Abstract
Free full text
Fasciola Species Introgression: Just a Fluke or Something More?
Abstract
The threats posed by a range of viral and bacterial zoonotic diseases inevitably receive renewed attention in the wake of global pandemic events due to their overt and devastating impacts on human health and the economy. Parasitic zoonoses, however, many of which affect millions of people each day, are frequently ignored. In the case of fasciolosis, caused by infection with Fasciola hepatica or Fasciola gigantica, this oversight has allowed for the expansion of areas of parasite sympatry and thus increased the incidence of hybridization and possible introgression between the two species. Here we highlight how an increased demand for animal-derived protein, combined with a lack of appropriate tools for detection of these events, is changing the status quo of these zoonotic parasites.
Parasitic Zoonoses of Livestock in Developing Countries
As seen during the current coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic, zoonotic diseases are one of the greatest threats to human health. The high death rates associated with the more overt viral and bacterial diseases demand global attention and a rapid and coordinated response in order to limit human health consequences and impacts to the economy. Chronic and subclinical diseases, however, such as those caused by infection with parasites, are largely overlooked despite affecting millions of people each day. Parasitic diseases of livestock are of particular concern due to the additional threat they pose to animal productivity and food securityi. Despite these concerns, the propensity for these diseases to impact rural communities in developing countries means that they are often neglected by the wider scientific community (Figure 1 , Key Figure).
Fasciolosis: Inequality in the Context of Parasitic Zoonoses
One example of a parasitic zoonosis that is largely overlooked in the developing world is fasciolosis, caused by infection with the digenean trematodes F. hepatica and F. gigantica (Box 1 ). The economic impacts of fasciolosis on livestock production outcomes are underestimated but are expected to exceed US$3 billion/year, with over 180 million people – primarily women and children – considered at risk of infection [1,2]. Livestock production impacts due to infection with either Fasciola species range from sudden death, in the case of acute infections, to chronic losses due to decreased milk yield and fertility, reduced body condition scores, liveweight gains, and wool growth [3., 4., 5., 6., 7.]. Infection with F. hepatica has been shown to modulate the immune system of infected hosts by causing a shift towards a T helper 2 (Th2) cell response, leaving hosts more susceptible to infection with other bacterial pathogens such as Mycobacterium bovis and Bordetella pertussis [8,9]. This immunomodulation has also been shown to confound the outcomes of diagnostic tests for diseases, including bovine tuberculosis, due to the suppression of an effective Th1 response, increasing the rate of false-negative results [10].
In both human and animal infections the clinical signs of fasciolosis depend on the period of infection (either invasive/acute or chronic) and are related to the level of damage to the liver [11,12]. Ectopic or aberrant fasciolosis has been shown to occur when migrating immature flukes find their way to other organs, most commonly elsewhere in the gastrointestinal tract but also the abdominal wall, heart, lungs, and occasionally, the eyes or brain [13,14]. Reports of infection with F. hepatica are more common in human cases than infection with F. gigantica, leading to the assumption that F. hepatica has the greater zoonotic potential. The case may be, however, that human cases of fasciolosis caused by infection with F. gigantica are under-reported due to their occurrence in countries where limited access to medical care prevents diagnosis and disease reporting [15].
In countries where livestock production tends to be more industrialized, such as Australia and the UK, human infections are rare [11,16]. The considerable production impacts, however, make F. hepatica one of the primary foci of integrated parasite management programmes in these regions [4,17]. Alternatively, in countries where subsistence and smallholder farmers account for the majority of livestock owners, human and animal Fasciola spp. infections often go unnoticed and remain largely untreated (Figure 1) [11,15,16]. This is despite the availability of a treatment donation programme as a result of collaboration between Novartis and the World Health Organization. Zoonotic outbreaks are primarily associated with the highlands of South America, particularly Bolivia and Peru, where fasciolosis is considered to be hyperendemic (see Glossary) [11]. More recently, however, there have been a growing number of reports from the Middle East and North Africa, in countries such as Egypt, Iran, and Ethiopia [15].
While fasciolosis is considered a neglected tropical disease in several countries, a reliance on aquatic rice production in conjunction with large ruminant husbandry presents an ideal scenario for disease re-emergence in Southeast Asia in particular. Limited access to healthcare services and a high incidence of outdoor defecation further contribute to the increased zoonotic disease risk in the region [11,15,18]. Studies on the prevalence of Fasciola spp. in Southeast Asia are primarily limited to Vietnam, one of the wealthier countries in the region (Figure 1) [19,20]. Here, 47 of the 63 provinces have recorded cases of human infection, with more than 10 000 cases reported between 2006 and 2009 [20]. Prevalence data on human and animal infections in the countries neighbouring Vietnam is limited. The similar agricultural activities and human sanitation practices in these countries, however, suggest that they are likely to be similarly affected by fasciolosis, yet the disease remains relatively unnoticed outside of Vietnam.
