R- 3
C1 i
f
t
r
f•
tf
•
f
1 i !
! ! ' f セ@ 1 I l I ! ! i
s l .
g i セ@ • セ@ • セ@ ' ' J i •
•i
.. t セ@
i I• ii i• fセ@ i; I l .. I' f;
• J
i l . : セ@ , セ@ ;. 1 セ@ 1 '. r
D"
i !
·~
•.
セ@ i ' i
I
I
セ@ セ@
&•
t • r
r セ@
セ@ •
ti
, •i ~. ,; I, •1 a 1セ@
a
t
t J
r. I!. セ@
! " ;. セ@ & !. ( l ! .
l rr 'セ@ l• セ@, セ@ fr i• a• . ,· 1..
i I
j , i • 1 • • !
セ@ .
セ@ I
fI I • ; tセ@ セ@ • i ' ' i r 1 セ@ セ@ i' •r セ@ 1 •£ : セ@I ; I : 3 i •l i
f i f l i I !. ·, ! i i
1
i
r
l
!
@
セ
;
I
!
t
;
i
!
!
J
t.
i
I
J f
.. '
I i
f f f I • I 9 1 .. •
I • セ@ 1 •
,.a セ@•. I 1::I ir !l ! ia ;r 1' i i! i!, セ@t t ! r 1; 2, ;r •i f.p; ; ; ',
,..
t f -;;
5 セ@ & " ' · f :
I .• • f i' 8
1' S セ@
c- =- : ;
t
t'
--
•
&
!.
;
セ@
.
セ@
セ@
セ@
セ@
セ@ セ@
セ@
J!
:i
セ@
1
ti
1
i
セ@
セ@
セ@
セ@
セ@
I
i::
'
9
t
!t
•
.,,
f :.C
f
•
I
2
セ@
セ@
I
o
I
0
•
i::
I
:!. ... ... f
t f
I
セ@
8
f
It n
g
if
セ@
-
f
I
&
I
•
OD
"'•
I ; 1 ::i ; i 1· セ@ 1 I
it セ@ Ii; !I r• J@セ ,.t,I ! tI, If. .,·,i
f 1 セ@ ·' . ..
a 1 • . r f g セ@ I f c 'IfI. I セ@
~~l . :! 1!1 , :{11f
r ~, セ@ J J • セ@ • &I I
I .. : S
I- '.
i:: I • i セ@
f
.1
it ,: t i I r 1 t
,I
•
I ' :1 : :.i i e .&= 'I ,i:: ,J '
'
セ@ f . i ic- , ..f
1
fセ@ ,. '• a# .f -r -;,
£ .. ! f s ,I I .•
•.
. '.f 1 f i t I f ! ! :j i :I
( t £ t- J • .. J • セ@ 11i: I
セ@ iit .i
I rI#;!i ! ·I I .! f2 ( r J
!a !セ@ ' i• 1" i, •' £• i, . !' .:
1
I
!
'C
. i~
:
I
!
I
t c-
,
I
1 I ' f I J! ;
· I a i J .,! ·f , 1 i セ@
i
.
ii ...
I セ@
セ@
...
•
D
.
-""
••
•
:
-. :1
lr
I,
o
0..._
セi@ •
セ@
rt'
D'
@セ •
J'" '
It.
I
H
t
·.I •. 'o
セ@ •
•
I
a·
· セ@
,
' r
I
',f
i
-J.r.
i a I:
r i ; •
I
セ@
s. £セ@ i セ@ 5セ@
l!fi•JP
;:r
セ@
rt
sr
t
4
•
Iセ@
•
セ@
セ@
·
:lr~
'JS
a . Ii
f ~r •• ·,
.
I
'
I
, r I : セ@ . ,
li
i •
,i
'I
O
"'
'.. セ@ •
I
f , .. .
f
セ@
l !
r ea{ If
' I r : セ@
セ@
i : ' I @セ. .r I
r £ t ,
i
Iセ@
f
セ@P-
セ@
I ,i1 ,a!,
f
a.::·
A
I ,f
l, 1 1 •
It ,
R
r ., ,
111
!
:
f
f I•
a
a.•
! I セ@ f i I I セ@ セ@ I (
f { ! f : f :. . i ' . V .: i ·~
.セ@ ' i f I :. ' I セ@i . f. .L3, !fI
fi
I
i
セ@
'
@
セ
f
~·if
(111
f
8 ',
1
It
I
•
i-
'
!Ii
' t セ@ ·
I セ@
i
'
-
セ@
en
Iセ@ iセ@
セ@
セ@
•
•
セ@ セ@
I
,...
J.. It
&
1
11 f
1
eE I
セ@
91.
be
Mfle1.m4ea
a'IU"faoe •~
._..
ttlU)
A poiDt
•Dd
ot am.nl
ffanolitbia
tbNe
Cl,ark
ia the aiae
tour p•noaa eeabe
セ@
11ooounta tell
a
ot
The aite
ot PrMernUoa
un
i. gl ...
(Deepcar,
セ@
aooia1
ar-..
IIDder
place,
wolithlo
Taaamam
ot ftOtDt
that there
•.n
_..
and tbN•
o..~bl..
Dnc-
ot holding
tbaa
three to
':.'here 1a no wy or knolr!JI& precia•l.¥ hm •JIIJ ••
preeent an .:illJ one of the n:entionecl :Oriti.ah •it.a
'feotan
An4
(19)91 le&) lJ11if1ea'tathat 1D thia reapen
DrlMU •7 baTe zwaabled
or tour huta tolmd in
1.aD
(&.cJaerSlaoka) ait••
1Atv•~
Sl.gbteent.b o.ritury
...
with Horllhall riuea,lag•-
\o llonbam (ot, Dmntell),
CM . M
•s.uw~n•
KMol.1'1110 ooaditiGDlh
ti..,..,
Dug-ol&1a OOOl&l'N41D .gl
(ot• Col.DeValle7) a• well••
oon'8na
WllftOGk
pi....,,.,
• cultlarel
encl aaawtion,
ill Tielfi or 1lbe •• _...
or hw •IV ..._..
of Ster Carr 1a the GQl.7one wbioh gt"fee poaitiYe
1a cli.aauaae4 in the t'oll.ow~
a.er; '\.oa.
._..
OC011pi.ed
et
im'oraUan
GIie tt.me.
aD4 tlt.ia
92.
u
Pwr buio
teoeu
az"CIUll9iD bmtbe:rD
Britei.DI
1.
The IKJ)loUauoa ot mt.urel
2•
'ffle expl.oi~ttoaa
3•
The explot111t1aa ot .,..1ten
セ@
~-
1¥, orpm.o
1.
rw.aiJIII
,lt.hougb then
papws i:-rellela
a.
tha1:
~1;
ia fort.boaaiDC
ai..,
llbiqlliU.-
traa BritUlh as.tee.
Ci9
flint
aw
ta U"l•
ot 1ih• llaaolitbio
1-rse prt
•7
eYW b--.
nta.noe.
セ@
•• aaab ••
7Cf'ot
be OQllll'Olllec!
ot plant
セ@
'°'-l
tooda•
c!uooYered are ,anaU catlb•
at stAR CAa eJM! •' • t•
ausgaat.1.n ot d.eliblll'll\e
41el
ot th• a.....
•1•
セ@
tile 1Dtem1w
41.t •111111
--'lbe
Cllll.Jplan
et oarbald.ae4 lauel
lil the w.. 1a.
oolleriiOlle
~tatioa
or•• foo4
t.raa tbNe a1tee 111 IIJ&lam all4 •• i..,
ot
llodm'll .....
9attfl IIZ T1M
Jrtd.ao•
セ@
aotiYitiell
ot 'lib.a tact
tut•
auge11t bt
iJIC ,nd •tbert.lla gr-,.
Thee• en
eNPIIIJdC
Ullt'ortwaatel.7,
tram the ooUeotiaD aad OCl"IIIJIIPti.ODoL the ...aa •114 A,d.U
•114 pJ..meJ
•* a.a.
oppenrml\J•
•ilaa•
d.1-a~reand
• aet• ••\lllptica
4eriYe4
naatm
1cag
fFPlo1ffll9P !I emA
;Jae
It .....
wt.a
•D'a
•11.iM, 'b7 vtrtu
a.ft
NGO\ll"Cela
aid al.t.·u.c
and pogn5talc
Cllll.Ja ulllU'ul. ot
end avian lllilat na•tt"Ceh
,t •IV t.ima 'tlGU14baYe c1eperded i.rae17
ot ...
t.Daible ffideDoe tor ».oJ.itbio
hoa
too&a.
ot inl.em e'J'li'tic
iaprianoe
aq;aa aw.U.'biUV,
plent
ot aea tood reaourcaa.
'l'h• aplo1tetion
rei.u~e
ot tSrrol.tlblo
mq be pr.awnecl wiWD the eoonoa:L•
reaauroee Sa
セ@
.
~
'
'I.• Ill,.
·· I r
'
I I' :f f•
:;
f
i
I
i l3..I 'I
I
·
· !r
セ@
t
\II
セ@
·=- セ@
.. :,
•
セ@ 1 セ@
i ...
I "i
"
'-
...
:r
•
•
f
I --.., f I. ';."'
Si
f 1•
0
·i ·•• . r -.f
セ@ i 1 セ@
l
セ@
&
セ@
I; i;3
,
f! •1
l1 f1 -.
;
,z
: [ •
. ..
1
l •
·E: '
!t
I
1·
2 (
·•
,:t
'2
I,
4
• r •
- r
•
I i , . .1
·
ll ..
•
: ; I !
f ~. l .
'
J, -i. I
·=-
(
f
:11 1
5 i 1 f
r • セ@ f i @セ
! セ@ .t
.. !
II
i
fl
!t ll
•
I,
Ii.
'
; i r
f f
f l f r
•
;
c- I . .
s. ;
I• セ@ if pi ; I• I : I i~ 'i r
i I ! .. I f . r
i a
セ@
i
.
n
•
.--.
. .
f
.
i ! l f ! ! J : i ; : i ! i [ i セ@ ; ! I
I .r,!1
l - i f
I E' £ 1 1::, .
t
! f
- ..
,ia,i
i ·1"l!g·
. ;_fi.'.ie!
セ@ ! ..
I ::.1 . - , f i t :! I . .
I.:
l
I ! i g J ! : t ! !' •
i
セ@ • セ@
r ·ft I r ...i Ji '
it, · セ@ i; I l セ@ I ·, セi@
J
·,
:.
~
i
I
:I:
{
I=
!
i P ,
セ@ ·(· j : . i セ@
;
f
i セ@ 1. ·t. r f [
tt.
=
セ@
ff
-
.
f!"
-
:z
J 1 ::.2
I
'
s.: セ@ •
.
•
-
r!
.
1 ,. i I r r
J
! i f at i 5 £- l !.
• •
a i
1;: i 't
i... IILf f r & I g 1
i.
! 1·
•
I. ,.
i . i
fl
fl
'!
f
.i
11- I
I
セ@
セ@
ij,-
!
i
1
i
.
tJ
: J. セ@ i.
if
.t-'
: •
I·
セ@
f
I
セ@ セ@
't'
r
•
1I, rI
;
!
\0
\,,I
•
.
94,. .
uw
be.a lnY•UaiaW
• i:Dd one
S.brid.-;
.a
al
ibouBta• -.bole
tnoee
dMr,
or apeoi•
~!IC•
P.,•...ii.,.
a-ntl_J
fta04 wlue
ot wr1111111apeei•
UH
• ._.
tanih
tno•
ot 1-rpr
.....
"9o, ,talw
the OroaM:,
tqo4
a,aMatiaal.1-J
baa b ..
•lculaU..
_.
.It ....
birdl1
ol•r
·~
•'
.-.pt
ot ooeat.l
20 people.
•ugg•til
_...ill
Gblterw,t.o11 la.• -ble4
Mlaolitllto
Alao, cl.1.•ttc
ht
00011.Ptioa
IIDIII ot
gl"Glll'8•
u1Skel.y tbat
obt:Ailled by Melle19'
have b1dcl8D or 4•voye4.
,tor- lb• ooeatal
~nii
tialli ._.
._,
tluQ' ._..
ocn1U..t.lcam
•••oml,
••
oacnr
11..S•II
4urin8
only.
ODe taot hoWner ta oertela.
a wq
t•
, and•
....
t1BbJ a,'GC!that
abell
of ..
• D..,.,.,. ot 111tel-
Sootu.b
aona't1or.w
oaapl.etelJ'
Obaaun gr,aup •' lN8'9
auai;eau thlit aiBd.l&itr evidttDDe will be tor1iboca:l.ag trOll ai"'9
••
roe
t.be reeai.Dt or aaba.
tS.Alh.••
llh.U
.. セ@
our p:lctw-. ot tb• t,OG11011Jot ••
n14eno•
....
a.er,
("4
baa al.Noct_J nv•l.414
an4 11 would ....
6una1 rwim
Th• .re,tulW al~4y
wa\
Uapeit,
•
In eddU,lOII セ@
and preliJli.,mry
Vm'WOftl", •reM
·tt.a
ol _..
IIClllliba
C«i1
'TV'S S,MiaDlf'1,aant la the too4 wppl.7 (PeJ.eJINlal"II,
as..- an -u
511111,aia Oil the
The balk ot '-
ot tb4t
ntea.
alllllb • •lk
reoovff\94e
ot
8CQI09
e1a.Uoll).
セ@
AU,,,...
••
セ@
セ@
.._.
oonoern1n&aoat.l
taterenc.a
ple4 lq'
alllala
a
JWJmnJR
the
ek•) , l111·p 111-i.
or nah,
!be naim
セ@
paraGDal oa
the
( t_...
ot •ifflDI ~.
!he
t ..
ftl,Tele
ta
nleW
•n
haa 'begua n-8'COl'•t1.0IA of' the midclu ot ~00
•tudied•
1..
-·
the tuet
orcne.7-
Tb...
reoorct.a.
p1s}, • Dt.llti>er or fia h boliee, ••
and wild
•
••
1.1111Sa
lap ot ah.lla 1 J,Pl"ticultrl1
ot the 'bOllell ot ... birtll
SLI<aai
ref\ae
fQOd
<>rma.1(IDier
Clll
Beat laM:Jlln or 'ihe Oben •it.II
nna• ot
CJ..\'B trm 'Wbiob e wide
ud.da.A •'-rial
ot Obaftt thrN
'\be Iale ot R1-QII in LoGh Sunert.
CID
•2.~•ruiu~ .nee.
\o the
ill the •ne
- tbrN
--
ODe セ@
Ri.eUlS ••
•IV
tun.II& 1iba •rl.7
ooeatal ai'Me• ...-wine
or lit..
-.
i.,.i.
セ@
,ADA -.
90lltb.
.Poat-gl.oal
t.be lN1k ot the
UndalbtecUT,
"C,be oaplal
-..ol.itllio.
al.Mr
indua'r.J
,.
11mree
bnllkvl
Paual
r-1•
hlln
.-.
CAa all4 fflA!CBAX(Berka.)
Durlaaa ooeat ••
•-la,
,a-.1ewtrio
(althaup
m••beea
loaeW
bud
ell\irel7 ..
roe
a
at tale edge ot • i.u,
a.er, U
S.---'ebra'-
., .....
8U&•I
•
alaCIII-\200 aquan
an•••'·
l~
a.
\otal
flt
Oil W..
people Iii.pt
~ti•
....
baw lte.a aupporie4
,-z,a,
Siar
loabD4
C.rr
1,.i.DL
ot ••• -.1
the
•it.
•Y
-a••
M that
iil»t
ta
clepoa1ta altout
the P'OlliP d14 _.
alN.e
Mll
folaDI t.D
the aite
.....
•
to lmlat larp
waa oocu.pi..S
PM•
4uriDc
11DIIaben4c1Dedclm-1lll tbe aun rr•
tor 6
aJl4 the
•••
ot
"
ot ill• anU-nt;
tldeat
4epUI ot aultunl
ot tile ... , NPNSeD-4
trca Odaller to AJll"il,
U-15
...
•U-'-
1a "111'-r,
!he •real
S were acJlalt
l&-2S 1n41Yichaala of wh•
ot 1be
1a
.-11 \be •-lua
ataUar
••ta Cladt •ua•• tba\
•1.Dter dd •PJ'iac ( OdGMZ" - April)
b9aia
ot Nd .....
••l,ata
~t
the •erii.•l
ot '1le net deer anUen
The ••'•
ta-.
5 ot wild Pia, tcptbel" With
)t
Boiila pollen
-~elillP'd9'•
tonet
.,.._,
la the
rN tm, •ol.t, badaer, ban 9114beclpMc.
-~
today ( Clal'k l9S,..: 70-9S) .
arU•ta
to
I\ ....
flle •-lt.D
80 Ua41Yidu.la
ot elk, 9 ot wU. ea ( c:w.roc..hl>
••r,i.11&
.... rot'-••_.,
ftata or
ot tbeae •1'•·
preeenae.
ot woodl.114 ton,, : at; l•el
u
IJ'OIIP
and •oae NMOad.o Utenat
ta reaor11e4 by \heir
lUe
by •fff'7 ..
( eo.,i.m 19,9 ) .
ta b7 tar the .. t 1..iplrteat
STil Odl
Sautlr-••'
•114 anaU
to ihe 'S.lffeterrua•
are i.c~dnc)
fora
THI BIAOOR, near ••
1.aduatJ7abanoieriaecl
wi1.h • tU.at
wt•
'bona are aNooia'W
ot wil4 m, wil.4 pig, ltirta,
.net wbiob oaal4 be aaoru..4
lllorolitu,
1ao i.Dl.Dd •i\ell& Stia
alliaal
•it•,
A third
produoed r...im
all auooatect
aqua\ia
ID botb aaa•,
un tUnt induatry.
a llagl ...
traa oal.7
ncorencl
by ...
,-:ra.
hma.l
Blat t.D
probable••
NeD Npeeteclly
ot
oollentaa,
•1• ot
•Cllle
Oil t;he
20
a .. acaal oocna-
••a-table
oocnap1e4 tO/t' .,
tboda
1 •• ,
poaau.l.7 •1 th aoae U~ioaa•
ia lllliq11e 'la the pi.o'un
The general
it
aubllateno. i-twra
(•uatu-) •• ,ueaen,, wu.b
Ulll duriJtc tna t .... -.
Wut
a1.-
ot V.olithio
ilabitat
u tbaaaght ·• •••
.i.a.,~°'91
~•ta
tu-ppenecl to \be P'OIIP dl&rinc ••
•
1D
bMD
••
• ...,
aan,a
..,..._la,
bat oomtden~
priaarU.J •1tu.te4 •
It ...
tonaW
tllri:NIDMlat.
a .-...1
•Setlart,7
repne....S,
lb• •1'-,
セ@
ntl.-
bare encl wU4 ••
•Ub
•
t•
t1ab aD4
._..
•ar
••',.., __
an 1-rs• -
o.-..lliq
セ@
セ@
Cl<unl
period
UMt
(•
ntleou
•
~•
s,noiaaq
1J191ot-.
iaa
1'he
au-,-.-rre4
Botb
•s...
wild
セ@
are putaa19 avepat1••
••--l
hetar
:i:.u-i it••
セ@
.at
1a
セ@
N1'111aat11, w _..
•a1-ua
..a prcr-
reooww .. wlalab
wttll Ster
ot wilater ooouptS...
aNOOiaW Witla JIMolltldo
... _..
lSUli,
raoaptae4
aultunJ
t.•mt 1.d.o D41111F
Star a.no, • 1-1-114
ol•r-
aa11>J •• alao ~PI
oaeatal ailaa ot
eat
an
aature
'° 1ib• .A'1.ntio
niMDoe ...
te \be ,......11;r
l.Mlawtae,
t.aseth.-
ar ban• ...
Qll
peri_o4ioall.J ·,
.Pre- Ban.l
Jla
ba dg er,
ot tnia,
the ••
1\ waa naitecl
... 1191.a) •
laGIIIUlia Nla•
terrun•
•1•
1be
f1De_....,
t.ban 20 taatYidlMlal
_..
tut
poll•
tar a
•1•, •• • wua'-r
.. 1.s.
Red cleer ••
ot OOG1aptua. wt \be oloa• aildlarili•
••••
Bri'lab
aature ot
.
ot ~• O"OUP, al 'tbo•
pcaailtly
a.er the U.m frca
C.1"1' la 01:ber :napeo'9
lNI
•
•vu-•
••1.aot
1'Gllld N ~ec!,
•ta•.-Ver
a, *llat ttat.
aD4 ooa.allllalq
probabl7
1-7_..
•bl-7 latend. ttenl.7,
aJl.ilala ._..
•1.A•
or tb• ••'"1_..,.... 111K
pouible;
or the
abaN
tar t__.
roe deer; •UcS pi&,
tat-.
birdllJ
traa U.. a1'4t
.
la tu
auba1.a-....
all
IM2•••117
ot • lake la a
1ibl edp
• 4ift'_....
alao eupplied.
tat,
.nal.ogoua to Star
\be fa1111aliaentGr;y
la セ@
elwnt
•UIT'l
•atna tar.ta
1A •19 •79
abunclanoe ot am.la
•~l
i.lprt,aat
1a
tibat ot i.>tr.r C.1"1', ~-
witb
wl:d.ab •7
•
\he _,
Konower,
セ@
tood WGlll4 be awUa'ble
•eptr.'ble
ot 1'11Af<JWf(1,111111'
19'2)
!b. eite
C.rre
....
.....
Uttanl
--.
•7
111417
n~•'
•U•abon
1,000•
Bonba•
ai'-9
bliw NIii
セ@
o.D.
•&1--
la
*
Plll'IIU*I'•
N1111Ja*ialla•
la
*-
Puatr•
end .ia.hen
'DI•
•7 ..U
ODl.y auriJ11 tibe atanrr
•1Pit1.•DGe ot all theae 1191ha•r4 taota
obamnJ •pecd.all¥
paitterm
ba••beeD oaaapiecl
•
la•• ••enoe
AIL kiaMII ot Brttiab
ot
aileil•
·S. to .. .,. the
'-IJCibl• n14eDN 'tor
aaatbl.
1-at
aubeiatenc,e
•
f'IJII
I
i!
I i J I ! I • ,'.I r,r セ@- r1 I..セ@ r. IR •,f ..r= if'l r• fセ@
I I $ g i t !I [
!
;~
;
C f f f I t セ@ !
1セ@I [' 1=11 !- , a- 'f f..If 1 f·I
.,
,... .. 1
I 1i!F11
,;
t r
セ@ £-If
5
I f ,1...f J ' f• •' I... セ@ ' ,· • .._
If £
• セ@ f f
I
!