Fasciola spp. Distribution in Southeast Asia as a Result of International Livestock Movements
The global distribution of F. hepatica and F. gigantica was historically associated with postdomestication livestock movements [18]. Translocation events are limited by the indirect life cycle of Fasciola spp., which requires a variety of prerequisites to be met in order to facilitate their successful expansion into a region. These include the availability of permissive hosts (both snail and vertebrate) and environments (water bodies to enable transmission), most of which have already been extensively reviewed [2,21]. The role that the international trade of livestock plays in the more recent dispersal of these parasites, however, is often overlooked despite sustained growth in global live export markets [2]ii , iii , iv. This is especially concerning in Southeast Asia where a rapidly growing middle class in countries such as China and Vietnam has driven an increase in the demand for animal-derived proteiniv. As demand outstrips local production, and higher-quality meat is preferred, animals are sourced from the major live cattle exporters, including Australia, Argentina. and Brazil, where F. hepatica is endemic [22]iv. In 2019 over a million cattle were imported into China, Vietnam, and Indonesia from Australia alone, an increase of 40% on the year beforeii , iii. Many of these animals are then moved via international livestock corridors throughout the region for fattening, slaughter, or breeding purposesii , iii.
Leaking into Local Livestock Systems
The impacts of international livestock movements are well recognized in the case of the more overt and devastating viral and bacterial diseases, such as foot and mouth disease and African swine feveriv. In an attempt to mitigate these transboundary disease risks, livestock corridors throughout Southeast Asia have been well documentediv. Regardless, undocumented livestock movements across land borders occur commonly, providing ample opportunity for 'leakages' of both animals and the diseases they carry into local livestock systems as they are trafficked towards their final destinationiv. Unlike many other production-limiting diseases, fasciolosis is often subclinical in large ruminants, allowing infected animals to move through these systems unnoticed. The subclinical nature of the disease further contributes to the neglect of this economically important parasite in the region, allowing translocation events to go undocumented. While the conditions supporting these parasite translocation events are most apparent in Southeast Asia, similar Fasciola spp. translocations are likely to be occurring elsewhere, such as in the Middle East where the importation of sheep and goats from F. hepatica-endemic countries is equally commonii , iii. Hence the sustained increase in the movement of animals from F. hepatica-endemic to non-endemic regions is likely to be quietly changing the status quo of these parasites around the world and expanding regions of parasite sympatry (Figure 1) [22].
The Proof Is in the Pâté
While it seems only natural that an increase in the trade of livestock from F. hepatica-endemic to non-endemic regions would facilitate parasite translocation events, there is a lack of data available to support this hypothesis. This is primarily because, until recently, all molecular Fasciola spp. identification was restricted to the analysis of DNA from adult flukes collected from the livers of infected animals during postmortem examination [23., 24., 25.]. A reliance on access to adult parasites for species identification via molecular methods precludes widespread surveillance in a system that inherently requires the movement of live animals. However, the postmortem examination of sheep livers in Saudi Arabian abattoirs suggests that between 10% and 22% of imported animals are infected [25,26]. In one instance, the morphological and molecular characterization of adult flukes revealed the presence of not only F. hepatica and F. gigantica, but also an ‘intermediate’ Fasciola species in imported animals [25]. By carrying the genetic signatures of both species, this ‘intermediate’ form is assumed to be the outcome of interspecific hybridization between F. hepatica and F. gigantica [27]. Although limited to the Middle East, these results provide evidence for the capacity of the international livestock trade to facilitate the movement of these parasites via infected animals and suggest that similar translocation events may be occurring in Southeast Asia.
Newer molecular methods that enable Fasciola spp. differentiation from faecal samples have extended our ability to conduct surveillance of parasite translocation events beyond the abattoir (Box 2 ) [28]. The molecular detection of F. hepatica DNA in faecal samples from local cattle in Northern Laos, a major livestock thoroughfare into China and Vietnam, suggests that not only are these parasites being imported, but that their life cycles are likely to have already become established in the region [28]. The introduction of F. hepatica into Southeast Asia is of cause for concern in its own right due to the considerable human and animal health impacts and potential for the development of anthelmintic resistance in livestock compared to F. gigantica. Perhaps more alarming, however, are the possible outcomes of animals coinfected with both species.