!
f I i i セ@
f
I
1
1
f
1t• • - :i I
ri ·1 !j!: 1.. i!1r
I
g • 11
1
l..l I ! , ; I ! ; ;
f . ! ( Jl i ;
! J J• i i
f セ@
J i I , . t - セ@ i
P ,!'•11
'
I
,..
I セ@ セ@
i.. ..t· ' , i... i J;I.. i I 1· 'I
t I t
I • セ@.. •I
セ@
! •
I
! '
j
I
;
'
i
I
1
.. f • • rf
j
r
l セ@ , . l 1 i I
IJ•
r ·:
i!
...,_
•
I
N
•
,
f i.'
i: ·.
'
I
•
I~
ti
n
,J
'
.;•
C
P
セ@
f
0
Ii.
i
! I f , .. ...
l
..
11
:Z
!
'f
;l
I
I
;I •
...
I
IF
i
c1
.,.
.
0
•
'
p
ii
i
•
'
'J.. 1f!;I
.i.,
..
c-'§ ,1
,.
i . 'セ@ '
.
'
...
,I
セ@
0.
セ@
•
f(i !i 'i
セ@ I :, s r
·r:
;-.
-i:
f
If O .• i
ft!!,
-.a..
t f-.
m ...v
-
-e
.
.
.
;
·
1
~t
!
i[l:1:1 J.,.I-,
- ...
セ@
! 5! i I f
ft
il!ll'
I ;
i.
セ@
セ@
i:
1 , :
&:J'"
II•
-
セ@
1
•
•
,..
.
•
_
I
-
"
-e
l i.·
'"' I
S: ,
ai •
.g~
i
f .
!. -
:1.
.
r
·
I:'
i ,
!~
.. .
•
'!C ....
a~c'i! ; ·.
1~:セ@
I•
t'!'C
!
ir
,, . i• . セ@ la -, . r
!!f
J
1...1• f I "'.Ji !
s..,ae- :l セ@ :£I,· l:a f... I
t'f
J•,•,
• t D I
{ • i 1 - J. i'i •i i 1! i lii~ l
•• .•. .!PI
,r .~.. f • ,
PP, I,
£ ' : ' l . i8 ...
...
s
[ ! :t i;: !I ~'(I)
!
f&
is
セ@
I
£セ@ ,l f ... i i= ,11 •
•
i セ@ i f i ,. p ,'...p' -!;a"'セ@ .. p• , .~• - セ@•
~.
j
O
•
I
ff
j
•
•
i
!セ@ !1·I fセ@ ;
a.
...
•
t;
..
f•
r~
.,..
t · i!
II fr: s;~セ@
n.-
f
--,~l ,..
•
tl'r··
·
:
,
I ' セ@
i
-
0
1
i
I~
セ@
E
•
I
•I
..
,
セ@
I,
f
,
..
'I
e
0
If
I
fI lr;,r, ~,t I~f,..1 I!セ@ I
,lI rI ,i· Ia If ;i ; 1r J, J
5
t
r 'I (
_
セ@
•
,o
';"
N
~
.
&
~,,
i
• .,.:; .
l
•
I
._
•
I
r
•
i f
.,
•
セ@ s: a
·=
,..
'f l セ@ f~·
,f
1
I
i
!~
I ..
l.
,
:iI I'a '..i t a..,セ@ •.. f • ·•·
セ@セ@ • iiセ@ 1
5セ@ !r セ@g :! ;; .a - • I • @セ セ@
...
I:' I.
'8,:
2 :-"
-~ '
•
• •
rr
....
...
l.
'I
,~
"
_,.
..
f ..
; .. f セ@ ! 5\ セ@c.o •f Ia ..
セ@
セ@ &
f e
&
11i .il
· i
1·
I
lJ
I'
1
'I
:
,
i ••i
セ@
ij
n'
ii
i •...
,
•
i
1
ii- ... , r ..; セ@
セ@
•
f
r セ@ t ,~ Ii
セ@ -セ@ ~;:
i , 1I J
セ@
I
::
a •
.I
セ@
1.
1
;
.
..
i
f i. セ@ i
t: : .
•
セ@
t:
セ@
•
100.
u •re 1.lltenaUJts•
!belt• Nlllll
1.ea iaduatr,
.u.,1 ...
prior
bet.De--1'eot\&Nd
'tu
well •itb
s..
'11• BalUo
I.A Brlt.ia
_.. •• a
2.
•ld
after
Oil
bolfner,
tor t.a.
were
hrthe1..-.,
l*riode
1aa ali•
el'Ollll4
Jan>cRbea•
ooatra-. ... aooepi.4
ot ibe Britt.ah lDduatq.
oaaU...
... ..W.&•
clicl Jaal,-ian
6ooo J.C.?
MDn CW.c11iteaare requiNd
to
before
t.b1a auJi,JNt•
•stn•HD111'1,trB:\w
Tta.n are 110n41~•non
... •i.,...
u tilll
•
thalle Obt.laecl f'J'Gla11a,1...
alld afflniti.N
Th• qUNUOII ..._l.M
be••
t.be PrebOl"Nl
Col'a9eqlMD'17, the7 4o IIOt
tbe onplla
Q~
aur~
aua-t
•A4 tbtti Mlab auNl>la.-
to 6000 B.C.,
tD 8r1tai.D
clateil oaapan
Tbv ell
!hia taot el-.
&it.a
tor detiDitel.7
enlla'ble
,o 'Nlard
p.rOllla•
'Sa11Yeterr:un•
Pl'"OIErll• ta ».oU.tbio
•tudt.•·
.At S1'UIIP cacm
atnUfied
wlUwa
(ranca.
Pe•1.,..)
o1.n
•
poll.eD-b•rtaa: Mu..d.s
セ@
-.lab
litb8
OOllld 'Nloag
(Maal-ian
au ...
••"'°"Blade'
ta
Brit.au,
the •~
( 'S.11We'terria11') or a 'Brae4 Dla.cle'
PBACOCX'SPAIII oomia.r.cl
'Swvet.rrm'
セ@
195'; •
(lelker
are IIIID-'tt.a,
ID ac1c!iUcm, lbe pnaeat writer
J ocm'9Xt.
laa• boa
aite ot
to •
(At,lanUo)
ot ttwt aueablaa•
etttnitua
'th• PNOiN
aiarolttm
~1-
• OU. .. te ot Aa.500
!'.
,10 .B.C., en4 • apeotzwa aNi,aDabl• to at.me fft.
~.
"*
1.11•
b7 Clark
la ....
QODN5*ion ot • Borabaa 1nduatz7, a..pite
1D
tb•
(1955)
teela
tat
to be セ@
keepuac11U,b
am-.
Ula
••
(apparent?}
t~
,__..1
of•
oon
axe el_..
Boaewr,
poll•
a11a1¥U0tl
nta.no. ••
quNUOD ot ' the obroaolOQ ot tb• bri.Uab
OD tbe J.lo:nb Yorkahlre Koon
•ilwtttied
bl peat
e'bau.t tbe poeittoa
bn*•11 tl'Ga
a'bn•
ot
Atb8'to
tn,t..lq
(VIX.,
'be lal'OUPt to DNr
'Sa\tteterru11•.
'SaUYe'erriaa'
a.~.
end
sooo- lOOOa.c.
(Ra41-., 19'8).
1b
At WHIT.Iam..
aiorolltu
tOWld
•Re
••ill aub-bonel
or Ula 'e1a daol.iae' J ·tma talli.Jlg
\lpoll
peat at
w1 tibia a obrollologiaal
oa the P•at•
1,000• O.J). • l,o1:b 'X.l"l"OIIalacla' aD4 • ar,c,.4 Bi. .. • ~triea
moorurada
•n
101.
Umarialtl.7 taulld •t ~•
Pollea atudW
ht
halve aban
a.~.T.
the tlae ot ~·
qlMDU,, \be Femtne
nearl.3 nn,when
(YI/YIIa - m•SOOO
a.c.)
(.North \11111•
) ••
attoa
(•ff
aaia
prortdN
•••tlllblagee
•en
• but
at l.••t
11eeol.itbic than do•
to an •rl1
The utating
(ll)
ooou.-Uon
lay•ra
are pr•eotz
1.DFiwno. ( trca lcaafflp•)
7cw.5,"'°20,
B•·C• • Boreel
dew
PIA<X)(JC'S PAD
peric:14)•
are ••ilabl•
(ea•):
n.5'So セ@
5 Borebt11 a1tea:
150
a.c.
(Q.587)
alao poll•
5280 ! 14,0 Be c.
CHIPBJU, (Wil ta} :
- セ@
•
to Obliqul7 Blunt.a •114 'lTtaDglllar
a:1.oroli t.ba
b--th
tuh·
セ@
lCMer
( Oztorda) :
G1 bODe ••lei
"'500 !
150 B. C. (llf89)
wi:tb fU.n•
U
tor 6eUYete1Tien
1A the 61ib Mill.4Nlium
or l-
t.11 _..
- tor the X.olittd.o
oocu.piit10D lwelJ
aatea to Zelle VI (Jlc>zwl) •
- .trca d
ih•
upper l.a7er • •sauftterrun•
••
••lect
(U.1)
The roak
la ilatereatiJ»& 1JI Ul1a na ..-ct•
Bsnbe• 1Ptmk1M
(t)
bOlr
peraonel ac s •D1•ttcn ) .
(F•A•lileU.ra,
bdi~•rlKm
Wora-
Preciael7
oamot 'be a.oide4•
of Sb•tti.U)
1Adultr,,
tba t
bel.CIIP to • aore
It u el.a ,o 1.ntereatt.nc tct note that ·the aDly CU.. datell
J•
pm••
ot
1D Brit. iD by, • t t.be
the K.gl•1111»iaa.
lbere ••
4.t •IV,
oontella1ng • waale,..ian
.B.C. (of•
1951t,). Come-
1D t.vh at l?US'?AffH
per104 (c.500() B.O.).
two dta1:iuaot llnol1'1lio
induatrie•
to torm at
lete :eoz.e.1 in age
oriwrie
bttiJII •llllhctund
at 'lf!ORPICXUIION
(••t
induatrr
Con.7
(but only taa.t ) Uae •sawet..rian'
abraDolcciaaJ. owrlep,
1111Gb
la1er
{•••
vw, aoent7 1.ncliaati.OD9 it wml.4 eppur
o~ ~•
rec•• Jlba••
ot the
Apperentl.7,
pe.t
Cl.ric l-9'8) .
tbe eD4 ot the Bonal
ahelter
bepn
thia
•••NDlea•avatitied
been ... 1gne4 on aeologla.l
pvio4
' Sa11T•terrian'
la ,teat,
•1'-• .,..
'SaUYeterrian'
riDBl.1-J,
• •s.uvetemP'
OD tu
aoS.l •Dd OY9rl.Jinl peet.
at..n.nl
B. c.)
( VIo - prr,000
the Ail,anUc
b••••
ilnfffaoe
tut..
(iT)
O>JQWiGII (Haata) , USO ! l.20 :a.c. (I•t•.Arob- •rt.taou
tawad at l lnel•i
cla~ relatea w
-~I••
PA i.Ddiat.l
•ll l9"l.a NlCJDC to
, U.nta period (ma ) .
( T)
BI<ll RCUS (Jtut),
3780t
,100 t
,1 A 68)
IM••II
150 B.c.
150 a.c.
ot at.nititied
h•~,
••oot.tea
•Uh
aDCS
Ebbatl•t
JO''Cel7(1) • Suppor*e4 lt7 P.A.(1)
- trGlll o~rooal
tl.illia
'l'b••a.tea
inda'lr7
be1Jtl allllflotund
••
(z ...
•rut.•~
tbea• .....
wltb pott..-,
dotlll the ... oc1at1oa
the
grcaapa
bullUJlg
ia SmtherD 1nsi.na 1111t.il•ell
1.Ato
the ttae ot 1::1:w
Jteol.ithic
aD4 attor
or a alarolitaic
1D
{Hare.II)
... ..i.,.
1a a1ira&itie4 clepaaita deDO~ an t100lll1il&l-.te4 llllaoliiaaic,
( t. •·
twU.-
1.Dd9~nd•t
•nd th.t
ot
prt
ot BIGH JlOC&C1
(MaDey1950, 1962) 1a aipit1a.Dt
1'h• •1\•
oolontNtion.
,bi.a
r•PN't'
i.aea pereiate4
utter
•• ••
:a.c.),
'by a..5,00
if' not up unW
period,
the t the Borahaa
The 1.AteNDOe la
at 1••t. •• •rl.7
VIo - at. 1-•t
.Boniil period
the Atlan\io
•eri••
tcma • onclibl•
a11
n tber U.a alri,Gl&l turei),
9D
cma1,u,ter1.M4 'by lluatiJIS
:Bbbetl .. t ovl.ture
explalla U.CIIIIWGlll.4 o•
!be ~-,
or
•
M•oli~
lieoli W.0 .OODWI°'•
A
•l
a1&14n.n t•tun
onrlap
J.»gleaaaieD
•11ib. Uaia•
ml.le•
ld.aroli\ba
t.o olaMU)'
and•
NID8•1JI:50 ••ll
• • i\e
QAlaU.HDR
la a,aoi.el
• .a
'la OOIIIINUoa
or cme aqu.ere
w.-. IIOl"e or
aut 1D 1952 ea •atu
••
• i.gl-1-a•.
ot u,..e•
1').
1960) l"ff•le4
tiDda,
oallt...,.Hm...-,
Ra*iDa
But aub1Jeq11•t.
NCOW•N4 trica •a1te II',
1D v 1•
1...
1" wb1ab procJuoed
Bo1.lolf-'b.ae4 pot.a\ (P).
(Renld.N A DuDlebJ
I•.
q\Ull9U.•
*heft ............
of }*)pl.• (Ranktne lj5',
•~•
'rodlJ' were
セ@
f'cra . • 11°'9 Witb.ill •• ana
p,MP
tbtJ •NNitla&•
tu other ait•
be.aecl Pelata tra
u•
w...-oarrie4
acefttiom
•'lomat.
alt•
abrollolast-
1a: tb• iAterred
8Ql"lb.
of UI• opt.ntOD that aU
••
1'h• produot at t.be
~1-V'io
•t
Ben 5 diatillot
fur~
-·
ot
1he ......
1'11• .-fftor
the tirtlt
i.p,ecl
cwerup, if •••
iadullV'i•?
date.
Horebt•
•s.u••Ml"l'UJI•S.-.trtea
be aaked: ·•t
... , ..
onr1J
w1tb ,
ot th.-•
• totall.7
••
eace..clitter-
enl 2 Bollow-
• 114ea the be• w ot
10.}.
AD ilitereatillg
thlt
abcaat tb• chronol.oa ot 'tbe Borsua
point
appears to be mon or 1...
it
grol&P ia
tu CoaU.0.tal
oon,eaponmoua wi~
fi&ell) •
Tt1rclenotai•11 (••
OULYIRYrlLL(Poril.and, Doraet)
:5200:!: 1,5 a.c.
a:lctci.a with avatft.e4
tUn auMlbl.ea••
(1)
- tor•
>
(U.)
I JSi'trARD HOI (DnoD}
4':,5 ! lJ O a.c. (Q.672)
• for the ~pill"
,•
of all 8• pae \ be4t a. ... qilla a
ai.d4ell OODte1Jd.llaa llllaroUlbio
iDISllltr:J•
PA giv•
Ati..dio
(VIIa) date.
(1U.)
l"RJS
JIIAmt OS!
)
.fe,010t 120 B.C. (Q•5l0)
1.nduatr,- oont.u.a
iA aa.atal
(i ..-.
• tor a ld.arolithtc
pat
( •WNlil!'Secltcnat ) .
ot ZOM Yila (•U.Dt.lo ) .
PA • ld,4clle
••raea
Same pa tterD
pl.a••
Ul•
•1'-
arouna the tiae ot the a •.A.T.• er 1D the tta.l
and F'REIIWADB i' ltl!
.AtleDUo;
Current
pologioel
oplld.oo ••
am prombl;J 1D tb• letter
littoral
•au.l.d appar
(ChuroblU l9'S) •
t,lat
'° lb• lat'-r
.......
tba t ••14
\he AU.AU•
to haft 'bMD an ara
or
balt
'ia
l.eY-1 aahined
...
pw1.oa(:,OOOBn•tol
fll•
ot nNeQ\Mllt
the
AOtbiltg
ait•
ult
lffelJ
DGII
ot
{a• a.m.aaa •U•
et pra.at
the A'U.DUO
••
l>olh 11• i• ooeatel
am tbereton
r• l •k
,OOO a.c.,,
ct»•el
.
lomted oa or
w ban been)•
wcall.clrebte
lnel
period
....
1'8
ooea1;el ••blllt7
ANUld.D&
tba ·t aaw coeatal ld&.n ait. ••
Bo& and Frea ... ter "·•'
pna•
pi.a••
ot the
'lben
period,.
ai.1t ot tbat perio4e
the OOD'tNll«•rJ' •bore U..
IIIIL&h't
toll•
lt
u.. lilr1III
paaii10D at HIie
pnaat.
to tb9 llid-A\lalltic
the •rliR'
t.o
ill tbia•
aurpriaiqE
•t
CULYD • ILL wml.4 appear
141"1ocS. fiE ?'WA
RD 1:1)1 aen 'be aaaigDacl to
BoNal
wr
a. '*e tor
'lb•
here•
1t
at the •rl1-
(4,000 - ,ooo B.C.) I Nward
pe9ta
to•
•
t•
teet beloll the
loww, .IJID4camequ.utly
.," t
~., •• ,
•
Cl-::·rr:~·~::T
..:..a:;1 e
Pollen
.3.tl l'.1IH
J.htes
t:,~oo--l- 200
+
Tha. tc r:.1:::
7540
.0:::1 ....::
-
.
. 1-:
0
200
t
r-1
0
>1
Jtar
lo
7538
-~
セ@
"I i-'·
0
セ@
セ@
<T
l':J.oG t er lu :1d
~~oc~-;~loG terlund
.~
....
c.,
....
~J
I-' ::s
I-' ;;;a.
.;:::uvet-:r~·i 'ln
:1ouf i'i,..;r.o.c
::0 0
•
0
- 1L•O
- 150
7040
6l•'•O +
I!artle1,ool
70!..5
6420
c:, ::,
•
c-t-
•
!:j
-1-'·
Ickcrnsh::i.w
::s
"'
I-'
I·;r
6750
6150
-++
180
100
6150
-
18 0
'.:' 'J
rdP. r: o i:-;ian
5850
.!ouffi:nac
Peacoc!:. • s Fm
.
5650
n
..)
Cherhill
Culver ·.ielJ.
セ@
セ@
<:l
.
<T
r.:
4625
Eoedic
C.l
....,
-+ 350
0
>1
-....
•
<TI
-6'
.....
.....
-~
(')
~fostward I!o !
:3lns lle mre 11
Ca!-:hancer
.?,re shwn t er ~[
Hi:;h
C.1
0
,.,
"'
....
r~
-
+
'Joinc::,·-cn-TardE:!! O i s
+
. 3C•)O - 350
+ 'i')O
27 90
-
,
i :coli
t 'lic
~u:rnic
lt030
.
.<OCks
- - - - - - Fu:;;~;el.1.'z;
5280
5200
!•635
l.500
r.350
'•010
-
I
130
-+ 150
3230
-+
7,140
+
-
I-'
I
+
- -
0
セ@
1
1lfO
135
--+ 120
-+ 120
+
3780 150
+
150
370c -
Lod,,;e
I!e:1bur~r
-+
+.
-·
1-i
.
-+ 150
....
u,
0
j roxbourne
Ipin5 Co .;,;,.on
.
Q
!'..I
0
-++ 210
- 350
....
0
• ,.
7600
Ca.rr
1A0
Narrow
'
·.ihite
t
Gill
••
••
•
••
••'
••
•
. .•.....e
.;.cu.
••
..
•
I
I
-
I
•?
..
CT
••
,
'2lade
Pre.::.tat:rn
•••
- - 130
P•nine
セ@
I-'
::,
....
c-t-
(')
,.iill
-
•rllw,
lwel•
••
with 1:ihla b,Jpotheaia.
•ooord
d1a.-.tnbl7
"1ate
·--••l'
io e-.u..
... , •urelJ'
be
It toll ..
Atlantic
'-
d9ua •114 poll•
, theretc:w-e
'-t
.,.,,
the Korth COl"llia~Soutb
•lore
ei._
Withta
lf aot ell,
"telala littonl
•1'•
•rli.w
Slp1tio.ntl7
period.
••lJa•
•\lbiiersed.
io be •rUer
WClll14
•fflNr
CIJI,VJR YrlU,
cllt.4 ai\••
tbaa tbe ot.ber •o
ot 11a loc.•lOD ._..
But the o~tanoea
•h
IIQt
ty tbe •a.ftMr
ol•r
1'70).
(hlaer
ot t.heae oo..'91
!be aft111lt1•
oomU..
the ...
M\rie
--i.,. tra
w Uluavau .. ot
llollner,
alMI MD-& ....
,r.,oloaim~
'1-io
ea .. ,
ol-.rl7
ot ••
••IIIWa
... are
t1i11t
zaatve.
a.tea alreecl.J
to ell•
tale
••rtt.J
aD4
I
"ICWleD'-
'peUt
ot セ@
ere tCIIIIMSe .PI tile
111.arolit.bl
...a•
tnnoheta•
turlher
tb••••ih-w•tooaat.l
tbe
•Del Corta1ll,
Dnm
VPOlOCi•l oaapriaollll
ill the Rorabaa セ@
iena:lte
•crecwezo, tbe
--~
ait•
core••
rw•l
• aub-
owvlap witb the llaNbaa arouP aitea•
clu:•olcas1.ael
Clark (19.}2, l955J ... 1-
Al_..tinlJ,
au..-. ot aeo-
oon ••
deftld.M
la Sauth l•l•,
Potata,
abt.ellle4 tor
•
la omnrier-
11Dtbe llarabaa sreap.
att•
of llolloPlleN4
...
IIDNONI',
I•••
••ll
t;oo
el•r1'
ft&el)•
•114..-..-.a-10
, 1.a paralleled
ataatt.l
lllarolUlba
(1'70,
'bel..
Both, ..-trio
OCNftll"NDOe
.i ....
tw
OONt.l
•al-ta•
CULVlll "ILL ,o •
セ@
Palaar (1970)
ere • key ••·
•1•
•1111.ler a1te of~
Bot.h 1--'1-1.M
' I
both•••,"'4io-aarbaD
la
'° Id.a
Norlb Dnan and eor-11
BAY•il4 POUBAffl (all
' S• llfttlll'riea'
la eorm.U)
en
the ca.at.1
セ@
••Nb1-pe
ot
FINIITH, oaNSTANfDil
ea..,:l••
b1a ••
!be aiattaa
'
4oea _,
.u ••
•••cSJottb1.a IIOt.1.oala
at.a.•
a1t•
Gbillit
(tb• OIM.t.que~ Bla-4
ftaa•
22, aJ. II.. 2J) •
Nin,
a
•llf Yl8J•
unure
•• la
of•--'"-·
•en
alld ....
IIUlla in~•
, ...
...
tr1e
Clas
tne-
1,,1,
lo6.
1,
PISaSSI9!
tJu>t )Mllolitbic
It ia IIO Ulldarll•t--t
ot tla.
••••
MeaoUtld.o
ni4eaoe
>.p 1D Brit.ill'
•W-N4
tn ....
aaattered
ol•r
Jlaoh ._
tilat
ooael•t•
•
tor "1• parpoa•
t.QII
oanaider •tnah
••P..- ot
._
1'be OGIIYeDU.0.l
•111 セ@
....
obaerwDle
.i ...
t.
•114
•s. ...
セ@
~11•
ot the ot.ber
)vbr141NUan
Ill the laat t•
u.Dand
cU.tt...-t
,_re,
augg .. tiom
•sauveten-1an•
wrunt,
(•
ta
groul)
proc1eflna
ha••bMa
i.Dduatrue
i»n
•¥
1JIIO
•lMly
•
of••n-'•dae
the .. ,1 ...
1.an
1a taot cU:ffereat
blurriJlc ot Claric '•
_..1.Np4
•• •
traa the ttae of tbe
pert~
..-pbolol1,oell.Y
dllrina
diMiaUa-r
•"-
1-Mt the Br1:t:1.ah
'been ...
i.oturN
a ataln'
•~
by
oetween thla beiD& puNl.7
.._.u.oa1a iiba\
'l'be
end 1ibe •s.uvewrrun'
aoU:Yi.U.ea .,_..
aOOOUllb forth•
oulturee,
Bors••
(Col• end B1gp l.96~h 70-5).
1a • wua\er
ht
セ@
lllllbere ot • •iD&l• aoois 'l IX'OIIP, the difference
•••Ollll
(ill etten
abailDOe
~Uy
ocmtineDtal
two tn4it1om,
to
upon the 1mui. t1a11 ot nr1 taiAe
a.A. f. , OOIIII~
Magl ...
or
wo a~tiDct
'?be
llllller-
imaatr.1•
ll_•ol.iUaie
•Dd ahape11 of ad.wolitbl
•U\IIYd lllltU. qui\e
or1&ual arp1111nt, C'1-l'k 19S5).
tbt.11 •••
•ad Horabla - la beaecl llpGft
aJld 1ibe pnaenoe
aam.llS fr'OII 4ittff91lt
auah
K•ner,
111 SGllthWII Brit.ai.n.
ot the ~1,tab
repreaenW
aad it a
it ia wtNDti••
!llnertbel...
\be ».aol.itbie
au,
l'na.J,
aener.Uy
lt ••
セ@
~o
trio
rea•rab
end o~i••
UD, 'S.uYeWft'iaD'
iJl \be
wri.9UODI
nporta;
tore
ot \ha taota ta oalle4
olaaaiticeUon
- ... ,l ...
, ... wur',...1 ...
Jca&r11ala and excawUae
ot th1a p.per.
'Tbe
All ot th1a illtorm.tiOD 11•
ill 19.}2.
rMPPl'91Nl
mah aore 4Uipllt
Nl&ld require
aMWNlttecl ai.Dae C1-rk'•
••
perio41.oela,
l"OIII
1D BrUiaiD are 111•
atudi•
tu
lllgl-ian
wr1e11,, illpl.yiltc
end •int•;
IWll'Ol1'1d.o ...
and bt
..i•s••
1ihai
tb1a
11°'
oanaiclend
induatrJ 1a
!be......_.
1A tb1'1 erpaut
tor fWlotianal
Yeria~Ui'Y•
arel7
u
of t.he Maa].eaceaD variant•
noluUoa
Allart troll the thrN
boiill ea ••119ra,. ildaatr1••,
ibe ooeatel
Ill •&Uti•
oCld.•ecl •• • diatiJlcti'Ye
aneloaoua
ha••b••
•coordecl aepante
nell.¥ neel.••
Jut
boar real
• al \eraati•el.¥,
the iw--enatiOD
at.tu..
W.olitbic
illcluatri•
~np
"
ot tile
id•titiecl
1.ndull\ri••
11.• ta.ta
u....
•i~
that
to .n.bl•
セ@
•o 14en·Utiede
a wortbwld.le 41'1auui•
ot nriOIIII
pro\,l ....
U19WiWtI: MfFP
'?be
....-wt
U.tbio
•terlal
Alaaat
ilffcru'bl,J
Tberetan
'to tliat
••eaoe
oalwral
can diNrew
It ao, what 1a the •i&niftaanoe ot tibe
.. peola ooneerne4
be••taY°'lret
are the OOJWention.l t.xODOld.o cli:ri.aiw
'Dlft"e ere autticiellt
be••bHII reo-
Brit.ill
wo.
ino
tile DriUab
wi'tbin
eleaena.
It ta illt_...t1ng
ot ibe .britiu
pJd>l ...
~•el.Tea
._oli"tbio
1.
19',).
wbare oonc11Uam
Tb• .t.Jnerproetetioaal
a.
ot Sout.b-w•t
(W•imrrtpt
Cl'Ollp
atill
(C1-rk 1955, We!Jllrright
and •• c011tributGr7
i.Jlcbatri ..
aC11eeutbore
aroupinp,
auninla'
•1'• 1D ScoU.nd,
or l>aae •r'•taoa,
1.
'7P01,ogioal
ot 'Creawellian
tile pouibilit7
entertaia
l"J),
pri.Doipel
ill thia
oouatr,
4iYiai•
••emblapaJ
at\141.M
WitkiA tu
to ol.auU)
1N.a1e-Qpee or .tDdua
trt .. ) , -.
or
't.he
ia.ture
.. ol.i~io
ot ll•o-
ot the ••1'8aoe•
relate.
to t.be lliorol11ihic
iDd.uatry.
apec1tioall7
c~t
(u
b
lara.- tool tarwaJ•
eun:blape
a •t
cl.-aaUiattiOD
ot occnqatiOII U a liW.o
•Dd in prtieular
.,-,-,10
I.a • t'-Ptina
c:mr-•~
1a the
tile onl,J ildimtiOD
'.Jpolactael
or
to .. ajeotiw
•iD&l• Nat.ale
0110•
lato Wlli•flll
taoe4 •t 1ib \be
ll'OIIPI ( euer
ala--'ocwt..
ot
106.
prniaua
or oolleoUon,
1n r•peat
1'0l"k_..,
ha••bMn
t• 111.erol.iW.c a.. ellbleg ..
and Ulua'1'1aUam ill a1\e
be ayat.a.\t.U1
n"17
IIN
enalyaec! eaeordllla
Yer7
to Clark .'• a,atea;
acoo~
セ@
oaa.pram1Ye•
tbrclup a
•D111.orolU.bio ---
oi.eaiti.S.
AppenMx I la • liat
ta
olaaait1-d
appreobits.OD ot 'the vpea repnaer.ted
qwntiteti••
blaa•
N;pc:rla
NOOrdi»&and pwbl.icat.ioa.
ot \ha.e
to Clark'•
ait•
iD ll!JWl~radend
ola•.1.fioatiOD,
ao t.r
•l•
bNn
that haft
•• the preaent writer
.-..re.
v11m
n•e AA>11WP
Tht ••
Dellpt\e
lack ot guantitetive
tb9 auenl
t th• a'tandard Wipartit
1a U.
one, aDd broedl7
1.
.e ayat.a
• .,.114
•peeking
illt'cratiaQ
of t)'pol.aaical
41YiaiOD ia • u.aetul
Certa1Al.7'
CIIMI oall
or».
rt ..
a peraaml
~·:
charact.era.a
by • bigb ~J,JOrt.ica or DCDa.Dlt• • traac air/....
eleaallt
)•
.Aaa-1>l..g•
, ... ,r1o aicro11 '-•
u,.g1,_,.1-n
•1th • laigb pi-oporlioa ot ..U
geGMtria
alorol11iba, a114 l.aak.u.g •••
and •••
( 'Sawe ·arri.aa').
2•
J.Nablap9
,.
Aaatnl>la...
....
\Uy
, ...
aholfiq
t.i-10 ~.
• aenuine
•lob& •1~
lllx••
Tb•._. applud
to lheae sroupa an
pi-aavwaae
attiUatioaa•
dlmia
ot
&MMlrio
aD4
e.l.eaun (BorahallJ•
aD. ·-
aoa111.ha, i...
.. ,sataotory
But they are re'81M4
hen
••
•1.Doe
or
taa111ar1t7.
Cl•rl7,
on the
-.llll)lA,..... iJI
beau ot the alcroli~
1n Smthffll
a1, ..
IIIE'l'IR, ldlbt be aHr1"4
rortumW1,
end
t.
to autp
•"_..
nideJIN
an
ot oer1aln
•D7 allbllt.nial
theae are not diaoreM
!nclenct, auab •• '!00
to ei\her
aiaplitied
•1.-nt,
\be lla;leaoeian
b7 セ@
c11apae,1c
m1ol"olitbio
••
tnee•
BIU, •114 Iw-.&NB •
er Horeha•
ot duatributioaal
Ana
••abla1•to
gr'Glll'i8•
criteria
it abau.14 IJl'OT• pauibl•
•it.bar
a,1..,.1,an,
•9nt•tlU,n Sun1!Plt'
bl.ua' aDd '•edle-
Certata waaaual 111.orol.11ibic t;n,ea { • a.Qgl..,..okad
poinu•)
ahap-4
OIi
Na:Lm.aoent or Upper .PeullOU~
oooaaioll bMD NOOrded 1'rola aaleamian
iri teU.
'!bi.• b. ·• l:)ewa••en ••
,r.ditioaa
into
la'-
a&t oloa• 1nduatrul
:.-nUela
•uu•t that
ait•
··fi...t c.l1~u-.(u
.1DM1'111iaclial(Zane 11: •·
.
alaaift entirel.7 fra
i-•i.•
•iib
or Crenell.iaD
tbe atend.r4
Ii 1'0llld ....
'bt
coau..nt.l
:i.DCJulllri•
TJoacarlall
the r r ... ellitill
'b•Jenaa
to
c-&i~ p{I\A..(e
10000 - 9000
a.c.)Aeq
GD
1a
aild
ta. ~11-64
be••preolua.4
MoseowR• laimriaht'•
.artta1!.n.
bA:JA-9
lY&v4w
lauaaa OGCRr
'angle-'beoud
be aoacaa.S.W
o1oaer illapeotion.
of lliorolitba.
cl ... 1.fic.tiOD
tbu
tren.Ulan
of l'Mt.. s-,c.cee d ,~
bladea' alld 'DHdl.rahaped poUata' oan.
wiuu,a
1D Scaatb-w•t
MMoUthic pmod ('t•lmrrtabi 196J).
セ@
».pleman
•U•
tor ~. •urvival
ffid.ao.
m.cS.Do• for tb• date ot the 3.ritieh
Direet
•li&bt.
and coaatel
ba••
tw.
Crea•ellt.n
the .DOtum
ot •er.wellun
.i\&l"wivela'
a
an
Cofftel l,trtk1M
la reeP"'
l aiarright
al.Ill セ@
(19':S ) ooaaiden
•
tri•
ot ooaatel
ow.tual
awe1,J repnaent
セ@
t)'pol.ociael
oo.a1iel
aaaar:i,lage••
leOIDlltri.o 111.orolithio
group.
•1t.a
ill Sou1ib
it Juatif'lable
The preaent
セ@
coa;pariAona •rt
Wri ...-•a
lllglaD4,
'littoral
•i•
lq \he ••U
OOIIPID1t1.ell'
1a $llat
セ@
•••
D<ala Jloruaa
aiN
ot •87
·1111.Xture
of ceocnetrio alld IIGD-
But the epper.nt
taraa. the ooourrenoe of U. Jlollow-baee4 Polat at
tn Pel!lbrGlt•hire. •ll
eontut
w •PNk ot
• OOM1ial Tari.ant ot the sou,hull
•1'• (.... l :IS':'Yr"RD OOJ olld P'RJSIMJ.rlft
ax•
••l••D4 S ca&t.b-w•t
.. C1-rk tbaugbt ) .
im~t•
•
~JS!)• •nd • oono.-ra~1•
111:,nbam oettst
(noi •
laD¥
ot vaaabet
•a,unterriall•
\
\
110.
2.
mwnw
origiJ:l tor th• Lritiah
AD iaaigenoua
•m
unJ ikel1;
iaa tica
•de
1a ea • tinc1.iYM¥
wi1ib reprd
liW.o
or a
Clal'k' • h.Jpotheeia
• IIWllber ot p»1Dta aan be
lloWner,
ot .Bri\iab
ocm'U..Mntel etti.DitiM
MNo-
~.
Th• aunbla~•
r•tllllltl•
fflAmwt
floQII
~•
d.tea like BROXBO~
from ConUnimtal
COLIN VALtff, D1ZPCARend
•tt• セ@
ilffento17 f'l'oll the Brittah
ot ~-
tJae proporU.•
and tu
41ttenac•
{•"
1-ak ot ttne, •rraa
••
'b•
•ND••apeoi.al
a"1"1bl&•Dl• k cli.ttwnne•
119piie11l
boUl .bri ,tuh
ot • _..
.. r1a-i1w
ar aon likely
ta
Tni>M• tw.
.Araba-,logimll.7
1'be
•114
tbeae
•~!Jig
1•1Mrnliaecl culture,
to c!iffereraceia ill geo-
•ffl.nltiN
S.u.•wrri•n
theae
Y.h--•
•
aitea,
18), in .... セ@
'tb•
the tl,o g!"Glllp9 •re
ot their
aNNID1-£•
aiaroUthio
m•• •tf4...nit1•
11Nn t.lwt ihe7 ere nto ..
ru,
'Die altft"Nltt.v.-
Pa-..
StpU'i•ntly,
'S.w•wrrt.•a'
Sou\h ••lM
'i.Dduatri•
oloe•t
with Sa11n~n
pareillela
.not preou~
~ent.
with P.renah
s1.a1.lar (••
Clark 19552
.Tat btlc»ua• oez1ein
ld.th Yrenah S1niTeterri8D
the product ot
am
aD4 4-velop11e11t?
grQIIIII ·
ait•
doea
an ,
reeoburc Jn&land tNII
the p:-eaent •riter
!a
••re, ao
:ia kllowD 111 !ngl.l!Dd aouth ot t.he Tha_.
• eurp.--iairW it
Ja, .,_t
qUNtion
ts ein 1n,U,18lll0m ori,line
ao fir••
•it.
tiJld their
at.tM •re at
lltgl.-ua
b
M19glemcaian apr•d
1a the qUMt1.0D ot Britiah
cnacial
1
Brittah
•• 1ibetr ocat:1.Delltal aD11l0p&••
to 1Dter:pret
H"• ••
Non
dll*- augpiat bt
awU.bl•
•• •r~
BriU.h
1JI •1•,
apeoUt.lq
laaaU-.
fhe t•
1_.t
dittereDOM ri..
1951.,: 180) •
Clark
1'1t the 'ld.oro11W.O
\)'POl.oaS.0.111'auipi.-,
S'!Ai CABB•• ... la&• abClle lllpcrunt
OOIRtmDtal ail•
ot Bona1 •P
1-n ait•
w.,1 ...
SVADDBllO.. MOLLDUP, tDMOAARD,and DUVJNSD)•
(••I•
t.ben
•M•
wow.d
dl»l uwaa1GD ri th aubaeq\Mllt b,J'brij-
aimpl.e 0111h
•uaa•ted
to the
illutr1•
W.ollt.hic
t.be lritiab
inct\la\r,J
4id re}'NltPt
parel7
••lleJ
P
ar 1n
apemiOD
\
1u.
of th • :'renoh !:lauv•terru.u
(noutttpao
aite
J'Nllob
oomt.ner.t.l
and i.te
to 1ib• A.Urntic
th•t
,7 ,itiab
aaoh •rlier
Boreal
•U•
dated
The oontinental
to lld.c!-Bor.l
•seweterrua'
•i'-
will
eftlltutlly
S.UYeterrian
oo
• to aza at t1m1T• part or luro~
Falaeolltio
• api-Pitl•eolitbic'
paau»ili'7
l9ll•i
Do\
i.ra••
1"4,;.
or•
period.
Karecwer, 1awtr10
•u•mble.-,
1.a4Wael• 'l'ranglN
end in-egu].-r
n.tiYe
reaote, 1A •1•
....
.
tollowiJI& • • 0\11.tural b.Jpot,h•ia'
ill aoaa llaglwai,iin
) ta tbat
ooaoarden (Ratatriclk
tn-
ot al.orol11:ba are
th••
aliboaa&h edaitMcSly
C"N9oeP•
H ..
Bolrffff1
...
'
aeome\ric typee do oooaaioaall7
•ddiU.•
•Olll'C•
l'l"OII
B011ffff, '\b• poaaibil.ity
aow ltD01rn to"
ot
•n:1.t'•t.ttaaa
atead.ag
or the I011DC•rDrJa•
{aU.ll
Radle7 A aleU.re
UNCEM Cllt
often .
aurrinla
tn Hort.hem !nglend •n
ata\rtwU.om
ot aeY_..l
or1&1Dtor our geomt.ric 1Ddua~•
ot ov eool.oaiaal ~l4ICII•
Th• ttn.l
there 1a • paaaibility
cca:ie to light.
1a only me
wcn
·•••attally
tor the
cent.rt
ao rar • de tee!' beloag
Adldtt.sl7
perioda•
•mi
Opper
aal.7 CJ.4. de\ernlna ticm tcr a
ih•
•nearl.1
•ua•ta
)
irlduatf7•
J lao
graup.
1:be ohroaolqp.oel
occur ( et. 1'& TCfWf -
tnt.-.noe
ia that
I)•
J.~1•
•M
the lll!l-emaatan
u_.
I.a
1.llduatr., btlcap
to ·the periocl NWeen 8300 B.C. end 6ooo B.C. (7.0De8 IV•VI),
ancl the 'SeUYet-
emaa• to
VIC • VIIw ' VIlb) t
al~
th•
th•
bet.MD
period
.,.U.nce
1a too ·eli,tht
DO'UOII or • llagleaoea'll
ex.a •
NI40ialq'
•• aameriaall¥
'that
tbe
au, .. )•
'Ral'NII'
MIJ~
.on aN
It
~Atl
obetecl•
cm the pri
セ@
GD aClllla
'S.w•terria•'
(at• millX>N DINI, FU.;U.TrN,
m..a.• indua,17 ot
.......
\be PenniNB
or •robaeol.Hc.nv,
IDglaDd.
1a 111CarM'1.ltcw
to 't:h•
t.he •haenoe or tnnahet
•114 • conaiatein't failure
Obliqldl.7 BlwaW f'oinia
PaDrd.M 'Jllaff'OltD1-de'
thougbt
noluti
tatermec:U..at• 5.Dduatrue iD
tOl"IIII •n
IIGII-IMIM\rio
to be oonnluai•••
- 'S.uYeterrua•
•it•,
•s.weterriaD'
oetata to recopiae
6ooo ]3.C. aD4 3000 B.C. (~an.
,
•1'9111
end ....
111 19'2 Clark
ba4 nolwcl-'
ot
ua.
am ,1111t 111,l~li.. (196o)
the 'Broad &lade' lnduau,-;
\he baai,o t.nolaaical
ex• ••
Dffff
diati.mUon-
~.
from h,lcoak'•
l"ara ••
en
I) eDd t.hffe are dltini.te
t.be
are oaaplN1eDl1117J ao
JM>Nf.WW1
ot
Darib
t.,
.Adhffi.Dg
induatri
appioaala
__.
to~
the mtun
lM dra•J
sill "t.hen are
.m. ' ::»euva"arrun•
J:laraba•
w
'°9 ataodllrd
.. , auttioient
problem
ot
ot tbia
lllfGl'UtioD
cml.J' •ua•UODa
•••
t•,
tor~.
it.-:,,
ts.a-10).
ar-pa
int'l!'llletion
o'f'1&illa
t»Ye b ...
ware
Uaurpretat.S.on
'aultlinl'
._
onrlep
diatribut.iOM
aiaiuri-.s... (•"
ei'8e
a Uae fl'DII Hereford to Cambriclc• (••
bNa セ@
litbio
wlley,
t.o Uae Horaha• iD-
f"nd ' Si.-uyetarrt.aa•
iiorsh&ll
•wicl\l-7 'SeUYeterrian'
llltclalld aouth of tb• '!'b.-
i\ 1- pcaa,-
.Appendia
bi.ma -tmt t.be Borablaa 1n4•VJ" pcat-
abraaologia.l
•a1-un.
1- coueot,
l\Yl,ri.41-tica,
,no1,o&1a1l
diaUJ:lct
the OCDt.1-
(ea tile 'baaia ot the a.it•
reapeeti••
Their
with
opiaioa
trom the »tgl...,.un
and Wal••
...
"9Dt
p_..tber then•
.volut!cm
direct
セ@
19'0),
IICdern geologlc•l
.remte tmt
ot tb•
ooo.aiOlle& 'b7 inlw.ar
o'! ltinll oam.eotlom
Chu-bill).
in SOllibtlrll ~lld
da~
the oor•
•it••
• )Vbri4iNt:1•
~n41t1one,
I!