Hybridization and Introgression between F. hepatica and F. gigantica
Hybridization between F. hepatica and F. gigantica has been increasingly reported to occur in areas of Fasciola spp. sympatry as the result of interspecific mating (Box 3 ) [24,27,29,30]. Experimentally, successful hybridization between these parasites has been demonstrated via coinfection of Wistar rats and morphological and molecular characterization of the resulting F1 and F2 generations [31]. Experimental Fasciola-hybrid adults demonstrate an intermediate body-length to body-width ratio between that of their parent species and appear to be more infectious than F. gigantica alone based on higher than previously reported recovery rates [31]. Hybridization does not necessarily generate permanent genetic change, however, and the intermediate phenotypes observed in the experimental Fasciola hybrids may be inconsequential in the long term due to the apparent limited viability of successive generations under laboratory conditions [31,32]. While Fasciola hybrids may exist only transiently, a more permanent and thus concerning consequence of these interspecific mating events is the outcome of backcrosses between hybrids and either of the parental species. That is, the potential for introgression of advantageous traits from one species into the other.
Although successful hybridization between F. hepatica and F. gigantica has been demonstrated experimentally, there is no empirical evidence supporting introgression between these two parasites. Regardless, the terms ‘hybridization’ and ‘introgression’ are frequently used without differentiation throughout the Fasciola spp. literature and often without any consideration of the functional and epidemiological implications of either state [27,29,33]. The current lack of differentiation between hybridization and introgression in Fasciola spp. is alarming given the phenotypic and epidemiological outcomes of introgression observed in other species. Adaptive introgression has seen the transfer of resistance genes against organophosphates and pyrethrum between Anopheles mosquito species, as well as the experimental induction of ivermectin resistance in laboratory-maintained Haemonchus contortus populations [34., 35., 36., 37.]. Thus, it is not inconceivable that adaptive introgression may result in the transfer of anthelmintic resistance in Fasciola spp. due to the importation of triclabendazole-resistant F. hepatica into F. gigantica-endemic regions. Introgression between these two species, if it exists, may have other important human and animal health impacts, including increased infectivity, virulence, and pathophysiology, not to mention any potential implications surrounding the infection of intermediate hosts and the survival of eggs and metacercariae in the environment.
Differentiating Hybridization and Introgression in Fasciola spp.
The differentiation between hybridization and introgression is far from trivial in Fasciola spp., where their hermaphroditic nature, assumed potential for parthenogenesis, and the occurrence of polyploids complicate our understanding of these events [38., 39., 40., 41.]. However, the major ambiguity surrounding the distinction of hybridization from introgression in Fasciola spp. is due to a tendency to investigate single loci when a multi-loci or whole-genome approach is required (Box 3) [33,41., 42., 43., 44., 45.]. Most studies have relied on repetitive rDNA units to demonstrate hybridization, and only recently has a nuclear-encoded single-copy gene, PEPCK, been investigated [46,47]. Furthermore, the use of mtDNA alone, as evidence for hybridization in Fasciola spp., may be misleading due to a total lack of information concerning mitochondrial inheritance in these parasites and the limited recombination of mitochondrial genomes [41,48., 49., 50.]. It quickly becomes clear that, without knowing more about the genetic makeup of these forms, overinterpretation of naturally occurring hybridization and introgression events should be avoided. The availability of the F. hepatica and F. gigantica draft genomes, and next-generation sequencing technologies that allow rapid sequencing and assembly of the 1.2 Gb large genome, will enable documentation of introgression between Fasciola spp. [51,52]. Similar applications of these technologies have allowed the mapping of introgression events of Neanderthal- and Denisovan-derived DNA into the genomes of modern humans [53].
Despite the apparent limited viability of hybrid offspring under laboratory conditions, experimental back-crossing of Fasciola hybrids with both parental species should be pursued to aid in the unambiguous confirmation of the occurrence of introgression between these parasites and to provide insights into appropriate markers going forward. Until then, the characterization of these forms in hybrid zones should involve the comparison of many markers from a pool of individuals to external populations where it is known that only a single species is present [27].
Concluding Remarks
The continued neglect of these parasites and their human and animal health impacts in the developing world means that few studies have examined the role of the international trade of livestock in the expansion of existing hybrid zones. The limited evidence available is damning, however, and when considered in relation to what we know about the impacts of introgression between other parasite species, begs the question: is introgression between F. hepatica and F. gigantica just a fluke, or something more?
New and emerging molecular methods are extending our capacity to monitor Fasciola translocation events beyond the abattoir for the first time, allowing increased surveillance of coinfection and hybridization – the precursors to introgression [28]. Both have been proven in Fasciola spp. and are likely to be occurring with increased frequency due to the movement of F. hepatica-infected animals into F. gigantica endemic regions [22,25,31]. So, while there is no evidence in support of adaptive introgression between these two species just yet, it is simply a matter of when, not if. Thus, it is time we started considering the longevity and functional and epidemiological implications of these events in order to determine the impacts on the region’s food security and public health (see Outstanding Questions).
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank Graeme Brown, David Emery, Shona Chandra, and Emily Francis for their insightful comments and feedback during the preparation of the manuscript. We apologise to those authors whose work could not be cited due to space limitations.