~emblapa
1.ble a 11rsu- tar•
(;,aimrtght
re1Nae'nta
fl'OQ t.i..e セ@
5000 a.c. (:a.~.,.).
then c~ia
duatry
0Ulff•tionsll7
reaul'ting
MDt ercwad
1~~•0, in t.h.1B a.pl.an4 rag:laa.
ano ' Se11v•t.rrisa•
•~ei:.oai.l1
dnelopaeata
'° reeopi•e
..-en
Yer'I atraog ele:.ior..t on •E\r(l.td ·-1"'4•' {llagl-ull)
•
'lh• licrliba• p,NP
mU••
retuaed
noor4e4
Jlo.raba• ait•
9l'Ollal.7oani...,DNl'J'•
ot the Brl\iab
&rOlll41P
1a au.oh that no 4-tiJliw
• tNab
tdentU'1e4•
H~
ocmcluaica
paoblld
The l!l!lin tnte}NtiiaUaa.1
a g__..l
lack. ot quanti t.it.iYe 1nfo11•ticn
tllixOlnllc cli.vaiou
b)
the
,...,.1la&
'll,5lCII&
wbidl
comia\ent
cen be bPeet\.
of atratified
aiMa wUh o.roor-4
or pollllll
•it•;
en4 '11• ••ll
•t...
:ar.o-
to atbulate
areunct r
•)
in
.u1d it baa elNed;J
1a ••U.ble
•Jor
diatrilMtioal
naam.~
ot
0.11
rfl'ol..,•
ll,J.
,.
THJ9Yl1UOftW IWQ'I9WcJ6VtWWD
Tbe •ltel'lleii••
vul
pciupinp
t.,..
(Col•
•iti.D
ot a •~•
t.n dittennt
arcupa wauld ban
induat.17 relaW
•de
b7 lllllb ..
eeoacwd.o •otiYiti•,
at
1a that t.n winter
a '*al-un•
the lowlanc9a prodl.lO:l•
mon4 law
eld 1D aumae,: tb.,
• ditt_..
~t
WGllld •• • \o be tt.t
'?he 1Dtff'e00e
ariiviti•;
ia:hlll-
been ronu1..tec1 ua YaOAe
to ditterent
ilababi-4
the obeerYe4
in&aatri .......
loa.tta111.
to the •••oaal.
•rN•to
the upl.Dd
anq
Their •J'IIIMl>t
g:raup •ad related
......
lfeeoUtbio
25.>) •
to expuia
ha•
iaD 8J'ld'S.wetenua•
aoot.l
cl1tteNDt
ttae Meeolithio,
alld B1&ga l~9,
Mafil.
...
the DltiYe
wbiah a.-
!Qpoth•a
prodLlo1llg • 'S•UTetan"lan'
ba'bit.t,
i.nd\11\17.
llell.1'11 c1,1c) ...
ity•
in atone
thi•
•~•
\oal
tuW
aNabla&NJ
tora - that
by • •i.Dal• aootal
by
00Dli4encl
t\moUanall7
セ@
- •an
eYi.deDN whloh •ba
ComiAeriJrc the W.gl._.t.11
セ@
.. t 'tbe Col•
poealble
to
..,,., .So
date,
1)
but me •n
ot 'tunctiaml
ciu•ii•
CCIRn•UAg aueablaa•
Tirtually
..
a\lOh •A in•rl'l"•tati•
•ppeer
•Dd ' S•uveterrtaa'
to oer'aia
it
Yer'¥ Ulllikel.7' •
la Dot atriOU,
llb1ob
to apNitio
••t auapioiaiD
on
•wU.ble
a.tea •uq•t that tl» ' S• UT• tarria•' :ta nib_.
セ@ tbe f\anatianal
b;,potbeab aurely
tm11 t.he • ale-s..a
nqldna
'ViAr oaattlllll)On•ty ~t
the &anti•
ot the
The
t•
later
2)
11:MoU.
U\io period) •
.
There ta aot a ol•r-o11t
ditteNDCM in cUatributia.
S.t.ber セ@
tUa\ributlOD
ot Mlal,.-.ce1an and ' SaVYetefft.D' 1a ooaoordan"
noentJ.¥ the Mtgl ... tan baa bMD taun4 ill l&Pland
1.Dalud1ag
the Pemdnee•
•rN•,
to baw Nell both w1Jlt.r an4 •waer oaqa.
trCIIDStar C.rr
tbet the •1 te •a
OOOl&Pied
bet.ND .April •114 October•
Al'tel'l'l9t1Yely,
' Breed Ba4e'
ill the P•mai,,.., •t bes.gbta
1,000• o.n. at 1... t,
wcaa14 ha~
haw• bMD. 000\&Pi..Sduring the wiJJter .mat.ha.
.>) u. ai-s-n
•1' ......
! b• ta1111al セ@
.u ..
auas••
•'bcn•
ill
be • paatble
'Iii 1h Nteruoe
r.ow
apa ., ..
ot beiDI poeiU.vel.7 r.-
tno.pble
~-la
••rbbil-
•are •a&t.aturect
eTidenoe' • bl&t 1ibat it •7
aD4 Bigp
point
aot.
and be ccmolu4M that bJ'poth•
k1D4 or •rohaeol.ccical
91q
to •dduoe
tb•
114.
~.
lh• t\mcti.aml
t.k•
bypoth•S.
ao eccowat or the Borahe•
1Dduatz7•
ID ora.r, to •ube~nt.t.te
data
cm •••oaal
or retuie
ooau.~tioa
•pecuU,
9
'beWMl'l ld.orolit.bio
.....
i. ••
clitt••noea
\o oba_...'bl•
SJL111S1'0Man4 PSHAK.
etatua
wittwa an aree of -
eoal..-.rJ't
2 Holl
• s1 '- 11 •, .-.
1 81"-
.&'•,B'•
IY',
'rod'
50
*"
aipifiaaDt
Sautb-11••
BrUaiJI
II 1a pouible
v• bi
all4 the cleNio
the ooaatal
looatum
OIi the
,._.. mtplolted
~a
ot ' •••osal
ld.gb\ N e Win\ff
8\llaU'
•'
a..e
cli.tt--'
JIO
te be
m.oroli Ula
1') augpeta
.induatrul.
•otivit7
or aatiY-
1a UDCerlaille
befiNeD
•it• in
oca•t.1
ill uu.114 loc»tiom.
• a1-1.ea.
-
1.11an ilatU"IIDOe tm, 41.tt"ennt tnJeD4
••aamJ
D()W}i'lOI( (•
ai&bt irater bt
Bezmadabt
_.
1t7 llendlt 1111oalao eixpl.oitea the
'° ci.n•a
•~
(•
the ::>
urn7
t.be 1 1.lubire
allt)
(19.)9)
are,nesllll)
lllab\ be a
OIUll)e
SiaUarly
CII
..-geoaetrio
(195':
hllldlle
t.1148• l'.ARNIWl•'-
•I(),WMJ."N8
ft-GIi a
a\&Oh•• ,.JB'l't\Alm 801 9 U' tbe7 ._..
~--
oiiber band:, ~re
I',
T (oQllrlatllg
Site
titter.-,.
ait•
1a aot pau-
it
lbliQl&el.1 BllllaW Potata
Bcrahllm iDdUlliri•
.u-y•r-l"Cllllld
••,u--1111.....
AiJaterla~.
unol:n4
perbapa a.re~
that
GIi
or aome apeoial
ta •• iada
'•••m.11
lbe~
• Site
m •, • t•
.i,,...te.t P rar.).
alld ..
au911blap
1\i••
cm 'Site
A• )'•t
and whiab are beliwe4
tOWli •
._..
an4 orer 1,000 a:torolitha
and C'•,
' -bait ••
r ....
wri.a Ucm, w
at ~I <lWiGIR 5 •11•
9
aquan llll•
1111lNl-.4 poU'8
tor MMlb 41Yff&eD-
•••
of the ai1iee•
llo1Nftr
'be DOW
troll . PARNWI,
•&•,np.wl
la
aol1111-.
• poli',iti~•
••
'bel'Nell the ,auealapa
dltt___.
IJ'tlUP loaau4
oa
wit.b
Clark (l9}9& 95) polAta
are •nwal . pouible
'ltl_..
1D 1ihe (t\allotioaal)
to off•
•am wriat.ic:a
.trait Jlolwha111 •it••
Ua det.U
- ahanoea ot 41aoaft17,
ibl•
ill auooiation
tel&Ael. NlllliM
turlber,
To take lb• 4iaauM1GII a l.itUe
diaierlti•
11"4 aore Nlubl•
••
9
•••-1ag...
•sal.ffetem.A.
o1•
the ~heaS.
there ••
a ...
OOCIIIP7
l.ol,1.an4 •it ..
lib
-.1
s~
••l*Rto
the
CAlll ill w1Dttr,
11;.
Uk• Dl'.IPCA.Rill
•nd upl..,Dd •it.a
be •Dit•ted
in r•pective
In •ll
the"
thia
l.aU.om bea ..
••rutioM
•re likely
ot ...
lNt •Y nlate
,....-1
betaeen
cU.tfennc•
e1gll1t1.c.nt
and
•Y
DO"t ~--
wboUy ar 1D s-rt
1A the
~t.
are
a.en
baaed 11pon eGlll)l.ete wol-kU11.
obael"ftble ditte"J"ebc• be'heen •aa...i.pa
MODOalc aotiYitiN,
ditterencee
eoollGld.o •cliviti••
セ@
woul.c!
t'orm 1a probl.-ttoal.
Ulli.Dg tut
to reflect
equlpaent,
•terial
\o De· •4e, the, ahaw.d •t l••t
then
in aiarolit.bic
1a the a.nger
•Nemblag•
ld.croliW.o
Haw ~r euch •••ea.lit.,
8\Ullllm'•
purely
to 1eopapiioal
elld
ditt .......
lbenton,
\IPOD lnduat;rul
b.J'poth••
diai-n:U•
ot t\&rlot.ional wrtabili'7
abOllld not be maecl
•lane.
SIJ¥W1J
1)
flle Meaolitbio induat.ri•
ot swihern lrita!A b9n b .. a 41vide4 uato 3
preaeooe or
•.1or ~,
beaed llpGll the aha~
ot lllarol.itba ena セ@
• batDCNtot oore •••:
lltgl-ian
•j
l»
o
':":t
IntluatriN
Horeham
.
With SNffet.erri.aD •ft'i.Diti•
.
The ial>r'IHiOD 1a ti9t theae セ@
DOi aa •beol.111:,el.7dUCl"ete cl•NN,
to ......
.I!! be braa4l,J diatiAgu.i.ah.S, b\at
•• ~Olla
Workffe
MYe t..W
'
.'
2)
DliirlbuU.u.U7,
セ@
U.glemaaan iJlduatr7 ....
to be w1d.. l'r'•4 1A
lng1-lld , ill botb lwland • n4 bigbland •rw•; bCIIIItaar, U at all , t.i 1a
repa"tl8ented ill a l• ia probl ... t.iaal•
The 4iatrihlli1om
or ' SaUYet-
to be ~ementery
. .E\an
wriaD'
end &orama 1ncl.lat.r119 セ@
'SaUYeteni.aD'
•ulllblepe
la•e 'nc. lieen twb4 awtb ot '- Tba ...
wU.7 or iJI South •l• •
'l'h• Borabam cli.atribllt.1•
•1' be wider than
waa prnt.aual.J \booat,i, b\lt do.a aoi aeem to •tencl IIOrib ot • lim
セ@
Cambridc• and Heretard.
,)
TM awU.11~• ohrollolopoal
nidenoe •uu•ta that. Bonham and
'S.11Yeterrlan'
·ll'OIIP9 ere 'broecll7 oaal41111»01•17(paMlb17 ••'°°'¥'5500
JOOO &C. ) •
!he
gl ... ten induat.17 ....
to ~te
~b
(••8.)0(>6000 BeCe), al.Uto!agh 1:h4idegrM of aqJ CW«l"lapla \IDCe$Ule
-
ll6.
IJ'GUPinaa
wit.bi.II tile Britiab
1be ewU.ble
nei '-r
MNol~:W.o.
OD
,.ery ol•rly
mild,
the otber
reMed•
tvPotb•ta'
Die '1Jwea10lil •114 h,JbricliuU.oa
e)
to tit
tor ehrallolau end diatributiaa;
ffideaoe
o.n be paai ti"17
oiaed •
Hei,her .....
(C~rk
l9J9)
aaD
be ariti-
• IUliHar ot OGUDtel
TMn
en
•
•s.uwterrian'
when oae ...U
ai tea 1D Smtbara
to n.na tb•
u}leOt
1Dglall4l preoiaely
it the iJMlaaW.J••• deriv .. from
rnnoe•
b)
'?he 'S.uftMl'riara'
Borebaa
o)
4)
i.Dduat:17
-.ppae41.J
\ban , en
ao 'S•u'N~'
c!Sa\:rilNU....
•ft~--
.ert,iab
'l'h• al\erlla,iYe
DOI"
( COl•
It tak•
b)
•ai-un
DO
ao ap~nat
de! 'S.uwternan'
pno1.Ml.7 a ial.lar
to 'Iba
u •rl.J•
4e-tnlu1'
lllal.-.un
wbiab aNka to ezpleiD
••
& B1gl
•ai--s..n
in4a 1;ry la _.
~-1-
induatri•
'S.11Yetvriall'
•trs•w .....,,
but,
Jngland •hen
'S.we1errU11'
F1"91M1b
1Jkl.latr.,,
•••~l
aapeota ot tM .....
1969) • .....
..,_
1 ...
encl
olit.b.ic
OCIDYUICiDg•
aooount ot tta. Bortlh9a 1.nduatl-7
•114 'S11unter:rua•
iD llart.bara ID&laild
4iatributiolll
c,r:.,,oorclent encl IIOt oomplwnt.ey.
•N
a)
aiua,
1D Jonbern
•)
tbaa the
ill SOll\b- ... i IDal,eD4 •hen
a lQltrl.cUM\i.oD
~bricU•"-•
popalad.GD
•rlier
illduatz7•
'lben ••
TIie
DO'
d..-vebl7
ta
Mlgle ... ian 8114 1Sallfttlll"l'UD
~'17•
The oonw.-e
1
incSulltriea
are IIOt a..amtnbly
•PI>NN to be セ@
ceae:
the Jillgl..-UD
eppeera to precede the 'S•w•tarrt.11'.
dJ rbere ....
to be • ... aoaal aapeo\
ep~l'91ltl,1 retl~ecl
1A ld.orol.1~
Bawner, both th••
bypoth••
en
••ted'b,J \be
avaU.'Dle
ff'id...._
CIPIDOt be
to
tile v.g1 ...
1an, aot
••Nlbl.ea••
tOIW&laW
ill tfflll9 •uab that tbe,y
1'he preaent ·•ri\er
W.oli\ld.o
\be aot1an
u pcpOl• to
anl.opnenurr.
Wtial
Wldttterent.ut.ecl
••
iD tact,
geo-
rba 'te.ndenoyta11arda in8NIII ,
to
ha••protwo
Therefore
prcwiDc••
tll• urit:l.ah ..,_olithta:
witlwl
reoogalaed
countr,-,
thia
Jlllglemoaun:
1D the northen2 (SeuTeterrun')
mi&bt'be
lDto
ead ameUer aiae ot 111.crolitha woul4
oreaaed pGaltrioity
ceedea turtber
Maglnaaian
elld Horamm 1nduatr1N
ot an ewol..a aa.gleaceua».
'ftru1'l9
aore OOllt'orta'bl7 •1 tbiA
culture
eDYtuge boUl 'S.unt.errun•
セ@
eonoel'llin& tbe
the Britiab
tbet
eh extenaioo ot the l!ltltio
1\:
arastat•l
tbe klllMD taota
be aooc · xtat.t
•D
jooepttna
indua'tr,J repnaenta
I
:that
ia Smt.ber:1 Bri'-SA
• 1.h1rd b.JPot.beaia•
i,eriodl
avapeta
.a.c.: tbe gn&aal colonaeti<lll ot Brit.in by peopl•
*
...
un or Proto-Millgl-1.Dn tratit.ion 1a the Ire-Baral
perio4;
l\nd tb• gnbl
edaptetiola
to cmncin«ecological
セ@
et
COD-
and a nnp
ot eDTU"OllllalJ.U aot Mt with 1a lolrlaD4
o%"tharr1 !Urope•
Th_.. •1 w.U. h,iq been• coeatal eapeot,
4itum
wideDOe tor wlaicb
II
セ@
JIGlr
tbe
aublarge4.
1:9•'
with np:-eilentatiTM ot two NlaW
UW4iUmaa
Souihern Briuin,
botb ate
tram the Nrlier
un; '11• 'S.uveterrara• ill llartti.rn Snfll•lld eacl lel•J •Del
tha H~m
u ->outbern ~nd
end l.111••
Both probably a,p4e4
lnlo the lieoU.thio perioc!e
@セ
Magl ...
Alamt
•na
Oer'hiDl7
bu.t S.t •en•
a)
u
th1Jtp
to illuatnte
• point.
'b• dllt to • teUlal'"e
reoop1ae
aw,b
ma le4
• elbld.o' wran•
.i.tber
•a.a1...
'1.D~te'
or
•
_,.t
1.Dduatri•
•••enl>upa000\U"
'° • atria\
••
poillta
(•M U.U.a
•UM
aotta11
ot
aetegoriatioa
Tha writer
b•tltND
(l~O)
'N•rrar
'° ait ..
like
1960,
AR,~U
INCl..Ua>
ot arobaeologiata
ux!.Uble
8,U.a
do Bi.ate
Pemia
a two oowiu1
pouibl•
•
·the ~r'
'S.UYeterrta11•.
1nchlatriM
d1Jlt:1notioa
Blade'
1aa•
OD
tba hit.berto
ia4ua1rt.•:
IIIID4el.
augg•t,
I1'1XJSTRIJSIN .IQfflWUI
.na 'S•u••Ml'l"laD')
betatND Jlegl-~11
Thie •7
セ@
CriUoua
THI A.l:-f'ARBL?l'
LACS c>' •nrmll!DIAR'
(1 ...
•Ulll••• Ulia
D0t. qu.i:te ea
._..
ot
to
two
••i-nu
•-embl•1•
••
•ugg•ta
tt»t
retuaM to mke •'DY
Bade'
COOK'S STODt
·C: ttg.5).
end 'nro.cS
CII
whiab 'miucS'
1 セ@ r
.t ;1
.e:.
• 1 a •
( ·~ : f t
1
I , r t f f r i f 1. I i ! I E. a
r&. r f.~.e: • r, I~
, ' • I . r f ,
!.
i... E
•
• ;._ • i' セ@ I
(1:i : ... f f., 1l. 5r f• 111
if r セ@
f lE ;i I! .i j! tI fI~セ@: r£ I.. f i セ@ セ@ ! f ' l = t J & i !
{ セ@ 1 j l { i 1 J l I i !i セ@ セ@
E i i I : セ@
f セ@ t • '1 ·i.~ :JI
11
•
·1
rf
I!.
c
i
Q
t ...;-.
i セ@
r·
: f セ@
'
I a
I
i セ@ セ@
I l
:
I
..
i
セ@ i
• { 4 i !
;
s
;
f
E l 1 i I ; セ@ i ,
' i ?l g i l ! !
!
t (
=11·1s:
I.
t
Iセ@ ;I : !
'f
1 ....
21.
セ@ I
f f .. I
f セ@
f i I• •8
tI セ@ l i
i
a.. セ@l I
セ@ I
..
セ@
-
•
セ@
•
セ@
o
I
l f
セ@
E~f r... r
I
.i :.
.....
I I: 1.. i
fi 1
f
tr
8 i
O
'f !.. :.c ..,. !• f• i
セ@
1 !
[• fi i.セ@ fセ@ •セ@
セ@
rt
I セ@
•
セ@
Ii
f 8
·•
:;'
2
•
i• t!f
I'B. •i I, '4C
t
f I
E1 ! .. @セ
• • I
D'
•
::.
8
i ,
I
i'
f
t
セ@
=-
セ@
f
r!i ij
セ@
..P
•
S B. S.
•
f r
..
•
'
I
•
=
II
ri
!
! l
f
i=
C
I
..
セ,@ I=
1:ac
i r I f (
r, I I 5
•
i I J I.
i
l
.
;
1 : e =Ii .
(
i fセ@
...
r i i!
i
CIJ
I j:
I
I.
a • セ@ I ;
JI ·i
f
•
•
f
t: :i
R-
I
セ@
:
I
toC
•
•
I
.. セ@1 1I a ,- .,セ@ •• '•
a. i.. .. ,. J· e; ;:z ., tI'" ; I ..
i;, Ir
I a
•
B.
1-1
E
•
l'ART IY
ABClfADA)CICAL
D'llf(J)QLOGI IM MISOLI'lBIC
STUDIIS
'Dae V.ol.i'tbio
ot .dritaiD
OOCGP1tiall
1a repruent-4
al.aoilt , ent:iNl.7
'b7 1111NrOUa 11u.1c ••Nblaa••
U.•
l&n4entending
•~'bUabiJlc
1D the aaal.Jaia : ot '1lee•
ocnaiatat
••emlaa•,
clinatom
tiJl)Oloeioal
•um a
...
ot objectivi\7
'be•~
oaa piooe,t4.
tollostna la
iDt.....S
セ@
In ih• 1D'4n-
or
t.h• daia
ot llbat ld.gbt be
iDd!aeUcm
•• ••
to,
u
It;
a GWJDtii:tative reprMematioa
and olerit¥,
Th•
w1 tb • vi•
and nriatiom•
t!ln'
...ninlf\ll inYrPretaU.aa
upon
1a requ1Ncl.
to 11a
aohir,ed.
PlfHM'MPMM
Altw• all.,
\;be
p-ee'teat
cbataole
•1•t••ot
1a tbe laGk ot a at.at.I'd
QPM•
aingl•
Cone
2.
R•~
.,.
U.-.wuall.a
;....
Retaacbe4"uWued
,.
.fur•
artehcti
•Del DOt.tioa
ci.aaitt.catioD
fiYe tunaa~l
One m:lght 41.atUlgllUh
l.
to \&l'idnwtandUJs the V..olithio
ci. ....
ci. ....
tlak•
••tie't'lak8e
to •n.J olaNitiaaUGD.
aaa tlexibil:tt.:,
10 beJ'Obdtht.• bllaio divialcDe
I•
Clark'•
l9J9) bu bND the onl.7aenoue•t,eapt,
.JA 01,JnJaal
'b1liti7 within
ot tu
f\lll
rana• ot
.1:1ritiab aNeml.ag•
セ@
Borde'• oldaif1eat1oa
of '\he *-teriaD
•obi.n.d
~riaa
«.II
ot •• •Nnblage:
divalom
J •nd At,ere aQ.JdJszh.t•J'IU9bl• 4iY1aiom;
Cl.au•
or artet.ct
objeoti••
but Uleir
·won..-
ban
ner
but nm t.b1a ••
vseni,
a 'tti41111>t.ed
to
required,
after
ot nrubUit,i7
(l9Jlta,
lta l.ild.t.ttom
and uabniael
(Bal'dea 195,)•
•nd •lle~U
waal.4
ot ad.arolilba
olaNU'iaaUM
ertet.9'-\JPM
1-lualala
wru•
the •nner
Osll.1--
•
ot
awa 1a
prooNCL
120.
tlM42e •eA raw1:eP!e1Ar9betolm
&sneer
ot the f\mntom
A ~l.age
to idea• •bout o1-uitica\ione
rel9te4
kwl.-la•
of 'the tuaoU•{•
liklNe¥er,
it. •ou.14 ....
DO
•it.a
Brtt.iab
OIi
ot 11ti11Mc1 (....-.uuohe4 ) tlak••
1JI thia
'° oi...U)?
•IC'i»c to m.D4 - JliorOll•r
little
about whiata ._,,,
to .Brit.tab au..i.
-~oaa
ot
llllla•
11D11•n ot •IV •tudt•
s...-.
Sa W.olithio
u,
ta, boa
Th•~-
ot ·~
Mtbcdi
.Arobaeolao.
ot lliorilll•r
(1'5')
patt.eraa ni.w
an tbN17 •114
ot kWleda•
19'a..)J aad l ortere
C1111
be ..
eaaeaiQ •• •oate
rel.9ftDt
•D4 EKperimental
... , elt;laoup • whole~
( ...
セ@
u
wrl-..
1'lae Jll'Neal
Iani .. bJ.7, ..
amdi•
ocaneot.iGDe
there 1a an 11.nanaaUy large
lleHli~o
11u,
Wldoub\edl.1 tbelte •en •• aigDltiean,
iJI セ@
n\ouahec! vs-. and ao a!aou14 fipre
111·~ ••l.Jaia•
end DZwaat. --
ta »oOJ" or
anetact-\7149
retoaahe4
\el.1
1a lllti•
IIIMle111teteaent that our
to ad.114iliDedia\el..J•
OCIQ
tut
artet.ct-tn-
I\ 1a
) ot ~ill
JliorolUha
acm-uiatell\•
••
ot indiYidual
baa 11141-W
セ@
'ftlu
at.11111.ea.
lent m:1111nmwif •94 1:es:1PUI• •tnH•tJee
'Jhe taae of c11Nript1ft
ta qld.M fnJlkq
and it
セ@
anl7
fliia
atlltta\ica
•••tnc that
to •erk
1A o1ilNr •na•
vpea end ... Nblepe
ot &laeolitbto
t.a lbat. abJen1-,1t7
..
-aureMllta
TimallJ'J
.,,.
llarpi-trio
d•••1PUTe
ope4 al"OIID4 the
Seale•" l9"J
wpe.
'\h..
t'NQ111911q
••ta ot
•••-la ...
SUllb セ@
clia\rilNt.iOD
t, •ntqu•
-.4
to at.mple
Roe セ@
... Dl• t.n,eaend
•i.,,
'retsJi••t.'
4nel•
alld 19'81
•••lape
ta Mleolithic
the
aD4 laiato-
.iAfon..t.lGD ••
aDCl t.,pea (••
haw DOt NU
of' -..ah
OUl"T..
uaet\11 oaroli.17
pananera 11u au••
<••I•
ilW•ttpttGD
..._Dile4
b.J ~•t.t.Dg
alld • oarpaa ot •1bodo1.0ai,•l
OolU.w 1'70)•
so tar
all4 taau 1a
t:oo1a an•
ot •--
•tud.rot Ulhio
be OCllll!Pare4
• the
...a,
ia JllrUGlll.r
aml.Ja•
ataU.tia;
ta b-e
ta Br1'8ta.
1'be w1-
Bardea 1~50 et. NCI•J Doh ,re 195'J Roe 1961.,aid 1968) •
Mt.boda
ap\aoeJ
C·
•t.hocla t. .... Olll.y
atat.iattoel
a~
ot Maaolit.hic
uaec1 ill the aftl.y
u lD oa11taeet.
iJI ArohaeolGC7 ta W
to
and
.trohaeol.OQ
121.
MM
1S1DEHMt!f U1\1e IF 921J7Gtr
•Pt\uif
lillall 11rcbaeoloaioel
eeacmottete
,,.
plot.
tlllo-diamialll91
diNn
ot aa1u-a1-1.ona1
thta kind
apeie4 ~'-"
A wide nnp
Bia~ ~•tr
appliati.a
•'-C..
Ill a-.n1.
tbat rill
lblt
atatuUaal
arahaeolosUta
ocapla
a.ta
that••
ta Cluaw
te cU.rta
a
ibe
a a..de
to ard>aeol.opa.l
pertlalal..r atnteo
proaedm •
UIP'B-'ial~e
oil mlliwria\a
aiaplit)
... ...i.pa
tntQl'lllatum.
r... 1bl•
beea
-.a
la w
awilebl••
at the u::pertNntal
loakina tor auitable
withla
lat.at
ae
..
セ@
1~
Olle
ot a lllllber ot -rl.c:$1
A.mlyaia.
1.'hia aak•
at•• セ@
ot llllita into hcallleneo.aa ~.
mmnN-ei weHE\M ,.
s (scu1 •
u> llll»-c11rm1e1 wHr (Ja) (Sbei:ard
thia _,
!b1a Jd.114 ot
-~u-
&laeoli'Ud.o
a ta
Bod9ca 1"6J
ltodll•
abauata
DO ....
sne.t.h 1~,,
in &1-eolitld.o
tb8 lalllbw ot セ@
and Opper PaI.eoU. tbto au--1.ac•
a.a 1,10),
t.rcll
1~
..
••ta arobaeololical
.-paw
am uJ)RiaaDt.l
Boc1MD~,
1961)
aftilabl
ia.
so tar,
•~••
bliw bND ot • lWW
et al 19"J
J--•
19'2, Xrtaaal
or olaaaU'iaaUGll
pai-t:tmi.i-ly
Jkluat.rilln
s.o.1
ill oomaeot10D•ii:11 atu41.M or lithio
s.)
t.ak,
-1,1.-cu. ...
uae4 to a.ta are:
widely
- al~
,an ... -17.
ago.
•tructure
an4 rffNl
1• •peot.lly
lnel.
••lJ-1'1 ot
p-ooe4ilna
•till
aDDOt
Thu
..w. ..
et.ta 1a •till
P"e
alld •
auttatioa,
oonoepta at 'the ...
baa •de
da'8 IA •.JII ta.t ....
1A •""'••
•• witb l&IOb clea~in
ot mlldlJ.mc ni.tioNbip
lbe laip
ta aal.tiwrtate
illtOl'IIIIUGD
••i,..
or
nature (Doaa A
OODNl'lle4 wU.b
••te:ie
a.repe.
ra,,wMPma
2.'be baalo p.na,O>re
Anal191i1, •1
be Cl*Hl-4
tar
tl&• ~iall
••
talloaaa
ot • olaNU'im1olall
by Cl1111ter
1)
!he llllita to b• CUNi t 1ecl (••&• 8Neal>lapa ) •re •ffdpcl
1A a 4at.
aDd the aillilarit1•
betltffn •ll pauibla
pairtl ot unite •N
ooapatecl 1-aea upa11 all their ettributN
(••8• artehot-Q'Pe8)•
A wriety or •thM9ti<»l
ca.ttiobnta
l»n bMD 4ffiae4 to repainUarit.,y be•een llllita ( ... R•nh'Mr and St.ru4 1969) .
•tris,
lb•
ra•t
2)
TM •1.ld.1-ri1i7 co.tt1c1enta an セ@
•trl.x' wbi.ab abCllle tibe ai.aUariV
tD fferJ other \ln1 t.
TM 1118trix •'¥ hn
セ@
1D Tna..,.i.r
,)
be ordered
tut
90
•1-c
the du ...
U1oaU.an ot Ulllta 1Dto IJ"'OUPI•
~)
rar
セ@
out 1.a • '•111:llerii;,J
wd.t With r•pect
prtatecl
-nl1&e or •oh
ldp aiad.larit7
•lUM conde,,..
l.
tia ,Jiel.61 • ralllb olau-
110N p.reciae claNi.ft.oeu ... , • variety ot ~i•l
oluateri.Dc
• .,.been a...i.ope4, ancl an •1Tie4 can apill uailfl • oo.-
p&ter•
11i...
inol\&de:
( 1)
BI!RABC'BICAL
CLtBftRil(G SatJMJB
•i
!
b
(u)
SJJtsl•
A._.p link
11.Dkanal.JaU
enal,1111-
0
Dole1- U.
d
Ooaple-
link
anal19ia
f'lnal,sia
MULTIDIMINSI01'AL
SCI.LINO
<Xher oluaterina
c!ffelope4 1.adel*ldenU7 ot 1:b1a generel.
(Baran 19'<>), Cloae Pl-ar1.ait7
A Sterwt 1969J , aD4 Prinoi»al ec.tDIWlta Allaqaia ( ...
prooeclJNe
'bod1'ot tlaear7, iaol11cla J'aotar >.nalpia
(R~
BodaOll l.970) •
ADeqllia
5)
Th• reaul:ta ot a Cluater AJ»lyaia en• •ud.1'ir1t7 •tnz
•7 be reprr
•et.a ia • aaber セ@ 4ittff'ellt ._,.,
_,
tNquen1iJ.7uae4 are&
1)
c-~
•tno•
UJ ~iaa.l
·2-41aaaioal
.,..,.
111) Yema 41.agn• (•l~ olatue
••~nte4
aD4 encloee4
ri tbiJI bamc1ari•)
(lY)
~(Pber:,gw• ) , abOlfi»c the PIOSr•••tva
1\ailiOll ot Ullita iDto larger oi. ....
!
ot • Clualer Amlye:la Uaen, ta w •• ...-ia.l
!be セ@
io diTtae • gi'ftD IJ'GIIP ot -.1.'9 1Dtio bolaaa..,..
ArohaeolacJ, en
of Palaeoli\bio
euew>J ....
attribla'-8)
( ••
•
wd.1ill) •
ihe
1.'b• 'beaio Ida
セ@
their
o
I• the ocmtext
awt-~·
epplioatiea
••ta ot
セ@
ot
1a the ol.Niticatian
Mi••'
arletao ... 1;J'pea ( tibe
ot U.e PI ua+lN •N obJeoUrli,1
•114 repea.,..
aitillv•
IIMtl Nftllt
lDdiTidlul
wt
wcric ta• betll clireeW
oluateriltg
auita-1•
'-bmq\MII,
ai61 to olaaaiticatiOD
abaw.cl be boa'M 1A al.DcS.
toardll
and wa.rda
"9l•tilla
ta..etta-turc
(Baclloa 19'9,
セ@
wli41 V ot
llb1ab are tohe
1970}• But •n_..1
poillta
u,.
1)
• thocJa ot Clullter Anal,aSa 1A ltaelf
'1D~ta•
arcbllDM ot セ@
•eoloei•l
m terul..
All ~t
1a auppoaMl.7aah1ne4 ia '•• obJectiT-17 oan'rOll.-4 re-pr-.-ente~OD
ot 1:be a.ta, ao that. inter1Nt.t1oll
avaigb\tOJ'lllr4'
(BoilOD 1969) .
HOO•
2)
Qoo4 queU
nau.l ta are IIOt .... ""4 b.J tbe 5r00edure ua.a. ao aada ••
'b1 the ci•liQ'
aD4 •1111ab1l1t7 ot tu iApa\ • t.rtal •
v
.J) Tb.n 1a
DO geDt1nU7 aooeptecl olateri.Da
-'bocL
D1tteren\ •t.bocll
yiN4 tiff'e"Dt
J'NUlta (aN ffOdNA 1~70, •
Baab ba• ita GIID Ull)licit
•UWIPtiam,
aD4 tbeM ... , alwa,a be~
1D alJlde
セ@
BwU!le セ@
Warit.W
... \llll>ttom ebOllt their
\hat the QPel8 (or a\~•)
eleerq Dot the ....
•19
tha\
oiaeq
•
セ@
orclillal
... llllle4
of eqaal aiFlficaDN•
'1laia 1a
•tbocll
ell
t.n
la 1ilM -~
pr•ent
"-olltblo
...
.was-
PftMi».
writer
r.lt
to t.unewto
Pr.-
nmtM
•~
Cll"it1•11¥•
ta.,•
WCllll4'be a uaetul
me4 tor a ..., appwoh
•-'•
tor •rameoloeioll
- la •11¥ wen, taa.7 ahclal4 be n•rded
~•
.bav• hith...-0
l)l"GSreM
1Mol"'1
Jiwertbel_.,
JlriUQ
cml7.ua,l•
W ak•
an
••lu OQIIPlt«rUled
llbat
セ@
ooaplter
_..,t.iA:lm
•re
natrieUTe
lt• ....
-~
c»'-,
DOllplWI'
••1-Yaia ot
cmnribuUaa.
lJI •1•
prabl.-.
The
ot
tolloltiJla
t
aeoUaa •rk:a
......,...
1, 1a
tbe tuwt.
atNl7 aD
aperlalll,,
aWlll.7 ot Ua ld.114 1a lleaol.1~
•114 セ@
mtboaa
•n4 naulte
Araba.alagJ
an
oritioal.ly
lau\
15
4 'PR1tORNW:DJSer12YPSitJMQM8PN:6fP
PP: PtTA
'?he idae bebind
tb1II snal191a
to,.- • taXOIIDllio 41.villiOII of
...
c... ..,i.g.-tnea)
t'.-
(•••
euab fill an.~ia
Clan.
taund
OD
( 19,-,
w, ._,.
ta
DO
Mon taportan,
DA!A.Sft1
age...nt
._n
PP3,5I
I 19
iibia,
•to•
It•••
•t
1a takea
._..
pcuOle
taa,18Mllt
SON worknw
ea to~
ld.arol.11ihio
pert-'
~.
tne-
'there
セ@
1lbe broe4
h8w det1Dec1aub-ca,ep-i•;
or det'ini'U.Olla•
1a 11:Mlt aubJ-ive;
aJ\Y t,prlia't
altlaough
XICROLI'DllC •••amblagea (••e 11.at 1)
.,,rppuw,t.he percentap
categori ..
ot
t.t•
Wic1el.¥
eppl.s..4-
been
th••
tor ibe Britiab
type-liat
b.ia olaaaitiaa
of' •crolltt.to
bur1m
punl
atanard
DO
aD4
tOIUl4 1D
1!aia 1 1baQp uaet1&1.,i• far fNa,
ta 110 at,.nderd obaeit'toatum
of aori!pers,
or a11 edequate
or artet.otrtypa
lSJ9 ) pnaen'-4
,ai'9a•
Britt.ah
ia
F.a41.e.,1'68) J am f.t baa nner
m"tegoriea
0114 to
', be diaocwerec!
OOllld b•t
ia the ew1labU1t7
tJnfoz-'W. 'WJ' there
•Neml,lapa.
Kaaoli tbio.
•••NblageaJ
Jfaaolithic
cwaaaitim tioa aA4 aaotatiOD
widel.ruaed
tu baaia
adDe quanti'tatiYel.7
lllto • OCllplt.r.
w
Crucu.l
'to ..
'tbe Britiah
dete!'llllne 11ti.lhar !JM!uatriM
by t"4tlls
••
( table
to at~
troa ex<1awticm re~·
ot tool.a 1D -·
ot 20 tJpe-liat
I, Ap}*l41x 2) •
actual
••eal>laa.. J
hen
d1aoO'ftl'94 1llbioh 1-4 been cl.Meit1e4
ao,
セ@
ocmequnt~
19 .taroli\hia
•ooor41Acto CJ..rk'•
.u
the cltta
... eabl.apa
aiarolitld.o
12.5.
o1-uitiaetioa,
t.be writ.er wow.4 m'Tt pnterred
altboup
~r
uapl.ea
to aM114 oerleill
fclwad. neoeaHry
(J5 -
IIIIIHr ot lliarolitba
and 11biob i.a • 're~erdil!t1••'
ot at 1... , ,0).
uoavatonl'
It ..
DOteti.OD Clll the baaia
or \heir llluatrau.aaa.
Ral:B'
DA?ASIT2
'TO'?AL'
auNJbla1•
1J
(•M lui
1:,va,,..z
2)
tn-
tbe pero.me&• · ot 9 retouobecl ,..,i...,t
(•aroU.tbic
aDd tolel
mioro11tba) (•M table II, Appendix 2).
;pouible ·~ ttnd lJ aua:ab~g•
It••~
or ver., genenl
tie.S; and than ODl)t 1A napeot
vaa,se,Th• .. M
DJ.TASff'
Uk»vw :
illpl.___.
whioh had 'been ad.a:iuatsl.7 claui-
arlahct
cotegorua.
lJ aaaub1-g ...
ot 8 Ntouohe4 •crolitbic
the pecentagae
a.tegoriM
Uat III,
( ...
Appendix 2)
TflJSJHILA,RJTI
OOlfl,ICIE!flB
l)
iTMe.r..oo-ebaence coettioient
2)
~idecn
J)
Rank order di.a'8noe
-
t-.a.ncUoo -
cla~ncs
( et. Cla:rite 1~62;
(at, Donn & Bodaan 1366}
tunaciQJl
(tor •ob uaeamlage \b• percenteg .. . ot •ah
tJPe •ere given
2, , eta - aA4 the
... eablapa ,._.. ocm;ar-4 on Mle beaia ot tb•e
order
the approprt.."9 ndt
Ol"der 't'al.Q - l,
•1u .. ) .
1, ••
boped tbet
• aore •cou.nte
appniaa
the uaa ot
J 4U'tertnt
l of t.be wlidit.¥
ooefficient;a
end pnotiao'bilit1
"*
would taoilit.M
ot
the -~
WHtde
Ill all , aaparet.
ot •ah
1a tnoludecl
progre•
wen uecle
aa AppendiX ,.
A prl.Dt-Ollt
troll tu . ftllal
run
LIS%1
19J1m1Jt,bic «'!•eettlese(rip.
1)
セ@
セ@
BDDING lotl> ( &ent J
liPIGHAK( Yorkae)
OOLQ VALLJ:'J·(Baa•)
il
10
11
12
1'
J4
15
1'
17
l8
19
DDfOAR (Yoru )
DOltNTOB( Wilt&. )
DOZIIIARSl:'OOL ( CoZ'DlaU)
pMU'ffl,\K
(SUrNy )
IPiliG CQOPi (S11U8J
D !RNBMD6'llR (ltU .ta)
NABHIAD (P..._)
0.flL'V'NCIR(Ranta. )
PIACIIIAVIN (suaaa)
~OD'S
F ABK(O.mbe•)
PRJS'lAffN , Unta. J
1
SJLMIS'l'Oli Sauex)
STAR CABR lorka• )
1'HAT® l! (Berka• )
TOGHIIL ( c.late)
WAROOOC
JQrnt (Yorbe )
ws;a
BRIGIWI
!Yark••)
ISlfCAJl 'lorka• (
D<lfM'ON WU•• (
PAINEAX Surrq ,
r RJS.. ATIR 11ST {Puma.)
IPllfG CXIDPT(Sua•ax)
,HDIG
lltm!BR (1111.ta)
(Banta. )
~CJRAVJN (SuaaGJ
STJ.B CAB ( ICll"U)
amwma
1'f1'1fflWI (Berka,
TOGJlt1L ( aloe.)
WAR<XU r«:Rft ( 'loib•
)
12. lJ •114 14)
127.
I.
!h1a prcsraa ••
DeP'• ot
inst••tirat
セ@
•ab
:e.,.1.aa,Shett1.i4)
'l'be nnlt
1a
aalalllet.4,
l Nlaret.
'b7
141-.D.AJ"19 (~ute,
ill 1971, 1D m.. l.900 ••rue
ell4 tbeD pri.DW
&ataN'I
wntua
•••
'POlmlAB IY
ror
ot aill:l.1-rit.J ooettt.cienta
out tbeae Yalaee 1a •1111.larlV •trtoea.
tor •at& or J a.taae1a ( ...
•triaea
prta-
ca&t1)
Pw+-PI11SU9ML
§GeHffli
P\MTt• lp>:
II•
セ@ ......
1 (Bell TelepM)lle Laban\orua,
la A.S.A. PCRTJWilIV•
Aa:1 ••
a1t,7 ICL 1"'1 .-.pater
Sbeffi.eld
lj71)
Jfilrn7 Hlll,
Sbettiel.d
セッ@
t.eobaiqu•
dnia-4
All l
JWN7 - 196,)
...
O·L•ela
(Dept. ot PaJabolau,
2)
m. WP689WWca.mmgqJSPSDp:
ot PaJ'Dbol.oa,~ttieldJ
tbia ••
wn\ten
'b7
c.r...ab
aDI!s.Saltb lDept. or liil••gwnt
b7 s.Jablllaoa. (• ..
Jcu»OD
GIi
Ille Sbettiel4
flle7 uael
セ@
re9ul.'9
1$'67: 24,l-~
UDiT..
(Dept.
StwU•,
- 1~70) MAICL 1900 .. riea r.LGOL.
PJ'OCI••
._.. 1'1111
.r...
1»7 llr•
tor Ille oa tbe Sheffl.elc1 UlllTer-
actlpkct
lt7 S.Slll1ib •n4
(• .. pn.n-wt
wri.._
'1b1a ••
•
,>
(prin~Gllt
i\7 ICS. 1,07 ooapater
(1'7lJ•
THJl&kleli
lt -·
lll~W
Cluater Anal,aia
et.ta .. ,, i.a.a
a
1)
~·
•
dlttN'ellt
Ill tb• tint
• OQIIPleu ••'
•s1-,• (l,d.Dt-wt
the"-'•
tu.
1
1' z 19 (AM-1ta&•
~clidean
N
l"UII OD
both
(J fell' •Clb
cliat.noe
alld
•--•l
ot renlta.
•tricea
were P"N
1).
1... A) DfteU\
(IJ
In
9 IIDorderN aiad.1-rity
pl.•
abaa)d
d.1.ata11ee t\&lloUomJ abaald oe nm wt.ai ltotla tibe
CluateriJlc PK..-••
did aot eU.
fl"aa 'Smt•
j \MIClrdere4 atrieea
That 1a that
and Bienrah.laal
ilftDl-
.u
-~
19, f3PN 2C)
•trl.Jt
11S111111tc
f
a•
I II セ@
It I
セ@
,~~Jli
a. r
Jf
'i
,!..
,.,i. "'=
!.i ...
I t E: f . ....'
N
:,
:,,..
p
-1,~;
( .. f •
,•t;;e
f
I
i .