Glossary
Adaptive introgression | the permanent establishment of beneficial alleles from one species in the gene pool of another through repeated backcrossing. |
Cercaria(plural: cercariae) | a free-swimming larval stage of Fasciola spp. that emerges from the intermediate snail host prior to encystation. |
Hybridization | the process of mating between two species resulting in a hybrid with theoretically equal genetic makeup from each parental species. |
Hyperendemic | high prevalence in a population (>10%) with very high faecal egg loads (>1000 eggs per gram of faeces). Human sanitation practices (lack of adequate sewerage and a high rate of defecation in the environment) contribute to the maintenance of the life cycle. |
Introgression | the transfer of genetic material from one species into the genome of another. |
Metacercaria (plural: metacercariae) | the most environmentally resistant encysted stage of Fasciola spp., infectious to mammalian hosts. |
Miracidium (plural: miracidia) | the short-lived free-swimming larval stage of Fasciola spp. that emerges from the eggs; it is passed in the faeces of mammalian hosts and infects the intermediate snail hosts. |
Parthenogenesis | reproduction without the need for fertilization of the ovum. |
Phenotype | any observable characteristic resulting from the combination of genotype and the environmental factors. |
Polyploids | individuals with more than two pairs of homologous chromosomes (vs. diploid, in which one set of chromosomes is inherited from each parent). |
Prepatent period | the period of time from infection of the mammalian host to the detection of Fasciola spp. eggs in faeces. |
Redia (plural: rediae) | the second stage of Fasciola spp. after infection of the intermediate snail hosts; it can produce daughter rediae by clonal expansion, and eventually cercariae. |
Sporocysts | elongated sacs resulting from infection of snails by Fasciola spp. miracidia that are capable of producing daughter sporocysts or rediae, the first larval stage within the intermediate snail hosts. |
Sympatry | the occurrence of two or more species within the same geographic locality at a given time. |
Resources
i www.who.int/neglected_diseases/diseases/summary/en/
ii www.livecorp.com.au/about-us/livecorp-information/annual-reports
References
Full text links
Read article at publisher's site: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pt.2020.09.008
Read article for free, from open access legal sources, via Unpaywall: http://www.cell.com/article/S1471492220302506/pdf
Citations & impact
Impact metrics
Article citations
Editorial: Trematode infection in ruminants, volume II.
Front Vet Sci, 10:1258751, 14 Aug 2023
Cited by: 0 articles | PMID: 37645674 | PMCID: PMC10461614
Cancerogenic parasites in veterinary medicine: a narrative literature review.
Infect Agent Cancer, 18(1):45, 26 Jul 2023
Cited by: 0 articles | PMID: 37496079 | PMCID: PMC10373346
Review Free full text in Europe PMC
High prevalence of liver fluke infestation, Fasciola gigantica, among slaughtered cattle in Boyolali District, Central Java.
Open Vet J, 13(5):654-662, 23 May 2023
Cited by: 1 article | PMID: 37304607 | PMCID: PMC10257458
Molecular characterization of Fasciola hepatica in endemic regions of Colombia.
Front Vet Sci, 10:1171147, 09 Jun 2023
Cited by: 0 articles | PMID: 37360412 | PMCID: PMC10288157
Proteomic analysis of Fasciola gigantica excretory and secretory products (FgESPs) co-immunoprecipitated using a time course of infected buffalo sera.
Front Microbiol, 13:1089394, 23 Dec 2022
Cited by: 0 articles | PMID: 36620027 | PMCID: PMC9816151
Go to all (14) article citations
Similar Articles
To arrive at the top five similar articles we use a word-weighted algorithm to compare words from the Title and Abstract of each citation.
Which species is in the faeces at a time of global livestock movements: single nucleotide polymorphism genotyping assays for the differentiation of Fasciola spp.
Int J Parasitol, 50(2):91-101, 22 Feb 2020
Cited by: 10 articles | PMID: 32006549
Distribution of Fasciola hepatica and F. gigantica in the endemic area of Guilan, Iran: Relationships between zonal overlap and phenotypic traits.
Infect Genet Evol, 31:95-109, 17 Jan 2015
Cited by: 25 articles | PMID: 25602718
Chapter 2. Fasciola, lymnaeids and human fascioliasis, with a global overview on disease transmission, epidemiology, evolutionary genetics, molecular epidemiology and control.
Adv Parasitol, 69:41-146, 01 Jan 2009
Cited by: 292 articles | PMID: 19622408
Review
Fasciola spp. in Armenia: Genetic diversity in a global context.
Vet Parasitol, 268:21-31, 01 Mar 2019
Cited by: 9 articles | PMID: 30981302
A prospective view of animal and human Fasciolosis.
Parasite Immunol, 38(9):558-568, 08 Jul 2016
Cited by: 71 articles | PMID: 27314903 | PMCID: PMC5053257
Review Free full text in Europe PMC