,, t
-
1
.
セ@
! •
I
II
,•j.f·~
i
.t
f
f
s
i11,:1
· • •
セ@ セ@
i セ@
セ@ i
I
f.
i
r
t
: i i t
'i
I {
i セ@ i i
I
セ@
j
1.
Ii
i セ@ I I i
f
I
.s:: ,.
- i {
f
f
セ@
°"
I セ@
I... I
'
セ@
M
51 Ii'
f
f
!• ;
セ@
l
セ@-
i
li =,. 1f I,I
セ@ f
セ@ i
i
g
i セ@ti セ@• rt §.. i· •; ; l 1
&; i
• t!'
f' ,_.
, :r
セ@ セ@ i . ?' ?. I I • a
,. £ 2 i
i :i
f
• t
0
UI
:
l
;
セ@
! I . '1l
I
0
Q_
セ@
fr
'1
0
i ? .I
! i 2!
:,f'l
_,
i'=''
l • l ! f r
セ@ f i r i • I I セ@ ,
' : II i• I i J . f I i
I
セ@
-!... -r: •• e-= s:
...セ@
..( , I ' i l l
r·
=
,
i: i;:
!(-'~Ji
1. · 1 1 ' i! £;·'i セ@ f a. i f E ,.. : l I ' l
I
i
l
i ! ii セ@ t I
f I! t i r I i !
I ! a. I l i J f i : J i
a•i;J
,~ E
I ' "
セ@
t:
t:
llC
..
t:
t:
i
i
セ@
セ@
l
I.
..
i
セ@
! r
r
I
I
1 !
•
"'
t:
1
e
,-...
I
iI
aI
f !
t:
\0
F
la Ol'lldelJ
U.1118
•illlFle
to oo.pen
deHriptiv•
1111eot
....
• fll11
ott•
• pGINlibl.e .....
aal.U.-Mmaai.Ollll
Here the .naulte
pro1,1 ..
1.
wlU be
セ@
ot
or Oluater-
O"t ccai.arl.DC lol"I• D:lllbere ot a•elll>la1•
a1J11l,Jaa of 'Meraol!.ihic aaaed:>l.agea, ana •oaie
cu..... .a..
po115U»l..
1.atoawttaa
_.iiW,Wn._
it 1a •
a-ers-l,
•'-tiJitic:al
pawftll.
111 セ@
N oon:-'
.Ill
Clwater .ADalJ111aen
e1M·ILl)tioa
infarmstian
but 1 ...
to •k•
..-.
one
will
pc,we:rt\&1
•t.tat.iaul
aa
.it•,
data, P.-nd one can
i.Dp&t
t.oolaJ ba:t cmo u
'.rhe t ....
well
'the mare aaawiq,1;1.0IJII ex»
trca tbo
wUl l>e obt.tn.d
tbN• ••MIP1ii.olae
A)
Teabn:lqUM
PZ'U?
ti .....
illiU.l
1A cl.aai:!"1otion.
and •lao to
•••
With e,q atat!attoa:.
.,...
••embl.aeatoa•tbni,
t•
than •
nnc• or data
ill the i-•t
it bia Pt'(J't'e4 4U'fiault
at.tietica
~ivel.7
A•lJaia
•iaa
b7 Leeab •114
(1970)•
Sllltb
•k•
baa••cltY1M4
• ... 11\11."eol aillUariV
d4
to ...
l~
.1-_..,th•
_..
be obteinecla
tool.a, and involn
r. ••• ...the
_..
•k• ••
ot
• lllat.lte
li.kel7 -.
.All tana
1n
ta to
of
• ,...,.,.
ot
wU,b 11.a
Olm
... umpttom.
Iii ftftfflif
1he Jl:8 •-lpia
auunq,tloau
ilnolYM
2 atatilstu,al
, •eh
proc .....
_
1)
2)
1)
wbat date
Jie •"-'
diatana&" •t.)
~.
tbe -•ure
1
the Mll3セ@
a.N ar4i.Del (or ra•
ot a111tiaUa.l
u
tDDJu-4
aiat.lariti.111
( ~IIIB)
(Pn11tn0.-.lalltnoe•
wUl ~1-..,e nk•
Baa:ariar
idantioel
1
JIIOJ14••
-uapU.cmaJ
arier) aulllll",laaa abaut 1ibe date end an atlllwl.
lJO.
n.t
ta, to,: •ah
tba1. ta all
or datanaee
peir
1:Ut. cen be said Pbcut itJ
tude ot the cU.tterence.
if' one le lerger -than the other,
put in,
Por a:Niple;
notbiJl.i aen be a.aid 8bout 1be ag:nt-
if
II
diatanoe
of 20 ond a 41.atanoe ot
10 an pu1i ilno \he ... 1,-1- -
10
20
;be el19l)'aia will
- eU
7hua the actual
cllt.e.
lnput
l.D
~.
other
prooecau-e
.11Dke8a ram order
Mll,
t.tw. a.anae, it lil • Ye.r7 p.r:rul
whioh in&k• w17 f•
2)
11uun;,ticna,
••r•aptiom
the first
セ@
'l'b1a nU
anat
ot 10.
•• • dat.ooe
iuwlve4
Type A
-.
teabld.qu
ere tboae involYecl
ea••• l aaperah
a !UCLIDIAN dilltanoe
i'here wUl 'be airoumltenoea iJI wbiob -.oh
s1»a
21'
"'
Siif l
§1\f 2
セ@
セ@
•.
ibe
tmt • diataooe o~ ( ••1•) 20 ·la 2s ••
§1511
(1)
sr-t.
very poa,ffful rea\11.ta.
Ill tbe pnaent
dataoet
aNW18
ia 2z ••
•••umptioD abcut
••lJaie
(ar ~•--)•
tor •eh
t1ml,-ia
lt
at.tietiaal
-nd cou.1..1!
give
•cle by the ~te
la oel.aaleUJag aild.larU,S..
•)
20 ia ) 10, not th.t
aay 1a that
,
la arableo.lagiaal
セ@
4ifterent
llllbt
f'rca セ@
an"
ten8
·t.be aite with ~ ;
aite with-..
Ye¥
clittertlllt
ot tn,t
ot
tne
.A.
lli&ht be ftt'I
Ai whene• tbe ath
frma the aite with
50,~
with
NA••l.Jata
lJl.
11111Jag
a Euolldean
'*h••pab11
be~
bolb
tan
BI••••hat
•1
~ . TIie aeeorod .-qaia
be • Yer, oruoial
ot
a.ta.et.
•Gb
tat
Ule cliataDOe
?be amlJllta
ihlll'e-
dittareme•
ilffol.y.S a PRISINCI-.AIBDCZ 4iat.DN
ure
iznolw4
ot oertaia typaa
the aere Pl'.'N._
......
ot attee U i4ent.ta.l..
'?be ••Wllftiom
hDD'iaDe
•ill
tunoU•
diat.llN
It. 1a mt ODlT
are clbYi....
ta iJl&,Orten', but alao b
t.i»t
qunU ttea ill wbiab they OCIOUr•
•)
ot •oh
Tbe 1ibll'd ••l.yata
111 JIB lbeor7, it
1-.
aU "-'
aNt• rs GIily
ODIi
41.atame 1a greater
about tt.
oan 'be uid
1:h.ta•
Sud.l.rl..Y
'l'heontiGaUy,
the B&ol.14-A 41- 'laDOe f\lllnicn,
the 1.ntonatioa
Camia.r
contaiMd
tbta
W>
(2)
\n,e B
0
(1)
,.
セ@
t~
liallk orde:t-d1•t.ance
).
Therefore
ata•••~ioa)
arueul
lAtoraU.
~·
At bct.h att.a
a....,tiallll
tma
ot
LO.Val&&e
(2)
(l)
1. A • 2 {nllidac tna
B ia prea.ni
ill the ...
u .. t
doee DQt. pie'k up wbl t •1
i..,
•-•·
be • oruotal
•, aite 1.
1Jatbta oaaple
it ia
(end thf) oon•pcmcltng
t;o weip
WHUr:J
!hat,
ta,
c109I tt
•ttv
up llblt
it' ..
one ff¥r the a.olic191i
•re
goilll
lGM セ@
to be._
•~
ot
?
Therefore• it ie wortblrhil• to
tiff_....
1...
t.r
SU. g
.,,
B.
M the bnk Order ~riND
4itf•rence
ta
111 the -...b6re.
1
\)'pe A
to ~-,
'&bat
at the ooet ot the loM ot ._.
but
LO.Value
ti
tban dO'iber,
the remc GN1er t\&nat.iOII
•k•
*1a
セ@
.uaanoe
ePllll)le ,
,, '"'
nitih
セ@
d91a .. , iDvolTed • iwtt
•nal.18•
•IV' a.t.
clia1ienoe t"m1ot1oDI,'CO diJIOOW"er
tf e:lmlar
•OD01"41111
to • ....,..
reaulta
are obi.iJlecl.
of
lj2.
It ao, '11• arael,1Ma m,J be oonai4ere4
DOI Obiieilled セ@
'° weip
•itih
the arch..,.eolosl~l
i
<litter iJa eom ~nt
t~que
at.tiatietl
it •k•,
aad ...
1.t tbea• aaumptiom
then the C011-pondi.Dg
1."\llv:Uon
•tab
Ul>l,1...
1a
Ill)
they
it
41-t.noe
In other worm, U' 1ib• ••nmpiioa
titw~ tne diat.nc•
ua.a, GIiie ua
1a
It they ,o not m1toh (i ...
••\IJl'l,IltiODII•
napeot)
abould not be uaede
セ@
•hf.te'rer
up the •••umpticma
1"99111• are
I..t audlar
to look 111__.. cle~U •t the lapli•tiOIII
it la neca••r:,
ot tbe vartc,ua aM\WPtiODI•
utlatectoq.
tmaoUoa
ill •rabaeoloaiaal
ot c:Wdoua wl.141i1,
U1en -.
al:'.ialld HOi .we thll t di.a t.ance t\aaottc;ia.
All tna
lmalrins
brinp
11hi, t aaSU,I\Jtiomt
the7 &ive all
•9tuli~l•
out a11eget.ieml point.
the E-~pl~tioD
aw daili (1 ...
puo•,
.P"ri-
'WCl!'kve,tena
~·
Cl•rl7
methoda requine
at to pot.at to oertiaia
tbe Clater
.Aaa.l,...
Mn~
or 'buri.M•
• ip:l.tioei
nc..
1apc1rua, ta
Por ..
tba'\
llh_...•,iJI
u l°'
and
hen
ot
._,..,i.
aD4 tllaae
1J1
1...
with
セ@
bac! mob 11"911
tM,1 •Y well. •••
re-ahe~
'.rr.DObet ax•
oca.paN4 •7,
aktll wou.14be Ul901Ye4 ta •kins
"'_.. r.diq
aa •• ta.a
OD 1be olber ~lld,
,u.w -..
ot
•re ot equal aipitt-
-et•, X.olitbic
ear... -i..ce,
let ea.._•lly
.... pralaa'bl.7
c11ecarded after
'•eicb'!Jr&'-'I
4-orl'l*S
tb&t
More tial
• IMll"aper, and ax•
tbi*
aaaumptiODI lllpl.ici•
,o-UM1111uv1au.1 tn-
lb1a ia aut tbe _...
•-" nrel,J •uriaall¥
atrtiJltialt
ot
or t,Jpaa).
quentitiell
Ia \be til9t
W31J>e
the iJllpn'ta.,.
Rnd lJ& a atre:lc;ht.!"orwal"\, •Y•
of atati,.tia:,l
.m ..
s_, ia
:)eJ'Oll4 'Wa,
Jlr...et peoplt.
ar e D•de•
the amr1ere abply
It. Ml,iQNia..a
1tlua tb• セ@
aarepae
QV,IIIUoll
lie oona1.dere4. and will lnffitllbl.Y tnolft
.r
orwpl•ili.-
alld
aubjecrliY--••
Alao• • a9l"OY11lw • tor o~i.ll
\JPN
due
'° the taat 1ibat •
11)
ltmmMM\ Qlwter1r 4RPlJl31
'Dala aDa'l,aia
parti~r
al'teapfa
ar-i>
la aa anel,aia are aot aeo•••rilJ
414 not •ma~oture
to 4ia00Yfl' whether the 4-t.
1hOM
tn-•
oan be aOOOlllltecl
l
' 'I
. c;
.g..
0
"
r
セ@
9 ,._ セ@
I?> セ@
1)
II 11.f-IS ll,
Diameter
l°l
IC.,
It C.
10
4- f
1q
!llet hod
'STRESS' = 316
+
I
! '
I
l
I
r r
2)
,/
'
Fi , ·ure
12 :
Connectedness
Computed hicrarcJdcal
of
19 111icrolil.hic
..llist ance function)
method
solution
.:u::Gemhlnces
.
1
for
the ~na lycis
(Presence··
- · absence
tor
:I.a tua
or aome acrt ot hien~.
•re :lDYolved. Nab Yr.ltb S...icit
•thoda
iat.ioel
l)
'!he =-•ure
2)
'rhe aotual
1)
The wriaua
Jwn
elrsq
2)
11M anaqaa
... Ulfi'tialaa,
•~tati•l
hienrdlicol
sneilJBia
clitt11NDt 4iataaoe
in •iltg
eMUIIP1.toal inYol•ed
t\mcilom
been cliaeu11ae4.
it.ae~t can
wricus
US•
moth•
,,t oluste~
(a!n8,le lt.llk,
4.;
ot
tbeae sae~11ona
~nealih 196.H liooaoa 1970); bu.t
Mt
ot data (~1;p11e9
Dae caaneateGZ»N !!ethod
b)
~e
Dieaeter
:,,._.. 1D
acirae
in
lllllllllUZoins
au1 table
or (UJ
It
pero.nta~•
( ...
-they en
th8
conmDU
the ~gram
di.tferer.t
1a ordffe
8N
2 •clutt ..
produo•
the dob
t. e, thff'e
or •OC\11'901'
duff to leok
plaoe,
ta
hee not bNII
dt-'tlt, but the pro~m
tor !Jlllt&nce,
oaa be
·':hen eitberi
the trtrJ,
iii
in the tirllt
l'OC0\.11\~d
probl.am iJI ill a .....
aowuanareq11ire •'Git»
or b7
ror by
• hiera~;
IIOt
uaiJlg •
,~Jid the:ratore
aor.iei kind of 11:6 alllll:,a!JI.
iD& •bethe:r tb• 2 aalu.tiana
D&Lrwrio"l expre••ion or theu-
{1970) n.ve
the •au.ea
general
セ@
f\lnc 'tion
there 1a e DN4 to perlo.ra
'be aallecl
1a eG1NWhat0Gllplia.1.e4
then t1e m,n e1i1 thrt
1t propel•ly;
diatane.
1'*7• i...a1a end ~llitb
r..
r.r;JX.1.Dt
at srror
large
Die ckte oamot be
'lh• •U
ot
JlethoJ
1 hien.l.'Cl\}· in
acme 1 1"8111
able to rff9l
I
11::atris),
a)
aoooam1.iid f'or b;; • hiC"Jroby•
( t)
Bowrnr, .a eppnu,al
wbiab iJI taot are qu.ite ldAial.
If tbea• , a.i..luw.oza are •i.J:c:ihr,
•1
auwnpU.011u
ot du tanoe ~tam
•i&Di,fimaoe
~or •eh
Dae 2
2 •••
lJJak eic) • and eucb of these inv ilYf'II • ~tffe1•,mt eet ot (cr.ttml)
everap
Sokal
••l.Jltia,
lilce tibe O
ADd,
aevieed
e\Mltl •
•l•' •• wlMI aa &
r• sria.l
•olut.iaa.
are ab4lar.
degree ot aildlazexp1
na1eft 1 セ@
,
'Conn-'-4.,..•'
•nd 'Du•ter•
p,"()81'9-,
and •
•noe atriola
ted int o the
aoluUom
alao oalau.l.atecl ( ...
••
wl.ue auttioienU.7
beat ti,
The
•• to
l•
OJRSHII (n.taaet
1 (ti)).
12.
•tnx
For •• illpat
auttioi~
1t7j WGQl4 'be < 100.
•uae•t
tor •ah
wlue•
In
DO OM
ibat the 2 •olutiom
'•tnu
vel11e 1 )
ot
peir
oaae _.
thia
were aiad.lar.
obt.tDecl ·tor \be
••
The reaalturc cleDdrqp,aa are ahOlllll 111 ttgure
ot 1.bu
'•treaa
l.Glt
•atreu
Jrtntl-au\ ,).
(lGa•I
aol.111\iall
wre obtaiMd tor •11 9 &11-
aol.u\iom
wlue'
Ia
•ta•(19 x 19)
(aor1•palkl1wc
tan
to•
'•tnaa' ill
the
Leaoh OODai&tra tbet •
,ooaw•ure
ot aiadlaz-
tbia oa•• 1a }16.
19 r19E9HIlls •MrtkW
N!tlDJN
29 PPM
Pel•
fntMPrtW:W
'•"tnlla••lue'
'lb•
aoluUam
wlu.•'
-.
(ft&.12),
or }16 ta aot • pod walll"e
but it
-uer
ta 'ft17 ·atpfteaaU.,
ao the aoll.tltoa elmaat oer'-ilaly
Holl.._.,
aoae a!Jdlaril,1
セ@
ot
••embla&•
are
ao..
DOt reir-en
oan be obeftff4
be..._
by both (
~·l"ft4
bathe
.tor th!a Mt
tor the ot.lier 41.atenoe t'llncRian OQIIPriNm
tor
ot atld1-r1t7
tbe 2
•au.a
.r a.t..
• b1 ... ~.
l
the 2 a.n4rogre•I
tsa.12) •
c)
In
•i.. of
ihen
.....
that tiw, illp&t
the tact
11iu.
&i ta
oannosbe aooOllme4 tor 'b7 •
po11a, 1a p-o1onc1,ng • cliaouu10A
oomia.riJls
OG1Wentiollltl
..
aurprsa..
The
aitea
セ@
iA
cl.1U&io t.xCIIGlllr,
A ,re
セ@
ot tihea• Naul•·
Bt&t
A end C a.uae DO
OOUY.att1.0D9U.,chllnoteraecl
·illdua'\17, aD4 tboa• 1D Sl'Gllp c by • lltal, ...
bitnrchy
ua 1Dduafir7•
b,1 • Borei.a
Table l (Appendix
a
-
~Irr;... ~"
:a_
,5 1 I
; i
1
·. •セ@
1
'!r
i::e·
.·
•t1
r セ@ ,. i f t
,
セ@
J
セ@
a 5 I =f I iI
1 I ...
• t: l ! f. ;
r i I f •
l,f
I
fJ
•
C'
,. .i V q;
O '.1 ~f
i.
' I•
'f~
ffJ;1]
セ@ r
• i I
i セ@ "'
:· 1 t ~' ! ..
&
a
5 I l 1·i
:
5I i
! I t
'ii
'
"
..
fi
...
l!
..
'
•
i
a.
i ·'· ;!
i:I !• f!
•
"'
0
"
\,e
I! I
t:
-1
I
f
:
I f .... f
I
I •
{
f
g
ti
r
I ~
5 r
l, =
t ! ! ' i!
& ._ a '=
...
•
i i
Ii'•
f ' f ! セ@
I Ii ; I J;
. - i ... セ@
! • i
1 '
I
'-
IS'
I i セ@ I I
a• I. I."
·
r
セ@ t ; t
Ii
I
m
セ@
'-
I
p
:
•セ@
•セ@
i.
,
セ@
t
セ@
f rt-
r
a . ,,
s
1r
.i
セ@ セ@
t!f~
1 ..
a 1r
• i
セ@
, .. ;- f
e
I r if :r "'• a
" 'I セ@ ! ... Ii 'fI s I
J ' fI "J ii ;f f1 i' I gf i.
• r i 8 : •
• セ@
I
ff
! I::
•
Iセ@ i
I . r
f =I· •r •I
1 - , ;
.
;
'!II
J...f !
! !
I I a:, セ@•, r :;;lI rt
I -' r.
r
i! f
•
: , ,
•
•
セ@
f •
ff
t
セ@
• 4'
:i
,
.
1
rt#
r Jセ@ i: ! {f~1· ;
&lo ....
i
J 1,
r;
•
.
t'o
I
,;
.+
• -·
I ;;!
.,.
- s.
1·
I
セ@
D"
1
i. 1
,
t,,t
3
I ' @セ
o
l., ·
ff
I
...
;
•
セ@
I-
i
s.
;
"
セ@セ@
I
f
,
1 I
1.セ@f' i• -セ@
"O
,-
IP
t
I
,:
Il !
1ii1,
11
8
セ@ a
! { セ@ l I
11! ,! ;
i•
I
!·:a.:;le!.losian
' ...~u \rotcrri.:
: 0 . 045
0
u.i'
0
0
Horshn'1.·
0
.,
•
II.
0
l't
'•
0'
38
13
I ,s
0
- - ____ __ Q J セ@ --- - - ----セ@
I
•
2
'$ Oq O I 0 5
Ill.
..e•"'
I
I 0 11
II
0
- . - -··o· ©
セ@
•e
11
e
q
,, ~ 3
I ,s
00
_____ _____ ....8__ "___ _1 0________ _ ____ ____ ©
.
""• ·
9
2
I
0s
.,
o,
• '~
0
I(
•
S'01t2 I
0
0,3
I
. "•Oq
~,e,c
------...---- ------- - - - --
IO
I
I
"o
0 17 12.
.
p
o'
,}
i&
·- ----
7'9"-
o,~
I
•...
0
....
I
o,o
Co· _;.;t,:?d 3 - :i1::cns ional
( ~ucl~.ean
co:ifi_:;ur~tio!l
l ist ~~c c fu nc tion)
-.-·
.
of
19 :.,i c ::o:!..it:li c as::.e1:1blaces
io 0
I
1
0
f'f
@
I
0
l-
0
1.
07
©
IS
I)
0
I
f.
�
8
_____________________________ o __
__________________ o __--�
Q
',
"o
17
03
oq
e"
o"
..
5
0
1$
,q
0
'STRESS' = 0.102
Figure 14: Computed 2-Dimensional configuration of 19 microlithic
assemblages (Euclidean distance function).
r
l...
.
il
l
fi
セ@, 5
,
t •;: r r1 I... セ@; ', ;°' I.,
...
I i ; i J セ@ t ; i • , •
I ; ,I i : 1'; .. •
セ@
p
I
•
i
f :
fr.
セ@ t ' i '
I ..
ll: •
;
i
•
.
r1 l
t
·
..
..
t
If
t
I •
:a
s. i a. r
t : セ@ i - I (
a i ( ; I f I @セ t I f
f' ,I I ;,f i '1II t i' 1l @セrr
i i I セ@ l i ! セ@ ! ! I
J...if ' i f I• It •f "• セ@ . ,.s: '•
I
II
.. • •
1·' t
' I l
i
!
,f... • セ@
:
J
'
:
I-
セ@
セ@
,
; ; ! JI i I f i : l i I &I
f• ;• ii
0.
i.
I
ff
l
;i JI af ffr ..I i ...i jfi.
r°' .セ@; セ@ 'lI l~;f !セ@
セ@
1·
I~
I
s: :
f
1
. l • •tJ
'I
Ii f I
.. It i
I
セ@
:
•
t
I__
; @セ; I.
A
...
II I:
..,
J
! I
...1!
! r : I
l
'S.f;"
I
•
I ;
rt1f•
= セ@ セ@ t
:fl'tf
I •
.
, = セ@ ' a
.,.. I
-..
l 2ill
·セ@'. .II f I ri rtI
f'-'
"'• ... セ@
.. ,.z,l
I
..
rC' t; ,- ;'
!
セ@
t
tl
セ@
セ@
1· Iセ@
I ..
I
-•
•
I
I
1, :
i .. f
'
.
&
Ei
• I:::: ... ,
1
i i
f ..,.
I~
1· ,,_
•f
,1
! "
f f
I
•
D
...
IL f •
セ@
•
l i
!!,
I
I .. \
C
I
f
I
f
I
'
•
f r r 1. f セ@
i ) : t .f f.; [ : I 'U
; , , =i f セ@t f 1' If !
i i
l ..
..
ff セ@セ@ .f t セ@f c-セ@ 'I
, f
i;
I
-
a·
w
£.
I '~
セ@
!?,
f!i:' i'! PI!!
i1
i r!セ@ f JI !J
f Ii !If ,;: u
!i i;
f .!,.~
., !1 I=
s::
l fI
.
!• I di
I
.e
Ii It
f
,If セ@
f
E
'f ,
I
It.
I
P
f
! I f I J I セ@
...J !! !,; セ@
1] i f'
a 5 l
R. ;
:
0
II
;-
i · I, I' r! ,r セ@• ·I i' .iI セ@ • ...l ie:
E .. li';
t}l l: LlJ;. ,·
f
·,::
..
.. ..
1
セ@ r r .i •
:I
lif!it:
1 ..
!!Ii 1·z i ... 1 1i , r 1I i f
セ@ 1 セ@ .. f " r
,;
I • ! ,J • I ii
f
;> - · t i
•
.. ' .
t セ@
•·a II
• • '.,"i- rセ@ セ@ a •.'iis: i;ff . i .; ,I i C" '1'
rI s
i 1 -:t l I i f i i~.f i=f •fif i;!f "I I. It fI lI I: !t '!I セ@•
" ! l. l I -• I f ~:
((;c
Ii fi
!iii' r, l. 1' ·tl1
1{
I.
~f i .i t 1 i( sf
f '
f f
qi .,I .. ·,=
(.
..セ@ , =- fc 'i g~
@
セ
'
f
..
セ@
J,..
le"
:.
I . -··,
セ@ i セ@
ft 1 t
.. ...
,ii a::"1
1'
;1.1
f• f
,
I
1
·
t
·•
l
!.
セ@
f
ii:,'
;
I
1!
2
, ft
s; '•
f•
.If
i
C
セ@
C
f
•
rt
I
I
セ@
I
'i1Ii' f
i
I...
..
Qi
1
:"
I.: . r
l
I
セ@
0
-~
{i
..
f;
141.
Com1derin& tigura lJ • it ia pcuible
be'-••
idle •'9oiD& ot a11iea ill ••
to IBk•
41.,..,.ioD,
セ@
WI 4 Cs,)
セ@
ll
a,.s
ao.s
netmnaez,
v•
llUC
Oil
,.u..,
Sle,.4,
Co1ne
1lt,.9
73-7
72.9
~toba•
Deepaa~
1....-
16)
2)
..
Doa-re
Star O.rr
ter
P11o1.
70.2
,o.,
56.9
,,.,
52.0
5'.o
Briaba•
'1.S
P•oebaftll
foe JIUl
s.i..too
5 · Dontca
Fanabaa
1
セ@
t)
10)
4,0.9,
1)
u~
15
• hl'Wl
Waroook 1lor1ill
4,1..2
!N:M.n& Wood
KabB•4
17.1
s•r
BMc1:1J1s
Wood
'•
lfana
S.,._tiOII
P•oet.YeD
bWlaa
J
Col.De Velle7
Bnaba•
Iw ........
5
8
J)antOD
lplac
Caaoa
o.klaana•r Y
Doa-n i'oOl.
!~ foa
:~·"°*--Deepcal"
BUl
'2.7
20.0
,o., as.1
u.,
u..,
a.,
1.,
40e7
hrabaa
~}
'U)
c1 G5l¥1DIQJ:9PI J)lb
O...tria
lt,lt.O
Carr
1--*
,,.o
'2.7
Prat. ..
Bab B•c1
2
27.9
JJ.)
セM@ Paooak
PPfllI9JI
セ@
7)
ot •
and \be YHi.a\ioD
PI¥11U9Jl
U)
3)
11)
•ort or oorreletiall
119nmater, .. tolloaa
i-r'tou.lar
8)
aOille
Atl-4
1-7•S
lJ•8
22.,
i,..o
~2
a.2
10.1
16.8
!lt-5
4-2
..
a.9
2.,
,
21.,
19.1
1.,
'°-•
15.,
21.2
a.1
u .•
5-.J
-
17.1
2.a
,.,
.,., ,.,
,.2 ,.2
a.a
).9
,.o
le,.l
1.a
2.,
J.1
2.0
---
,.1
-
142.
m, I
PWPll<il l
10
,o.o
11\U.4
Preat.a'FPaooc*.
hJ"lll
1J
lt.-7
17.9
Toa Bl11
l8
19
J5.4,
,1.2
1faroook Jlortla
Star ~ff
1'
-
セ@r)
9.5
hrabl•
n.,
,.,
28.8
DQlrntaD
Brllba•
23.7
Deepaar
s.i..t111
Doa-n Pool
セ@
21.0
15.5
i. .......
coin. Y•llQ
t.ood
1.5.:,
»-••
a.9
,.,
lJ·'
a.a
heCMbe"911
m
8)
bW..
O.khaapr
V
,.o
Ipina Oa ara
lD Diw1arl
eD4 the percMDtep
セ@
•••lea••
reaperi1••
'n.-.
ot
tne • (~iquly
ta .-.
., ...
tb• •1199lnc
ot altea ia Dialllai_.2
セ@
_..ean (or
t1uat 11nangl•,
Dt_ioD-,ancl 1b•
4acrnte
t:raa tbS. i .t •7
(i.•
•114 1:be Plll'O_..P
ot g ...
Wl7loaae
anti•
be-
trio
b••••
ocrnlatlola
la TUIIJ of tbe lllilllber ot tn,tlll
.
._,
ot Id.ah.aipitiaaw
be ooaoluclH tbal
'ritlaill • •iDBl• t~
w para•ter
'*•
oorrel-
)•
baa.a
olaMitioetiom
.
1lpaD
an i1ot .iuatiti ...
oluatne•
Bllt 11 ta •U..Dl•
1a tb• e11ai.,.1a,
lr.l.a»ll•
oornletiall
(20) it , ia not to be セ@
a'1ona aboul4 'be wrJ' pnoiae
'Vi• nria\iGII
m),
faln"t}, lD
BluaW
aori ot ...-.1
of Qpe Bot
~ge
1Dtolw4 la tbia ••~ia
b...-
C5f)
taU. ..U
'tlGllld ...
that FRJISTAftl (1'J tile セ@
aper'
trca
セ@
1io •OOGUDtfor tbia) •
セ@
'Selffe~a•
ai~
( tibe ldall ~iCIII
ot
llh-1:ber, U mn
'Sew•terri.ea'
セ@
Ii f t
, f
i t 'i. ..r·- r
.. , ,
e
;
,
f
I セ@ .. I -
f :1 l :·
t:
•
f
.
'"
t
I
It ..
rt
Q
セ@
I
I: tic s
fl-t:J -
I
i
I
::
' .
!l ••
•
t r i,
セ@
セ@
o
.._
I
I i - '; !i i t
i
r
!
l:
i
!
I
:
I .
'
1
!
セ@
I •
- • ; •
· 1 a,
··It,~,,.,
A'
.,..
i
gf
·1· ;
1; · : , 1
t
11 ,
·セ@ i"• :
l
r
·1 , "'
_
.. セ@ X
i • ..
-•
!r
:s. II
Ii 2
tl ,· f :. f
;
J'I
l
i i I ' : l 'l
I l t • • i
J
.
'
.
I
.
•
i ,...
" ,.
3"
,
,: r .·(' - 1i &·r
セ@
I.
I
I . • ;
,i ;
セ@
C°t.c
•
!
e I
.- •.. .;,
..
• セ@
•
a ••セ@
~ts i1 1t • 1
· 9.. a~
•
,;!-~'-
,1
セ@
i
.I
I
lif : i1
rlif11lf~·1,1.~1efi~!~11'1l
f ; t l I r ' ', セ@ f r i ; · t · l t ! .r • · •
'
•
11 • i ,
I .• ... !rt :?
.. .,
i IItr
' J
:It
1
•
.i
I ,;, •
1; I:
r C' l
Ji
f f !
• 1 if l
i f セ@
f
..
f
:. ...
Ii セ@
.
.
セ@
•
'
·c- a-
r. i
J r; -•.:f i• ,...
: 3.' I•
f.
! I
i ·I ' . ' f '
C -
J· !1 I 1f,
Jf
f ! f
r
f
1
j
.•
,.
'·Ii!
·1
; セ@ f •
I
r
I;
l~,
}
!A
2 ( •
,• ,
セ@
:1:
-
t i •
-
r •.. 'cIC~.r - セ@ ! ' f i
!
.
~ ·, E,
S
•
l ;:.~r
2 ' II
セ@
f i I f
: a r
5 !
r
@
セ
•
r i
r f ~j·
(
!
11f
I:. l ll • r 1
1
it
f
!
ij : i ; f )
Ii
J セ@
l
J
--
I
I
@
I
"'o
,:ao
,
I
®
o~
0
1(i)
-------------
f
I
I
I
c,"
Ql,
'o"
I
0 '~
---~ ! ____e• I_ ~ e,.
110
-$'0
0~
©
."
----------
- ---- -,o.
- - -- - - ------ - --- ----orJ'
2
o'
Q
'
•'°
•
7
@ -- -------- - -------- ---- ----- - ------- •• 0
''e I
I
2
-·
et'
o,..
0
I
'1
e"'
o'
o,~
o""
f
Cor.-.pu ted
3 - :)i :.1ension
1l conficur1
tion
of
13 "..:'ota l ' osse i.::bl o.~;es
( Buclideo.n
distan
c e function)
.
. .,.,....
@
q
C, I
I
I
I
I
i
0
701
I
?. I
I
I
I
'o
•o
I ,,
I O ll.
,
I
Q
t
0~
qO
0
& -
© - ------. ---- - I -0
f) I
I
4
- --- . - ..- .- -11
•
•1
I
I
I
I
0,1
I
I
,0 1
I
I
®--- -----·-----------------
.::&
I
o'
Os
Olj.
IO~
I II
II
---- -- ------ - ,o~.;o,~-- ---
0~
o,
13~
8 1~
0~
'"e'I
I
o,
'.<'i ·ure
16 :
'.:0::10-.ited
3 - ) i :·1ensio!la,. l confi c-uratio
'o'
I
n of
13 ' ':'ot o.1'
a s se i'..l
b l o.:,;es ( Presencc
- o.bsen ce diGt n.nce f un cti on ) .
'o
i
0
"
.
o•:l.
5'
0
I
(D ---------------
-----
I
-----
- , -- ---- -----------" I
•
o ..
10
:t
Oq
CoP1:1ntcd 2-D.i.; 1cnnion:1l
confi
";Uro.tion
of
1.:-{Ge:1bln 7ca (' ro::-;c-ncc - nh:::-:lnCe cocffic:ic:1t)
/
13 ' 'l'ot.:d •
.
f· i
·i~
J
! セ@
l.
I
f
i
. t
I I'11
!
e
....c,~
I!
! : i ( i ! I セ@ I
II·- lit•=
!tt
t
i i- !. 'i ·.- if~f;•·~~,i' af• ; f
...
§
セ@ セ@
セ@
i'
1
セ@
•
セ@
I' B
• 'r
8
i f
!
i r ' •
&I
セ@
セ@
I I
セ@
'll!f
;if(lJI
1
1!
r:
3
セ@
i
'If
ii 1 ~•1 ~a!J1a 1 i ,,,
r セ@
t , • 1·
lif1r •sliJf
'"'I • !
I... I
r: - i ·r·~ii.~
i5!i
r~i
...
..
r,.
;~1i
ift 1Jr·:1r(f
•fls
I 1
1 l ·
l
(
-J=f
~1,1;
.~
i' r
~!«+
1'
t• •~
f 12,~i ~,a
~!
1 I i ! J I セ@ l- i f t I ' @セ セ@ セ@
"I f 1 • 1. r f.•"
:
l
I~J•tt11I
fi; : fi
:1 -i Ia i f f :3 if it I, It i• i. I1 I• ~i!I
11,r J 1,;~;;a
!f I =
セ@ i
l i i I"f' I f i5 !r
i. ! セ@
!!, . f 2'•'c+
i f .. & セ@
• r
1
I
rf!i
t 11~~f
.J I"
:i
セ@ iJr ' ;(
(!
i?
i
• ;if セ@
::1 •
1n ii:f :
1 f
セ@
v,' •
• ::t..
'l
•
,
•
;
f
r.t
&
Ii -
•
I
I
セ@
セ@
•
セ@
ft ;
o•
;' f;
f
Ii
!
N
.!!.~
i :
I i
l セ@
I セ@
fI 't
E セ@
•
-
i
f
;
' I ! @セ r : [ I '
l 2 ' 5f i l
f セ@ : i i セ@ セ@ I
I
f
Il
I
:i.
I ~1.1
I
i .
t Il
fi I
!
! :;
f
I
I I セ@ @セ
(
f '
;
r.t
1.1:·
i • .... .• •
1~,·1
• ;~&1l2f ~.;
f ..fi ! i'r Ill
l f
,s ! !ftJ'
8 ••
ff'
lr
••
:a
f
'
...
•
セ@
fセ@
,t
t
セ@1 ( tl
•
t•
tセ@ セ@1· lセ@
ti セ@
1J
セ@ I :• 5
セ@
f
セ@1t
f
セ@ ,
I...
セ@ I
;•
•B.
セ@• セ@ •
r
..
;
i
& r 1 I I ~l' '
!
! r, セ@ 1 , , ; : • セ@ 1
-~
セ@
, セ@ ...
J =t, •,
rセ@
11
,. II!,•-·I~"
•• i 1
.•'"
i セ@ f セ@ t I f : l セ@ セ@ 1 .. • r , ! i : i t セ@ セ@
セ@ ' , , I i ;
セ@ 1 1 t i ! , ; 1 , ; 1
I ' I •
• I
; セ@
I • r
I 1 セ@
r
;
f r セ@
I
f; セ@ et ·! t l. f セ@ セ@ i .. ft di: a ;
; セ@ l I セ@ i f ' セ@ I i i I g f - セ@ ! i I I " f
f K ?
? '1 i; •1 I セ@ I セ@t ,r !f aセ@ aI t J 5f tt :2 ;• i
• • , 1 ;
セ@
セ@ ti' セ@ t:: .. ; I I i • "
セ@ セ@
r i r, セ@ セ@
g t: 'i
" f
• ! i r5
セ@
r
S:-il
• ... t ;
Jセ@ l,
セァ@
io
f f
- i•
..
4
' 1; :
ai ;• ii
I
•
lI .,
,
f
II
セ@
""et
I
セ@
I (
f
J
• f I
t:'
If
•
f
•
r •
;
I .. 2
{
t
セ@ l
(
f
I
セ@
! r •
i ...f
'J
i I I [ i
•
O
セ@
!,i.
セ@ •
C
~I•
セ@
IS-
セ@
!
f
_o
111
t ;
-I セ@ t
I
'
セ@
'1
'
I i : : •
セ@
I
•
I
It
i 2•
r
! i
f
!
, .. ai
!
f
i
セ@
•
f
! セ@ I
;IS- if セ@ . セ@f '-f
t'f
i i ;
t I I i
·i'i!
ci'
•
Ii:ri ii
~,1ir1
r
ffi
: :
I
r
! I
1...t; •I Iセ@ 'f
I rt:
i.
; [ l セ@ 1 f f
r1e ,t,
i. 1 I ;
セ@
0
l;
I
I • セ@
~f..:~
•
I
2 I
t
(~ .
. "
セ@•
f
!
I
.
i
'1
i
'
f•
149.
for
oedlll7, large qanU~
ewer •
• wide ana
troll
fOl'IIII
'b7
~banns...._
ot
a trant.on
ot Brit.ta
the••~ot
GUI'
ooU_...,
a-..W7
~nti.Tel.7
to~.
•ra
••
'ftda,
r••vcni•e4
ai
aD4
.-;r ...
•tllr•of
tu ..-.1.de4
ot aaa-1.a,-,
ta the analpia
rdl atnwpm
DI tile ~eat
cle&aattoa
•"-Wt
1I01'k an
ill
19,a.
hen the 'rta'-8t
HDNild..as
1a
the au.ltual
,-i'ble,
ot-.
».aoU\bio
1D ltil on tenllJ
ta a at.te
_.
lt
to ...
1Dftlce4 axta .....
of tlae
.a adll
--~
セ@
...
111))anu
._J•114'be.._
Nlnllt
bee be•
a1Doe Cl.rk
ar-t
tater.-\
ot ft1ola ••at.aattlJl:l.tier
alll
to ..... .,. 'brief'q
~iahecl
RJ)fff'loul.
ai.DN ••
n.
Br1t.111e
ta.a••poaei1-l.e ton•
l.lMU&_..cleftl•1
••
._..
Al•
...
lleaJA taeta
daUJtc aac! d:utrillldia
ta s• ._.
tbe _..
Ilia •ia.olit.b:1.o
a.a •11 be.a tt セ@
111M1Q,
pei1.o4
•de
oau.at.
f.l"G& the
• '-ral
tile
aTe
o.
,1ae
the BrlU.U
Pl"ffi-
Nell
aata or
JlaMli.ado
work.-•••
i.llflueDoer•
la all
.. , -~
1118'-~lq
OODOertd.Da
oult_..l
of ne11••1'1',
r .. 11.-,
oomiDNlntcmati•
セ@
fl'Clll tUa,
ut~te
Suoh a aurn7
baa bed
a11tQ11ecl tbia
ot a
\be ni&lenoe, atuulatN
GIie
ot nideDOe tllo\ bd aMWIUbW
iD Br1•111'
hne be•
a.a lillke4 wt 'lb
tGIID4
porUoa
to lipt.
baft ....
aaa c!iat1apiabe4
w • .,.
ao
piau.pe
•t:w\J ot the •r1-J 11.taratiar• _..
A abnllolasi,al
••
Yet \Id.a -11
to \a.. ~la
peried
altea
f•
セ@
aDd aoawtan,
ot the Merolitld.c
kwl.ace
aW •114 fw orpm.o Naim
n-1_.,
reoorde4a
OGIIUl7tZ'CIII the encSof the Pldatooeae
fal'IIUII NGZDEQ•
baft bMa p tner..a
ot tliata
...
'be l•l'l*L
W..
u oanoluai•..
iataraUGD
_.
Ill ;partiallar,
Jleeolit:bio
'be ..
lrretri
ah.ii•
... bq
oeria1JI ••~1-1
an atUl
loatJ
but
tNllalqua
•1
••M.
pzwa nr:,
•teri.al
aaltiwr»M
H .. Ollll1ae4
ua aeotiaD ls.
pza , ••
'aatmoepolosiaal
•».r tittica&l
tllat
•
wit!> lb• BrlUII> -oltWo
••PM'•
Al1bougb tbia peper ....
laaa
..an
IQ?
,...
.. , liYiJIS •
w,.,ta •
tliJa~ and aberl
Ddl
ream
HrYiY-4.
llurie4
\oa9rda
Brit.in.
ta. ••
lt
u
1-1
aitea
plaoea•
ot II.ball•
thq
sa,av•;
and witb tbe iaumt:w ·• agriaal_..l
akel.et.1 "9im
•IIPlM&
..
ft1la
a larp
Jll"O-
fM.1- a
tbe7 ..U
•'1"1'7
t tbeil• woa1abe
Chief' ....
Oil セ@
lllUOpe
Bat 1, •PPM"
Briialaa
nn.ta-,
セ@
at •IV zate,
apl.Ol'laU.
a.n
U.t
fllulo ot
ak:-1.etal
a..a
tbe
• セ@
1ibea"9••
an4 lt tbta P1"9ft1N _.
the laoal
_.
19119"4 ta
aoU aatla
flt
tit~-
an.a,
--1
a.t.rt_.
...
qalilT
ot their
tlin
llplalld anaa,
•117
MTe Nell 4-~
AbMD'
alao an •IV•r'
••Mt
to .--,
.....
-.Ill! imluie
ll~t
t.bat. in
not aurprbi.n&
••
taun4 it.
~t
.In
セ@
acmagroqa •-14
DI .....,.
people ia .i1ot.
en.,
ta
aa4 .-.
et ••
as..-lllabt Jmat s.atta. l•l•n4
_,
••tala-
ot tba aotu.l
SA apeo~l
414
al"GIIIIII fNa
witb Do fiXe4 aettlaMDta.
ot ... olithio
'WI• ....
floa
• .,.
セ@
fOo4 la tbeh- cU.etl at.her O'<IIQ9 ldpt
pi.Oke4 11PYbeNnr
011r lmalfle4p
"-i&Md '
•i
._,
ot tbll9e llulatient
u
tor,111•
al.tll...,..
da rstnW
\
n4 cleerJ \Nt WJ!'7UIC
*eir
woocSe4lliPl,alll!area•,
la~
eoGIICNq•
tlla
rei ... n, ._
...-,
414 tbe,J' llw
u .....
a..e17
plan
t•
quatioew1
their
セ@
111•tat.r
4-r' an4 ••
1ibe 1-
ln9
.....
aa.
p•,
of
•MIit wttll 1rh• .... U' ...
•ff8
the -~
IID\ apeaitl•~
1-.-ot J:wllltera llllnllC
......
partlaD et ptk8Nl4
1
'flllt
pae·lulate aaU
1lo aDOtber lJI parllld.t
.....
, '.I
'
how mg].""'"
M lake•
...,.1 ~-
to •
lllllr 41.4 1M,J· wCll'k it!
•• lllgbil
\be» __.
,-.ible
pi~
&roli .11119llulnelwf
tw,
.,....
an 1Jffo1Ye4, -'
tiell
-.....a
to Ida\ at tbe ••• ..
lbaa•
·,or tec.J
'-'
••peen,it
to OONI' tbla
._..
~-
to the
..u.
_, -
1-,
a~cb
atattati•l
eD4 tlw. N!Mllw ot a
••l*'IJ
twmtt--1
hall•
~t.riHcl
セ@
t11IR
6) II•
I
be atua1.a
Id.pt
(la ...-lea
It , ba• 'bND :1n4imW
ta セ@
the
-.Na-
151.
u.11111,aa; aD4 ...
to oi .h ff14 ...
the »..ollUd.o
Spaia, wbiab
uaai
balN WClll"k. AB/iiDt it ta pa11albly aot iffelnaat
t1-.. abra.a.
Pftmpl
e
n .. u .. pincrul
.,.tez,e •7 'be m•illecl tram
now 11•eq aoeD88 ot •• _...
OOJ&r..U, 411W \o セ@
... olitbic
~lo4,
the red
impnNiaD
pal.J1t.!Jlp
U "-•
or
ot
••tern
~ba*!JWI are
it ta aot wltkely
tlat
eiallar
\
J Olll'tlll l •
JCIUl'ml ot the Ro19l .Anthropological
Allti.Q\111
ri •
p.p.s.
p.p.a.J..A.
s.1,..c.
sx.1,..c.
a..1..s.
,.s.
Tram•
1,.
.lft.Soo•
w.1,..lL
y.1..J.
A C•
ImUtute.
Proceeding• of' the Pruietoric
Society.
Froceeclinga ot the Prehi.11toric Society
of Eaat Anglia.
Surn7 J.rcbeeol.ogic»l Collectiom.
Suu ex J.rcha eol.ogic»l Colleotione.
Tranaect10IIII or the Hriatol en.4 Clouc .. "-r
Arel» eolog i cel S00iet7.
Tnnsa cticma ot the Laacaahire and Cheahir•
intiqur1-n
Soci•V•
I U whir• .lrcba .ologioal
and • 'turGl
Hiatory Jlap•ine•
Iori;ahi.re Arcba eoloei-aal .1Ollrllal•
15)•
AIUISftCIIO, A•L• (19'l2)
(1923)
(1925)
BABMIS,
1..s.
BtJillUJU,
0.
BIWCIID, L.R.
(1~7)
Two
••t torabin
TM llfllgl-.
realm
Bel tic oaunterparta.
( 19'8)
(19~;
EOBDIS, -,.&.
(195.l)
(1888)
»cpl.ore ticim at .Mo1.har Gr\lDdJ''
•
,., 57•
nrloar,
J,L4.1., .50, lft.6. -78•
ot olea produo\laD
fri•A•, U:
t1.r.oea.
ea.pte,tam.
la
§•ir i Lri• ftfl PslWMYM
ip
Poa.-Pleiaiooea.
iD Meaoli*io
101-1,.
!19(9£4
Amlwll19R•
1D tbe •tlacJir
.....i.,... flltrb!t59111,
5: 1-,e.
Stati.aU.•
On ._.
Ul?l.-n~,
~.
p.
et llol.4eroeu and their
f•f•§•l:4•,
er...u eras.a,Derb,ahiN•
TM \eabld.qu
and Neolithic
p. 75•
(19,.. J
BCID«IP6
• A•
rm..u,
a.
bone barpoa1111.
セ@
end arapiioa
••llfOWld
b1.lbl7
ill
tl.18'
apeculiaed
forml ot •taae
North Atria. ea4
i•l•A•X•,18(2): lJl..-39•
uu,
(1892)
On the coat11111it7 ot the Palaeolithic
•114
lteoli 1:bic perioc!III• ,I•l•A•I• • 22( 1 & 2) s ~98.
(1921)
c6JliqroliW,c Ipdyttg.
Mente, XWilNn•
(l924,J
The t:ranaitioD
BeoUtio
'be••thePlilaeolitbic
•1111
-..oli.t.b.ta perio4.e
f,f,§•l•A•• 5(1>1
JIJ!ZJa,
1{. I•
cmxm, v.o.
1'-,,.
t.i.Ma 1 1 ...
( 1?'4.)
(192S)
(1931)
The tonat
lD wolutima
:,2~.
(19}7)
aul~
ol llortbnta a..rope: •
and d.1tru1oa.
•twti
J•l•A•l•• 61(2) a
Adai,tati..on w '\he paetalaoul
tcna't •
1111,aaia'10 plei.11. la Q:9, MP9MEdy( 9)
the aarUa
llrk••
an.mcmtt. :o.v. (19'2 )
Die abe U&rasib.1ot t.be M•ol.1 tbio • i •
Ill •114
IV at Tmtobaa, Derkabire, Enclellll• P.Pz§•, 281
"2-70•
:O.M.end (19'5)
~HILL,
IIMD. ~.J.
'the k1.tcbe11 a1M• ai a • t W•1aar4
Jta&uDC11
eoot.os,, •••• and relatica
u
CLA&, J. C..1).
(19,2)
land end••
P.P.s. ,1:
1....i.
Bol ,
nn-cm.
to abana..
7~
Pt !Mill!a1P Ac• MlDJ11P1.aor e morol.ithto culture:
or Bera.baa.
kshet%9f99fl
{19,a...) Th• claMitia.tioa
the .a.
ardeno1-un
., ...
1. 90,
sa-n.
(193!.b) A late
•1.t• et 3elaMtoD,
l4.i lJlt--58•
KaoU.tbio
4nt•J•,
Suaaa.
ot Mall• f•f•§•,
itae prela:i.ator7 ot 1ibe Iale
lt 7<>-92.
(19.)6)
(1938)
traa tllfa 49J)Gll1U et
a nd Blaabear.U, DDZ9•~
i.Ddul~
Jll.airolltld.o
P:r'9eta911, l'lintahiN
f•f•§•, A.I .330-~
(19,0)
The •rll•t
eeiu_. , ot ,he••'
tu t.b• l.isbt or recNIIS na•rab•
01-100.
(1951.)
l!Se" \ire es s11rctrr-
(1955)
A aiaroliUllc
CLARK.
J.c..p.
and
CtiBROD,n•.1..1..
•a.. f•f•O•,
(19'7)
'Pit StoneAg ftMHEI•
(196_5)
l'rild.ti"Ye
~IMI
(19.,9)
!xo.wticm
{19)q.)
.AD er1-,
IV lltINI. I ., •
CLAP
.K, J.o.n.
,~.
s.11.
CURICB,D. L.
( 19'2)
CUB0. R.R.
(196())
COLE, J .)(. •n4
BIQOS,a.s.
( 19'9)
C<LLllti,
n.
(1970)
.. tern Aaia
at rerllbaa,
P.P.8., 5: 61-118.
••le4
G('ODf, u. セ@ It. E.
Jlla'Jl1tP,
'•-'•
Ul ~t,
•D
end
'.lbr
Cf!S14U Angie, Biftsa,
lO •
Bllr<>pe.
(!'aaciole
C4\.RX, J.G.D.
ftf•I•,
t.n4ulltri•
ot Ul• l\arOpeen
24-=2Alr-42•
Blecle an4 tnpeae
ataae
en.
1'1
in&lllir:, fraa the Cambri-..adn
ena otbar uaauatrua ot SaU"N'-'riall
fl'OII Brit.ta.
p.p.s., 21: }-20.
tenlead,
effln1t1•
(1958)
~lUo
Meaoli tbic
uur .sor..1
l
:,Ul"l'e7 (1937-,a).
•it• at
peat.
BraldMlurlle,
J.1,4.1., 61..:101-28.
Matrix a1111l,au end. H"ClbeeoletgJ Wit.bi Iertiou.1-r
reterenoe to liri \1ab Beaker poh•r:J•
2a1
f•f•I••
,11-a,.
Ifft Jp;if
(AW)•
1\1
""*'tolw
9' EfEk ••
Stolle ertetaot
ana~ia
aD4 the reoogm.U• ot
aul"""
tnclitioaa.
)!grld :AmtefOler, 2(1) :17-27.
COJIUY, V.11.
(1951.,)
StreU&rapq
and pollen cal19ia
or NIii~
pata.
.TOlll"Dlll or BcoltlfQ',
Pewd.ne 'bt..llket
ui
u7-4,7.
(19,9)
(1950)
(19'7)
(1891.,,
en '*••r-1.atian ot
Jleolit.bi.c
(1912)
( 19")
(l96o)
their
prcwe•D04t and
·+E!RI• /t• & C• bDteSQC•, }O: 2}-24-
• d.i.gitel
tl.int
Th•
the PPlaeolitbio
to the
2J: 242-51..
i•l•l:•l•,
111p1_.nta:
Pypf1 t'liat
•••
'IXIL\N, J • I• end
BOISON, p.1.
periad.
coq.uter
a nal,ai.a
ot .Paleeoli t.bic
•••eabi.g•••tun, 210, 688-S,.
chan~
lr,el
ot the••• §StllUfi9
Aprj.cap, 202{ 5J•
(1961)
GAJROD,D.A• I•
(1957)
01ao1a1,r4 fl•MlrrRD Geo\m•
(192')
Di• Rmm:Pplf l9M,tb1oAl• ilt BJ:111
&I-
(1''2)
CABROD,l>eAel• alMl
BAD, D•Jf.li•
(19}7)
~TTI, R•A•
(l9C.,)
ClllBO'D.S, JI.
Fypq
t'Unt iapl .... ta.
1£1•, 20:
21~28.
Tr•• k• t c. Ae5•
tunt 1Jllplea111taa their prwenanoe and
1.• t c. ,4n1:s99., ,o, 14--2,.
(1912)
P'ylQ
(195')
1"t fm11\oa of t!IW! IJR:oRt•
(196})
hropMll
...
tna,
prebiatc:.-r
a.alitldc
to
921,1
Rgip
1963(StaDt
•
B. J . S1..ge l (e d. )
olop,
(1~5 )
or the Jllor1ibS•
ot lnncl alM.1••-lwel
•.Hmol ya,s, 4'.,: 29-69.
Cc:»atal paat b.a.
iD41cea
(195')
IJ'OD Age, 111
ot 4nthropr egica ••
II!
156.
COlliD1,
suoo.n,
n.
(19.)l)
Miial..aeten a-rpoon •it.a.
Antiquiiz, 10: l6....,S.
(1958)
S.aiocarbcm
R.P. •
WILLIS, J. U.
GRDEJLL, L. V •
HALLAM.
J .s.
Britiah
ot ~.
daUJJg
rue ill
lulatatic
M9tjgt, 181: 1518•
ocean lev•l•
(1958)
Th•Boakot MM19!•
(1958)
l'heArohf•eloq ot l•u·
(1970)
Pit Jmi?eeol.5¥EJ
g( p
\o»r;141WW-
(196o)
l'be K•olithic
u:
Bigford hi
P•min••
ot the Centrel
Jlll.Yll'liV ot Liy,n,pol.
l:A• Dl!M,
(1960)
(1959)
he5Ya.tiCll'la
at • a•ol.ithic
n.r Saliablar7,
20'J-J2.
,.a.
acmON,
(1969)
at Dalmtca,
ait•
f•f•§•,
l'iltabi.N.
251
Sea rchiJls tor atructa&re wU:hiD lliltinriate
al"OM eolosiaal
data. WorldArcbp f9log. l( l)
90,-105.
Hot:Smi1 f.B.
SI\"kTlf. P.H.A• and
'l>OIAB,J ,!.
IVJEEII, J.
Cl.water .Ali8lyeia and arobaeoloa:
clevel~and appl.ice tic:m.
Af9hefOlogJ
, ,l(}) I 299-)20.
(1966,
.3ou expe~
archaeologioal
}11-24,.
(195'.J
The late-glacial
hwaa ot DeDDrk and 1 ta
rel,itica
to cliate
alll4 aoU. Ptfflrk! 9tol..
(19'<>)
ta the lll&Mriml anel,at.a or
B\Wk1!St, 5.3(}, At.)1
(19'1)
~w.
(197<>)
(19'7)
l:XIP, .PeA•X.
liDIJR, J .J. •nd
DI?al,!Bt, G.I.
KO~II,
L.
(1.9'5 )
II, 801 87-9•
Problea
'1t the •rl7
Poatalacial
dnelopmen\
Ul Dellark•
Seri•
:VPdtPMltlft,
J"ILGlll3MA,
s.
Holocene ••-lnel
Mt4e
a.ol.SM,gh$1¥•
tor•t
Dtwri
o,o1.
IV,
J.,: ~.
ohanc.. ta tb• Me*•lallda.
Serie C-VI, Jlo. 7•
§SN\k:e•l Jnsl..p94(.AW)·
Bienrobioal
cluaUri.Da
amemea•
f11M8Nk1kn, ,2, 241-5-,.
.A K•oU tbio eiie
an IpiJtg Ca an, Sua••,
Enalanc:1.
f·f·A·• ,11 e5--92.
(192,)
(19'4)
l'orlf
ote.
VJ¥!trt9Mtlft
• Seri•
a.
•aae ._
(1970)
bl9hdet-r1kt • 29 no. l.
I
157.
(19'1)
Meeolii.hio
tring ...
Wai,
SMITH,
(1970)
C. an4
s.
A i..-
tr9:napo"'t-i"'~
faciea in tte
s.,-.c.,
,,.
mea•\U9
ot oopi.tiYe
coa:pl.uit7.
~ PK J?N!Stfd
to tilt LondonCol)(,nnc•
the Britiab Pazchologicel
eoo1et7 1 Dt9•
(1951)
Prelimuary
ucaawtiom
• t Abil\ter
on a 1'eeolithic
ait•
Per.P.
Socie\J, 1'o~
Re&t'lrcb
CouaoG, ~\ll'N7•
2f tbt Surr,x Archpeologipl
(1966 )
Crenellua
of
197Q•
ait.e at. Bri.gbam,
Anl•s•, ~: 211-28.
••t
torkahire.
(19~
(l.883)
ttPe or pHnM, •e4 Wlao
r••hienf1)1,-.
6991!,al
(1,0})
(1912)
(19'7)
MARTIN, P.s.
tli.nta:
Pypq
pl"O'V.ne~e and uae.
Ael•§op., )o: 8-lJ.
t.beir
TrtM• L. 6
c.
1-reAiawrio
OYeridll,
~dl*!t
iA
JcrUn. f•§•
eDd
fle1•$00191 Ext.ipc}iffl•
Cp)
MARTIN,F.S. and
IRI<ET,
e.•.(eda) • (1967)
(1970)
MJLLA.RS'p • A•
Sane C01111Mnta
an the notio!l ot •tunotioia.l
iD atone tool fl .. eui:>legee.
veriability•
1or1c1N9bttol211,
(19'0)
l.z:oayaUom at Jligh RocJca, Tunbridge W-1.la
sx.A.c., 9a,
{19~-5' ).
(19'2;
Le
s11:.,.c.'
h:eb1•tod,gya,An$1qu!te41 l'Bc
1.he ~ton.
•nd
11. •
a.~.
•
ot the Iale ot PorUarad,
ot Poi-U.nct Cberl •• arte1D Southern JnglaDd. P,f•I •,
Ag• 1.Ddu8tri•
1:h• utili.3at1.on
fact • terul
.}6: 82--U.5.
~UAltl.
17}-221.
at Bigb Rocit•, '.l'unbrid@• Well•
{1951.-56) : au.ppl..a.nt.ar7 note.
loo:
:!X~YatiOM
U.9-51.
{1970)
.-a,.
2( 1), 11
ot ta• Br1ta,h Yti•k\199-
{1969)
A U1•lm
(19}7)
t•x\n• §51t1e:MSJ:9Ro1• %=o\4ntita!e»e
ta
IR:r1t1bel•
( 1951.J
•
Plffll,
I•
MJLLI, BS'
~wnq
L•1,9thropolsst•,6: 21~2.
'l'he aa.olithio
J,4.J., le,2:
P11'1,od lJI
nortb-••t
Torka~.
,u.,.27.
A Meeolithio atJ\lcture at 0.epcar, l'cirabi.N,
Jng1-a, and t.be attiAiti•
or ita auocut.cl
tlilat 1.nduatr7. f•r•§•, 30: 1-24,.
(19,,.)
J&iaol1*1o
lnglende
(19,~)
RAISTRIClC,
A•
....
d 1 etbel'p»plie
(1964.)
P •A•
BAl::iTRIO<.,A•
t;!ft;,!ZrrQ;fl::a:r1'
OM
(1891a) ltudae
(19'8)
R.ADLII,
J •• na
•
aiiell ot the aortib-••t
caea"t
or
f•ft§•l:4• 7• 188-98.
tbe 41.atrilnlUoll or M.-oli tibia •1 '- 1JI 'aortb ot. lngl•nd•
J•4•i•, ,11 lJel.•5'•
(19,6)
COUPlJ RD, G. and
COUPL,\ l'\D, 1".
RAl«INE, ~.,.
(191.,9)
Maoebeeda witb ._olUild.o
••oaut.tom
England f•f•§•, 15: 7o-6•
troa
SCMth-•at
RANICDI, ~.F.,
セ@
•rreD,
(1952)
A
(195')
Th• MaaoU~o
( 196o)
r\lrlber oa.wiiom
et• W..olitibic
Oakheager, Selbourne,
Banta. f•f•§•, 2,: ...
RAJ'iCINX,la.11. and
DI ICJ3l
.KB!, G• tw•
Rltnlri,
A.O. and (19'9 )
S'l'IRUD, G.
(1961..)
M•olUibio
or
•t
P.P.s., lB: 21-,s.
Briut.n.
wGl&tberD
Pfpg ot Mt• §F£V
BMMl"fE
JMbe•plesJeel
soc1u1,ao.z..
•it••'
Ol.oae 1Tad.llity .Amlyau:
a npicS •thod
1:be arderiDg ot arcmeolo giael •t•ri•la·
tor-
1,mms,a4pt1au1v, J4.: 265-n.
The Br itiah
aaee ~l-,
reelll.ta.
(19'8.1
abipp1Jag tl.oor
Oakbenaer, ~•lbaurne, a.nu.
Jritiab
grau.pa.
laler
•114 ald4le
••*
~le•ol.itaio:
ot atud;y aDd prelild.lllr;y
f• f •§• Joa ~7.
loaer
aDd alddle
Pelaeol.Uld.c
P.P.s.• .,_,,1-82.
bandax•
2.
(19:,7)
..,,,,
e• 119\W:nMW:HSS
Jee111ilff1Ptl91
(•
(l,i.J)
(19'2)
l9E 20,000eI•bzr.
(19'6)
SIMINOV, S •A•
(1961.)
SHm!ARD, R.Jl.
(19'2)
fnb1t'5119 Tdmelsr·
PfzsahmMJse,27, 125-219.
SHIHfARD, P .p.
and CURRAY,
(19'8)
C.rbaa-U..
J.a.
I.a
cletuw.tn.ttoa ot ••·lnel
cbanpa
lla §en , • {14}
SMI'DI,
.A.a.
(1952)
•Ai
S1'1A?B, P.H • .A•
SiaG,
··~
(1961)
SXI'ffl, X.A•
S<*A.L, LR.
Pros•••
••bl••rea••
Ml 99encmx
J.p.s.
:,&-4.9.
••UalB:
ot Pnnce: •
lc}-20.
The "'9ol1W.O ta \be
crttiaal
••11aia• f.r,s.,
(19'J)
(19S8)
SUJIMIRS,p.a.
(1~)
SUTCLIWI, W.B.
(1897)
--
(.AW).
A MNol.1Ulio
f,P.s.,
7: セ@
aite
near I._..
tna.r•a
A laoUtbio
a\Qre ot p-.phite.
SU'lCLIWI, I• B•
aad PJ.RKJR, I •A•
(1912,
Pn,q
SU.,,
C.L aDd
HI'nLB, S.L.
(l9'S)
A tlim-clr.lpp1D& atte •
111rabne1cs.
, ••
1'EWiABDde
CHABDIB,P•
(195')
DaeBrr? ET
m*30K, D•P•
(19)9)
The S•aaa.l
...
tlial
YIJl,LI,
u.s.
(1915)
J.
(1890)
tbeir
Pl"ffeDaDOe ••
Mh§og., ,o, 1-8.
Bill ne.r
q,,,s.,Toa
&.J ,-u..
f•ft§•' ~'
T<IS,
illpl...-tai
C,
'&PM•le: 6
Doi-a•*·
s. hP·. s. ,,-~.
Bz:¥1\• I:t t
tna•
111.mter,
llaNOaka
9(
t'lotor 1D lll1111ua
oult.11re.
20,-221.
aMOOuW
hl7 1,15.
IP•
tiDll•
4!W::9MIJ'b
tlecbel typiqgea cle Perr~
(Aume•
At s~
9\r1t 4t fedl , l(6~er1-•
95
Point.a._
Tardeeoi•
ft
r,
l'M*9R-
l.6o.
WAINIVRI<ffl,G.J.
(1959)
The uoantie&
ot • Keaolitbio
PreabWater eat, Peai>reicNhire•
BullQip Boprd· Cfltic Sty.di•,
(1960)
Three aicrol.ithic
Bnaland and their
(19'3)
J.
(195' )
i.Ddulltri•
attim.ti••
•it• •t
18(2 ) : 19'-205.
trca aauth-w•t
f•f•§•, 26. 19}-201.
reinterpret.tion
ot the ad.croUthio
iDduatri•
ot itel••
f•f•§•, 29: 9'-lJ2•
· A aite
a,
St\lllp Crcaa, ne.r Gnuiag'°°,
I~bire.
aha the
ot the Pemine
Mioroli1ibio induatrJ• f•f•§•, 22 : 2}-28.
•a•
(19'6 )
§•a!\99tM Qeglm Y4 4sJw•
(1962)
!Xoantiona
Tbatabaa,
'29-70·
at ,he Milgl... an ai'he at
Berkahire,
Bnglalld.
P.hS. • 28: